OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Pure states, excision, and peaking projections · §2

Lemma 2.6 [Cross-excision]: If positive contractions xix_i excise a pure state hh and decreasing ones yjy_j excise k≁hk \not\sim h, then ∥xiayj∥→0\|x_i a y_j\| \to 0 for every aa

Cross terms of inequivalent pure-state excisions tend to zero.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let BB be a C*-algebra. A positive contraction of BB is a positive element of BB of norm at most one. A net (xi)i∈I(x_i)_{i \in I} of positive contractions of BB excises a state hh of BB when limi∥xi(a−h(a)1)xi∥=0for every a∈B.\lim_{i} \bigl\| x_i \bigl(a - h(a)1\bigr) x_i \bigr\| = 0 \quad \text{for every } a \in B.(1)

Take two pure states hh and kk of BB whose Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations are not unitarily equivalent, a net (xi)i∈I(x_i)_{i \in I} excising hh and a net (yj)j∈J(y_j)_{j \in J} excising kk. The question is whether, for a fixed a∈Ba \in B, the cross terms xiayjx_i a y_j tend to zero in norm as ii and jj increase together.

A net (yj)j∈J(y_j)_{j \in J} of positive contractions of BB is decreasing when yj′≤yjy_{j'} \le y_j whenever j≤j′j \le j'.

Pure States and Their Representations

A state of BB is a continuous linear functional hh on BB of norm one such that h(a*a)h(a^*a) is real and nonnegative for every a∈Ba \in B.✦ A pure state of BB is a state of BB that is an extreme point of the convex set of states of BB.✦

A representation of BB on a Hilbert space HH is a *-homomorphism π\pi from BB into the bounded operators on HH. A representation π\pi of BB on a Hilbert space HH is irreducible when π≠0\pi \neq 0 and the only closed subspaces MM of HH with π(a)M⊆M\pi(a)M \subseteq M for every a∈Ba \in B are 00 and HH.✦ Two representations, π\pi of BB on HH and ρ\rho of BB on KK, are unitarily equivalent when some unitary operator UU from HH onto KK satisfies Uπ(a)=ρ(a)UU\pi(a) = \rho(a)U for every a∈Ba \in B.✦

The GNS representation πh\pi_h of a pure state hh of BB is the representation of BB on a Hilbert space that the GNS construction produces from hh.✦ Two pure states hh and kk of BB are equivalent, h∼kh \sim k, when πh\pi_h and πk\pi_k are unitarily equivalent.

Excision Nets of a Representation

The null algebra NξN_\xi of a representation π\pi of BB on HH at a vector ξ∈H\xi \in H is the *-subalgebra of BB, not necessarily unital, of the elements bb with π(b)ξ=0andπ(b*)ξ=0.\pi(b)\xi = 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \pi(b^*)\xi = 0.(2)✦

The excision index Λ(N)\Lambda(N) of a C*-algebra NN, not necessarily unital, is the set of positive elements ee of NN with ∥e∥<1\|e\| < 1, ordered as in NN.✦ The excision net of a representation π\pi of BB at a vector ξ\xi is the net (1−e)e∈Λ(Nξ)(1 - e)_{e \in \Lambda(N_\xi)} in BB.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let BB be a C*-algebra.

(a) Let hh and kk be pure states of BB with h≁kh \not\sim k, and let (xi)i∈I(x_i)_{i \in I} and (yj)j∈J(y_j)_{j \in J} be nets of positive contractions of BB over directed sets, the net (yj)(y_j) decreasing, such that (xi)(x_i) excises hh and (yj)(y_j) excises kk in the sense of (1). Then for every a∈Ba \in B lim(i,j)∈I×J∥xiayj∥=0.\lim_{(i,j) \in I \times J} \|x_i a y_j\| = 0.(3)✦

(b) Let π\pi and ρ\rho be irreducible representations of BB on Hilbert spaces HH and KK that are not unitarily equivalent, let ξ∈H\xi \in H and η∈K\eta \in K be unit vectors, and let NξN_\xi be the null algebra of π\pi at ξ\xi and NηN_\eta that of ρ\rho at η\eta. Then for every a∈Ba \in B the excision nets of π\pi at ξ\xi and of ρ\rho at η\eta satisfy lim(e,e′)∈Λ(Nξ)×Λ(Nη)∥(1−e)a(1−e′)∥=0.\lim_{(e, e') \in \Lambda(N_\xi) \times \Lambda(N_\eta)} \bigl\|(1 - e)\, a\, (1 - e')\bigr\| = 0.(4)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if h≁kh \not\sim k are pure states of BB and (xi)(x_i) and (yj)(y_j) are decreasing nets as in its Lemma 2.4 for hh and kk respectively, then ∥xiayj∥→0\|x_i a y_j\| \to 0 on the product directed set for every a∈Ba \in B, and either net may be a peaking sequence of projections.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over pure states of BB, compared through the unitary equivalence of their GNS representations, and over irreducible representations of BB on Hilbert spaces, with the null algebras, excision indices and excision nets of their unit vectors.

Beyond the claim, the library proves that a continuous linear functional on BB that is real and nonnegative at every a*aa^*a is real and nonnegative at every positive element of BB✦.