The Setting
The comparison concerns the signed relator counts of a finite product of conjugates, recorded at vertices of a Cayley graph. Let be a group, let be a generator alphabet with assigned values , and let be the free group on . Word evaluation is the homomorphism extending .✦ Distinct letters of remain distinct even when their values agree.
Let index relator words . With acting on the left, the based edge module and the relator module are the free left -modules in (1); for a vertex , their integral basis elements are written and . (1) An edge labelled runs from to . The based path chain is the signed integral edge chain obtained by traversing from , with reverse traversals counted negatively; write .✦ The relator boundary map is the integral linear map specified by (2). (2)✦
Normal Factors and Labels
A normal closure factor is a triple consisting of a conjugating word, a relator index and a sign.✦ For a normal closure factor and a vertex , the conjugate relator word and the translated signed relator count are defined by (3). (3)
For a group , an edge labelling is a function assigning an element of to each based edge. The semidirect label homomorphism extends , with the shift action on functions.✦ The path holonomy is the value at of the function component of , equivalently the product of edge labels in traversal order, taking inverses on reverse traversals.✦
Let be the group of unit quaternions, consisting of the quaternions of norm one.✦ For an index set , a relator factor is a triple consisting of an element of , an index in and a sign.✦ The signed relator count of a finite list is defined by (4), where denotes the integral basis vector at . (4)✦ For labels , the evaluated normal factor is the relator factor in (5). (5)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Suppose every relator evaluates to the identity in and the relator boundary map is injective. Let and satisfy . For a finite list of normal closure factors satisfying , the identity (6) holds. (6)✦ For any finite list satisfying (6), let be a group homomorphism and let be an edge labelling. At every starting vertex , the identity (7) holds, with the integral basis vector in . (7)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for the aligned presentation, with denoting the final relator index corresponding to , and fixed finite normal closure expressions , one has in the free module on all final relator indices.
What Is Checked
The claims are stated over arbitrary groups and alphabets: (6) requires closed relators with injective boundary map and a specified normal closure expression with the prescribed based chain, while (7) requires the count identity and allows arbitrary homomorphisms and -valued edge labels.