OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· Β§5. The image of the leading projection

Section 5: comparison free Lie dimensions: Weight and bracket length in the comparison free Lie algebra over the field with two elements 𝑭2\mathbf F_2

Odd weights and finite dimension sums.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The comparison free Lie algebra has one generator in each odd weight 3,5,7,…3,5,7,\ldots. Its weight and bracket length give two degrees: the former counts generator occurrences with their assigned weights, and the latter counts each occurrence once.

Let SS be a commutative ring and Ξ±\alpha an alphabet. The free Lie algebra 𝔏S(Ξ±)\mathfrak L_S(\alpha) is the Lie algebra freely generated by Ξ±\alpha over SS, with the ordinary bracket [,][\ ,\ ].✦ A bracketed word tt over an alphabet Ξ±\alpha is either a letter of Ξ±\alpha or the bracket of two bracketed words over Ξ±\alpha.✦ The evaluation ev⁡S(t)βˆˆπ”S(Ξ±)\operatorname{ev}_S(t)\in\mathfrak L_S(\alpha) of a bracketed word tt over Ξ±\alpha is the element obtained recursively by sending a letter to its free generator and a bracket to the bracket of the two evaluations.✦

The underlying word leaves⁡(t)\operatorname{leaves}(t) of a bracketed word tt is its list of letters in left-to-right order; the underlying word of a bracket is the concatenation of the underlying words of its two arguments.✦ For a letter weight w:Ξ±β†’β„•w:\alpha\to\mathbb N, the word degree deg⁡w(u)\deg_w(u) of a word uu over Ξ±\alpha and the tree degree deg⁡w(t)\deg_w(t) of a bracketed word tt over Ξ±\alpha are the sums of the letter weights in their underlying words, as in (1): deg⁡w(a1β‹―as)=βˆ‘i=1sw(ai),deg⁡w(t)=deg⁡w(leaves⁡(t)).\deg_w(a_1\cdots a_s)=\sum_{i=1}^{s}w(a_i), \qquad \deg_w(t)=\deg_w\bigl(\operatorname{leaves}(t)\bigr).(1)

For a letter weight w:Ξ±β†’β„•w:\alpha\to\mathbb N and nβˆˆβ„•n\in\mathbb N, the homogeneous Lie component HS(w;n)H_S(w;n) of 𝔏S(Ξ±)\mathfrak L_S(\alpha) is the SS-submodule spanned by evaluations of bracketed words of tree degree nn, as in (2). The bihomogeneous component HS(wa,wb;n,r)H_S(w_a,w_b;n,r) of 𝔏S(Ξ±)\mathfrak L_S(\alpha), for letter weights wa,wbw_a,w_b on Ξ±\alpha and degrees n,rβˆˆβ„•n,r\in\mathbb N, is the intersection of the homogeneous components of degree nn for waw_a and degree rr for wbw_b, as in (3). HS(w;n)=span⁡S{ev⁡S(t):deg⁡w(t)=n}βŠ†π”S(Ξ±).H_S(w;n)=\operatorname{span}_S \{\operatorname{ev}_S(t):\deg_w(t)=n\} \subseteq\mathfrak L_S(\alpha).(2)✦ HS(wa,wb;n,r)=HS(wa;n)∩HS(wb;r).H_S(w_a,w_b;n,r)=H_S(w_a;n)\cap H_S(w_b;r).(3)✦

For the odd generators, take the alphabet β„•\mathbb N and label its letter kk by zk+1z_{k+1}. The odd letter weight woddw_{\mathrm{odd}} on the alphabet β„•\mathbb N is the function given by (4), so indices 0,1,2,…0,1,2,\ldots label generators of weights 3,5,7,…3,5,7,\ldots. The word length β„“(u)=deg⁡𝟏(u)\ell(u)=\deg_{\mathbf 1}(u) of a word uu on the alphabet β„•\mathbb N is its number of letters, where 𝟏\mathbf 1 assigns weight one to every letter. wodd(k)=2k+3(kβˆˆβ„•).w_{\mathrm{odd}}(k)=2k+3 \qquad(k\in\mathbb N).(4)✦

The Claim

Definition 1. The reduced coefficient field is 𝑭2=β„€/2β„€\mathbf F_2=\mathbb Z/2\mathbb Z.✦ For n,rβˆˆβ„•n,r\in\mathbb N, the odd weighted Lie component 𝔣n,rβŠ†π”π‘­2(β„•)\mathfrak f_{n,r}\subseteq\mathfrak L_{\mathbf F_2}(\mathbb N) is the weight nn, bracket length rr subspace defined by (5).✦ 𝔣n,r=H𝑭2(wodd,𝟏;n,r).\mathfrak f_{n,r} =H_{\mathbf F_2}(w_{\mathrm{odd}},\mathbf 1;n,r).(5)✦

Theorem 1. Let FF be a field, let wa,wb:Ξ±β†’β„•w_a,w_b:\alpha\to\mathbb N be letter weights, and let n,mβˆˆβ„•n,m\in\mathbb N. Suppose that HF(wa;n)H_F(w_a;n) is finite-dimensional and that every word of waw_a-degree nn has wbw_b-degree at most mm. Then its dimension decomposes as in (6). dim⁡FHF(wa;n)=βˆ‘r=0mdim⁡FHF(wa,wb;n,r).\dim_F H_F(w_a;n) =\sum_{r=0}^{m}\dim_F H_F(w_a,w_b;n,r).(6)✦ For a word uu on the odd generators with deg⁡wodd(u)=n\deg_{w_{\mathrm{odd}}}(u)=n, the length bound is (7). β„“(u)≀n.\ell(u)\leq n.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the free Lie algebra 𝔣F=Lie⁡F⟨zk:kβ‰₯1⟩\mathfrak f_F=\operatorname{Lie}_F\langle z_k:k\geq1\rangle, with wt⁡(zk)=2k+1\operatorname{wt}(z_k)=2k+1 and generator length one, has dimensions dn,rd_{n,r} in weight nn and length rr agreeing with the rational free Lie dimensions, and dn=βˆ‘rdn,rd_n=\sum_r d_{n,r}, a finite sum since weight is at least three times length.

What Is Checked

The statements concern words with nonnegative letter weights and ordinary free Lie algebras, using 𝑭2\mathbf F_2 for the odd components and an arbitrary field FF with the stated finite-dimensionality and word-degree bound for the dimension identity.