OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Vanishing on products

§4 (proof of Proposition 3, Step 3): induction on the remaining slots: For positive natural numbers a,ba,b with b≥a(a−1)b\geq a(a-1), lower-arity forms preserve symmetry and diagonal vanishing and yield conditional vanishing

Second transfer gives vanishing on products.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let VV be an arbitrary complex vector space. The vanishing problem asks when the values of a symmetric multilinear form on repeated products of vectors determine the whole form.

For n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, write Finn={i∈ℕ:i<n}\mathrm{Fin}\,n=\{i\in\mathbb N:i<n\}, and let ι:V→SymmetricAlgebra⁡(ℂ,V)\iota:V\to\operatorname{SymmetricAlgebra}(\mathbb C,V) be the canonical inclusion. The ambient symmetric monomial Mn(y)M_n(y) of a family y:Finn→Vy:\mathrm{Fin}\,n\to V is the element of SymmetricAlgebra⁡(ℂ,V)\operatorname{SymmetricAlgebra}(\mathbb C,V) given by the product Mn(y)=∏i∈Finnι(yi).M_n(y)=\prod_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,n}\iota(y_i).(1)✦ The symmetric power Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^n V is the homogeneous component of degree nn in the symmetric algebra, defined by (2): Sym⁡nV=span⁡ℂ{Mn(y):y:Finn→V}.\operatorname{Sym}^n V =\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb C} \{M_n(y):y:\mathrm{Fin}\,n\to V\}.(2) The symmetric monomial Mn(y)∈Sym⁡nVM_n(y)\in\operatorname{Sym}^n V is the product in (1) viewed in the homogeneous component; for x∈Vx\in V, write xnx^n when every vector is xx.✦

Multiplication in the symmetric algebra gives, for natural numbers m,nm,n, the bilinear map in (3) called symmetric power multiplication: Sym⁡mV×Sym⁡nV→Sym⁡m+nV,(P,Q)↦PQ.\operatorname{Sym}^m V\times\operatorname{Sym}^n V \longrightarrow\operatorname{Sym}^{m+n}V, \qquad (P,Q)\longmapsto PQ.(3)✦

A multilinear form FF on Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^b V with aa arguments, for natural numbers a,ba,b, is a complex-valued aa-linear map on (Sym⁡bV)Fina(\operatorname{Sym}^b V)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,a}.✦ For natural numbers a,ba,b, a multilinear form FF on Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^b V with aa arguments is symmetric if it has the permutation invariance (4) for every family Q:Fina→Sym⁡bVQ:\mathrm{Fin}\,a\to\operatorname{Sym}^b V and every permutation σ\sigma of Fina\mathrm{Fin}\,a: F((Qσ(i))i∈Fina)=F(Q).F\bigl((Q_{\sigma(i)})_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,a}\bigr)=F(Q).(4)✦

Lower-arity Forms

Let r,mr,m be natural numbers, TT an (r+1)(r+1)-linear form on Sym⁡r+mV\operatorname{Sym}^{r+m}V, and x,t∈Vx,t\in V. The lower-arity product form Sx,tTS^T_{x,t} is the rr-linear form on Sym⁡mV\operatorname{Sym}^m V obtained by fixing the first argument of TT to tr+mt^{r+m} and precomposing each remaining argument with multiplication by xrx^r.✦

The second-transfer principle for VV is the following property: for every pair of positive natural numbers r,mr,m satisfying (r+1)r≤r+m(r+1)r\leq r+m, a symmetric (r+1)(r+1)-linear form UU on Sym⁡r+mV\operatorname{Sym}^{r+m}V whose lower-arity forms Sx,tUS^U_{x,t} vanish identically for all x,t∈Vx,t\in V satisfies (5) for every v:Fin(r+1)→Vv:\mathrm{Fin}\,(r+1)\to V: U((vir+m)i∈Fin(r+1))=0.U\bigl((v_i^{r+m})_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,(r+1)}\bigr)=0.(5)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let r,mr,m be natural numbers, let TT be an (r+1)(r+1)-linear form on Sym⁡r+mV\operatorname{Sym}^{r+m}V, and let x,t∈Vx,t\in V. For every Q:Finr→Sym⁡mVQ:\mathrm{Fin}\,r\to\operatorname{Sym}^m V, its lower-arity product form has the evaluation (6): Sx,tT(Q)=T(tr+m,(xrQi)i∈Finr).S^T_{x,t}(Q) =T\bigl(t^{r+m},(x^rQ_i)_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,r}\bigr).(6)✦ If TT is symmetric, then (7) holds for every such QQ and every permutation σ\sigma of Finr\mathrm{Fin}\,r: Sx,tT((Qσ(i))i∈Finr)=Sx,tT(Q).S^T_{x,t}\bigl((Q_{\sigma(i)})_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,r}\bigr)=S^T_{x,t}(Q).(7)✦ Suppose also that r≥1r\geq1 and TT satisfies the diagonal vanishing condition (8): T((Mr+m(y))i∈Fin(r+1))=0for every y:Fin(r+m)→V.T\bigl((M_{r+m}(y))_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,(r+1)}\bigr)=0 \qquad\text{for every }y:\mathrm{Fin}\,(r+m)\to V.(8) Then its lower-arity diagonal satisfies (9): Sx,tT((Mm(y))i∈Finr)=0for every y:Finm→V.S^T_{x,t}\bigl((M_m(y))_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,r}\bigr)=0 \qquad\text{for every }y:\mathrm{Fin}\,m\to V.(9)✦

Assume that VV satisfies the second-transfer principle. Let a,b≥1a,b\geq1 be natural numbers with a(a−1)≤ba(a-1)\leq b, and let FF be a symmetric aa-linear form on Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^b V satisfying (10): F((Mb(y))i∈Fina)=0for every y:Finb→V.F\bigl((M_b(y))_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,a}\bigr)=0 \qquad\text{for every }y:\mathrm{Fin}\,b\to V.(10) Then (11) holds: F=0.F=0.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for fixed x,tx,t, writing b=r+mb=r+m, the form Sx,tT(Q)=T((xrQi)i∈Finr,tb)S^T_{x,t}(Q)=T\bigl((x^rQ_i)_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,r},t^b\bigr) is symmetric rr-linear on Sym⁡mV\operatorname{Sym}^m V, its diagonal vanishes on products of mm vectors by Step 2, and since m≥r2≥r(r−1)m\geq r^2\geq r(r-1) and m≥1m\geq1, induction gives Sx,tT=0S^T_{x,t}=0 for every x,tx,t, with the QiQ_i varying independently.

What Is Checked

The claims concern complex-valued multilinear forms on the symmetric powers of an arbitrary complex vector space VV, with symmetry given by the permutation invariance (4).