OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 2. Globular models and the weak-equivalence test

Proposition 2.4 [Weak-equivalence test]: For models of a coherator; the same lifting condition reflects joining of parallel cells

Exact-boundary lifting yields weak equivalences.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

An exact-boundary lifting problem for a globular map prescribes a boundary in the source and a cell in the target over its image.

A globular set UU is a family of sets UnU_n with source and target maps s,t:Un+1→Uns,t:U_{n+1}\to U_n satisfying the globular identities (1). s(s(a))=s(t(a)),t(s(a))=t(t(a))(a∈Un+2).s(s(a))=s(t(a)),\qquad t(s(a))=t(t(a)) \quad(a\in U_{n+2}).(1)✦ A globular map g:U→Vg:U\to V between globular sets is a family of maps gn:Un→Vng_n:U_n\to V_n commuting with source and target. Two positive-dimensional cells of UU are parallel when they have equal source and target; all vertices are parallel.✦ Write a⤳Uba\leadsto_U b when an (n+1)(n+1)-cell has source a∈Una\in U_n and target b∈Unb\in U_n.✦

The set BnUB_nU of nn-boundaries and the boundary map ∂:Un→BnU\partial:U_n\to B_nU are given by (2), where *\ast denotes the unique zero-dimensional boundary. B0U={*},∂a=*(a∈U0),Bn+1U={(a,b)∈Un2:a,b are parallel},∂c=(sc,tc)(c∈Un+1).\begin{aligned} B_0U&=\{\ast\},& \partial a&=\ast &&(a\in U_0),\\ B_{n+1}U&=\{(a,b)\in U_n^2:a,b\text{ are parallel}\},& \partial c&=(sc,tc) &&(c\in U_{n+1}). \end{aligned}(2) The induced boundary map Bng:BnU→BnVB_ng:B_nU\to B_nV sends *\ast to *\ast and sends a pair (a,b)(a,b) to (gna,gnb)(g_na,g_nb).✦

The exact-boundary test EB⁡(g)\operatorname{EB}(g) is the lifting condition (3) on a globular map g:U→Vg:U\to V. b∈BnU,y∈Vn,∂y=Bng(b)⇒∃x∈Un:∂x=bandgnx⤳Vy,n≥0.\begin{gathered} b\in B_nU,\quad y\in V_n,\quad \partial y=B_ng(b) \quad\Longrightarrow\\ \exists x\in U_n:\quad \partial x=b\quad\text{and}\quad g_nx\leadsto_V y, \qquad n\geq0. \end{gathered}(3)✦

Theories and Models

The globe category has one object in each natural-number dimension, identity maps, and two face maps from dimension mm to dimension nn whenever m<nm<n. Its adjacent source and target inclusions select the two faces. A globular presheaf is a contravariant set-valued functor on the globe category.✦ The representable disk DnD_n is the Yoneda presheaf of the nn-globe, and its face maps are the Yoneda images of the globe faces. Write ∂Dn\partial D_n for its boundary. The underlying globular set of a globular presheaf is its family of values on globes, with source and target given by restriction along the adjacent faces.✦ A natural transformation induces a globular map by its components on globes.✦

A globular pasting shape SS is a finite globular sum specified by a table of dimensions with a distinguished last globe.✦ Such a table starts with one globe and successively attaches an hh-globe along a bb-face, where bb is smaller than both hh and the dimension of the preceding last globe.✦ The realization of a globular pasting shape SS is the iterated pushout of representable disks, retaining the inclusion of the last disk; the new last inclusion is the new disk’s pushout inclusion.✦ The height of a table, and of its shape, is the greatest dimension of its globes.

For a shape SS ending in dimension ℓ\ell, the attached shape and its realization have the form (4); the gluing map Db→SD_b\to S is the target bb-face of its last globe, and the map Db→DhD_b\to D_h is the source bb-face. S∐DbDh,b<ℓ,b<h.S\amalg_{D_b}D_h,\qquad b<\ell,\quad b<h.(4) The previous shape inclusion is the other pushout inclusion. The single-globe shapes and their face maps give the globe inclusion into shapes.✦

A category under globular arities is a category whose objects are globular pasting shapes, equipped with an arity functor from globular pasting shapes that is the identity on objects.✦ A globular theory is a category under globular arities whose arity functor sends every gluing (4) to a pushout.✦ A morphism of globular theories is a functor fixing objects and preserving the structural arity maps.✦ The globe inclusion into a theory is the composite of the globe inclusion into shapes with its arity functor.✦

Two operations a,b:Dn→Sa,b:D_n\to S in a globular theory are parallel when their source and target restrictions agree, with no condition in dimension zero.✦ An admissible pair in a globular theory is a pair of parallel operations a,b:Dn→Sa,b:D_n\to S with height⁡(S)≤n+1\operatorname{height}(S)\leq n+1.✦ A filler for an admissible pair a,ba,b in a theory BB along a theory morphism F:B→DF:B\to D is an operation z:Dn+1→Sz:D_{n+1}\to S in DD whose source and target restrictions are F(a)F(a) and F(b)F(b).✦

A free extension by fillers of a theory BB is a morphism F:B→DF:B\to D with specified fillers zgz_g for a family of admissible pairs pgp_g in BB, such that every theory morphism A:B→EA:B\to E and choice of fillers wgw_g along AA extend uniquely to a morphism H:D→EH:D\to E with HF=AHF=A and H(zg)=wgH(z_g)=w_g.✦

A cellular presentation of a globular theory is a sequence of free extensions by fillers starting at an initial theory, with compatible inclusions exhibiting the given theory as its colimit.✦ A coherator CC is a globular theory admitting a cellular presentation and a filler for every admissible pair in CC.✦

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC taking the gluings (4) to pullbacks.✦ The underlying globular set of a model XX of CC is the restriction of XX along the globe inclusion; write XnX_n for its nn-cells.✦ A model map f:X→Yf:X\to Y between models of CC is a natural transformation, and restriction gives its underlying globular map, also denoted ff, with components fn:Xn→Ynf_n:X_n\to Y_n.✦

Components and Homotopy Classes

For a model XX of the coherator CC and a vertex x∈X0x\in X_0, let en(x)e_n(x) be the iterated identity, starting with e0(x)=xe_0(x)=x and taking the identity cell at each successive dimension.✦ The based globular loops Ωn+1(X,x)\Omega_{n+1}(X,x) are the (n+1)(n+1)-cells with source and target en(x)e_n(x).✦ For a model XX of any globular theory, the component set π0(X)\pi_0(X) is the quotient of its vertices by the equivalence relation generated by joining cells. For a model XX of the coherator CC and a vertex x∈X0x\in X_0, the homotopy groups πn+1(X,x)\pi_{n+1}(X,x) are the quotients in (5), where brackets indicate the equivalence relations generated by joining cells. π0(X)=X0/⟨⤳X⟩,πn+1(X,x)=Ωn+1(X,x)/⟨⤳X⟩,n≥0.\begin{aligned} \pi_0(X)&=X_0/\langle\leadsto_X\rangle,\\ \pi_{n+1}(X,x)&=\Omega_{n+1}(X,x)/\langle\leadsto_X\rangle, \qquad n\geq0. \end{aligned}(5) A model map f:X→Yf:X\to Y induces the map on loops a↦fn+1aa\mapsto f_{n+1}a, with basepoint f0xf_0x, and the maps on quotient classes π0(f):[x]↦[f0x]\pi_0(f):[x]\mapsto[f_0x] and πn+1(f,x):[a]↦[fn+1a]\pi_{n+1}(f,x):[a]\mapsto[f_{n+1}a]. A weak equivalence f:X→Yf:X\to Y between models of CC is a model map satisfying (6). π0(f):π0(X)→π0(Y) is bijective,πn+1(f,x):πn+1(X,x)→πn+1(Y,f0x) is bijective(x∈X0,n≥0).\begin{gathered} \pi_0(f):\pi_0(X)\longrightarrow\pi_0(Y)\text{ is bijective},\\ \pi_{n+1}(f,x):\pi_{n+1}(X,x)\longrightarrow \pi_{n+1}(Y,f_0x)\text{ is bijective} \quad(x\in X_0,\ n\geq0). \end{gathered}(6)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let g:U→Vg:U\to V be a globular map satisfying the exact-boundary test (3). For parallel nn-cells a,ba,b of UU whose images are joined in VV, one has a⤳Ub.a\leadsto_U b.(7)✦ Let CC be a coherator and f:X→Yf:X\to Y a map of its models whose underlying globular map satisfies (3). Then f is a weak equivalence.f\text{ is a weak equivalence}.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a model map f:X→Yf:X\to Y, being a weak equivalence, inducing bijections on π0\pi_0 and on the homotopy classes πr(X;u,v)→πr(Y;fu,fv)\pi_r(X;u,v)\to\pi_r(Y;fu,fv) associated to every parallel pair u,vu,v in XX and every r≥1r\geq1, and admitting, for every r≥0r\geq0, specified boundary b:∂Dr→Xb:\partial D_r\to X, and rr-cell yy in YY with boundary fbfb, an rr-cell xx with boundary exactly bb and an (r+1)(r+1)-cell fx→yfx\to y are equivalent, and in particular a weak equivalence reflects homotopy between parallel cells, including equality of components for vertices.

What Is Checked

The statement (7) is over arbitrary globular sets and an exact-boundary test for their map, while (8) is over a coherator, its presheaf models preserving globular sums as pullbacks, and a natural transformation satisfying that test on underlying globular sets.