OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 4. Partial cylinders and elementary expansions

Proposition 4.2 [Contractibility of cylinders and their domains]: Cofibrancy and boundary fillers for cylinder stages and shape realizations, with one-sided maps in the source-generated left class

Contractibility of partial cylinders under expansion contraction.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A partial cylinder has two endpoints that coincide below a chosen dimension nn. Its higher stages have boundary objects formed by gluing two copies of the preceding stage. The relevant contractibility condition is the existence of a filler for every cell boundary, including the empty boundary in dimension zero.✦

A shape SS is a finite globular sum, described by a table of dimensions.✦ An attachment adds a globe of dimension hh by identifying its source bb-face with the target bb-face of the previous last globe, where bb is smaller than both adjoining globe dimensions.✦ The two pushout inclusions are the previous shape inclusion and the new globe inclusion; the latter distinguishes the last globe. The height of SS is the largest globe dimension in its table.✦ Write |S||S| for the globular presheaf obtained by these gluings of representable disks.✦ The gluing face inclusion into SS is the inclusion of the target bb-face of its last globe, followed by the last globe inclusion into SS, where bb is smaller than that globe’s dimension.

A globular theory CC is a category with shapes as objects and an arity functor that preserves these globular sums.✦ An admissible pair (u,v)(u,v) in a globular theory CC is a pair of parallel operations from a jj-globe to a shape of height at most j+1j+1; parallel operations have the same source and target restrictions, with no restriction in dimension zero.✦ A filler ww for an admissible pair (u,v)(u,v) in a globular theory CC is an operation from the (j+1)(j+1)-globe to the common target shape of uu and vv whose source and target restrictions are uu and vv.✦ A free extension by fillers C→C′C\to C′ of a globular theory CC is an extension of CC characterized by the universal property of adjoining specified fillers, relative to morphisms of theories that preserve the arity maps.✦ A cellular presentation (Ck)(C_k) of a globular theory CC is a sequence of free extensions by fillers, starting at an initial theory and having colimit CC.✦ A coherator CC is a globular theory with a cellular presentation and a filler for every admissible pair.✦ Fix a coherator CC. The globe inclusion into shapes sends each dimension to its single-globe shape and each face to the corresponding map of representable disks; composing it with the arity functor gives the globe inclusion into CC.

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC sending elementary globular sums to pullbacks.✦ The underlying globular set of a model XX of CC is the restriction of XX along the globe inclusion: its cells XjX_j have source and target maps, denoted ss and tt, satisfying ss=stss=st and ts=ttts=tt.✦ Model morphisms induce maps of cells commuting with source and target.✦ Two positive-dimensional cells are parallel when their sources and targets agree; all zero-dimensional cells are parallel.✦ The set Bdy⁡0(X)\operatorname{Bdy}_0(X) is a singleton, and Bdy⁡j+1(X)\operatorname{Bdy}_{j+1}(X) consists of ordered pairs of parallel jj-cells.✦ The boundary map ∂j:Xj→Bdy⁡j(X)\partial_j:X_j\to\operatorname{Bdy}_j(X) sends a positive-dimensional cell to its source and target, and is the unique map in dimension zero.✦ A model XX of CC is contractible when Contr⁡(X)⇔∂j:Xj→Bdy⁡j(X) is surjective for every j≥0.\operatorname{Contr}(X) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \partial_j:X_j\longrightarrow\operatorname{Bdy}_j(X) \text{ is surjective for every }j\geq 0.(1)✦ A morphism f:X→Yf:X\to Y of globular sets induces a map Bdy⁡j(X)→Bdy⁡j(Y)\operatorname{Bdy}_j(X)\to\operatorname{Bdy}_j(Y), sending the unique boundary to the unique boundary in dimension zero and applying ff to both cells of a boundary in positive dimensions.✦

The free model on a shape SS is the representable presheaf at SS.✦ In particular, DjD_j is the free jj-disk.✦ The boundary ∂Dj\partial D_j of the free disk DjD_j is the model representing jj-boundaries, and restriction along Ij:∂Dj→DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j corresponds to the cell boundary map under the Yoneda correspondence between maps Dj→XD_j\to X and cells XjX_j.✦ The source face induces Jj:Dj→Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1}.✦ The disk frame consists of these objects and boundary inclusions, with ∂D0=0,∂Dj+1=Dj∐∂DjDj.\partial D_0=0, \qquad \partial D_{j+1}=D_j\amalg_{\partial D_j}D_j.(2)✦

For a nonnegative integer qq, a qq-coskeletal model XX of CC is a model whose boundary maps are bijective in every dimension above qq.✦ Let 𝒜q\mathcal A_q be the full subcategory of models of CC consisting of the qq-coskeletal models, and let ρq\rho_q be the coskeletal reflection into 𝒜q\mathcal A_q. Applying it to the disk frame (2) gives the reflected disk frame, with notation D¯j=ρqDj,∂D¯j=ρq(∂Dj),I¯j=ρqIj,J¯j=ρqJj.\overline D_j=\rho_qD_j, \qquad \partial\overline D_j=\rho_q(\partial D_j), \qquad \overline I_j=\rho_qI_j, \qquad \overline J_j=\rho_qJ_j.(3)✦

For a class ℳ\mathcal M of morphisms, write ℳ⟂\mathcal M^\perp for the maps having the right lifting property against ℳ\mathcal M, and ⟂ℳ\,{}^\perp\mathcal M for those having the left lifting property against it. The generating boundary and source classes in 𝒜q\mathcal A_q, for a nonnegative integer rr and using (3), are ℐq,r={I¯j∣j≥r},𝒥q,r={J¯j∣j≥r},ℒq,r=⟂(𝒥q,r⟂).\mathcal I_{q,r}=\{\overline I_j\mid j\geq r\}, \qquad \mathcal J_{q,r}=\{\overline J_j\mid j\geq r\}, \qquad \mathcal L_{q,r}={}^\perp(\mathcal J_{q,r}^{\perp}).(4) An object XX of 𝒜q\mathcal A_q is cofibrant if every map X→YX\to Y lifts along every map Z→YZ\to Y in ℐq,0⟂\mathcal I_{q,0}^{\perp}.✦ Write Cof⁡(X)\operatorname{Cof}(X) for this condition. The expansion contraction principle E(q,r)E(q,r) is the assertion that, for i:X→Yi:X\to Y in ℒq,r\mathcal L_{q,r}, a cofibrant domain XX satisfying (1) has a codomain YY satisfying that condition as well.✦

Cylinder Objects and One-sided Domains

A globular frame FF in a category 𝒦\mathcal K is a family of objects in each dimension, boundary objects with inclusions into them, and two maps from each object to the next boundary; the zero boundary is initial and each successor boundary is the pushout of two copies of the previous object along its boundary.✦ Composing these two maps with the next boundary inclusion gives the source and target maps of a coglobular object, hence a functor from the globe category. Iterated source and target faces give its maps on nonidentity globe morphisms. In a category with all small colimits, the realization functor of a coglobular object sends a globular presheaf to the colimit of its diagram of globes interpreted in that object; the realization of a globular frame is that of its associated coglobular object.

For the reflected disk frame, a cylinder node in dimension jj consists of a boundary BjB_j, an object PjP_j, an inclusion bj:Bj→Pjb_j:B_j\to P_j, and endpoint maps ejε:D¯j→Pje_j^\varepsilon:\overline D_j\to P_j and βjε:∂D¯j→Bj\beta_j^\varepsilon:\partial\overline D_j\to B_j, for ε∈{0,1}\varepsilon\in\{0,1\}, satisfying bjβjε=ejεI¯jb_j\beta_j^\varepsilon=e_j^\varepsilon\overline I_j.✦ The partial disk cylinder with threshold nn is stationary below nn, is critical at nn, and above nn uses the successor cylinder construction, which completes the two disks attached to the boundary Pj∐BjPjP_j\amalg_{B_j}P_j along the maps induced by the endpoint maps ejεe_j^\varepsilon: (Bj,Pj,bj)={(∂D¯j,D¯j,I¯j),j<n,(∂D¯n,D¯n+1,J¯nI¯n),j=n,Bj+1≅Pj∐BjPj.(B_j,P_j,b_j)= \begin{cases} (\partial\overline D_j,\overline D_j,\overline I_j),&j<n,\\ (\partial\overline D_n,\overline D_{n+1}, \overline J_n\overline I_n),&j=n, \end{cases} \qquad B_{j+1}\cong P_j\amalg_{B_j}P_j.(5)✦ The boundary endpoint maps are identities through dimension nn. Both disk endpoints are identities at a stationary node, and are the source and target inclusions at the critical node. A cylinder boundary step consists of the two maps from PjP_j to Bj+1B_{j+1} giving the pushout in (5), compatible with both boundary endpoints.✦ These steps assemble the nodes into the partial cylinder frame PP, and its endpoints into morphisms of globular frames eε:D¯→Pe^\varepsilon:\overline D\to P. The stationary cylinder transition between consecutive stationary stages uses the two face maps of the reflected disk frame and its boundary pushout square.✦ The critical cylinder transition from a stationary stage to the critical stage in the next degree also uses the two face maps of the reflected disk frame and its boundary pushout square.✦

Given a boundary inclusion i:∂D→Di:\partial D\to D and two attaching maps eε:∂D→Be^\varepsilon:\partial D\to B, the double boundary attachment is formed by attaching one copy of DD to BB along e0e^0, then attaching the second along e1e^1 followed by the inclusion of BB into the first pushout.✦ The attachment base inclusion from BB into the double boundary attachment is the composite of the left inclusions in these two pushouts.✦ The attached disk endpoints are the inclusion of the first disk followed by the inclusion of the first pushout into the second, and the inclusion of the second disk into the second pushout.✦

For B∈𝒜qB\in\mathcal A_q and maps eε:∂D¯j→Be^\varepsilon:\partial\overline D_j\to B, the cylinder factorization is the chosen factorization used to complete the two disks attached to BB along these maps.✦ The completed cylinder stage over the reflected disk frame has boundary BB.

The successor boundary endpoint from ∂D¯j+1\partial\overline D_{j+1} to Pj∐BjPjP_j\amalg_{B_j}P_j, for each endpoint choice, is induced by the boundary pushout square of the reflected disk frame: its two restrictions are ejεe_j^\varepsilon followed by the respective pushout inclusions.✦ The successor cylinder transition uses the two canonical inclusions of PjP_j into the glued boundary Pj∐BjPjP_j\amalg_{B_j}P_j.✦

The one-sided domain AjεA_j^\varepsilon of the cylinder node PjP_j is the pushout adjoining the endpoint disk D¯j\overline D_j to the boundary BjB_j along βjε\beta_j^\varepsilon and I¯j\overline I_j.✦ The attachment map ajεa_j^\varepsilon from the one-sided domain AjεA_j^\varepsilon to the cylinder node PjP_j is the map induced by the boundary inclusion and the endpoint map ejεe_j^\varepsilon.✦ The partial shape cylinder P(S)P(S) of a shape SS is the realization of |S||S| by the partial cylinder frame PP: Ajε=Bj∐∂D¯jD¯j,ajε:Ajε→Pj,P(S)=Real⁡P(|S|).A_j^\varepsilon =B_j\amalg_{\partial\overline D_j}\overline D_j, \qquad a_j^\varepsilon:A_j^\varepsilon\longrightarrow P_j, \qquad P(S)=\operatorname{Real}_P(|S|).(6)

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Proposition 4.2). Let CC be a coherator, let n≤qn\leq q, and assume E(q,n+1)E(q,n+1). For every j>nj>n and ε∈{0,1}\varepsilon\in\{0,1\}, the one-sided domains satisfy Cof⁡(Ajε),Contr⁡(Ajε),ajε∈ℒq,n+1.\operatorname{Cof}(A_j^\varepsilon), \qquad \operatorname{Contr}(A_j^\varepsilon), \qquad a_j^\varepsilon\in\mathcal L_{q,n+1}.(7)✦ For every j≥0j\geq0, the cylinder nodes satisfy Cof⁡(Pj),Contr⁡(Pj).\operatorname{Cof}(P_j), \qquad \operatorname{Contr}(P_j).(8)✦ For every finite globular sum SS, the partial shape cylinders satisfy Cof⁡(P(S)),Contr⁡(P(S)).\operatorname{Cof}(P(S)), \qquad \operatorname{Contr}(P(S)).(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for fixed 0≤n<q0\leq n<q with E(q,k)E(q,k) for every n<k≤qn<k\leq q, every PjP_j is contractible, both AjεA_j^\varepsilon are contractible and Ajε→PjA_j^\varepsilon\to P_j is an upper cellular weak equivalence for n<j≤qn<j\leq q, and P(S)P(S) is cellular and contractible for every pasting scheme SS of height at most qq.

What Is Checked

The statements (7), (8), and (9) are over models of the coherator CC in 𝒜q\mathcal A_q, with the reflected disks and the source-generated class (4), under n≤qn\leq q and E(q,n+1)E(q,n+1).

The coskeletal reflection exists, its unit is bijective on cells through dimension qq, and precomposition with the unit gives a natural bijection between maps ρqX→Y\rho_qX\to Y in 𝒜q\mathcal A_q and model morphisms X→YX\to Y for Y∈𝒜qY\in\mathcal A_q.✦ The category 𝒜q\mathcal A_q admits all small limits and colimits.