OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Deletion operators and injectivity of the leading projection

Proposition 4.4 [Injectivity of the leading projection]: For characteristic-two solutions of weight greater than two; weight and BB-count determine the A,CA,C-count

Vanishing leading projection raises the solution filtration.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The issue is whether deletion of a quadratic generator can annihilate the leading part of a characteristic-two solution of the Grothendieck-Teichmüller equations. The coefficient field throughout is 𝑭2\mathbf F_2.

For a commutative ring SS and an alphabet EE, the free Lie algebra 𝔣S(E)\mathfrak f_S(E) is generated by EE with the ordinary Lie bracket✦, and the free associative algebra 𝒜S(E)\mathcal A_S(E) has the words in EE as its monomial basis.✦ A word denotes the monomial with coefficient one supported on it✦; a letter denotes the corresponding one-letter monomial.✦ The universal associative embedding ιE:𝔣S(E)→𝒜S(E)\iota_E:\mathfrak f_S(E)\to\mathcal A_S(E) is the Lie homomorphism sending each free generator to its corresponding one-letter monomial. For an associative algebra DD over SS and an assignment f:E→Df:E\to D, associative evaluation is the unique SS-algebra homomorphism 𝒜S(E)→D\mathcal A_S(E)\to D extending ff. Alphabet renaming is the associative evaluation that sends each letter to its renamed letter.✦ We suppress the subscript SS when S=𝑭2S=\mathbf F_2. For a Lie algebra MM over SS and u,v∈Mu,v\in M, Lie polynomial evaluation at u,vu,v is the unique Lie homomorphism 𝔣S(x,y)→M\mathfrak f_S(x,y)\to M sending xx to uu and yy to vv; for a Lie polynomial qq in its domain, its value on qq is denoted q(u,v)q(u,v).

A bracketed word tt on an alphabet EE is a letter of EE or a bracket of two bracketed words on EE; its evaluation uses the ordinary Lie bracket, and its underlying word lists its leaves from left to right.✦ Given letter weights d:E→𝑵d:E\to\mathbf N, the weight d(w)d(w) of a word ww on EE is the sum of its letter weights, and a bracketed word on EE has the weight of its underlying word. For letter weights d,e:E→𝑵d,e:E\to\mathbf N and nonnegative integers j,sj,s, and writing tevt^{\mathrm{ev}} for the evaluation of a bracketed word tt, the homogeneous spaces and the weight filtration are the spans 𝒜d=j(E)=span⁡S{w:d(w)=j},𝒜d≥j(E)=span⁡S{w:d(w)≥j},𝔣d=j(E)=span⁡S{tev:d(t)=j},𝔣j,sd,e(E)=𝔣d=j(E)∩𝔣e=s(E).\begin{aligned} \mathcal A_{d=j}(E)&=\operatorname{span}_S\{w:d(w)=j\},& \mathcal A_{d\ge j}(E)&=\operatorname{span}_S\{w:d(w)\ge j\},\\ \mathfrak f_{d=j}(E)&=\operatorname{span}_S \{t^{\mathrm{ev}}:d(t)=j\},& \mathfrak f^{d,e}_{j,s}(E)&= \mathfrak f_{d=j}(E)\cap\mathfrak f_{e=s}(E). \end{aligned}(1) For an alphabet EE and a condition on words in EE, the prescribed word span V⊆𝒜S(E)V\subseteq\mathcal A_S(E) is the subspace spanned by the monomials satisfying that condition. For a prescribed word span V⊆𝒜S(E)V\subseteq\mathcal A_S(E), the word support projection onto VV is the projection that retains precisely the monomials spanning VV.✦ The associative homogeneous projection Πd,j\Pi_{d,j} retains the words of weight jj✦, and the Lie homogeneous projection πd,j\pi_{d,j} takes values in the Lie homogeneous space of (1) and satisfies ιE(πd,jq)=Πd,j(ιEq).\iota_E(\pi_{d,j}q)=\Pi_{d,j}(\iota_Eq).(2)

The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 is the quotient of the free Lie algebra on ordered-pair generators eije_{ij}, for 0≤i,j≤30\le i,j\le3, by the Lie ideal generated by the relations in (3)✦; its chord generators tijt_{ij} are the images of eije_{ij}: eii=0,eij−eji=0,[eij,ekl]=0({i,j}∩{k,l}=⌀),[eij,eik+ejk]=0(i,j,k distinct).\begin{gathered} e_{ii}=0,\qquad e_{ij}-e_{ji}=0,\qquad [e_{ij},e_{kl}]=0\quad(\{i,j\}\cap\{k,l\}=\varnothing),\\ [e_{ij},e_{ik}+e_{jk}]=0\quad(i,j,k\text{ distinct}). \end{gathered}(3)✦ The antisymmetry, special identity and pentagon operators are the linear defect maps 𝖠,𝖲,𝖯\mathsf A,\mathsf S,\mathsf P defined in (4), with the last one taking values in 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4: 𝖠(q)=q(x,y)+q(y,x),𝖲(q)=[x,q(y,x)]+[−x−y,q(y,−x−y)],𝖯(q)=q(t01,t12+t13)+q(t02+t12,t23)−q(t12,t23)−q(t01+t02,t13+t23)−q(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} \mathsf A(q)&=q(x,y)+q(y,x),\\ \mathsf S(q)&=[x,q(y,x)]+[-x-y,q(y,-x-y)],\\ \mathsf P(q)&=q(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+q(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23}) -q(t_{12},t_{23})\\ &\qquad-q(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23})-q(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(4) The reduced solution space Wn⊂𝔣(x,y)W_n\subset\mathfrak f(x,y) consists of the Lie polynomials homogeneous of ordinary weight nn, with x,yx,y of weight one, whose three defects in (4) vanish: Wn=𝔣1=n(x,y)∩ker⁡𝖠∩ker⁡𝖲∩ker⁡𝖯.W_n=\mathfrak f_{1=n}(x,y)\cap\ker\mathsf A \cap\ker\mathsf S\cap\ker\mathsf P.(5)✦

Quadratic Representatives and Leading Terms

The quadratic alphabet consists of the formal letters A,C,BA,C,B.✦ Its associative substitution QQ and quadratic Lie evaluation UU are Q:𝒜(A,C,B)→𝒜(x,y),Q(A)=x2,Q(C)=[x,y],Q(B)=y,U=Q∘ιA,C,B:𝔣(A,C,B)→𝒜(x,y).\begin{gathered} Q:\mathcal A(A,C,B)\longrightarrow\mathcal A(x,y),\qquad Q(A)=x^2,\quad Q(C)=[x,y],\quad Q(B)=y,\\ U=Q\circ\iota_{A,C,B}:\mathfrak f(A,C,B)\longrightarrow\mathcal A(x,y). \end{gathered}(6) Here the associative bracket in (6) is the commutator. The quadratic weight wt\mathrm{wt} on the alphabet A,C,BA,C,B is the letter weight assigning weights 2,2,12,2,1 to A,C,BA,C,B, respectively.✦ Let a,c,ba,c,b be the occurrence weights of A,C,BA,C,B: each assigns one to its named letter and zero to the others, and put α=a+c\alpha=a+c. The BB-count differs from ordinary yy-depth: CC has yy-depth one and BB-count zero.

For n>1n>1, the quadratic representation map Rn:Wn→𝔣(A,C,B)R_n:W_n\to\mathfrak f(A,C,B) assigns to a solution its chosen quadratic Lie representative.✦ Its defining substitution property uses (6): U(Rnψ)=ιx,yψ(ψ∈Wn).U(R_n\psi)=\iota_{x,y}\psi\qquad(\psi\in W_n).(7) For a subset DD of an alphabet EE, the letter retraction of 𝔣(E)\mathfrak f(E) onto DD is the Lie endomorphism that fixes the letters in DD and kills the letters in E\DE\setminus D. Let ε\varepsilon be the retraction onto {C,B}\{C,B\} in 𝔣(A,C,B)\mathfrak f(A,C,B). The deletion map δ:𝔣(A,C,B)→𝔣(x,y)\delta:\mathfrak f(A,C,B)\to\mathfrak f(x,y) also kills AA, and sends CC to xx and BB to yy.✦

For n>1n>1 and r≥0r\ge0, the solution filtration FrWnF^rW_n is the subspace of WnW_n consisting of solutions whose quadratic representatives contain only words with at least rr letters BB.✦ The leading component deletion ℓn,r\ell_{n,r} is the map defined together with that filtration in (8): FrWn={ψ∈Wn:ιA,C,BRnψ∈𝒜b≥r(A,C,B)},ℓn,r:FrWn→𝒜(x,y),ℓn,r(ψ)=ιx,yδπb,rRnψ.\begin{aligned} F^rW_n&=\{\psi\in W_n: \iota_{A,C,B}R_n\psi\in\mathcal A_{b\ge r}(A,C,B)\},\\ \ell_{n,r}:F^rW_n&\longrightarrow\mathcal A(x,y),\qquad \ell_{n,r}(\psi)=\iota_{x,y}\delta\pi_{b,r}R_n\psi. \end{aligned}(8)

For an index set II, the free Lie algebra on a distinguished generator XX and generators YuY_u, with u∈Iu\in I, has iterated commutators (ad⁡X)jYu(\operatorname{ad}X)^jY_u for nonnegative integers jj. The commutator tensor algebra is the free associative algebra on indices (j,u)(j,u)✦, with jj a nonnegative integer and uu in II; the commutator substitution is the algebra homomorphism from this algebra to the free associative algebra on XX and the generators YuY_u that sends the letter (j,u)(j,u) to the associative image of (ad⁡X)jYu(\operatorname{ad}X)^jY_u. For a single index u=*u=*, identify XX with xx and Y*Y_* with yy by alphabet renaming. The positive index inclusion is the 𝑭2\mathbf F_2-algebra homomorphism from the free associative algebra on nonnegative integer indices to the commutator tensor algebra for I={*}I=\{*\}, sending the generator indexed by kk to the generator indexed by (k+1,*)(k+1,*).

Write z2k+3z_{2k+3}, for k≥0k\ge0, for the generators of a free Lie algebra over the coefficient field, of weights 3,5,7,…3,5,7,\ldots, and let 𝔬n,r\mathfrak o_{n,r} be the subspace of this free Lie algebra consisting of elements homogeneous of weight nn and bracket length rr, with each z2k+3z_{2k+3} having length one.✦ The positive commutator substitution η\eta and its restriction Jn,rJ_{n,r} are η:𝒜(z3,z5,z7,…)→𝒜(x,y),η(z2k+3)=ιx,y((ad⁡x)k+1y),Jn,r:𝔬n,r→𝒜(x,y),Jn,r(v)=η(ιv).\begin{gathered} \eta:\mathcal A(z_3,z_5,z_7,\ldots)\longrightarrow\mathcal A(x,y),\qquad \eta(z_{2k+3})=\iota_{x,y}\bigl((\operatorname{ad}x)^{k+1}y\bigr),\\ J_{n,r}:\mathfrak o_{n,r}\longrightarrow\mathcal A(x,y),\qquad J_{n,r}(v)=\eta(\iota v). \end{gathered}(9) For n>2n>2, the associated graded projection is the map γn,r:FrWn→𝔬n,r,γn,r=Jn,r−1∘ℓn,r,\gamma_{n,r}:F^rW_n\longrightarrow\mathfrak o_{n,r},\qquad \gamma_{n,r}=J_{n,r}^{-1}\circ\ell_{n,r},(10)✦ where the inverse in (10) is taken on the image of (9).

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Proposition 4.4). Let n>2n>2 and r≥0r\ge0. Let ψ∈𝔣(x,y)\psi\in\mathfrak f(x,y) have vanishing antisymmetry, special identity and pentagon defects, and let p∈𝔣(A,C,B)p\in\mathfrak f(A,C,B) satisfy U(p)=ιx,yψU(p)=\iota_{x,y}\psi. Suppose that ιA,C,Bp\iota_{A,C,B}p is homogeneous of quadratic weight nn and has BB-count at least rr. If ε(πb,rp)=0\varepsilon(\pi_{b,r}p)=0, then πb,rp=0.\pi_{b,r}p=0.(11)✦ For a reduced solution ψ∈FrWn\psi\in F^rW_n with γn,r(ψ)=0\gamma_{n,r}(\psi)=0, the filtration conclusion is ψ∈Fr+1Wn.\psi\in F^{r+1}W_n.(12)✦ For every word ww in A,C,BA,C,B, its quadratic weight and occurrence counts satisfy wt(w)=2α(w)+b(w).\mathrm{wt}(w)=2\alpha(w)+b(w).(13)✦ Let N,s,mN,s,m be nonnegative integers, and let f∈𝒜(A,C,B)f\in\mathcal A(A,C,B) be homogeneous of quadratic weight NN and BB-count ss. If N=2m+sN=2m+s, then f∈𝒜α=m(A,C,B).f\in\mathcal A_{\alpha=m}(A,C,B).(14)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for n>2n>2 and every r≥0r\ge0, the map gr⁡rL¯n→Lie⁡𝑭2⟨C,B⟩\operatorname{gr}^r\overline L_n\to\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbf F_2}\langle C,B\rangle, χ↦χ(0,C,B)\chi\mapsto\chi(0,C,B), is injective, where L¯n\overline L_n is the paper’s reduced solution space in weight nn; its source is zero unless n=2m+rn=2m+r for an integer m≥0m\ge0, and in that case its image has CC-count mm and BB-count rr.

What Is Checked

The kernel statements (11) and (12) concern the reduced solutions of (5) in ordinary free Lie algebras over 𝑭2\mathbf F_2, with n>2n>2 and the filtration of (8); (13) and (14) concern word weights and homogeneous subspaces of the free associative algebra on A,C,BA,C,B. The homogeneous projections in (2) preserve addition and scalar multiplication, and the quadratic representation map of (7) is linear. The inclusion Jn,rJ_{n,r} of (9) is injective for all n,rn,r✦, and for n>2n>2 the image of ℓn,r\ell_{n,r} lies in its range.✦