OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Vanishing on products

§4 (proof of Proposition 3, Step 4): removing the common power: Quadratic degree bounds for vanishing on pure powers

Removing common powers from multilinear arguments.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The issue is removal of a common vector power from the arguments of a multilinear form on symmetric powers. Let VV be a complex vector space, and for each natural number nn let In=Finn={0,…,n−1}I_n=\mathrm{Fin}\,n=\{0,\ldots,n-1\}; write A=SymmetricAlgebra⁡(ℂ,V)A=\operatorname{SymmetricAlgebra}(\mathbb C,V), with degree-one inclusion ι:V→A\iota:V\to A.

For a natural number nn and a family v:In→Vv:I_n\to V, the ambient symmetric monomial is the product Mn(v)∈AM_n(v)\in A in (1).✦ The homogeneous component Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^nV of AA, for a natural number nn, is the subspace spanned by the products Mn(v)M_n(v) for families v:In→Vv:I_n\to V.✦ For a natural number nn, the multilinear symmetric product pnp_n is the map from VInV^{I_n} to Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^nV that sends a family vv to its symmetric monomial, regarded as an element of Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^nV: Mn(v)=∏j∈Inι(vj),Sym⁡nV=span⁡ℂ{Mn(v):v:In→V},pn:VIn→Sym⁡nV,pn(v)=Mn(v).\begin{gathered} M_n(v)=\prod_{j\in I_n}\iota(v_j),\qquad \operatorname{Sym}^nV =\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb C}\{M_n(v):v:I_n\to V\},\\ p_n:V^{I_n}\longrightarrow\operatorname{Sym}^nV,\qquad p_n(v)=M_n(v). \end{gathered}(1) The pure power xnx^n of a vector x∈Vx\in V, for a natural number nn, is the element of Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^nV given by xn=pn((x)j∈In)x^n=p_n((x)_{j\in I_n}). Symmetric power multiplication for natural numbers m,nm,n is the bilinear map in (2) given by ambient multiplication: Sym⁡mV×Sym⁡nV→Sym⁡m+nV,(P,Q)↦PQ.\operatorname{Sym}^mV\times\operatorname{Sym}^nV \longrightarrow\operatorname{Sym}^{m+n}V,\qquad (P,Q)\longmapsto PQ.(2)✦

Let a,ba,b be natural numbers. A multilinear form on aa copies of Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^bV is a complex-valued map TT that is linear in each argument.✦ For a multilinear form TT on aa copies of Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^bV, the flattened multilinear form T̃:VIa×Ib→ℂ\widetilde T:V^{I_a\times I_b}\to\mathbb C is the map defined by (3): T̃((vij)i,j)=T((pb((vij)j∈Ib))i∈Ia).\widetilde T((v_{ij})_{i,j}) =T\bigl((p_b((v_{ij})_{j\in I_b}))_{i\in I_a}\bigr).(3)✦

For natural numbers r,mr,m, put b=r+mb=r+m. A form TT on r+1r+1 copies of Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^bV satisfies the common-power vanishing condition (4) when, for every x,t∈Vx,t\in V and every family Q:Ir→Sym⁡mVQ:I_r\to\operatorname{Sym}^mV, T(tb,(xrQi)i∈Ir)=0.T\bigl(t^b,(x^rQ_i)_{i\in I_r}\bigr)=0.(4)

Block Polynomials

The transfer blocks for natural numbers r,br,b form the set BrB_r in (5).✦ The slot assignment λk:Ir+1×Ib→Br\lambda_k:I_{r+1}\times I_b\to B_r for a tuple k:Ir→ℕk:I_r\to\mathbb N is the map specified there: Br={X,Z}⊔{Ui:i∈Ir},λk(0,j)=Z,λk(i+1,j)={X,j<ki,Ui,j≥ki,i∈Ir,j∈Ib.\begin{gathered} B_r=\{X,Z\}\sqcup\{U_i:i\in I_r\},\qquad \lambda_k(0,j)=Z,\\ \lambda_k(i+1,j)= \begin{cases} X,&j<k_i,\\ U_i,&j\ge k_i, \end{cases} \qquad i\in I_r,\quad j\in I_b. \end{gathered}(5) Write k+δik+\delta_i for the tuple obtained by increasing the ii-th entry of kk by one.

For index sets J,BJ,B, a multilinear form L:VJ→ℂL:V^J\to\mathbb C, a coordinate family e=(eα)α∈Ke=(e_\alpha)_{\alpha\in K} in VV indexed by a finite set KK, and a block assignment λ:J→B\lambda:J\to B, the polynomial 𝒫e(L,λ)\mathcal P_e(L,\lambda) is the scalar polynomial in (6); arguments with the same label use the same vector variable: 𝒫e(L,λ)=L((∑α∈Kzλ(s),αeα)s∈J)∈ℂ[zβ,α:β∈B,α∈K].\mathcal P_e(L,\lambda) =L\left(\left(\sum_{\alpha\in K} z_{\lambda(s),\alpha}e_\alpha\right)_{s\in J}\right) \in\mathbb C[z_{\beta,\alpha}:\beta\in B,\ \alpha\in K].(6)✦ With TT a form with r+1r+1 arguments, put Pk=𝒫e(T̃,λk)P_k=\mathcal P_e(\widetilde T,\lambda_k). The polarization operator DY,UD_{Y,U} from source UU to destination YY, where U,YU,Y are coordinate blocks, is the differential operator given by (7), with all other blocks independent: DY,U=∑α∈KYα∂∂Uα.D_{Y,U}=\sum_{\alpha\in K}Y_\alpha \frac{\partial}{\partial U_\alpha}.(7)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let r,br,b be natural numbers satisfying r(r+1)≤br(r+1)\le b, and let k:Ir→ℕk:I_r\to\mathbb N satisfy kj≤rk_j\le r for every j∈Irj\in I_r. For i∈Iri\in I_r with ki<rk_i<r, the source and destination degrees satisfy ∑j∈Irkj<b−ki.\sum_{j\in I_r}k_j<b-k_i.(8)✦ For a multilinear form TT on r+1r+1 copies of Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^bV and a finite coordinate family ee, suppose Pk+δi=0P_{k+\delta_i}=0. Then Pk=0.P_k=0.(9)✦

Let r,mr,m be arbitrary natural numbers, put b=r+mb=r+m, and let TT satisfy (4). For every finite coordinate family ee, P(r)i∈Ir=0.P_{(r)_{i\in I_r}}=0.(10)✦ If VV is finite-dimensional and r(r+1)≤br(r+1)\le b, then for every family v:Ir+1→Vv:I_{r+1}\to V, T((vib)i∈Ir+1)=0.T\bigl((v_i^b)_{i\in I_{r+1}}\bigr)=0.(11)✦

Let a,ba,b be arbitrary natural numbers and SS a multilinear form on aa copies of Sym⁡bV\operatorname{Sym}^bV. Suppose S((vib)i∈Ia)=0S((v_i^b)_{i\in I_a})=0 for every family v:Ia→Vv:I_a\to V. Then S=0.S=0.(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: fix tt and let f=T((vib)i∈Ir,tb)f=T((v_i^b)_{i\in I_r},t^b) in independent viv_i blocks, with one further block xx of degree zero; applying Dx,virD_{x,v_i}^r for every i∈Iri\in I_r gives (b!/m!)rT((xrvim)i∈Ir,tb)=0(b!/m!)^rT((x^rv_i^m)_{i\in I_r},t^b)=0, at every step the source degree is at least m+1≥r2+1m+1\ge r^2+1 and the shared destination degree is at most r2−1r^2-1, differential injectivity gives f=0f=0, and pure-power spanning gives T=0T=0.

What Is Checked

The degree comparison (8) and polynomial descent (9) use natural transfer counts bounded by rr and the quadratic bound r(r+1)≤br(r+1)\le b. The terminal statement (10) is over arbitrary complex vector spaces and finite coordinate families under (4); the transfer statement (11) also assumes finite dimension and the quadratic bound. Pure-power detection (12) is stated for arbitrary natural degrees over every complex vector space.

For natural m,nm,n, let P∈Sym⁡mVP\in\operatorname{Sym}^mV and Q∈Sym⁡nVQ\in\operatorname{Sym}^nV. PQ∈Sym⁡m+nV.PQ\in\operatorname{Sym}^{m+n}V.(13)✦