OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 3. Cutoffs, spines and tree diagrams

Proposition 3.8 [Contractibility after adjoining whiskers]: For natural numbers n≤qn\le q and every finite globular sum, under expansion contraction at source threshold n+1n+1

Uniformly whiskered free models admit boundary fillers.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Adjoining whiskers to a globular pasting diagram introduces new cells with prescribed endpoints. The contractibility question concerns fillers for all boundaries in the free model on the enlarged diagram, after imposing uniqueness of fillers above a cutoff.

Let 𝔾\mathbb G be the globe category, with one object in each natural-number dimension, source and target faces, and their iterates. A globular presheaf KK on the globe category 𝔾\mathbb G is a functor 𝔾op→Set\mathbb G^{\mathrm{op}}\to\mathrm{Set}; write djd_j for the representable presheaf of the jj-globe. Its source and target face maps are the Yoneda images of the corresponding faces in 𝔾\mathbb G.✦

A finite globular sum SS is an iterated gluing of globes, specified by a table of dimensions with a distinguished last globe.✦ The realization |S||S| of a finite globular sum SS is the globular presheaf obtained by its iterated gluing of globes; the single-globe shape GjG_j is the finite globular sum consisting of one jj-globe. If the last globe of SS has dimension ℓ\ell, an elementary attachment glues the source bb-face of a new hh-globe to the target bb-face of that last globe, as in (1): |S∪bGh|=|S|∐dbdh,b<ℓ,b<h.|S\cup_b G_h|=|S|\amalg_{d_b}d_h, \qquad b<\ell,\quad b<h.(1) The maps from |S||S| and dhd_h are the pushout inclusions, and the latter is the new last globe inclusion. The dimension dim⁡S\dim S is the greatest dimension in its table.✦ For b<ℓb<\ell, the gluing face inclusion Gb→SG_b\to S is the target bb-face inclusion of the last globe followed by its inclusion into SS.

A globular theory CC is a category with finite globular sums as objects and a structural arity functor from shapes, fixing those objects and preserving the elementary pushouts in (1).✦ A morphism f:C→C′f:C\to C' of globular theories is a functor fixing the finite globular sums that are their objects and preserving the structural maps.✦ Two operations a,b:Gj→Sa,b:G_j\to S are parallel when their source and target restrictions agree, with no condition in dimension zero.✦ A parallel pair of operations a,b:Gj→Sa,b:G_j\to S in a globular theory CC is admissible when dim⁡S≤j+1\dim S\le j+1.✦ A filler z:Gj+1→Sz:G_{j+1}\to S for a parallel pair of operations a,b:Gj→Sa,b:G_j\to S in a globular theory CC is an operation with source aa and target bb. For a morphism F:C→DF:C\to D of globular theories and an admissible pair (a,b)(a,b) in CC, an operation z:Gj+1→Sz:G_{j+1}\to S in DD fills the pair relative to FF when its source is F(a)F(a) and its target is F(b)F(b).✦

A cellular presentation (Ck)(C_k) of a globular theory CC is a sequence of globular theories starting at an initial theory, with each successive theory freely adjoining fillers for a family of admissible pairs, and with colimit CC.✦ Freeness means that a morphism from the next stage is uniquely specified by a morphism from the preceding stage together with chosen fillers for that family.✦ A coherator CC is a globular theory admitting a cellular presentation and having a filler for every admissible pair of operations in CC.✦ Fix a coherator CC.

Globular Boundaries and Models

A globular set KK is a family of cell sets KjK_j with source and target maps s,t:Kj+1→Kjs,t:K_{j+1}\to K_j satisfying ss=stss=st and ts=ttts=tt.✦ Its associated globular presheaf acts on longer faces by iterated source and target maps. A morphism f:K→Lf:K\to L of globular sets is a family of cell maps commuting with source and target; it acts on boundaries by applying those maps to both endpoints. Two cells x,yx,y of the same positive dimension in a globular set KK are parallel when their sources and targets agree, and all zero-dimensional cells of KK are parallel.✦ The boundary sets and boundary maps of KK are given by (2): B0(K)={*},∂0K(x)=*,Bj+1(K)={(x,y)∈Kj2:x∥y},∂j+1K(z)=(s(z),t(z)).\begin{aligned} B_0(K)&=\{*\}, &\partial^K_0(x)&=*,\\ B_{j+1}(K)&=\{(x,y)\in K_j^2:x\parallel y\}, &\partial^K_{j+1}(z)&=(s(z),t(z)). \end{aligned}(2) A globular set KK is contractible when it has fillers for every boundary, including the empty boundary in dimension zero; write Fill⁡(K)\operatorname{Fill}(K) for the property in (3): Fill⁡(K)⇔∂jK:Kj→Bj(K) is surjective for every j≥0.\operatorname{Fill}(K) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \partial^K_j:K_j\longrightarrow B_j(K) \text{ is surjective for every }j\ge0.(3)✦ The underlying globular set of a globular presheaf PP has jj-cells P(j)P(j), with source and target maps given by the action of PP on the source and target faces. A globular map f:K→Lf:K\to L induces a morphism between their associated globular presheaves whose component at the jj-globe is the cell map fjf_j. A morphism of globular presheaves induces a map of their underlying globular sets by taking its components at the globes.

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC taking elementary globular sums to pullbacks.✦ Write Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C) for their category, with natural transformations as morphisms. The underlying globular set UXUX of a model XX is its restriction along the globe inclusion 𝔾→C\mathbb G\to C; thus (UX)j=X(Gj)(UX)_j=X(G_j).✦ Restriction of a model morphism gives its underlying globular map.✦ The free model C(−,S)C(-,S) on a finite globular sum SS is the representable presheaf of SS in CC.✦ Write Dj=C(−,Gj)D_j=C(-,G_j) for the free jj-disk.✦ The canonical boundary representing model ∂Dj\partial D_j has an inclusion Ij:∂Dj→DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j whose restriction map corresponds to the cell boundary map under the natural bijections (4): Mod⁡(C)(Dj,X)≅(UX)j,Mod⁡(C)(∂Dj,X)≅Bj(UX).\operatorname{Mod}(C)(D_j,X)\cong(UX)_j, \qquad \operatorname{Mod}(C)(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_j(UX).(4)✦ The source inclusion Jj:Dj→Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1} is induced by the source face of globes.✦

Free Cutoff Models and Whiskers

For a natural number qq, a cutoff model XX of CC at level qq is a model for which ∂jUX\partial^{UX}_j is bijective whenever j>qj>q.✦ Let 𝒜q\mathcal A_q be the full subcategory of these models.✦ The coskeletal reflection RqXR_qX of a model XX is a cutoff model with a universal map ηX:X→RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX, characterized by (5), where YY belongs to 𝒜q\mathcal A_q: 𝒜q(RqX,Y)≅Mod⁡(C)(X,Y),h↦h∘ηX.\mathcal A_q(R_qX,Y)\cong\operatorname{Mod}(C)(X,Y), \qquad h\longmapsto h\circ\eta_X.(5)

The globular-sum comparison map γS\gamma_S of an elementary globular sum SS in CC is the map from the corresponding pushout of representable presheaves to the representable of SS.✦ A presheaf XX on CC is local for the globular-sum comparison maps when mapping each such map into XX gives a bijection. Reflection into these local presheaves gives the model reflector.✦ The free globular model functor FF is left Kan extension along the opposite globe inclusion followed by this reflector.✦ The free cutoff model functor is ℱq=RqF\mathcal F_q=R_qF.✦

Let KK be a globular set, nn a natural number, and ε∈{+,−}\varepsilon\in\{+,-\} an orientation. The uniformly whiskered globular set WnεKW_n^\varepsilon K retains every cell of KK and adjoins, for each x∈Knx\in K_n, a tip xˆ\widehat x in dimension nn and a joining cell exe_x in dimension n+1n+1. The tip has the same boundary as xx when n>0n>0. In the forward orientation, the joining cell exe_x has source xx and target xˆ\widehat x; in the reverse orientation, it has source xˆ\widehat x and target xx. All old source and target maps remain those of KK. For a globular map f:K→Lf:K\to L, its whiskered map sends each original cell to its image under ff, each tip indexed by xx to the tip indexed by f(x)f(x), and each joining cell indexed by xx to the joining cell indexed by f(x)f(x).✦ Taking associated presheaves gives the globular whiskering functor.✦

The free forward and reverse whisker models H+(S)H_+(S) and H−(S)H_-(S) of a finite globular sum SS at the fixed levels q,nq,n are defined in (6); whiskering is applied to the globular set underlying |S||S| and then regarded as a presheaf: Hε(S)=ℱq(Wnε|S|)in 𝒜q,ε∈{+,−}.H_\varepsilon(S)=\mathcal F_q\bigl(W_n^\varepsilon|S|\bigr) \quad\text{in }\mathcal A_q, \qquad \varepsilon\in\{+,-\}.(6)

The Preservation Hypothesis

The reflected disks and boundaries are RqDjR_qD_j and Rq∂DjR_q\partial D_j, with reflected inclusions RqIjR_qI_j and RqJjR_qJ_j. For a lower bound rr, the generating boundary and source inclusions are the families in (7): ℐq,≥r={RqIj:j≥r},𝒥q,≥r={RqJj:j≥r}.\mathcal I_{q,\ge r}=\{R_qI_j:j\ge r\}, \qquad \mathcal J_{q,\ge r}=\{R_qJ_j:j\ge r\}.(7) For a class 𝒦\mathcal K of maps, write 𝒦⋔\mathcal K^\pitchfork for the maps with the right lifting property against 𝒦\mathcal K, and ⋔𝒦{}^\pitchfork\mathcal K for those with the left lifting property. A cutoff model XX is cofibrant when every map X→QX\to Q lifts through every p:P→Qp:P\to Q in ℐq,≥0⋔\mathcal I_{q,\ge0}^\pitchfork.✦

The expansion contraction property 𝖤𝖢(q,r)\mathsf{EC}(q,r) is the preservation condition that, for every map i:X→Yi:X\to Y in ⋔(𝒥q,≥r⋔){}^\pitchfork(\mathcal J_{q,\ge r}^\pitchfork) with XX cofibrant and UXUX contractible, the globular set UYUY is contractible.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be a coherator, let n≤qn\le q be natural numbers, and assume 𝖤𝖢(q,n+1)\mathsf{EC}(q,n+1). For every finite globular sum SS, the free forward whisker model satisfies Fill⁡(UH+(S)).\operatorname{Fill}\bigl(UH_+(S)\bigr).(8)✦ The free reverse whisker model satisfies Fill⁡(UH−(S)).\operatorname{Fill}\bigl(UH_-(S)\bigr).(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: fix 0≤n<q0\le n<q and assume its conditions E(q,j)E(q,j) for every n<j≤qn<j\le q; then Hε(S)H_\varepsilon(S) is contractible for every finite globular sum SS with dim⁡S≤q\dim S\le q and both orientations ε\varepsilon, with the same conclusion when each nn-cell’s join is oriented independently.

What Is Checked

The claims (8) and (9) are stated over the underlying globular sets of free cutoff models on uniformly whiskered realizations of finite globular sums, for a coherator CC, natural numbers n≤qn\le q, and the expansion contraction hypothesis 𝖤𝖢(q,n+1)\mathsf{EC}(q,n+1).

The unit of the coskeletal reflection is bijective on cells in dimensions at most qq.✦ The reflection bijection (5) commutes with postcomposition by maps in 𝒜q\mathcal A_q.✦