OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 2. Globular models and the weak-equivalence test

Lemma 2.2 [Division with specified boundaries]: For two cells with a common source in a model of a Grothendieck coherator

Top composition admits a cancellation homotopy.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For a nonnegative integer nn, division at top composition concerns (n+1)(n+1)-cells composed along their nn-dimensional boundaries. The prescribed data here are two such cells with a common source; homotopy between their composites means the existence of a cell one dimension higher.

A globular set UU is a family of sets UjU_j with source and target maps sj,tj:Uj+1→Ujs_j,t_j:U_{j+1}\to U_j satisfying the globular identities (1). sjsj+1=sjtj+1,tjsj+1=tjtj+1.s_j s_{j+1}=s_j t_{j+1},\qquad t_j s_{j+1}=t_j t_{j+1}.(1)✦ The globe category 𝔾\mathbb G has one object for each natural-number dimension, identity morphisms, and two face morphisms from dimension jj to dimension kk whenever j<kj<k. Write σj\sigma_j and τj\tau_j for its source and target morphisms from dimension jj to dimension j+1j+1. A globular presheaf is a contravariant set-valued functor on 𝔾\mathbb G; its values and its actions on these faces give its underlying globular set. The representable disk DjD_j is the Yoneda image of the dimension-jj globe, and its faces are the Yoneda images of the globe faces.

Globular Arities and Coherators

A table of dimensions is a description of a finite globular sum SS together with its last globe. It starts with a single globe and is extended by attaching a new globe along a lower-dimensional face.✦ If the last globe of SS has dimension ℓ\ell, an attachment of a globe of dimension hh along dimension bb requires b<ℓb<\ell and b<hb<h. The realization S′S' of a table obtained by attaching a globe of dimension hh to SS along dimension bb is the pushout (2), whose gluing map into SS is the target bb-face of the last globe and whose gluing map into DhD_h is the source face. S′=S∐DbDh,iL:S→S′,iR:Dh→S′.S'=S\amalg_{D_b}D_h, \qquad i_L:S\longrightarrow S',\qquad i_R:D_h\longrightarrow S'.(2) The maps iLi_L and iRi_R are the previous arity inclusion and the attached globe inclusion. The last globe inclusion is the identity for a single globe and becomes iRi_R after an attachment.✦ The height of a table, or of its shape SS, is the greatest dimension of a globe occurring in it.

A globular theory is a category with finite globular sums as objects and an arity functor ι\iota from globular arities that fixes objects and preserves the elementary pushouts (2).✦ The globe inclusion into a globular theory with arity functor ι\iota is the Yoneda inclusion into globular arities followed by ι\iota.✦ A morphism of globular theories is a functor that fixes arities and commutes with their structural maps.✦

Two operations u,v:Dj→Su,v:D_j\to S in a globular theory are parallel if their source and target restrictions agree; in dimension zero every pair is parallel.✦ An admissible pair p=(u,v)p=(u,v) in a globular theory is a parallel pair of operations u,v:Dj→Su,v:D_j\to S with height⁡(S)≤j+1\operatorname{height}(S)\leq j+1.✦ For a theory morphism F:C→EF:C\to E, a filler of pp along FF is an operation z:Dj+1→Sz:D_{j+1}\to S in EE satisfying (3); the faces in that formula are regarded as structural operations in EE. z∘σj=F(u),z∘τj=F(v).z\circ\sigma_j=F(u),\qquad z\circ\tau_j=F(v).(3)✦ A filler in CC means a filler along the identity morphism of CC.

A free extension by fillers is a theory morphism with specified fillers for a family of admissible pairs, universal for these choices: a morphism out of the original theory, together with fillers for the images of those pairs, extends uniquely to a morphism sending the specified fillers to the chosen ones.✦ A cellular presentation of a globular theory CC is a sequence of free extensions by fillers starting at an initial globular theory, with compatible inclusions exhibiting CC as its colimit.✦ A Grothendieck coherator CC is a globular theory that admits a cellular presentation and a filler for every admissible pair.✦

Models and Cell Operations

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC that sends every elementary globular sum (2) to a pullback.✦ The underlying globular set of a model XX of CC is the restriction of XX along the globe inclusion; write Xj=X(Dj)X_j=X(D_j) and s,ts,t for its source and target maps.✦ Evaluation of an operation f:S→Tf:S\to T is the map X(f):X(T)→X(S)X(f):X(T)\to X(S).✦ A globular sum tuple a∪bd∈X(S′)a\cup_b d\in X(S') is the element restricting to a∈X(S)a\in X(S) and d∈Xhd\in X_h, when their restrictions to the gluing bb-face agree.✦

The binary composition arity BnB_n is the attachment of two copies of Dn+1D_{n+1} along DnD_n, with first and second composand inclusions iLi_L and iRi_R as in (2).✦ The composition boundary pair on the binary composition arity BnB_n is the pair of operations iL∘σni_L\circ\sigma_n and iR∘τni_R\circ\tau_n.✦ The composition operation μn:Dn+1→Bn\mu_n:D_{n+1}\to B_n is a chosen filler of the composition boundary pair on the binary composition arity BnB_n.✦ The inverse boundary pair on Dn+1D_{n+1} consists of τn\tau_n and σn\sigma_n, in that order✦; its chosen filler νn:Dn+1→Dn+1\nu_n:D_{n+1}\to D_{n+1} is the inverse operation.✦

For cells α,β∈Xn+1\alpha,\beta\in X_{n+1} with t(α)=s(β)t(\alpha)=s(\beta), their composable cell pair ⟨α,β⟩∈X(Bn)\langle\alpha,\beta\rangle\in X(B_n) is their globular sum tuple.✦ The cell composite and inverse cell are the evaluations in (4). αβ:=X(μn)(⟨α,β⟩),α−1:=X(νn)(α).\alpha\beta:=X(\mu_n)(\langle\alpha,\beta\rangle),\qquad \alpha^{-1}:=X(\nu_n)(\alpha).(4)

Two jj-cells x,y∈Xjx,y\in X_j are joined by a cell, written x∼yx\sim y, when the condition (5) holds. x∼y⇔there exists H∈Xj+1 with s(H)=x and t(H)=y.x\sim y\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \text{there exists }H\in X_{j+1}\text{ with }s(H)=x\text{ and }t(H)=y.(5)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be a Grothendieck coherator, let XX be a model of CC, and let n≥0n\geq0. For cells a,b∈Xn+1a,b\in X_{n+1} with s(a)=s(b)s(a)=s(b), there is a homotopy a(a−1b)∼b.a\bigl(a^{-1}b\bigr)\sim b.(6)✦

In the paper, the result reads: in any model, for an rr-cell γ\gamma and i<ri<r, left multiplication α↦γ*iα\alpha\mapsto\gamma\ast_i\alpha, where *i\ast_i is composition along ii-cells, induces a bijection from the homotopy set at any prescribed input boundary composable with γ\gamma to the homotopy set at the induced output boundary, and the same holds for right multiplication, including empty homotopy sets.

What Is Checked

The cancellation law (6) is stated over the underlying globular set of a model of a Grothendieck coherator, for two (n+1)(n+1)-cells with a common source. For a composable pair α,β\alpha,\beta, the source of the composite (4) is s(α)s(\alpha)✦; inversion interchanges source and target.