OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· Section 6. Tensor products and stable finiteness

Section 6 (proof of Corollary 1.2): the spatial tensor obstruction: Absence of tracial states gives the obstruction, and the bounded shift algebra supplies a concrete example

Proper infinitude in spatial free group tensor algebras.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let 𝔽2\mathbb F_2 be the free group on two generators, and let Cr*(𝔽2)C^*_r(\mathbb F_2) denote its reduced group C*C^*-algebra.✦ Fix a unital C*C^*-algebra DD and a unital complex **-representation ρ:D→ℬ(H)\rho:D\longrightarrow\mathcal B(H) on a complex Hilbert space HH.

A tracial state Ο„\tau on DD is a positive complex-linear functional Ο„:Dβ†’β„‚\tau:D\longrightarrow\mathbb C satisfying (1): Ο„(1)=1,Ο„(de)=Ο„(ed)(d,e∈D).\tau(1)=1,\qquad \tau(de)=\tau(ed)\quad(d,e\in D).(1)✦

For an index set ΞΉ\iota, the Hilbert sum β„“2(ΞΉ,H)\ell^2(\iota,H) is the space of square-summable families with entries in HH, equipped with the usual β„“2\ell^2 norm.✦ The reindexing isometry UeU_e associated with a permutation ee of ΞΉ\iota is the unitary operator of β„“2(ΞΉ,H)\ell^2(\iota,H) defined by (UeΞΎ)(i)=ΞΎ(eβˆ’1(i))(U_e\xi)(i)=\xi(e^{-1}(i)).✦

For Tβˆˆβ„¬(H)T\in\mathcal B(H) and gβˆˆπ”½2g\in\mathbb F_2, the diagonal operator IβŠ—TI\otimes T and the left regular operator Ξ»gβŠ—IH\lambda_g\otimes I_H on β„“2(𝔽2,H)\ell^2(\mathbb F_2,H) are given by (2): ((IβŠ—T)ΞΎ)(h)=TΞΎ(h),((Ξ»gβŠ—IH)ΞΎ)(h)=ΞΎ(gβˆ’1h)(hβˆˆπ”½2).((I\otimes T)\xi)(h)=T\xi(h),\qquad ((\lambda_g\otimes I_H)\xi)(h)=\xi(g^{-1}h) \quad(h\in\mathbb F_2).(2) Here Ξ»gβŠ—IH\lambda_g\otimes I_H is the reindexing isometry for left multiplication by gg.✦

Given a subset SS of a C*C^*-algebra, write C*(S)C^*(S) for the norm closure of the unital complex **-algebra generated by SS.✦ The concrete spatial tensor algebra 𝒯ρ\mathcal T_\rho, denoted Cr*(𝔽2)βŠ—minρ(D)C^*_r(\mathbb F_2)\otimes_{\min}\rho(D), is the subalgebra of ℬ(β„“2(𝔽2,H))\mathcal B(\ell^2(\mathbb F_2,H)) defined in (3): 𝒯ρ=C*({IβŠ—Ο(d):d∈D}βˆͺ{Ξ»gβŠ—IH:gβˆˆπ”½2}).\mathcal T_\rho= C^*\!\left(\{I\otimes\rho(d):d\in D\} \cup\{\lambda_g\otimes I_H:g\in\mathbb F_2\}\right).(3)✦

The Bounded Shift Algebra

A smooth test index z=(m,R,t)z=(m,R,t) is a triple in which m,Rm,R are positive integers and tt belongs to the smooth test base with parameters m,Rm,R; write ZZ for the set of smooth test indices.✦ Let Sm,R,jS_{m,R,j} be the slot set of the test-sequence stage at m,R,jm,R,j, where jβ‰₯0j\geq0. The finite-dimensional test fiber Ez,jE_{z,j} and the test Hilbert space HzH_z are given in (4): Ez,j=β„‚Sm,R,j,Hz=⨁jβ‰₯0β„“2Ez,j.E_{z,j}=\mathbb C^{S_{m,R,j}},\qquad H_z=\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_{z,j}.(4)

For a sequence (Ej)jβ‰₯0(E_j)_{j\geq0} of Hilbert spaces, put β„‹E=⨁jβ‰₯0β„“2Ej\mathcal H_E=\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_j.✦ The level inclusion Lj:Ejβ†’β„‹EL_j:E_j\longrightarrow\mathcal H_E is the isometry sending a vector to the family supported at level jj with that value.✦ The zero-prefix isometric inclusion J:⨁jβ‰₯0β„“2Ej+1β†’β„‹EJ:\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_{j+1}\longrightarrow\mathcal H_E places each input at its successor level and inserts zero at level zero.✦ Given contractions Tj:Ejβ†’Ej+1T_j:E_j\longrightarrow E_{j+1}, the operator-weighted forward shift STS_T is the bounded operator on β„‹E\mathcal H_E defined in (5), with the blocks applied coordinatewise: ST=J∘(⨁jβ‰₯0Tj).S_T=J\circ\left(\bigoplus_{j\geq0}T_j\right).(5)✦

For 1≀i≀241\leq i\leq24, the test block operator Ti,z,j:Ez,jβ†’Ez,j+1T_{i,z,j}:E_{z,j}\longrightarrow E_{z,j+1} is the normalized block operator of the normalized Hermitian test tuple at z,jz,j: the bounded complex-linear realization of its iith forward block.✦

The β„“βˆž\ell^\infty product 𝒫=∏z∈Zβˆžβ„¬(Hz)\mathcal P=\prod_{z\in Z}^{\infty}\mathcal B(H_z) consists of uniformly bounded operator families c=(cz)c=(c_z), with norm βˆ₯cβˆ₯=sup⁡zβˆ₯czβˆ₯\|c\|=\sup_z\|c_z\|.✦ The bounded shift generators x1,…,x24x_1,\ldots,x_{24} and their closed unital C*C^*-algebra BβŠ†π’«B\subseteq\mathcal P are defined in (6): xi=(S(Ti,z,j)jβ‰₯0)z∈Z,B=C*({x1,…,x24}).x_i=\bigl(S_{(T_{i,z,j})_{j\geq0}}\bigr)_{z\in Z},\qquad B=C^*(\{x_1,\ldots,x_{24}\}).(6)

The fiber representation ρz:B→ℬ(Hz)\rho_z:B\longrightarrow\mathcal B(H_z) is coordinate evaluation, ρz(c)=cz\rho_z(c)=c_z.✦ The representation space β„‹B\mathcal H_B is the β„“2\ell^2 direct sum of the HzH_z over ZZ, and the diagonal representation ρB:B→ℬ(β„‹B)\rho_B:B\longrightarrow\mathcal B(\mathcal H_B) acts as in (7): β„‹B=⨁z∈Zβ„“2Hz,(ρB(c)Ξ·)z=ρz(c)Ξ·z.\mathcal H_B=\bigoplus_{z\in Z}^{\ell^2}H_z,\qquad (\rho_B(c)\eta)_z=\rho_z(c)\eta_z.(7)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let DD be a nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra without a tracial state, and let ρ:D→ℬ(H)\rho:D\longrightarrow\mathcal B(H) be a unital complex **-representation on a complex Hilbert space. Then 𝒯ρ is properly infinite.\mathcal T_\rho\text{ is properly infinite}.(8)✦ For the bounded shift algebra BB with its diagonal representation ρB\rho_B on β„‹B\mathcal H_B, 𝒯ρB is properly infinite.\mathcal T_{\rho_B}\text{ is properly infinite}.(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: a unital C*C^*-algebra DD with no tracial state has properly infinite minimal tensor product DβŠ—minCr*(𝔽2)D\otimes_{\min}C^*_r(\mathbb F_2).

What Is Checked

The claim (8) is stated over nonzero unital C*C^*-algebras without tracial states and their unital representations on complex Hilbert spaces; (9) uses BB and ρB\rho_B on β„‹B\mathcal H_B.

The test blocks and bounded shifts satisfy the contraction bounds (10): βˆ₯Ti,z,jβˆ₯≀1,βˆ₯xiβˆ₯≀1.\|T_{i,z,j}\|\leq1,\qquad \|x_i\|\leq1.(10)

The fiber and diagonal representations satisfy (11) for every c∈Bc\in B: βˆ₯ρz(c)βˆ₯≀βˆ₯cβˆ₯,ρB(c*)=ρB(c)*.\|\rho_z(c)\|\leq\|c\|,\qquad \rho_B(c^*)=\rho_B(c)^*.(11)

The successor-level inclusions Lj+1L_{j+1} have mutually orthogonal ranges.✦