OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · Section 5. The algebra and a uniform additivity defect

Lemma 5.2 [Uniform additivity defect from a finite tuple]: Twenty-four bounded shift generators determine positive contractions in a matrix amplification

A fixed pair with uniform quasitrace defect.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The issue is additivity of normalized 11-quasitraces on a fixed pair of positive contractions in a matrix algebra. The library constructs the underlying algebra from operator-weighted shifts on Hilbert spaces with finite-dimensional levels.

A smooth test index z=(m,R,s)z=(m,R,s) consists of positive integers m,Rm,R and a point ss of the smooth test base with parameters m,Rm,R.✦ For each nonnegative integer jj, the test fiber Ez,jE_{z,j} is the complex Euclidean space whose coordinates are the slots of the test-sequence stage with parameters m,R,jm,R,j.✦ The test Hilbert space HzH_z is the square-summable direct sum in (1), with its usual ℓ2\ell^2 norm: Hz=⨁j≥0ℓ2Ez,j={(ξj)j≥0:ξj∈Ez,j,∑j≥0∥ξj∥2<∞}.H_z=\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_{z,j} =\left\{(\xi_j)_{j\geq0}:\xi_j\in E_{z,j},\quad \sum_{j\geq0}\|\xi_j\|^2<\infty\right\}.(1)✦

Given spaces EE and FF, a normalized Hermitian tuple from EE to FF, and a generator index ii, the normalized block operator Ti:E→FT_i:E\to F is the bounded complex-linear map E→FE\to F given by the tuple’s forward block at index ii.✦ For 1≤i≤241\leq i\leq24, the test block Ti(z,j):Ez,j→Ez,j+1T_i(z,j):E_{z,j}\to E_{z,j+1} is the normalized test’s bounded block map between these levels.✦

For a sequence (Ej)j≥0(E_j)_{j\geq0} of Hilbert spaces and a nonnegative integer jj, the level inclusion ιj\iota_j is the isometric linear map from EjE_j into their ℓ2\ell^2 direct sum that places a vector at level jj and zero elsewhere.✦ The zero-prefix inclusion JJ for a sequence (Ej)j≥0(E_j)_{j\geq0} of Hilbert spaces is the isometry from the ℓ2\ell^2 sum of the successor fibers Ej+1E_{j+1} into the sum of all the fibers that places each input at its corresponding successor level and inserts zero at level zero.✦ Given contractions Tj:Ej→Ej+1T_j:E_j\to E_{j+1}, the operator-weighted forward shift STS_T is the bounded operator on the direct sum defined by (2): (STξ)0=0,(STξ)j+1=Tjξj(j≥0).(S_T\xi)_0=0,\qquad (S_T\xi)_{j+1}=T_j\xi_j\quad(j\geq0).(2)✦

The ℓ∞\ell^\infty product ∏zℓ∞Dz\prod_z^{\ell^\infty}D_z of a family (Dz)(D_z) of complex C*C^*-algebras is the C*C^*-algebra of uniformly bounded families (dz)(d_z), with norm ∥(dz)∥=sup⁡z∥dz∥\|(d_z)\|=\sup_z\|d_z\|.✦ For a family (Dz)(D_z) of complex C*C^*-algebras, the contractive family embedding ι\iota is the map that sends a family (dz)(d_z) in these algebras satisfying ∥dz∥≤1\|d_z\|\leq1 for every zz to that same family in their ℓ∞\ell^\infty product.✦ The bounded shift generator xix_i is the element specified by (3): xi∈∏zℓ∞ℬ(Hz),xi(z)=STi(z,⋅)(1≤i≤24).x_i\in\prod_z^{\ell^\infty}\mathcal B(H_z),\qquad x_i(z)=S_{T_i(z,\cdot)}\quad(1\leq i\leq24).(3)✦

The unital C*C^*-algebra generated by a subset XX of a C*C^*-algebra DD is the norm closure in DD of the unital complex **-algebra generated by XX.✦ Let BB be this algebra for the bounded shift generators, as in (4): B=alg⁡ℂ*(1,x1,…,x24)¯⊆∏zℓ∞ℬ(Hz).B=\overline{\operatorname{alg}^{*}_{\mathbb C} (1,x_1,\ldots,x_{24})} \subseteq\prod_z^{\ell^\infty}\mathcal B(H_z).(4)✦ Write xix_i also for the corresponding generator of BB. The C*C^*-algebra operations on BB are inherited from the product; its order is the spectral order.

The zero-extended generator sequence y=(yj)j≥0y=(y_j)_{j\geq0} in BB is defined by (5): yj={xj+1,0≤j<24,0,j≥24.y_j=\begin{cases} x_{j+1},&0\leq j<24,\\ 0,&j\geq24. \end{cases}(5)✦ The defect algebra is A=M48(B)A=M_{48}(B). The first defect matrix a∈Aa\in A is the value of the first standard defect matrix construction on yy at size 2424✦; the second defect matrix b∈Ab\in A is the value of the second standard defect matrix construction on yy at size 2424.

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the constructed generators x1,…,x24x_1,\ldots,x_{24} of BB, the column and row square sums satisfy (6) and (7): ∑i=124xi*xi=1B.\sum_{i=1}^{24}x_i^*x_i=1_B.(6)✦ ∑i=124xixi*≤231B.\sum_{i=1}^{24}x_ix_i^*\leq\frac23\,1_B.(7)✦ The fixed defect matrices satisfy (8), with the defect bound holding for every normalized 11-quasitrace τ\tau on AA: a,b∈A+,∥a∥,∥b∥≤1,Re⁡(τ(a+b)−τ(a)−τ(b))≥1144.a,b\in A_+,\qquad \|a\|,\|b\|\leq1,\qquad \operatorname{Re}\bigl(\tau(a+b)-\tau(a)-\tau(b)\bigr)\geq\frac1{144}.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if BB is a unital complex C*C^*-algebra, N≥1N\geq1, and x1,…,xN∈Bx_1,\ldots,x_N\in B satisfy ∑i=1Nxi*xi=1\sum_{i=1}^N x_i^*x_i=1 and ∑i=1Nxixi*≤c1\sum_{i=1}^N x_ix_i^*\leq c1 for some 0≤c<10\leq c<1, then the tuple determines positive contractions a,b∈M2N(B)a,b\in M_{2N}(B) such that every normalized 11-quasitrace τ\tau on that matrix algebra satisfies τ(a+b)−τ(a)−τ(b)≥(1−c)/(2N)\tau(a+b)-\tau(a)-\tau(b)\geq(1-c)/(2N).

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the closed unital C*C^*-algebra BB generated by the bounded shifts, its matrix algebra AA, the fixed defect matrices a,ba,b, and normalized 11-quasitraces on AA. The test blocks Ti(z,j)T_i(z,j) have operator norm at most one✦, and the inclusions of the successor levels form an orthogonal family.✦