OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 3. Cutoffs, spines and tree diagrams

ยง3 (setting): whiskered shapes: Free cutoff models for uniformly adjoined comparisons between cells of a fixed dimension and their copies

Whiskering globular diagrams in either direction.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix a dimension nn. The problem is to adjoin a parallel companion to every nn-cell of a globular diagram, with an (n+1)(n+1)-cell in one chosen direction between the pair. For a coherator CC, the associated free models are taken with unique boundary fillers above a cutoff qq.

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has one object jj in every natural-number dimension.โœฆ Its morphisms are identities and, for m<jm<j, a source face ฯƒm,j\sigma_{m,j} and a target face ฯ„m,j\tau_{m,j}.โœฆ Write ฯƒj\sigma_j and ฯ„j\tau_j for the faces from jj to j+1j+1. A globular presheaf PP is a contravariant set-valued functor on ๐”พ\mathbb G; write ๐”พห†\widehat{\mathbb G} for the category of these presheaves.โœฆ The representable disk DjD_j is ๐”พ(โˆ’,j)\mathbb G(-,j)โœฆ; its face maps are the Yoneda images of the corresponding globe faces.โœฆ

A globular set GG is a family of sets GjG_j with maps sj,tj:Gj+1โ†’Gjs_j,t_j:G_{j+1}\to G_j satisfying (1). sjsj+1=sjtj+1,tjsj+1=tjtj+1(jโ‰ฅ0).s_j s_{j+1}=s_j t_{j+1}, \qquad t_j s_{j+1}=t_j t_{j+1} \quad (j\geq 0).(1)โœฆ The underlying globular set U(P)U(P) of a globular presheaf PP is the globular set with U(P)j=P(j)U(P)_j=P(j) and faces induced by ฯƒj\sigma_j and ฯ„j\tau_j. The associated presheaf PGP_G of a globular set GG is the globular presheaf that takes jj to GjG_j. Its action on a face from mm to jj first takes source faces down to dimension m+1m+1, then takes the source or target face in dimension mm; identities act identically.โœฆ A globular morphism f:Gโ†’Hf:G\to H is a family fj:Gjโ†’Hjf_j:G_j\to H_j commuting with source and target.โœฆ Its associated presheaf morphism has components fjf_jโœฆ, and a natural transformation of globular presheaves induces a globular morphism by taking these same components.โœฆ

Two cells a,ba,b of a globular set GG are parallel if they are zero-dimensional, or if they have the same source and target.โœฆ The boundary sets Bj(G)\mathrm B_j(G) and the boundary map โˆ‚j\partial_j are given by (2). B0(G)={*},โˆ‚0(x)=*,Bj+1(G)={(a,b)โˆˆGjร—Gj:a and b are parallel},โˆ‚j+1(x)=(sjx,tjx).\begin{aligned} \mathrm B_0(G)&=\{*\}, & \partial_0(x)&=*, \\ \mathrm B_{j+1}(G)&=\{(a,b)\in G_j\times G_j:a\text{ and }b\text{ are parallel}\}, & \partial_{j+1}(x)&=(s_jx,t_jx). \end{aligned}(2)

Globular Arities and Coherators

A table of dimensions TT is a specification of an iterated globular sum that starts with one globe and successively attaches a globe along a lower-dimensional face.โœฆ A shape SS is a finite globular sum specified by such a table, with a distinguished last globe.โœฆ Write โŸจSโŸฉ\langle S\rangle for its globular presheaf realization and ฮปS:Dโ„“โ†’โŸจSโŸฉ\lambda_S:D_\ell\to\langle S\rangle for its last globe inclusion, where โ„“\ell is the last dimension. For a single globe, the realization is Dโ„“D_\ell and the last globe inclusion is the identity. If b<โ„“b<\ell and b<hb<h, the attached shape SโˆชbDhS\cup_bD_h has realization (3). โŸจSโˆชbDhโŸฉ=โŸจSโŸฉโˆDbDh,Dbโ†’ฮปSโˆ˜ฯ„b,โ„“โŸจSโŸฉ,Dbโ†’ฯƒb,hDh.\langle S\cup_bD_h\rangle = \langle S\rangle \amalg_{D_b}D_h, \qquad D_b\xrightarrow{\lambda_S\circ\tau_{b,\ell}}\langle S\rangle, \quad D_b\xrightarrow{\sigma_{b,h}}D_h.(3) The two pushout maps are the previous arity inclusion and the attached globe inclusion; the latter is the new last globe inclusion. The dimension dim⁡S\dim S of a shape SS is the largest globe dimension in the table of SS, equal to jj on a single jj-globe and updated by taking the maximum with hh at an attachment.โœฆ The gluing face inclusion Dbโ†’โŸจSโŸฉD_b\to\langle S\rangle, for bb smaller than the last dimension of SS, is the inclusion of the target bb-face of its last globe.

Let ฮ˜0\Theta_0 be the category of shapes. A category BB under globular arities is a category with shapes as objects and an identity-on-objects arity functor from ฮ˜0\Theta_0.โœฆ A globular theory BB is a category under globular arities whose arity functor preserves the pushouts in (3).โœฆ A theory morphism a:Bโ†’Ea:B\to E between globular theories BB and EE is a functor fixing shapes and preserving the structural arity maps.โœฆ The globe inclusion into shapes sends a globe to its single-globe shape and faces to representable disk faces.โœฆ Its composite with the arity functor of a theory BB is the globe inclusion ฮณB:๐”พโ†’B\gamma_B:\mathbb G\to B.โœฆ

Two operations u,v:Djโ†’Su,v:D_j\to S in a globular theory BB are parallel if j=0j=0, or if their restrictions to both faces of DjD_j agree.โœฆ An admissible pair u,v:Djโ†’Su,v:D_j\to S in a globular theory BB is a parallel pair of operations with dim⁡Sโ‰คj+1\dim S\leq j+1.โœฆ For a theory morphism a:Bโ†’Ea:B\to E and an admissible pair u,v:Djโ†’Su,v:D_j\to S in BB, a filler z:Dj+1โ†’Sz:D_{j+1}\to S for the image of the pair is an operation in EE satisfying (4). zโˆ˜ฯƒj=a(u),zโˆ˜ฯ„j=a(v).z\circ\sigma_j=a(u), \qquad z\circ\tau_j=a(v).(4)โœฆ Here faces in a theory mean their structural images.

A free extension Bโ†’Bโ€ฒB\to B' by a family of admissible pairs in BB is a theory morphism with specified fillers for that family such that every theory morphism from BB equipped with fillers for the image pairs extends uniquely to Bโ€ฒB' with the prescribed filler images.โœฆ A cellular presentation B0โ†’B1โ†’โ‹ฏB_0\to B_1\to\cdots of a globular theory BB is a sequence starting at an initial theory, with each transition a free extension by a family of admissible pairs, and compatible inclusions exhibiting BB as its colimit.โœฆ A coherator CC is a globular theory that admits a cellular presentation and has a filler for every admissible pair.โœฆ

Free Models and Cutoffs

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC that sends every elementary globular sum to a pullback.โœฆ Write Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C) for the category of models. The underlying globular set U(X)U(X) of a model XX of CC is obtained by restricting its presheaf along ฮณC\gamma_C and taking the underlying globular set of that restriction.โœฆ A model morphism induces a globular morphism by restricting its natural transformation in the same way.โœฆ

Write yCy_C for the Yoneda embedding of CC. For an elementary gluing indexed by (S,b,h)(S,b,h) with b<โ„“b<\ell and b<hb<h, the globular sum comparison map is (5). ฮบS,b,h:yCSโˆyCDbyCDhโ†’yC(SโˆชbDh).\kappa_{S,b,h}: y_CS\amalg_{y_CD_b}y_CD_h \longrightarrow y_C(S\cup_bD_h).(5)โœฆ The gluing cospan in CopC^{\mathrm{op}} is obtained by reversing the two maps from DbD_b in (3)โœฆ, and its globular sum dual cone has vertex SโˆชbDhS\cup_bD_h and legs opposite to the two arity inclusions.โœฆ A presheaf XX on CC is local for the sum comparisons if precomposition with every map (5) is a bijection on morphisms into XX.

Let โ„›C\mathcal R_C denote the free model functor from presheaves on CC to Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C). The free globular model functor FCF_C is defined using left Kan extension along ฮณCop\gamma_C^{\mathrm{op}}, as in (6).โœฆ For a natural number qq, let ๐’œq\mathcal A_q be the full subcategory of models XX for which โˆ‚j:U(X)jโ†’Bj(U(X))\partial_j:U(X)_j\to\mathrm B_j(U(X)) is bijective for every j>qj>q.โœฆ A model XX of CC is coskeletal at cutoff qq if XX belongs to ๐’œq\mathcal A_q. Write RqR_q for coskeletal reflection and ฮทX:Xโ†’RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX for its unit. The free cutoff model functor FqF_q is the composite in (6). FC=โ„›Cโˆ˜Lan⁡ฮณCop,Fq=Rqโˆ˜FC:๐”พห†โ†’๐’œq.F_C=\mathcal R_C\circ\operatorname{Lan}_{\gamma_C^{\mathrm{op}}}, \qquad F_q=R_q\circ F_C: \widehat{\mathbb G}\longrightarrow\mathcal A_q.(6)

Cells and Their Faces

For a globular set GG and a dimension nn, the family of whiskered cells En(G)E_n(G) consists of an original cell [x][x] for every cell xx of GG, a tip xโ€ฒx' for each xโˆˆGnx\in G_n, and an edge exe_x for each xโˆˆGnx\in G_n, in the dimensions specified by (7). En(G)k={{[x]:xโˆˆGn}โˆ{xโ€ฒ:xโˆˆGn},k=n,{[x]:xโˆˆGn+1}โˆ{ex:xโˆˆGn},k=n+1,{[x]:xโˆˆGk},kโ‰ n,n+1.E_n(G)_k= \begin{cases} \{[x]:x\in G_n\}\amalg\{x':x\in G_n\},&k=n,\\ \{[x]:x\in G_{n+1}\}\amalg\{e_x:x\in G_n\},&k=n+1,\\ \{[x]:x\in G_k\},&k\ne n,\ n+1. \end{cases}(7)โœฆ Choose an orientation ฯตโˆˆ{0,1}\epsilon\in\{0,1\}. The whiskered source and target maps sฯต,tฯตs^\epsilon,t^\epsilon on (7) are defined by (8); the formulas for tips apply when n>0n>0. sฯต[x]=[sx],tฯต[x]=[tx],sฯตxโ€ฒ=[sx],tฯตxโ€ฒ=[tx],(sฯตex,tฯตex)={([x],xโ€ฒ),ฯต=0,(xโ€ฒ,[x]),ฯต=1.\begin{aligned} s^\epsilon[x]&=[sx], & t^\epsilon[x]&=[tx], \\ s^\epsilon x'&=[sx], & t^\epsilon x'&=[tx], \\ (s^\epsilon e_x,t^\epsilon e_x)&= \begin{cases} ([x],x'),&\epsilon=0,\\ (x',[x]),&\epsilon=1. \end{cases} \end{aligned}(8) For a globular morphism f:Gโ†’Hf:G\to H, its whiskered morphism acts by [x]โ†ฆ[f(x)][x]\mapsto[f(x)], xโ€ฒโ†ฆf(x)โ€ฒx'\mapsto f(x)', and exโ†ฆef(x)e_x\mapsto e_{f(x)}.โœฆ

The Definition

Definition 1. Let GG be a globular set, nn a natural number, and ฯตโˆˆ{0,1}\epsilon\in\{0,1\}. The whiskered globular set WnฯตGW_n^\epsilon G is (9), with cells and faces from (7) and (8). WnฯตG=(En(G),sฯต,tฯต).W_n^\epsilon G = \bigl(E_n(G),s^\epsilon,t^\epsilon\bigr).(9)โœฆ The globular whiskering functor ๐’ฒnฯต\mathcal W_n^\epsilon on presheaves is defined by (10); on morphisms it is the associated presheaf morphism of the whiskered underlying globular morphism. ๐’ฒnฯต(P)=PWnฯตU(P).\mathcal W_n^\epsilon(P)=P_{W_n^\epsilon U(P)}.(10)โœฆ For a coherator CC, natural numbers q,nq,n, and a globular presheaf PP, the free forward whisker model Wh⁡qn(P)\operatorname{Wh}_q^n(P) is the object of ๐’œq\mathcal A_q defined by (11). Wh⁡qn(P)=Fq(๐’ฒn0(P))โˆˆ๐’œq.\operatorname{Wh}_q^n(P)=F_q\bigl(\mathcal W_n^0(P)\bigr)\in\mathcal A_q.(11)โœฆ The free reverse whisker model Wh⁡qn,rev(P)\operatorname{Wh}_q^{n,\mathrm{rev}}(P) for a coherator CC, natural numbers q,nq,n, and a globular presheaf PP is the object of ๐’œq\mathcal A_q defined by (12). Wh⁡qn,rev(P)=Fq(๐’ฒn1(P))โˆˆ๐’œq.\operatorname{Wh}_q^{n,\mathrm{rev}}(P) = F_q\bigl(\mathcal W_n^1(P)\bigr)\in\mathcal A_q.(12)โœฆ

What Is Checked

The definitions are stated for arbitrary globular sets and globular presheaves; the free cutoff models additionally require a coherator CC and natural numbers q,nq,n.

For any globular theory, the inclusion of presheaves local for the sum comparisons has a left adjoint; regarding its value as a model gives the free model functor โ„›C\mathcal R_C. For a coherator CC, every model XX admits a coskeletal reflection whose unit is bijective on cells in dimensions at most qq.โœฆ The reflection has the hom-set bijection (13), natural in Yโˆˆ๐’œqY\in\mathcal A_q. Hom⁡๐’œq(RqX,Y)โ†’โ‰…Hom⁡Mod⁡(C)(X,Y),hโ†ฆhโˆ˜ฮทX.\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal A_q}(R_qX,Y) \xrightarrow{\ \cong\ } \operatorname{Hom}_{\operatorname{Mod}(C)}(X,Y), \qquad h\longmapsto h\circ\eta_X.(13) For any globular theory CC, a presheaf local for the sum comparisons determines a model of CC with the same underlying presheaf, and natural transformations between local presheaves give the corresponding model morphisms.