OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 3. Cutoffs, spines and tree diagrams

Lemma 3.5 [Top-dimensional base case]: From cofibrant sources, with weak equivalences for elementary pushouts into coskeletal models

Top cutoff expansions preserve boundary filling.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

An elementary expansion is a pushout of the source inclusion of one free disk into its successor. The issue is how these attachments interact with unique boundary filling above a fixed dimension.

Globular Theories and Models

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has natural-number dimensions as objects, identity maps, and two face maps mโ†’nm\to n when m<nm<n, distinguished as source and target. Its adjacent faces are denoted ฯƒj,ฯ„j:jโ†’j+1\sigma_j,\tau_j:j\to j+1. A globular presheaf is a functor ๐”พopโ†’๐‘บ๐’†๐’•\mathbb G^{\mathrm{op}}\to\mathbf{Set}โœฆ; its representable disks are ๐”พ(โˆ’,j)\mathbb G(-,j), with faces induced by the Yoneda embedding.

A shape SS is a finite globular sum, specified by a table of dimensions.โœฆ Such a table starts with one globe and successively attaches an hh-globe along the source bb-face to the target bb-face of its last globe of dimension โ„“\ell, where b<โ„“b<\ell and b<hb<h.โœฆ Its realization is the corresponding iterated pushout of representable disks, with a distinguished inclusion of the last globe.โœฆ The height of SS is the greatest dimension occurring in its table.โœฆ The two pushout maps include the previous shape and the attached globe. The single-globe shapes and their face maps give the globe inclusion into shapes.โœฆ The gluing face inclusion ๐”พ(โˆ’,b)โ†’S\mathbb G(-,b)\to S is the inclusion of the target bb-face of the last globe of SS, where bb is smaller than the dimension of that globe.โœฆ

A globular theory is a category on these shapes with an arity functor from shapes that preserves the designated globular pushouts.โœฆ A morphism of globular theories is a functor fixing the shapes and preserving the structural arity maps; identities and composition are those of functors. The globe inclusion into a theory is the composite of the globe inclusion into shapes with its arity functor.โœฆ

Two operations u,v:jโ†’Su,v:j\to S in a globular theory are parallel when their source and target restrictions agree, with no condition in dimension zero.โœฆ An admissible pair u,v:jโ†’Su,v:j\to S in a globular theory is a parallel pair of operations with height⁡(S)โ‰คj+1\operatorname{height}(S)\le j+1.โœฆ For a theory morphism F:Cโ†’Cโ€ฒF:C\to C' and operations u,v:jโ†’Su,v:j\to S in CC, a filler zz for their images is an operation z:j+1โ†’Sz:j+1\to S in Cโ€ฒC' satisfying (1): zโˆ˜ฯƒj=F(u),zโˆ˜ฯ„j=F(v).z\circ\sigma_j=F(u),\qquad z\circ\tau_j=F(v).(1) A free extension by fillers adjoins specified fillers of a family of admissible pairs: every morphism into another theory equipped with chosen fillers of their images extends uniquely, taking the adjoined fillers to those chosen fillers.โœฆ A cellular presentation of a theory is a sequence starting at an initial theory, with each step a free extension of this kind, whose compatible inclusions exhibit the theory as its colimit.โœฆ A coherator CC is a globular theory that admits a cellular presentation and has a filler for every admissible pair.โœฆ

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC sending the designated globular pushouts to pullbacks.โœฆ The underlying globular set of a model XX of CC is the restriction of XX to the globes: a family of sets XjX_j with source and target maps satisfying sโˆ˜s=sโˆ˜ts\circ s=s\circ t and tโˆ˜s=tโˆ˜tt\circ s=t\circ t.โœฆ A morphism of globular sets is a family of cell maps commuting with source and target.โœฆ A morphism of models induces this family by restriction of its presheaf components.โœฆ

The free model on a shape SS is the representable presheaf C(โˆ’,S)C(-,S).โœฆ Write DjD_j for the free model on the jj-globeโœฆ and Jj:Djโ†’Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1} for the morphism induced by its source face.โœฆ

Boundaries and Homotopy

Two cells of a globular set are parallel when their sources and targets agree; all zero-cells are parallel.โœฆ The set Bj(X)B_j(X) of jj-boundaries and the boundary map โˆ‚j\partial_j are given by (2), where *\ast denotes a singleton: B0(X)=*,Bj+1(X)={(u,v)โˆˆXj2โˆฃu and v are parallel},โˆ‚0:X0โ†’*,โˆ‚j+1(z)=(s(z),t(z)).\begin{gathered} B_0(X)=\ast,\qquad B_{j+1}(X)=\{(u,v)\in X_j^2\mid u\text{ and }v\text{ are parallel}\},\\ \partial_0:X_0\longrightarrow\ast,\qquad \partial_{j+1}(z)=(s(z),t(z)). \end{gathered}(2) A globular set XX has fillers for every boundary when each boundary map โˆ‚j\partial_j of XX is surjective. The induced boundary map Bj(f):Bj(X)โ†’Bj(Y)B_j(f):B_j(X)\to B_j(Y) of a globular map f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y sends the unique zero-boundary to itself and applies ff to both cells of every positive-dimensional boundary.

The free boundary โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j is the canonical model representing jj-boundaries, with inclusion Ij:โˆ‚Djโ†’DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j. The construction of the free boundary starts with the empty zero-boundary and forms each successor boundary by gluing two free disks along their common boundary.โœฆ The natural representing bijections in (3) identify restriction along IjI_j with โˆ‚j\partial_j: Hom⁡(Dj,X)โ‰…Xj,Hom⁡(โˆ‚Dj,X)โ‰…Bj(X).\operatorname{Hom}(D_j,X)\cong X_j,\qquad \operatorname{Hom}(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_j(X).(3) The first bijection is evaluation at the identity of the globe.โœฆ

Two jj-cells u,vu,v of a globular set XX are joined when a (j+1)(j+1)-cell of XX has source uu and target vv.โœฆ The set of components ฯ€0(X)\pi_0(X) of a globular set XX is the quotient of X0X_0 by the equivalence relation generated by joining.โœฆ For a basepoint xโˆˆX0x\in X_0, write 1x(j)1_x^{(j)} for its jj-fold iterated identity, starting with 1x(0)=x1_x^{(0)}=x.โœฆ A based (j+1)(j+1)-loop in a model XX of a coherator CC at xโˆˆX0x\in X_0 is a cell of Xj+1X_{j+1} whose source and target both equal the iterated identity 1x(j)1_x^{(j)}.โœฆ For a model XX of a coherator CC and xโˆˆX0x\in X_0, the homotopy group ฯ€j+1(X,x)\pi_{j+1}(X,x) is the quotient of the based (j+1)(j+1)-loops at xx by the equivalence relation generated by joining them with (j+2)(j+2)-cells.โœฆ

A morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y acts on loops by its cell maps and induces maps on these quotients, sending the basepoint to f(x)f(x). A weak equivalence f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y of models is a morphism for which the induced maps in (4) are bijective for every xโˆˆX0x\in X_0 and jโ‰ฅ0j\ge0: ฯ€0(f):ฯ€0(X)โ†’ฯ€0(Y),ฯ€j+1(f):ฯ€j+1(X,x)โ†’ฯ€j+1(Y,f(x)).\pi_0(f):\pi_0(X)\longrightarrow\pi_0(Y),\qquad \pi_{j+1}(f):\pi_{j+1}(X,x)\longrightarrow\pi_{j+1}(Y,f(x)).(4) For a morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y of models of a coherator, the induced map on based (j+1)(j+1)-loops sends a loop at xx to its image under the cell map fj+1f_{j+1}, a loop at f(x)f(x).

Cutoffs and Lifting Properties

For a nonnegative cutoff qq, a model XX of CC is qq-coskeletal when its boundary map โˆ‚j\partial_j is bijective for every j>qj>q.โœฆ For a nonnegative cutoff qq, let AqA_q be the full subcategory of qq-coskeletal models of CC.โœฆ A coskeletal reflection LqXL_qX of a model XX of CC at a nonnegative cutoff qq is a model with LqXโˆˆAqL_qX\in A_q and a universal morphism ฮทX:Xโ†’LqX\eta_X:X\to L_qX. Its factorization bijection is (5), with YโˆˆAqY\in A_q: ฮฆX,Y:Hom⁡Aq(LqX,Y)โ†’โ‰…Hom⁡C-Mod(X,Y),hโ†ฆhโˆ˜ฮทX.\Phi_{X,Y}:\operatorname{Hom}_{A_q}(L_qX,Y) \xrightarrow{\ \cong\ }\operatorname{Hom}_{C\text{-}\mathrm{Mod}}(X,Y), \qquad h\longmapsto h\circ\eta_X.(5)โœฆ For a coherator CC, the coskeletal reflection functor Lq:C-Modโ†’AqL_q:C\text{-}\mathrm{Mod}\to A_q sends each model to its reflection and is left adjoint to the inclusion of AqA_q into the category of CC-models.

The reflected disks and boundaries are LqDjL_qD_j and Lqโˆ‚DjL_q\partial D_j. For a nonnegative threshold rr, their reflected inclusions determine the generating classes โ„q,r\mathcal I_{q,r} and ๐’ฅq,r\mathcal J_{q,r} in (6): Ij(q)=Lq(Ij):Lqโˆ‚Djโ†’LqDj,Jj(q)=Lq(Jj):LqDjโ†’LqDj+1,โ„q,r={Ij(q)โˆฃjโ‰ฅr},๐’ฅq,r={Jj(q)โˆฃjโ‰ฅr}.\begin{gathered} I_j^{(q)}=L_q(I_j):L_q\partial D_j\longrightarrow L_qD_j, \qquad J_j^{(q)}=L_q(J_j):L_qD_j\longrightarrow L_qD_{j+1},\\ \mathcal I_{q,r}=\{I_j^{(q)}\mid j\ge r\},\qquad \mathcal J_{q,r}=\{J_j^{(q)}\mid j\ge r\}. \end{gathered}(6) For a morphism class โ„ณ\mathcal M, write โ„ณโŸ‚\mathcal M^\perp for its right lifting class and โŸ‚โ„ณ\,{}^\perp\mathcal M for its left lifting class. A threshold-rr source cofibration f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y in AqA_q is a morphism in โŸ‚(๐’ฅq,rโŸ‚)\,{}^\perp(\mathcal J_{q,r}^\perp).

A cofibrant object XX of AqA_q is an object such that every map Xโ†’QX\to Q lifts along every p:Pโ†’Qp:P\to Q in โ„q,0โŸ‚\mathcal I_{q,0}^\perp.โœฆ A cellular object XX of AqA_q is an object admitting a transfinite boundary-attachment presentation. The expansion contraction principle ๐–ค๐–ข(q,r)\mathsf{EC}(q,r) is the assertion that a threshold-rr source cofibration with cofibrant domain preserves the existence of fillers for every boundary.โœฆ

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be a coherator. Let a:Dnโ†’Xa:D_n\to X, i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y and b:Dn+1โ†’Yb:D_{n+1}\to Y exhibit YY as the pushout of JnJ_n along aa in the category of CC-models. Suppose that YY is nn-coskeletal. Then i:Xโ†’Yis a weak equivalence.i:X\longrightarrow Y\quad\text{is a weak equivalence}.(7)โœฆ For every cutoff qโ‰ฅ0q\ge0, the expansion contraction principle satisfies ๐–ค๐–ข(q,q).\mathsf{EC}(q,q).(8)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: for every qโ‰ฅ0q\ge0, E(q,q)E(q,q) holds, meaning that pushing out Jq(q)J_q^{(q)} along any cell of a cellular object of AqA_q is a weak equivalence.

What Is Checked

The statements (7) and (8) are over models of a coherator, with an ordinary model pushout in the first and lifting classes in AqA_q with cofibrant domains in the second. Every model admits a coskeletal reflection whose unit is bijective on cells in dimensions at most qq.โœฆ The reflection bijection (5) is natural in its coskeletal target: for g:Yโ†’Yโ€ฒg:Y\to Y' and h:LqXโ†’Yh:L_qX\to Y, it satisfies (9).โœฆ ฮฆX,Yโ€ฒ(gโˆ˜h)=gโˆ˜ฮฆX,Y(h).\Phi_{X,Y'}(g\circ h)=g\circ\Phi_{X,Y}(h).(9)โœฆ