OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. A rational Lie algebra of categorical values

Lemma 6.2 [Rational finite data - nonvanishing counterpart]: Nonvanishing of an associative-word coefficient on a real Drinfeld solution

Rational descent in a fixed weight.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A fixed associative word gives a linear functional on Lie polynomials. Here its restriction to a homogeneous space of Drinfeld solutions is considered over ℚ\mathbb Q and over ℝ\mathbb R.

For F=ℚF=\mathbb Q or ℝ\mathbb R, let LFL_F be the free Lie algebra over FF on x,yx,y, and write L=LℚL=L_{\mathbb Q}. For a Lie algebra MM over FF and a,b∈Ma,b\in M, substitution p↦p(a,b)p\mapsto p(a,b) is the unique Lie homomorphism from LFL_F to MM sending xx to aa and yy to bb.

For an alphabet α\alpha with a weight function d:α→ℕd:\alpha\to\mathbb N, a Lie word uu on α\alpha is a bracketed expression formed from free letters by ordinary brackets. A letter aa has weight d(a)d(a), and the bracket of words of weights r,sr,s has weight r+sr+s. The weight component HF,d(n)H_{F,d}(n) of the free Lie algebra over FF on α\alpha is the FF-linear subspace spanned by Lie words of weight nn. Giving x,yx,y weight one defines the homogeneous components in (1). HF,d(n)=span⁡F{u:u is a Lie word of weight n},(LF)n=HF,1(n),Ln=(Lℚ)n.H_{F,d}(n)=\operatorname{span}_F \{u:u\text{ is a Lie word of weight }n\}, \qquad (L_F)_n=H_{F,1}(n),\qquad L_n=(L_{\mathbb Q})_n.(1)

The free chord Lie algebra 𝔟F\mathfrak b_F is the free Lie algebra over FF on the chord index set {(i,j):0≤i<j≤3}\{(i,j):0\leq i<j\leq3\}. Its free chord generators are denoted cijc_{ij}, with cji=cijc_{ji}=c_{ij} and cii=0c_{ii}=0. The infinitesimal braid relation ideal IFI_F of 𝔟F\mathfrak b_F is the Lie ideal generated by the expressions in (2). The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4,F\mathfrak t_{4,F} is the quotient of 𝔟F\mathfrak b_F by IFI_F, and its chord generators tijt_{ij} are the images of the free chord generators cijc_{ij}. [cij,ckl](i,j,k,l pairwise distinct),[cij,cik+cjk](i,j,k pairwise distinct),𝔱4,F=𝔟F/IF,tij=cij+IF.\begin{gathered} [c_{ij},c_{kl}]\quad(i,j,k,l\text{ pairwise distinct}),\qquad [c_{ij},c_{ik}+c_{jk}]\quad(i,j,k\text{ pairwise distinct}),\\ \mathfrak t_{4,F}=\mathfrak b_F/I_F,\qquad t_{ij}=c_{ij}+I_F. \end{gathered}(2)

The antisymmetry operator aF:LF→LFa_F:L_F\to L_F, cyclic sum operator bF:LF→LFb_F:L_F\to L_F, and pentagon operator PF:LF→𝔱4,FP_F:L_F\to\mathfrak t_{4,F} are the linear maps in (3). Subscripts are omitted for F=ℚF=\mathbb Q. aF(p)=p+p(y,x),bF(p)=p+p(y,−x−y)+p(−x−y,x),PF(p)=p(t01,t12+t13)+p(t02+t12,t23)−p(t12,t23)−p(t01+t02,t13+t23)−p(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} a_F(p)&=p+p(y,x),\\ b_F(p)&=p+p(y,-x-y)+p(-x-y,x),\\ P_F(p)&=p(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+p(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23})\\ &\quad-p(t_{12},t_{23}) -p(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23})-p(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(3)

A Drinfeld solution in LFL_F is an element annihilated by the operators in (3). The solution space WFW_F of LFL_F is the FF-linear subspace of Drinfeld solutions, and WF,nW_{F,n} is its homogeneous weight-nn part, as in (4); write W=WℚW=W_{\mathbb Q} and Wn=Wℚ,nW_n=W_{\mathbb Q,n}. WF=ker⁡aF∩ker⁡bF∩ker⁡PF,WF,n=WF∩(LF)n.W_F=\ker a_F\cap\ker b_F\cap\ker P_F,\qquad W_{F,n}=W_F\cap(L_F)_n.(4)

Word Coefficients and Scalar Extension

For a commutative ring RR and alphabet α\alpha, the free associative algebra AR(α)A_R(\alpha) is the monoid algebra of the free monoid α*\alpha^* of words.✦ The associative generator XaX_a of AR(α)A_R(\alpha) attached to a letter a∈αa\in\alpha is the monomial supported on the one-letter word aa, with coefficient one.✦ The universal associative embedding ιR\iota_R from the free Lie algebra on α\alpha to AR(α)A_R(\alpha) is the unique Lie homomorphism sending each free letter to its associative generator.✦ For a word w∈{x,y}*w\in\{x,y\}^*, the coefficient functional cw,Fc_{w,F} on LFL_F is the FF-linear map to FF defined by (5), where [w][w] denotes extraction of the coefficient of the word ww. AR(α)=R[α*],cw,F(p)=[w]ιF(p),cw=cw,ℚ.A_R(\alpha)=R[\alpha^*],\qquad c_{w,F}(p)=[w]\iota_F(p),\qquad c_w=c_{w,\mathbb Q}.(5)

For a rational vector space MM, the real scalar extension T(M)T(M) is the real vector space given by T(M)=ℝ⊗ℚMT(M)=\mathbb R\otimes_{\mathbb Q}M.✦ Write Lie⁡F(α)\operatorname{Lie}_F(\alpha) for the free Lie algebra over FF on α\alpha; the free Lie scalar extension map Φα\Phi_\alpha is the unique real Lie homomorphism specified in (6). Write Φ=Φ{x,y}\Phi=\Phi_{\{x,y\}}. Φα:Lie⁡ℝ(α)→T(Lie⁡ℚ(α)),a↦1⊗a.\Phi_\alpha:\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb R}(\alpha) \longrightarrow T(\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Q}(\alpha)), \qquad a\longmapsto1\otimes a.(6) The quotient projection ρn:L→L/Ln\rho_n:L\to L/L_n sends qq to q+Lnq+L_n.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let KK be a field, let V,E,SV,E,S be KK-vector spaces, and let f:V→Ef:V\to E and ℓ:V→K\ell:V\to K be linear maps. Suppose u∈S⊗KVu\in S\otimes_K V satisfies (1S⊗f)(u)=0(1_S\otimes f)(u)=0 and (1S⊗ℓ)(u)≠0(1_S\otimes\ell)(u)\ne0. There is v∈Vv\in V satisfying (7). f(v)=0,ℓ(v)≠0.f(v)=0,\qquad \ell(v)\ne0.(7)✦

For p∈Wℝp\in W_{\mathbb R}, the extended rational equation maps satisfy (8). (1ℝ⊗a)(Φ(p))=0,(1ℝ⊗b)(Φ(p))=0,(1ℝ⊗P)(Φ(p))=0.(1_{\mathbb R}\otimes a)(\Phi(p))=0,\qquad (1_{\mathbb R}\otimes b)(\Phi(p))=0,\qquad (1_{\mathbb R}\otimes P)(\Phi(p))=0.(8)✦ For n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N and p∈(Lℝ)np\in(L_{\mathbb R})_n, the extended homogeneous quotient map satisfies (9). (1ℝ⊗ρn)(Φ(p))=0.(1_{\mathbb R}\otimes\rho_n)(\Phi(p))=0.(9)✦

Let n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, let w∈{x,y}*w\in\{x,y\}^*, and let p∈Wℝ∩(Lℝ)np\in W_{\mathbb R}\cap(L_{\mathbb R})_n have cw,ℝ(p)≠0c_{w,\mathbb R}(p)\ne0. There is q∈Lq\in L satisfying (10). q∈Wn,cw(q)≠0.q\in W_n,\qquad c_w(q)\ne0.(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for every n>0n>0 and characteristic-zero extension K/ℚK/\mathbb Q, the weight-nn spaces of categorical values satisfy Dn(K)=Dn(ℚ)⊗ℚKD_n(K)=D_n(\mathbb Q)\otimes_{\mathbb Q}K, for n≥2n\geq2 their evaluation image is Vn⊗ℚKV_n\otimes_{\mathbb Q}K, where VnV_n is the rational evaluation image, and consequently nonvanishing of a fixed associative-word coefficient on a complex categorical value of weight nn implies nonvanishing on a rational categorical value of that weight.

What Is Checked

The statements concern the ordinary free Lie algebras L,LℝL,L_{\mathbb R}, their homogeneous components (1), and the braid quotients (2); the coefficient functionals are those of (5).