OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §7. Holonomy and odd depth-one values

Proposition 7.3 [Odd depth-one values]: Rational homogeneous Drinfeld solutions give finite categorical witnesses

Odd weights above one have nonzero depth-one values.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For free Lie generators x,yx,y of weight one and n≥1n\ge1, the coefficient of the ordered word xn−1yx^{n-1}y is a linear functional on Lie polynomials of weight nn. The proposition concerns this functional on Drinfeld solutions and on the values of finite categorical gauges.

For a commutative ring SS and an alphabet α\alpha, let LS(α)L_S(\alpha) be the free Lie algebra with its ordinary bracket, and let AS(α)A_S(\alpha) be the free associative algebra with its word basis. A letter represents its one-letter monomial, and an assignment of letters to an SS-algebra extends to an associative evaluation map. The universal associative embedding ιS:LS(α)→AS(α)\iota_S:L_S(\alpha)\to A_S(\alpha) sends free Lie generators to these monomials.✦ Write [w]a[w]a for the coefficient of the word ww in a∈AS(α)a\in A_S(\alpha). For the alphabet {x,y}\{x,y\}, abbreviate these algebras to LSL_S and ASA_S, and put L=LℚL=L_{\mathbb Q}.

A bracketed word ww on an alphabet α\alpha is a letter of α\alpha or a bracket of two bracketed words on α\alpha.✦ Its evaluation replaces each letter by its free generator and each bracket by the ordinary Lie bracket✦; its underlying word lists the letters from left to right.✦ Given letter weights, the weight of an associative or bracketed word is the sum of its letter weights. For prescribed letter weights on α\alpha, the homogeneous Lie component LS(α)nL_S(\alpha)_n of weight nn in LS(α)L_S(\alpha) is the span of evaluated bracketed words of weight nn.✦ Giving xx and yy weight one defines Ln⊂LL_n\subset L.✦

The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 is the quotient of the rational free chord Lie algebra on unordered pairs of distinct elements of {0,1,2,3}\{0,1,2,3\} by the ideal generated by (1).✦ Here cijc_{ij} is the free chord generator, with cji=cijc_{ji}=c_{ij} and cii=0c_{ii}=0, and tijt_{ij} is its quotient image. The relevant indices in each relation are pairwise distinct. [cij,ckl]=0,[cij,cik+cjk]=0.[c_{ij},c_{kl}]=0,\qquad [c_{ij},c_{ik}+c_{jk}]=0.(1) For a family fijf_{ij} in a rational Lie algebra MM, the free braid evaluation is the Lie homomorphism from the free chord Lie algebra to MM sending cijc_{ij} to fijf_{ij} for i<ji<j. A symmetric family with zero diagonal satisfying (1) defines the corresponding homomorphism from 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 to MM.

For a rational Lie algebra MM and u,v∈Mu,v\in M, the substitution p↦p(u,v)p\mapsto p(u,v) is the Lie homomorphism L→ML\to M sending xx to uu and yy to vv.✦ A Drinfeld solution is an element p∈Lp\in L satisfying (2).✦ p(x,y)+p(y,x)=0,p(x,y)+p(y,−x−y)+p(−x−y,x)=0,p(t01,t12+t13)+p(t02+t12,t23)=p(t12,t23)+p(t01+t02,t13+t23)+p(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} p(x,y)+p(y,x)&=0,\\ p(x,y)+p(y,-x-y)+p(-x-y,x)&=0,\\ p(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+p(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23}) &=p(t_{12},t_{23})\\ &\quad+p(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23})+p(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(2) The solution space W⊂LW\subset L is the rational subspace of Drinfeld solutions; its homogeneous part is Wn=W∩LnW_n=W\cap L_n. Ordinary yy-depth counts occurrences of yy, so the depth-one word of weight nn is xn−1yx^{n-1}y. The nonnegative index kk labels the weight nk=2k+3n_k=2k+3, giving the weights 3,5,7,…3,5,7,\ldots.✦

Real Holonomy Values

For a condition on words, the prescribed word span is the span of its satisfying monomials✦, and the support projection retains those monomials and kills the others.✦ The projection pr⁡n\operatorname{pr}_n retains words of weight nn✦; for unit letter weights it is the tensor homogeneous projection. Write AS≥mA_S^{\ge m} for the span of words of length at least mm.✦ For a nonnegative integer NN and a set of relations 𝒫⊂AS(α)\mathcal P\subset A_S(\alpha), the presented truncation and its quotient map are as in (3); the unadorned notation denotes the empty presentation. QS,N(𝒫)=AS(α)/⟨𝒫,AS≥N+1⟩,π𝒫,N:AS(α)→QS,N(𝒫),QS,N=QS,N(⌀),FNm=π⌀,N(AS≥m).\begin{gathered} Q_{S,N}(\mathcal P)= A_S(\alpha)/\langle\mathcal P,A_S^{\ge N+1}\rangle, \qquad \pi_{\mathcal P,N}:A_S(\alpha)\longrightarrow Q_{S,N}(\mathcal P),\\ Q_{S,N}=Q_{S,N}(\varnothing),\qquad F_N^m=\pi_{\varnothing,N}(A_S^{\ge m}). \end{gathered}(3) For a letter a∈αa\in\alpha, the truncated generator aNa_N is π⌀,N(a)\pi_{\varnothing,N}(a).✦ The bounded-degree word space BS,NB_{S,N} is the span of words of length at most NN✦, and its truncation projection τN\tau_N discards longer words.✦ Truncated left multiplication is the action p⋅b=τN(pb)p\cdot b=\tau_N(pb) on BS,NB_{S,N}.✦ For z∈QS,Nz\in Q_{S,N}, the quotient regular representation ρN\rho_N of truncated left multiplication defines the normal form ρN(z)1\rho_N(z)1, evaluated on the constant word vector 11.✦ The polynomial normal representative jN(z)j_N(z) of z∈QS,Nz\in Q_{S,N} is the image of its normal form ρN(z)1\rho_N(z)1 under the inclusion of BS,NB_{S,N} in AS(α)A_S(\alpha).✦ The quotient weight filtration on QS,N(𝒫)Q_{S,N}(\mathcal P) has degree-mm term equal to the image of AS≥mA_S^{\ge m} under π𝒫,N\pi_{\mathcal P,N}.✦

In the binary algebra QS,NQ_{S,N}, the truncated depth space DNmD_N^m is the image of the word span of words containing at least mm letters yy.✦ For S=ℝS=\mathbb R, the rational depth filtration consists of these same subspaces regarded over ℚ\mathbb Q.✦

A nilpotent multiplicative filtration on a normed real algebra AA is a decreasing family of real subspaces FmF^m with 1∈F01\in F^0, FmFn⊂Fm+nF^mF^n\subset F^{m+n}, and FN+1=0F^{N+1}=0 for a specified cutoff NN.✦ The word filtration FNmF_N^m on Qℝ,NQ_{\mathbb R,N} is the weight filtration used for holonomy.✦ For a connection form Ω:ℝ→A\Omega:\mathbb R\to A, its iterated integrals and finite Picard transport are defined by (4). I0(a,t)=1,Ir+1(a,t)=∫atΩ(s)Ir(a,s)ds,UΩ,N(a,t)=∑r=0NIr(a,t).\begin{aligned} I_0(a,t)&=1,& I_{r+1}(a,t)&=\int_a^t\Omega(s)I_r(a,s)\,ds,\\ U_{\Omega,N}(a,t)&=\sum_{r=0}^N I_r(a,t). \end{aligned}(4) For algebra elements XX and YY in AA, the singular gauge GXG_X, regularized Knizhnik-Zamolodchikov (KZ) connection ΩX,Y\Omega_{X,Y}, and left and right normalized solutions are given in (5). Their comparison at 1/21/2 defines the KZ associator in (6).✦ GX(s)=exp⁡((log⁡s)X),ΩX,Y(s)=G−X(s)Ys−1GX(s),HX,Y(s)=GX(s)UΩX,Y,N(0,s),HX,Yr(s)=HY,X(1−s).\begin{aligned} G_X(s)&=\exp((\log s)X),\\ \Omega_{X,Y}(s)&=G_{-X}(s)\frac{Y}{s-1}G_X(s),\\ H_{X,Y}(s)&=G_X(s)U_{\Omega_{X,Y},N}(0,s),& H^r_{X,Y}(s)&=H_{Y,X}(1-s). \end{aligned}(5) Φ(X,Y)=HX,Yr(1/2)−1HX,Y(1/2).\Phi(X,Y)=H^r_{X,Y}(1/2)^{-1}H_{X,Y}(1/2).(6)

For an assignment fa∈FN1f_a\in F_N^1, the truncated substitution is the SS-algebra endomorphism of QS,NQ_{S,N} sending every truncated generator aNa_N to faf_a.✦ For a scalar r∈Sr\in S, generator scaling σr\sigma_r is the substitution aN↦raNa_N\mapsto r a_N.✦ For a unit P∈QS,N×P\in Q_{S,N}^{\times} with P−1∈FN1P-1\in F_N^1, partial conjugation TPT_P is the substitution automorphism in (7).✦ The same display defines its comparison automorphism and comparison arrow for two such units P,VP,V. TP(xN)=xN,TP(yN)=P−1yNP,ΘP,V=TV∘TP−1,UP,V=VΘP,V(P)−1.\begin{gathered} T_P(x_N)=x_N,\qquad T_P(y_N)=P^{-1}y_NP,\\ \Theta_{P,V}=T_V\circ T_P^{-1},\qquad U_{P,V}=V\,\Theta_{P,V}(P)^{-1}. \end{gathered}(7) In Qℝ,NQ_{\mathbb R,N}, let PNP_N be the associator unit Φ(xN,yN)\Phi(x_N,y_N)✦ and let VN=σ−1(PN)V_N=\sigma_{-1}(P_N) be its sign-reversed unit.✦ The KZ comparison uses ΘN=ΘPN,VN\Theta_N=\Theta_{P_N,V_N} and UN=UPN,VNU_N=U_{P_N,V_N}, with frames H0=1H_0=1 and H1=UNH_1=U_N.

For an assignment aN↦fa∈FN1a_N\mapsto f_a\in F_N^1 in QS,NQ_{S,N} such that each fa−aNf_a-a_N belongs to FN2F_N^2, the unipotent substitution automorphism is the algebra automorphism of QS,NQ_{S,N} induced by this assignment.✦

A unipotent category automorphism on an object set OO is a family SpqS_{pq} of rational linear endomorphisms of an algebra satisfying (8), for a common nilpotency bound MM.✦ In that display, zz is a formal variable and [z][z] extracts its linear coefficient. (Spq−1)M+1=0,Spr(ba)=Sqr(b)Spq(a),Spp(1)=1,δpq=∑r=0M([z](zr))(Spq−1)r,(zr)=1r!∏i=0r−1(z−i).\begin{gathered} (S_{pq}-1)^{M+1}=0,\qquad S_{pr}(ba)=S_{qr}(b)S_{pq}(a),\qquad S_{pp}(1)=1,\\ \delta_{pq}=\sum_{r=0}^M \left([z]\binom zr\right)(S_{pq}-1)^r, \qquad \binom zr=\frac{1}{r!}\prod_{i=0}^{r-1}(z-i). \end{gathered}(8) The categorical logarithm δpq\delta_{pq} of a unipotent category automorphism SpqS_{pq} is the nilpotent operator logarithm in (8).✦ For an algebra automorphism Θ\Theta and unit frames HpH_p, the gauge maps are Spq(a)=HqΘ(a)Hp−1S_{pq}(a)=H_q\Theta(a)H_p^{-1}.✦ The KZ logarithmic category has objects {0,1}\{0,1\}, these maps for ΘN\Theta_N and its frames, and bound M=N+1M=N+1.✦ Its logarithmic comparison value is zN=δ01(1)z_N=\delta_{01}(1).✦ For n>0n>0, the homogeneous KZ Lie value qnKZ∈Lℝq_n^{\mathrm{KZ}}\in L_{\mathbb R} is a chosen weight-nn Lie polynomial whose associative embedding is pr⁡n(jn(zn))\operatorname{pr}_n(j_n(z_n)), the degree-nn part of the polynomial normal representative of the logarithmic KZ comparison value at cutoff nn; put q0KZ=0q_0^{\mathrm{KZ}}=0.✦

For each nonnegative integer rr, the binomial polynomial (zr)∈ℚ[z]\binom zr\in\mathbb Q[z] is the falling factorial polynomial of order rr divided by r!r!, as in (8).✦

Finite Categorical Gauges

For a commutative ring SS and a Lie algebra MM over SS, categorical gauge data g=(d,h)g=(d,h) on an object set OO are a pair consisting of an SS-linear Lie derivation dd of MM and potentials h:O→Mh:O\to M.✦ Their gauge differences upqgu^g_{pq} and loop derivations ℓpg\ell^g_p are defined in (9). upqg=h(q)−h(p),ℓpg(a)=d(a)−[a,h(p)].u^g_{pq}=h(q)-h(p),\qquad \ell^g_p(a)=d(a)-[a,h(p)].(9) For a Lie homomorphism F:M→M′F:M\to M' and an object map f:O→O′f:O\to O', a categorical gauge gg on OO with values in MM and a categorical gauge kk on O′O' with values in M′M' are compatible when uf(p)f(q)k=F(upqg)u^k_{f(p)f(q)}=F(u^g_{pq}) and ℓf(p)k(F(a))=F(ℓpg(a))\ell^k_{f(p)}(F(a))=F(\ell^g_p(a)) for every p,q,ap,q,a.✦ Edge compatibility between p→qp\to q and s→ts\to t under FF requires ustk=F(upqg)u^k_{st}=F(u^g_{pq}) and ℓsk(F(a))=F(ℓpg(a))\ell^k_s(F(a))=F(\ell^g_p(a)) for every aa.✦

Let ss be the substitution (x,y)↦(y,x)(x,y)\mapsto(y,x) and let rr be the substitution (x,y)↦(y,−x−y)(x,y)\mapsto(y,-x-y). A finite categorical gauge witness ww is a pair of gauges g3,g4g_3,g_4 with values in L,𝔱4L,\mathfrak t_4 on {0,1,2}\{0,1,2\} and {A,B,C,D,E}={0,1,2,3,4}\{A,B,C,D,E\}=\{0,1,2,3,4\}, respectively. The gauge g3g_3 is compatible with itself under (s,(01))(s,(01)) and (r,(012))(r,(012)), and satisfies ℓ0g3(x)=ℓ1g3(y)=0\ell^{g_3}_0(x)=\ell^{g_3}_1(y)=0. The five edge compatibilities transport 0→10\to1 of g3g_3 to the edges of g4g_4 specified in (10), whose columns give the images of x,yx,y. The value v(w)∈Lv(w)\in L is u01g3u^{g_3}_{01}.✦ edgexyADt02+t12t23DEt01t12+t13ABt01t12BCt01+t02t13+t23CEt12t23\begin{array}{c|cc} \text{edge}&x&y\\ \hline AD&t_{02}+t_{12}&t_{23}\\ DE&t_{01}&t_{12}+t_{13}\\ AB&t_{01}&t_{12}\\ BC&t_{01}+t_{02}&t_{13}+t_{23}\\ CE&t_{12}&t_{23} \end{array}(10)

For a rational Lie algebra MM, a first-order Lie jet (a,u)∈M⊕M(a,u)\in M\oplus M is a pair consisting of a base point a∈Ma\in M and a velocity u∈Mu\in M, with bracket as in (11)✦; for M=LM=L this is the tangent Lie algebra.✦ The tangent substitution attached to q∈Lq\in L sends xx to (x,0)(x,0) and yy to (y,[y,q])(y,[y,q]).✦ The tangential derivation DqD_q is the velocity of this substitution.✦ [(a,u),(b,v)]=([a,b],[a,v]+[u,b]).[(a,u),(b,v)]=([a,b],[a,v]+[u,b]).(11) Write (a,b,c,d,e,f)=(t01,t12,t23,t02,t13,t03)(a,b,c,d,e,f)=(t_{01},t_{12},t_{23},t_{02},t_{13},t_{03}). The pentagon potentials associated with qq are given in (12). PA=q(a,b),PB=q(a+d,e+c),PD=q(d+b,c),PE=q(a,b+e).\begin{aligned} P_A&=q(a,b),&P_B&=q(a+d,e+c),\\ P_D&=q(d+b,c),&P_E&=q(a,b+e). \end{aligned}(12) For each chord generator uu, the tangent chord ju=(u,vu)j_u=(u,v_u) has the velocity prescribed in (13). The symmetric chord matrix JJ in (14) specifies the four-strand jet homomorphism tij↦Jijt_{ij}\mapsto J_{ij} for homogeneous q∈Wnq\in W_n, n>2n>2✦; its velocity is the four-strand derivation 𝒟q\mathcal D_q.✦ va=0,vb=[b,PA],vc=[c,PD],vd=−vb,ve=[b+e,PD+PE]−vb,vf=−vc−ve.\begin{aligned} v_a&=0,&v_b&=[b,P_A],&v_c&=[c,P_D],\\ v_d&=-v_b,&v_e&=[b+e,P_D+P_E]-v_b,&v_f&=-v_c-v_e. \end{aligned}(13) J=(0jajdjfja0jbjejdjb0jcjfjejc0).J=\begin{pmatrix} 0&j_a&j_d&j_f\\ j_a&0&j_b&j_e\\ j_d&j_b&0&j_c\\ j_f&j_e&j_c&0 \end{pmatrix}.(14) For every q∈Lq\in L, the three-object gauge g3(q)g_3(q) has tangential derivation DqD_q and potentials 0,q,q+r(q)0,q,q+r(q).✦ For q∈Wnq\in W_n with n>2n>2, the canonical witness w(q)w(q) has this gauge and the five-object gauge g4(q)g_4(q) in (15).✦ g3(q)=(Dq,(0,q,q+r(q))),g4(q)=(𝒟q,(0,PA,PA+PB,PD,PD+PE)).\begin{aligned} g_3(q)&=(D_q,(0,q,q+r(q))),\\ g_4(q)&=(\mathcal D_q,(0,P_A,P_A+P_B,P_D,P_D+P_E)). \end{aligned}(15)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let kk be a nonnegative integer and put n=2k+3n=2k+3. There is a rational Lie polynomial qq with q∈Wn,[xn−1y]ιℚ(q)≠0.q\in W_n,\qquad [x^{n-1}y]\iota_{\mathbb Q}(q)\ne0.(16)✦ For the real homogeneous KZ Lie value in this weight, [xn−1y]ιℝ(qnKZ)≠0.[x^{n-1}y]\iota_{\mathbb R}(q_n^{\mathrm{KZ}})\ne0.(17)✦ For every homogeneous Drinfeld solution p∈Wmp\in W_m with m>2m>2, the canonical categorical witness has value v(w(p))=p.v(w(p))=p.(18)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for every odd n≥3n\ge3 there is ψn∈Wn\psi_n\in W_n with nonzero coefficient of xn−1yx^{n-1}y, equivalently with ordinary yy-depth-one part a nonzero multiple of ad⁡xn−1y\operatorname{ad}_x^{n-1}y.

What Is Checked

The rational existence statement (16) is over W∩LnW\cap L_n and its associative coefficient functional; (17) is over the real free Lie algebra and its KZ values. Equation (18) uses finite gauges on three and five objects with values in LL and 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4.

The tangential operator DqD_q is rational linear. The gauge g3(q)g_3(q) has transposition compatibility for q∈Wq\in W✦.

For every unit PP, its partially conjugated generators belong to FN1F_N^1✦; when P−1∈FN1P-1\in F_N^1, they agree with the original generators modulo FN2F_N^2.✦ Both PNP_N and VNV_N differ from 11 by FN1F_N^1.

The depth spaces decrease✦ and multiply according to (19)✦; the remaining identities there give the bounds for the rational depth filtration and the corrections for the KZ comparison and its frames. DNiDNj⊂DNi+j,DN0=Qℝ,N,DNN+2=0,(ΘN−1)(DNi)⊂DNi+1,Hp−1∈DN1.\begin{gathered} D_N^iD_N^j\subset D_N^{i+j},\qquad D_N^0=Q_{\mathbb R,N},\qquad D_N^{N+2}=0,\\ (\Theta_N-1)(D_N^i)\subset D_N^{i+1},\qquad H_p-1\in D_N^1. \end{gathered}(19)

Gauge maps preserve composition✦ and send the identity of each loop to itself.✦ With a decreasing multiplicative filtration FF satisfying F0=AF^0=A and FM+1=0F^{M+1}=0, frames congruent to 11 modulo F1F^1 and an automorphism congruent to the identity from FiF^i to Fi+1F^{i+1} define unipotent category automorphism data as in (8).✦