OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · Section 6. Tensor products and stable finiteness

Section 6 (proof of Corollary 1.2): traceless stably finite algebras: Simple and separable examples from the algebra of bounded shifts

Stable finiteness without tracial states.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The issue is stable finiteness in the absence of tracial states. The concrete starting point is a closed unital algebra generated by twenty-four operator-weighted shifts.

A smooth test index z=(m,R,t)z=(m,R,t) is a triple consisting of positive integers m,Rm,R and a test parameter tt in the prescribed parameter set for m,Rm,R.✦ For a smooth test index z=(m,R,t)z=(m,R,t) and j≥0j\geq 0, the test fiber Ez,jE_{z,j} is the finite-dimensional complex Euclidean space with coordinates indexed by the slots prescribed for m,R,jm,R,j.✦

For a sequence of normed abelian groups, the ℓ2\ell^2 direct sum is the space of square-summable families, with its usual ℓ2\ell^2 norm.✦ The test Hilbert space HzH_z is the direct sum in (1).✦ Hz=⨁j≥0ℓ2Ez,j,∥ξ∥2=∑j≥0∥ξj∥2.H_z=\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_{z,j},\qquad \|\xi\|^2=\sum_{j\geq0}\|\xi_j\|^2.(1)✦ For a sequence of Hilbert spaces (Ej)(E_j), the level inclusion ιj\iota_j is the map from EjE_j to their Hilbert direct sum that sends a vector to the family supported at level jj with that value. The zero-prefix inclusion for a sequence of Hilbert spaces (Ej)(E_j) is the map from the Hilbert direct sum of the successor fibers to the Hilbert direct sum of the whole sequence that places the given family at the successor levels and zero at level zero; both inclusions are isometries.

A normalized Hermitian tuple with source space EE and target space FF supplies twenty-four forward blocks; the normalized block operator at an index is the corresponding block regarded as a bounded complex-linear map E→FE\to F.✦ For a smooth test index zz, a nonnegative integer jj and one of the twenty-four indices ii, the test block operator Ti,z,j:Ez,j→Ez,j+1T_{i,z,j}:E_{z,j}\to E_{z,j+1} is the normalized block operator at index ii for the normalized test at z,jz,j.✦

The operator-weighted forward shift STS_T associated with contraction blocks Tj:Ej→Ej+1T_j:E_j\to E_{j+1} is the bounded operator on the direct sum defined by (2). (STξ)0=0,(STξ)j+1=Tjξj(j≥0).(S_T\xi)_0=0,\qquad (S_T\xi)_{j+1}=T_j\xi_j\quad(j\geq0).(2)✦ The bounded product ∏zℓ∞ℬ(Hz)\prod_z^{\ell^\infty}\mathcal B(H_z) consists of uniformly bounded operator families with the supremum norm.✦ The contractive family embedding for the bounded product ∏zℓ∞ℬ(Hz)\prod_z^{\ell^\infty}\mathcal B(H_z) is the map that sends an operator family with every coordinate norm at most one to the corresponding element of that product.✦ The bounded shift generators xix_i and their generated unital C*C^*-algebra BB are given by (3); the closure is in norm. xi(z)=S(Ti,z,j)j≥0(1≤i≤24),B=alg⁡ℂ*(1,x1,…,x24)¯⊆∏zℓ∞ℬ(Hz).x_i(z)=S_{(T_{i,z,j})_{j\geq0}}\quad(1\leq i\leq24),\qquad B=\overline{\operatorname{alg}_{\mathbb C}^{*}(1,x_1,\ldots,x_{24})} \subseteq\prod_z^{\ell^\infty}\mathcal B(H_z).(3)

Finiteness and Traces

A tracial state on a unital C*C^*-algebra CC is a positive complex-linear functional τ:C→ℂ\tau:C\to\mathbb C satisfying (4).✦ Write T(C)T(C) for the set of these functionals. τ(1)=1,τ(cd)=τ(dc)(c,d∈C).\tau(1)=1,\qquad \tau(cd)=\tau(dc)\quad(c,d\in C).(4)✦

A closed two-sided **-ideal JJ of CC is a norm-closed complex **-subalgebra satisfying CJ⊆JCJ\subseteq J and JC⊆JJC\subseteq J.✦ A unital C*C^*-algebra CC is simple if its only closed two-sided **-ideals are {0}\{0\} and CC.✦

A unital C*C^*-algebra CC is stably finite if every isometry in every positive matrix size is unitary, as in (5).✦ n≥1,v∈Mn(C),v*v=1⇒vv*=1.n\geq1,\quad v\in M_n(C),\quad v^*v=1 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad vv^*=1.(5)✦

A quasitrace value functional on CC is a function V:C→ℝV:C\to\mathbb R satisfying (6).✦ In that display c,d,x∈Cc,d,x\in C and r∈ℝr\in\mathbb R, with additional restrictions specified on the relevant lines. V(0)=0,V(1)=1,V(rc)=rV(c),|V(c)|≤∥c∥,0≤V(c)≤V(d)(0≤c≤d),|V(c)−V(d)|≤∥c−d∥(c,d≥0),V(xx*)=V(x*x),V(c+d)≤(1+r2)V(c)+(1+r−2)V(d)(c,d≥0,r≠0),V(c+d)=V(c)+V(d)(c=c*,d=d*,cd=dc).\begin{aligned} &V(0)=0,\qquad V(1)=1,\qquad V(rc)=rV(c),\qquad |V(c)|\leq\|c\|,\\ &0\leq V(c)\leq V(d) &&(0\leq c\leq d),\\ &|V(c)-V(d)|\leq\|c-d\| &&(c,d\geq0),\\ &V(xx^*)=V(x^*x),\\ &V(c+d)\leq(1+r^2)V(c)+(1+r^{-2})V(d) && (c,d\geq0,\ r\ne0),\\ &V(c+d)=V(c)+V(d) && (c=c^*,\ d=d^*,\ cd=dc). \end{aligned}(6)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the test algebra BB of (3), T(B)=⌀.T(B)=\varnothing.(7)✦ Let CC be a nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra with a quasitrace value functional, and suppose T(C)=⌀T(C)=\varnothing. There is a nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra MM with M simple and stably finite,T(M)=⌀.M\text{ simple and stably finite},\qquad T(M)=\varnothing.(8)✦ There exists a nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra NN with N simple and stably finite,T(N)=⌀.N\text{ simple and stably finite},\qquad T(N)=\varnothing.(9)✦ The separable traceless stable finiteness condition holds: there exists a nonzero separable unital C*C^*-algebra DD with D stably finite,T(D)=⌀.D\text{ stably finite},\qquad T(D)=\varnothing.(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the factor form of the quasitrace problem yields a simple stably finite traceless algebra, and a finitely generated subalgebra gives the separable example.

What Is Checked

The concrete assertion (7) is stated over the closed unital algebra BB of bounded shift families. The hypothesis of (8) is a nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra with a quasitrace value functional and no tracial states. The existence assertions (9) and (10) concern unital C*C^*-algebras, with separability required in (10).

The test block operators satisfy the contraction bound in (11).✦ The successor level inclusions form an orthogonal family.✦ ∥Ti,z,j∥≤1(1≤i≤24,z a smooth test index,j≥0).\|T_{i,z,j}\|\leq1\qquad(1\leq i\leq24,\ z\text{ a smooth test index},\ j\geq0).(11)✦