OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 3. Cutoffs, spines and tree diagrams

Lemma 3.6 [Upper-cell splitting and pushout]: Source generation and boundary filling in pushouts under expansion-contraction and cofibrancy hypotheses

Boundary cofibrations with boundary-filling source split.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A boundary attachment specifies the whole boundary of a new globular cell; a source attachment specifies its source face. The extension problems are compared in a category of globular models after a cutoff on the dimensions in which fillers may be nonunique.

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has nonnegative dimensions as objects, identity maps, and two face maps mโ†’jm\to j for m<jm<j. Write ฯƒj,ฯ„j:jโ†’j+1\sigma_j,\tau_j:j\to j+1 for its source and target inclusions. A globular presheaf XX on ๐”พ\mathbb G is a contravariant set-valued functor on ๐”พ\mathbb G.โœฆ The representable globe dj=๐”พ(โˆ’,j)d_j=\mathbb G(-,j) has face maps induced by Yoneda from those of ๐”พ\mathbb G.

A table of dimensions describes a finite globular sum SS with a distinguished last globe. It begins with a single globe and successively attaches a globe of dimension hh along a face of dimension bb, where b<hb<h and bb is smaller than the dimension of the previous last globe.โœฆ Its realization is the iterated pushout of representable globes. The gluing face is the target bb-face of the last globe, and the new globe is attached along its source bb-face. The previous arity inclusion and the attached globe inclusion are the two pushout maps; the latter becomes the new last globe inclusion. The height of SS is the greatest dimension of its globes.โœฆ

A globular theory CC is a category under these arities whose arity functor is the identity on objects and sends elementary globular gluings to pushouts.โœฆ Its morphisms are operations. A morphism f:Cโ†’Df:C\to D of globular theories is a functor that fixes arities and preserves operations under composition and identities, as well as structural arity maps.โœฆ Identity theory morphisms fix operations, and composition of theory morphisms composes their actions on operations.

Two operations u,v:djโ†’Su,v:d_j\to S in a globular theory CC are parallel if their source and target restrictions agree; in dimension zero every pair is parallel.โœฆ An admissible pair u,v:djโ†’Su,v:d_j\to S in a globular theory CC is a parallel pair of operations with height⁡(S)โ‰คj+1\operatorname{height}(S)\le j+1.โœฆ For a theory morphism f:Cโ†’Df:C\to D and an admissible pair u,v:djโ†’Su,v:d_j\to S in CC, a filler for its image in DD is an operation z:dj+1โ†’Sz:d_{j+1}\to S in DD whose source and target restrictions are f(u)f(u) and f(v)f(v).โœฆ A free extension by fillers f:Cโ†’Df:C\to D of a globular theory CC is a theory morphism adjoining specified fillers for a family of admissible pairs in CC, universal among theory morphisms with choices of fillers for those pairs.โœฆ A cellular presentation PP of a globular theory CC is a sequence starting at an initial theory, with each successor a free extension by fillers for a family of admissible pairs, whose colimit is CC.โœฆ A coherator CC is a globular theory admitting a cellular presentation and a filler for every admissible pair.โœฆ Fix such a coherator CC.

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC sending elementary globular sums to pullbacks.โœฆ Restriction along the globe inclusion, obtained from the globe arities and the arity functor, gives its underlying globular set.โœฆ A globular set XX is a sequence of cell sets XjX_j with source and target maps s,t:Xj+1โ†’Xjs,t:X_{j+1}\to X_j satisfying ss=stss=st and ts=ttts=tt.โœฆ A morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y of globular sets is a family of cell maps commuting with the source and target maps ss and tt.โœฆ Model morphisms induce such maps by restriction of their natural transformations to the globes.โœฆ

Boundaries and Cutoffs

Cells x,yโˆˆXjx,y\in X_j are parallel when they have the same source and target, with all zero-cells parallel.โœฆ The boundary sets Bj(X)B_j(X), boundary maps โˆ‚j\partial_j, and boundary-filling property ๐–ฅ(X)\mathsf F(X) are specified by (1): B0(X)={*},Bj+1(X)={(x,y)โˆˆXjร—Xj:xโˆฅy},โˆ‚0(x)=*,โˆ‚j+1(x)=(sx,tx),๐–ฅ(X)โ‡”โˆ‚j:Xjโ†’Bj(X) is surjective for every jโ‰ฅ0.\begin{gathered} B_0(X)=\{*\},\qquad B_{j+1}(X)=\{(x,y)\in X_j\times X_j:x\parallel y\},\\ \partial_0(x)=*,\qquad \partial_{j+1}(x)=(sx,tx),\\ \mathsf F(X)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \partial_j:X_j\longrightarrow B_j(X) \text{ is surjective for every }j\ge0. \end{gathered}(1) A globular map induces a map on boundaries by applying its cell maps to both members of a parallel pair and sending the unique zero-dimensional boundary to itself.โœฆ

The free model on an arity SS is the representable presheaf C(โˆ’,S)C(-,S).โœฆ Write Dj=C(โˆ’,dj)D_j=C(-,d_j) for the free jj-disk.โœฆ Its boundary โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j, with inclusion Ij:โˆ‚Djโ†’DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j, represents cell boundaries, compatibly with the Yoneda representation of cells in (2): Hom⁡(Dj,X)โ‰…Xj,Hom⁡(โˆ‚Dj,X)โ‰…Bj(X),Ij*โ†”โˆ‚j.\operatorname{Hom}(D_j,X)\cong X_j,\qquad \operatorname{Hom}(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_j(X),\qquad I_j^*\ \longleftrightarrow\ \partial_j.(2)โœฆ These boundary correspondences are natural in XX. The canonical boundary representation starts with the empty zero-dimensional boundary and iterates the successor boundary construction.โœฆ The source inclusion Jj:Djโ†’Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1} is induced by Yoneda from the structural image of the source face of the globe arity.โœฆ

For a nonnegative integer qq, a model XX of CC is qq-coskeletal if โˆ‚j\partial_j is bijective for every j>qj>q.โœฆ Let AqA_q be the full subcategory of such models.โœฆ The coskeletal reflection functor RqR_q assigns to a model XX its reflection in AqA_q, with unit ฮทX:Xโ†’RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX. Write Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C) for the category of models of CC. The universal property of the coskeletal reflection is the bijection (3), where YโˆˆAqY\in A_q: ฮฆX,Y:Hom⁡Aq(RqX,Y)โ†’โ‰…Hom⁡Mod⁡(C)(X,Y),ฮฆX,Y(h)=hโˆ˜ฮทX.\Phi_{X,Y}:\operatorname{Hom}_{A_q}(R_qX,Y) \xrightarrow{\ \cong\ }\operatorname{Hom}_{\operatorname{Mod}(C)}(X,Y), \qquad \Phi_{X,Y}(h)=h\circ\eta_X.(3)โœฆ

The Lifting Classes

For a nonnegative threshold rr, the generating boundary and source inclusions in AqA_q are the families in (4). โ„q,r={RqIj:Rqโˆ‚Djโ†’RqDjโˆฃjโ‰ฅr},๐’ฅq,r={RqJj:RqDjโ†’RqDj+1โˆฃjโ‰ฅr}.\begin{aligned} \mathcal I_{q,r} &=\{R_qI_j:R_q\partial D_j\longrightarrow R_qD_j\mid j\ge r\},\\ \mathcal J_{q,r} &=\{R_qJ_j:R_qD_j\longrightarrow R_qD_{j+1}\mid j\ge r\}. \end{aligned}(4) For a class ๐’ฆ\mathcal K of morphisms, ๐’ฆโŸ‚\mathcal K^\perp denotes the maps with the right lifting property against ๐’ฆ\mathcal K, and โŸ‚๐’ฆ\,{}^\perp\mathcal K denotes those with the left lifting property against it. The boundary cofibrations โ„ฌq,r\mathcal B_{q,r} and the source-generated class ๐’ฎq,r\mathcal S_{q,r} are (5): โ„ฌq,r=โŸ‚(โ„q,rโŸ‚),๐’ฎq,r=โŸ‚(๐’ฅq,rโŸ‚).\mathcal B_{q,r}={}^\perp(\mathcal I_{q,r}^\perp),\qquad \mathcal S_{q,r}={}^\perp(\mathcal J_{q,r}^\perp).(5)

An object XโˆˆAqX\in A_q is cofibrant if every map Xโ†’QX\to Q lifts along every map p:Pโ†’Qp:P\to Q in โ„q,0โŸ‚\mathcal I_{q,0}^\perp.โœฆ A cellular model XX of CC is a model admitting a transfinite presentation by boundary attachments from the initial model. The expansion-contraction principle ๐–ค(q,r)\mathsf E(q,r) is the assertion that every i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y in ๐’ฎq,r\mathcal S_{q,r} with XX cofibrant and ๐–ฅ(X)\mathsf F(X) has ๐–ฅ(Y)\mathsf F(Y).โœฆ

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let q,rq,r be nonnegative integers.

  1. Assume ๐–ค(q,r)\mathsf E(q,r). Let i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y be a boundary cofibration in โ„ฌq,r\mathcal B_{q,r}, with XX cofibrant and both XX and YY boundary filling. Then iโˆˆ๐’ฎq,r.i\in\mathcal S_{q,r}.(6)โœฆ

  2. Under the hypotheses of the first assertion, let a:Xโ†’Xโ€ฒa:X\to X' be a map in AqA_q, where Xโ€ฒX' is cofibrant and ๐–ฅ(Xโ€ฒ)\mathsf F(X'). For any pushout Yโ€ฒ=YโˆXXโ€ฒY'=Y\amalg_X X' in AqA_q, ๐–ฅ(Yโ€ฒ).\mathsf F(Y').(7)โœฆ

  3. Let i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y be any morphism in โ„ฌq,r\mathcal B_{q,r} with ๐–ฅ(X)\mathsf F(X). Then there exists s:Yโ†’X such that sโˆ˜i=1X.\text{there exists }s:Y\longrightarrow X \text{ such that }s\circ i=1_X.(8)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: for 0โ‰คn<q0\le n<q, assuming the contractibility-preservation hypotheses E(q,j)E(q,j) for every n<jโ‰คqn<j\le q, an upper II-cellular extension i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y in AqA_q with XX cellular and ii a weak equivalence has a retraction, and its pushout along every map Xโ†’Xโ€ฒX\to X' with Xโ€ฒX' cellular is a weak equivalence.

What Is Checked

The assertions (6) and (7) are stated over the coherator CC and its category AqA_q, with the expansion-contraction principle, cofibrancy, and boundary-filling hypotheses; (8) concerns the boundary lifting class and a boundary-filling source.

The units of coskeletal reflections are bijective on jj-cells for jโ‰คqj\le q.โœฆ The reflection bijection (3) satisfies the postcomposition identity (9), for h:RqXโ†’Yh:R_qX\to Y and g:Yโ†’Yโ€ฒg:Y\to Y' in AqA_q; it determines RqR_q as a left adjoint to the inclusion of AqA_q: ฮฆX,Yโ€ฒ(gโˆ˜h)=gโˆ˜ฮฆX,Y(h).\Phi_{X,Y'}(g\circ h)=g\circ\Phi_{X,Y}(h).(9)โœฆ