OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 4. Partial cylinders and elementary expansions

Lemma 4.1 [Skeletal gluing]: Whisker and disk presentations with lifting properties for comparison maps

Skeletal stages from partial lifting data.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A partially specified cylinder gives compatible maps on cells through a chosen dimension, together with a prescribed map on the whole globular set. Skeletal gluing concerns the objects that represent these data and the extension problems between successive stages.

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has objects the nonnegative integers, adjacent source and target inclusions ฯƒj,ฯ„j:jโ†’j+1\sigma_j,\tau_j:j\to j+1, and two morphisms kโ†’jk\to j for k<jk<j, subject to the globular relations. A globular set TT is a family of cell sets TjT_j with source and target maps s,t:Tj+1โ†’Tjs,t:T_{j+1}\to T_j satisfying ss=stss=st and ts=ttts=tt.โœฆ Equivalently, it is a presheaf on ๐”พ\mathbb G; the action of a proper face is the iterated source or target boundary map. A globular morphism f:Tโ†’Uf:T\to U between globular sets is a family of functions fj:Tjโ†’Ujf_j:T_j\to U_j commuting with source and target; composition of globular morphisms is dimensionwise. Passing between the presheaf and cell descriptions leaves the cell sets and the components of morphisms unchanged. Write dj=๐”พ(โˆ’,j)d_j=\mathbb G(-,j) for the representable globular disk.

Two positive-dimensional cells x,yx,y of the same dimension in a globular set TT are parallel when they have the same source and target; all zero-cells of TT are parallel.โœฆ The set โˆ‚jT\partial_jT of jj-boundaries is defined by (1); the boundary of a positive-dimensional cell is its source-target pair, and a globular morphism acts on both entries. โˆ‚0T={*},โˆ‚j+1T={(x,y)โˆˆTjร—Tj:x and y are parallel}.\partial_0T=\{*\},\qquad \partial_{j+1}T=\{(x,y)\in T_j\times T_j:x\text{ and }y\text{ are parallel}\}.(1)

A globular frame ๐’Ÿ\mathcal D in a cocomplete category ๐’ฆ\mathcal K consists of disk objects DjD_j, boundary objects โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j, maps Ij:โˆ‚Djโ†’DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j, and maps โ„“j,rj:Djโ†’โˆ‚Dj+1\ell_j,r_j:D_j\to\partial D_{j+1} exhibiting the pushouts in (2).โœฆ Its associated coglobular object has adjacent maps ฯƒj๐’Ÿ=Ij+1โ„“j\sigma_j^{\mathcal D}=I_{j+1}\ell_j and ฯ„j๐’Ÿ=Ij+1rj\tau_j^{\mathcal D}=I_{j+1}r_j; the iterated face inclusions give its functor ๐”พโ†’๐’ฆ\mathbb G\to\mathcal K. โˆ‚D0โ‰…0,โˆ‚Dj+1โ‰…Djโˆโˆ‚DjDj,with coprojections โ„“j,rj.\partial D_0\cong 0,\qquad \partial D_{j+1}\cong D_j\amalg_{\partial D_j}D_j, \quad\text{with coprojections }\ell_j,r_j.(2)

Let โ„ฌ\mathcal B be another globular frame, with objects PjP_j, boundaries โˆ‚Pj\partial P_j and boundary inclusions IjPI_j^P. A frame morphism e:๐’Ÿโ†’โ„ฌe:\mathcal D\to\mathcal B consists of maps ej:Djโ†’Pje_j:D_j\to P_j and โˆ‚ej:โˆ‚Djโ†’โˆ‚Pj\partial e_j:\partial D_j\to\partial P_j commuting with the boundary inclusions and both coprojections.โœฆ

For an object YY of ๐’ฆ\mathcal K, the globular nerve Nโ„ฌ(Y)N_{\mathcal B}(Y) of the frame โ„ฌ\mathcal B is the globular set with jj-cells ๐’ฆ(Pj,Y)\mathcal K(P_j,Y) and boundaries given by precomposition with the coglobular maps. Postcomposition by a map Yโ†’ZY\to Z acts on this nerve, and precomposition by ee gives e*:Nโ„ฌ(Y)โ†’N๐’Ÿ(Y)e^*:N_{\mathcal B}(Y)\to N_{\mathcal D}(Y). The realization Fโ„ฌF_{\mathcal B} associated to the frame โ„ฌ\mathcal B is the functor from globular sets to ๐’ฆ\mathcal K characterized by the adjunction (3).โœฆ Write ฮทโ„ฌ,T\eta_{\mathcal B,T} for its unit and ฮนj(x):Pjโ†’Fโ„ฌ(T)\iota_j(x):P_j\to F_{\mathcal B}(T) for the cell inclusions; descent sends a diagram g:Tโ†’Nโ„ฌ(Y)g:T\to N_{\mathcal B}(Y) to the corresponding realization map. The realization of a representable globular disk is canonically isomorphic to the corresponding disk object of the frame. ๐’ฆ(Fโ„ฌ(T),Y)โ‰…Hom⁡(T,Nโ„ฌ(Y)),Fโ„ฌ(dj)โ‰…Pj.\mathcal K(F_{\mathcal B}(T),Y) \cong\operatorname{Hom}(T,N_{\mathcal B}(Y)),\qquad F_{\mathcal B}(d_j)\cong P_j.(3)

Boundary representation is the natural bijection (4), taking restriction along IjPI_j^P to the cell boundary map.โœฆ A cell v:Pjโ†’Yv:P_j\to Y determines its disk diagram by sending a face x:kโ†’jx:k\to j to vโ„ฌ(x)v\mathcal B(x).โœฆ ๐’ฆ(โˆ‚Pj,Y)โ‰…โˆ‚jNโ„ฌ(Y).\mathcal K(\partial P_j,Y)\cong\partial_jN_{\mathcal B}(Y).(4)

Partial Lifting Presentations

For a diagram f:Tโ†’N๐’Ÿ(Y)f:T\to N_{\mathcal D}(Y) and a frame morphism e:๐’Ÿโ†’โ„ฌe:\mathcal D\to\mathcal B, a partial lift aa of ff through dimension mm along ee is a family aj:Tjโ†’๐’ฆ(Pj,Y)a_j:T_j\to\mathcal K(P_j,Y), for jโ‰คmj\le m, commuting with source and target wherever defined and satisfying (5).โœฆ The set Lm(e,f)L_m(e,f) consists of the partial lifts of the diagram f:Tโ†’N๐’Ÿ(Y)f:T\to N_{\mathcal D}(Y) through dimension mm along the frame morphism e:๐’Ÿโ†’โ„ฌe:\mathcal D\to\mathcal B. Restriction discards the dimensions above a smaller cutoff.โœฆ For xโˆˆTm+1x\in T_{m+1}, its next lifted boundary is (am(sx),am(tx))(a_m(sx),a_m(tx)).โœฆ aj(x)ej=fj(x)(jโ‰คm,xโˆˆTj).a_j(x)e_j=f_j(x)\qquad(j\le m,\ x\in T_j).(5)

A partial lifting presentation Qm(T)Q_m(T) of a globular set TT through dimension mm along a frame morphism e:๐’Ÿโ†’โ„ฌe:\mathcal D\to\mathcal B is an object of ๐’ฆ\mathcal K representing the pairs (f,a)(f,a) in (6).โœฆ Its universal pair is denoted (b,u)(b,u); descent desc⁡(f,a)\operatorname{desc}(f,a) is the unique map carrying (b,u)(b,u) to (f,a)(f,a). ๐’ฆ(Qm(T),Y)โ‰…โˆf:Tโ†’N๐’Ÿ(Y)Lm(e,f).\mathcal K(Q_m(T),Y) \cong\coprod_{f:T\to N_{\mathcal D}(Y)}L_m(e,f).(6)

For partial lifting presentations UU and VV of a globular set TT through dimensions nn and mm, where nโ‰คmn\le m, the comparison map cn,m:Uโ†’Vc_{n,m}:U\to V is the descent in (7).โœฆ A complete diagram Tโ†’Nโ„ฌ(Y)T\to N_{\mathcal B}(Y) gives a full lifting stage by restriction through mm.โœฆ cn,m:Uโ†’V,cn,m=desc⁡U(bV,uV|โ‰คn).c_{n,m}:U\longrightarrow V,\qquad c_{n,m}=\operatorname{desc}_U(b_V,u_V|_{\le n}).(7)

The one-sided boundary object AjA_j and its attachment map ฮบj\kappa_j are defined by (8). For a kk-face xx of dj+1d_{j+1} with kโ‰คjk\le j, let ฮฒj,k(x):Pkโ†’โˆ‚Pj+1\beta_{j,k}(x):P_k\to\partial P_{j+1} be its boundary inclusion. On the two top faces these are the two coprojections; on lower faces they are the corresponding iterated face inclusion followed by the left coprojection.โœฆ The one-sided disk lifting stage has cells inl⁡ฮฒj,k(x)\operatorname{inl}\beta_{j,k}(x) and base the disk diagram of inr⁡:Dj+1โ†’Aj+1\operatorname{inr}:D_{j+1}\to A_{j+1}.โœฆ Aj=โˆ‚Pjโˆโˆ‚DjDj,ฮบj=[IjP,ej]:Ajโ†’Pj.A_j=\partial P_j\amalg_{\partial D_j}D_j,\qquad \kappa_j=[I_j^P,e_j]:A_j\longrightarrow P_j.(8)

Critical dimension data at (n,ฮต)(n,\varepsilon), with ฮตโˆˆ{0,1}\varepsilon\in\{0,1\}, consist of isomorphisms eje_j for j<nj<n and an isomorphism ฯ‡:Pnโ†’โˆผDn+1\chi:P_n\xrightarrow{\sim}D_{n+1} satisfying (9).โœฆ Here ฮดn0=ฯƒn๐’Ÿ\delta_n^0=\sigma_n^{\mathcal D} and ฮดn1=ฯ„n๐’Ÿ\delta_n^1=\tau_n^{\mathcal D}. ฯ‡en=ฮดnฮต.\chi e_n=\delta_n^\varepsilon.(9)

The whiskered globular set TnฮตT_n^\varepsilon contains the original cells of TT, a new tip xโ€ฒx' in dimension nn, and an edge wxw_x in dimension n+1n+1 for each xโˆˆTnx\in T_n.โœฆ A tip has the boundary of its label in the original copy. The edge goes from xx to xโ€ฒx' for ฮต=0\varepsilon=0 and from xโ€ฒx' to xx for ฮต=1\varepsilon=1. Write i:Tโ†’Tnฮตi:T\to T_n^\varepsilon for the base inclusion. For a diagram f:Tโ†’N๐’Ÿ(Y)f:T\to N_{\mathcal D}(Y) and chosen (n+1)(n+1)-cells with prescribed ฮต\varepsilon-endpoint fn(x)f_n(x), the oriented whisker extension is the diagram on TnฮตT_n^\varepsilon extending ff that sends wxw_x to the chosen cell and xโ€ฒx' to its opposite endpoint.โœฆ

For critical dimension data, a whisker diagram g:Tnฮตโ†’N๐’Ÿ(Y)g:T_n^\varepsilon\to N_{\mathcal D}(Y) determines initial lifted cells ฮปj(g,x):Pjโ†’Y\lambda_j(g,x):P_j\to Y through dimension nn: below nn they are gj(x)ejโˆ’1g_j(x)e_j^{-1}, and at nn they are gn+1(wx)ฯ‡g_{n+1}(w_x)\chi.โœฆ These cells form its initial lifting stage.โœฆ Conversely, a partial lift (f,a)(f,a) gives a whisker diagram whose added edge at xx is an(x)ฯ‡โˆ’1a_n(x)\chi^{-1}.โœฆ More generally, cellwise factorizations through the eje_j through dimension nn form a lifting stage under the same critical data.โœฆ

The Claim

Write vโ‹”pv\pitchfork p when vv has the left lifting property with respect to pp.

Theorem 1 (Skeletal gluing). Let e:๐’Ÿโ†’โ„ฌe:\mathcal D\to\mathcal B be a morphism of globular frames in a cocomplete category, and let TT be a globular set.

For critical dimension data at (n,ฮต)(n,\varepsilon), the whisker presentation is (Qnwh(T);b,u)=(F๐’Ÿ(Tnฮต);ฮท๐’Ÿ,Tnฮตi,ฮป(ฮท๐’Ÿ,Tnฮต)).\bigl(Q_n^{\mathrm{wh}}(T);b,u\bigr) =\bigl(F_{\mathcal D}(T_n^\varepsilon); \eta_{\mathcal D,T_n^\varepsilon}i, \lambda(\eta_{\mathcal D,T_n^\varepsilon})\bigr).(10)โœฆ For every jโ‰ฅ0j\ge0, the one-sided disk presentation, with the base and lifting stage specified above, is Qjโˆ‚(dj+1)=Aj+1.Q_j^{\partial}(d_{j+1})=A_{j+1}.(11)โœฆ If TjT_j is empty for j>mj>m, the full realization presentation, with base e*ฮทโ„ฌ,Te^*\eta_{\mathcal B,T} and stage ฮทโ„ฌ,T|โ‰คm\eta_{\mathcal B,T}|_{\le m}, is Qmfull(T)=Fโ„ฌ(T).Q_m^{\mathrm{full}}(T)=F_{\mathcal B}(T).(12)โœฆ Let nโ‰คmn\le m, let U,VU,V be presentations through n,mn,m, respectively, and let p:Xโ†’Yp:X\to Y have the right lifting property against ฮบj\kappa_j for every n<jโ‰คmn<j\le m. Then cn,mโ‹”p.c_{n,m}\pitchfork p.(13)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: fix a cutoff qq, 0โ‰คn<q0\le n<q, the higher elementary-expansion assertions E(q,j)E(q,j), an endpoint ฮตโˆˆ{0,1}\varepsilon\in\{0,1\}, and a finite globular set TT with constructed cylinder levels PP; writing FF for free realization, sk⁡โ„“T\operatorname{sk}_\ell T for the โ„“\ell-skeleton of TT, and Cโ„“(T)=F(T)โˆF(sk⁡โ„“T)P(sk⁡โ„“T)C_\ell(T)=F(T)\amalg_{F(\operatorname{sk}_\ell T)} P(\operatorname{sk}_\ell T) using endpoint ฮต\varepsilon, for โ„“>n\ell>n the object Cโ„“(T)C_\ell(T) is the pushout of the coproduct of Aโ„“ฮตโ†’Pโ„“A_\ell^\varepsilon\to P_\ell over the actual โ„“\ell-cells of TT along their prescribed-data maps into Cโ„“โˆ’1(T)C_{\ell-1}(T), while for a pasting scheme SS one has Cn(S)=Hฮต(S)C_n(S)=H_\varepsilon(S), the initial whisker, Cjโˆ’1(dj)=AjฮตC_{j-1}(d_j)=A_j^\varepsilon for j>nj>n, and Cdim⁡S(S)=P(S)C_{\dim S}(S)=P(S).

What Is Checked

The presentations in (10), (11) and (12), and the comparison property (13), are stated over a morphism of globular frames in a cocomplete category; the whisker presentation uses critical dimension data, and the full presentation uses the absence of cells above its cutoff.

The initial lifted cells satisfy the factorization in (14). For a disk diagram ff and its partial lift aa through jj, boundary representation sends the next lifted boundary of the top cell to an induced boundary extension ha:โˆ‚Pj+1โ†’Yh_a:\partial P_{j+1}\to Y, whose compatibility is (15). ฮปj(g,x)ej=gj(i(x))(jโ‰คn).\lambda_j(g,x)e_j=g_j(i(x))\qquad(j\le n).(14)โœฆ haโˆ‚ej+1=fj+1(id⁡j+1)Ij+1.h_a\,\partial e_{j+1} =f_{j+1}(\operatorname{id}_{j+1})I_{j+1}.(15)โœฆ