The Setting
The issue is whether deletion of a quadratic generator can annihilate the leading part of a characteristic-two solution of the Grothendieck-Teichmüller equations. The coefficient field throughout is .
For a commutative ring and an alphabet , the free Lie algebra is generated by with the ordinary Lie bracket✦, and the free associative algebra has the words in as its monomial basis.✦ A word denotes the monomial with coefficient one supported on it✦; a letter denotes the corresponding one-letter monomial.✦ The universal associative embedding is the Lie homomorphism sending each free generator to its corresponding one-letter monomial. For an associative algebra over and an assignment , associative evaluation is the unique -algebra homomorphism extending . Alphabet renaming is the associative evaluation that sends each letter to its renamed letter.✦ We suppress the subscript when . For a Lie algebra over and , Lie polynomial evaluation at is the unique Lie homomorphism sending to and to ; for a Lie polynomial in its domain, its value on is denoted .
A bracketed word on an alphabet is a letter of or a bracket of two bracketed words on ; its evaluation uses the ordinary Lie bracket, and its underlying word lists its leaves from left to right.✦ Given letter weights , the weight of a word on is the sum of its letter weights, and a bracketed word on has the weight of its underlying word. For letter weights and nonnegative integers , and writing for the evaluation of a bracketed word , the homogeneous spaces and the weight filtration are the spans (1) For an alphabet and a condition on words in , the prescribed word span is the subspace spanned by the monomials satisfying that condition. For a prescribed word span , the word support projection onto is the projection that retains precisely the monomials spanning .✦ The associative homogeneous projection retains the words of weight ✦, and the Lie homogeneous projection takes values in the Lie homogeneous space of (1) and satisfies (2)
The infinitesimal braid algebra is the quotient of the free Lie algebra on ordered-pair generators , for , by the Lie ideal generated by the relations in (3)✦; its chord generators are the images of : (3)✦ The antisymmetry, special identity and pentagon operators are the linear defect maps defined in (4), with the last one taking values in : (4) The reduced solution space consists of the Lie polynomials homogeneous of ordinary weight , with of weight one, whose three defects in (4) vanish: (5)✦
Quadratic Representatives and Leading Terms
The quadratic alphabet consists of the formal letters .✦ Its associative substitution and quadratic Lie evaluation are (6) Here the associative bracket in (6) is the commutator. The quadratic weight on the alphabet is the letter weight assigning weights to , respectively.✦ Let be the occurrence weights of : each assigns one to its named letter and zero to the others, and put . The -count differs from ordinary -depth: has -depth one and -count zero.
For , the quadratic representation map assigns to a solution its chosen quadratic Lie representative.✦ Its defining substitution property uses (6): (7) For a subset of an alphabet , the letter retraction of onto is the Lie endomorphism that fixes the letters in and kills the letters in . Let be the retraction onto in . The deletion map also kills , and sends to and to .✦
For and , the solution filtration is the subspace of consisting of solutions whose quadratic representatives contain only words with at least letters .✦ The leading component deletion is the map defined together with that filtration in (8): (8)
For an index set , the free Lie algebra on a distinguished generator and generators , with , has iterated commutators for nonnegative integers . The commutator tensor algebra is the free associative algebra on indices ✦, with a nonnegative integer and in ; the commutator substitution is the algebra homomorphism from this algebra to the free associative algebra on and the generators that sends the letter to the associative image of . For a single index , identify with and with by alphabet renaming. The positive index inclusion is the -algebra homomorphism from the free associative algebra on nonnegative integer indices to the commutator tensor algebra for , sending the generator indexed by to the generator indexed by .
Write , for , for the generators of a free Lie algebra over the coefficient field, of weights , and let be the subspace of this free Lie algebra consisting of elements homogeneous of weight and bracket length , with each having length one.✦ The positive commutator substitution and its restriction are (9) For , the associated graded projection is the map (10)✦ where the inverse in (10) is taken on the image of (9).
The Claim
Theorem 1 (Proposition 4.4). Let and . Let have vanishing antisymmetry, special identity and pentagon defects, and let satisfy . Suppose that is homogeneous of quadratic weight and has -count at least . If , then (11)✦ For a reduced solution with , the filtration conclusion is (12)✦ For every word in , its quadratic weight and occurrence counts satisfy (13)✦ Let be nonnegative integers, and let be homogeneous of quadratic weight and -count . If , then (14)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for and every , the map , , is injective, where is the paper’s reduced solution space in weight ; its source is zero unless for an integer , and in that case its image has -count and -count .
What Is Checked
The kernel statements (11) and (12) concern the reduced solutions of (5) in ordinary free Lie algebras over , with and the filtration of (8); (13) and (14) concern word weights and homogeneous subspaces of the free associative algebra on . The homogeneous projections in (2) preserve addition and scalar multiplication, and the quadratic representation map of (7) is linear. The inclusion of (9) is injective for all ✦, and for the image of lies in its range.✦