OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Deletion operators and injectivity of the leading projection

Lemma 4.3 [The deletion kernel]: The scalar rows restrict bihomogeneous Lie polynomials in the letters A,C,BA,C,B whose A=0A=0 projection vanishes

The deletion kernel lies in two generators.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The deletion kernel concerns dependence on the commutator slot in quadratic leading terms of the pentagon relation. The coefficients are in k=𝔽2=ℤ/2ℤk=\mathbb F_2=\mathbb Z/2\mathbb Z.

For a commutative ring SS and an alphabet EE, the free associative algebra 𝒜S(E)=S⟨E⟩\mathcal A_S(E)=S\langle E\rangle is the algebra with basis the words in EE and multiplication given by concatenation.✦ A word denotes its basis monomial with coefficient one; a letter denotes its one-letter monomial. The ordinary free Lie algebra 𝔣S(E)=Lie⁡S⟨E⟩\mathfrak f_S(E)=\operatorname{Lie}_S\langle E\rangle has universal associative embedding ιE:𝔣S(E)→𝒜S(E)\iota_E:\mathfrak f_S(E)\to\mathcal A_S(E), the Lie homomorphism sending each free generator to its associative generator, with bracket [u,v]=uv−vu[u,v]=uv-vu in the target.✦ For an SS-algebra MM and an assignment of the letters in EE to elements of MM, associative evaluation is the algebra homomorphism from 𝒜S(E)\mathcal A_S(E) to MM extending that assignment.✦

Put Σ={A,C,B}\Sigma=\{A,C,B\}, 𝔣=𝔣k(Σ)\mathfrak f=\mathfrak f_k(\Sigma) and 𝔤=𝔣k({x,y})\mathfrak g=\mathfrak f_k(\{x,y\}). The quadratic substitution Q:𝒜k(Σ)→𝒜k({x,y})Q:\mathcal A_k(\Sigma)\to\mathcal A_k(\{x,y\}) and the quadratic Lie evaluation U:𝔣→𝒜k({x,y})U:\mathfrak f\to\mathcal A_k(\{x,y\}) are given by (1): Q(A)=x2,Q(C)=xy−yx=[x,y],Q(B)=y,U=Q∘ιΣ.Q(A)=x^2,\qquad Q(C)=xy-yx=[x,y],\qquad Q(B)=y, \qquad U=Q\circ\iota_\Sigma.(1)

Gradings and Retractions

The occurrence weights a,c,βa,c,\beta count AA, CC, BB, respectively, and ν=a+c\nu=a+c counts the letters A,CA,C together. The quadratic weight wt\mathrm{wt} and these count weights have the values in (2): ACBa100c010β001ν110wt221\begin{array}{c|ccc} &A&C&B\\ \hline a &1&0&0\\ c &0&1&0\\ \beta &0&0&1\\ \nu &1&1&0\\ \mathrm{wt}&2&2&1 \end{array}(2) The BB-count differs from ordinary yy-depth: C=[x,y]C=[x,y] has depth one and BB-count zero.

For letter weights d:E→ℕd:E\to\mathbb N, the degree |v|d|v|_d of a word vv is the sum of the weights of its letters.✦ For n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, the homogeneous associative component 𝒜d,n\mathcal A_{d,n} and the filtration Fd≥nF_d^{\ge n} in 𝒜S(E)\mathcal A_S(E) are the word spans in (3): 𝒜d,n=span⁡S{v:|v|d=n},Fd≥n=span⁡S{v:|v|d≥n}.\mathcal A_{d,n}=\operatorname{span}_S\{v:|v|_d=n\},\qquad F_d^{\ge n}=\operatorname{span}_S\{v:|v|_d\ge n\}.(3) A word support projection on 𝒜S(E)\mathcal A_S(E) is the linear map that retains precisely the basis words satisfying a specified condition.✦ The homogeneous projection πd,n\pi_{d,n} on 𝒜S(E)\mathcal A_S(E) is the linear map that retains precisely the basis words satisfying |v|d=n|v|_d=n.✦

A bracketed word on EE is a letter of EE or the bracketing of two bracketed words on EE.✦ The underlying word of a bracketed word on EE is the word listing its leaves from left to right; bracket evaluation in 𝔣S(E)\mathfrak f_S(E) sends a leaf to its free Lie generator and a bracketing to the ordinary bracket of the two evaluations. For letter weights d:E→ℕd:E\to\mathbb N, the tree weight of a bracketed word on EE is the sum of dd over its underlying word.✦ The homogeneous Lie component 𝔣d,n\mathfrak f_{d,n} of 𝔣S(E)\mathfrak f_S(E) is the span of bracket evaluations of tree weight nn.✦ For p∈𝔣S(E)p\in\mathfrak f_S(E), its Lie homogeneous component pd,np_{d,n} belongs to 𝔣d,n\mathfrak f_{d,n} and has associative image ιE(pd,n)=πd,n(ιE(p))\iota_E(p_{d,n})=\pi_{d,n}(\iota_E(p)).✦

For a subset D⊆ED\subseteq E, the letter retraction ρD\rho_D is the Lie endomorphism of 𝔣S(E)\mathfrak f_S(E) fixing generators in DD and sending the others to zero.✦ The retained letter Lie subalgebra associated with a subset D⊆ED\subseteq E is the Lie subalgebra of 𝔣S(E)\mathfrak f_S(E) generated by DD.✦ On 𝔣\mathfrak f write ρ0=ρ{C,B}\rho_0=\rho_{\{C,B\}} for substitution at A=0A=0 and 𝔥=Lie⁡k⟨A,B⟩⊆𝔣\mathfrak h=\operatorname{Lie}_k\langle A,B\rangle\subseteq\mathfrak f for the retained subalgebra with CC omitted.

Scalar Deletion Rows

The deletion alphabet is Ω={o,e,p,w}\Omega=\{o,e,p,w\}.✦ The slot map ϵ:Σ→Ω\epsilon:\Sigma\to\Omega sends AA to ee, CC to pp, and BB to oo, and acts letter by letter on words.✦ For a deletion label T∈ΣT\in\Sigma, weights κT(l,a,b)∈k\kappa_T(l,a,b)\in k assigned to triples (l,a,b)∈Ω3(l,a,b)\in\Omega^3, and boundary letters l,r∈Ωl,r\in\Omega, weighted word deletion is the sum in (4); its linear extension is the weighted deletion operator DκTl,rD_{\kappa_T}^{l,r} on 𝒜k(Ω)\mathcal A_k(\Omega): DκTl,r(a1⋯aN)=∑j=1NκT(aj−1,aj,aj+1)a1⋯ajˆ⋯aN,a0=l,aN+1=r.D_{\kappa_T}^{l,r}(a_1\cdots a_N) =\sum_{j=1}^N\kappa_T(a_{j-1},a_j,a_{j+1}) a_1\cdots\widehat{a_j}\cdots a_N, \qquad a_0=l,\quad a_{N+1}=r.(4) The weighted deletion representation Φκl,r:𝒜k(Σ)→End⁡k(𝒜k(Ω))\Phi_\kappa^{l,r}:\mathcal A_k(\Sigma)\to \operatorname{End}_k(\mathcal A_k(\Omega)) is the associative evaluation sending TT to DκTl,rD_{\kappa_T}^{l,r}. For a word vv in Ω\Omega, the complete deletion coefficient δκl,r(−;v)\delta_\kappa^{l,r}(-;v) is the linear functional on 𝒜k(Σ)\mathcal A_k(\Sigma) defined by (5) for z∈𝒜k(Σ)z\in\mathcal A_k(\Sigma), where [1][1] extracts the coefficient of the empty word: δκl,r(z;v)=[1](Φκl,r(z)(v)).\delta_\kappa^{l,r}(z;v)=[1]\bigl(\Phi_\kappa^{l,r}(z)(v)\bigr).(5)✦

There are four pentagon rows, indexed by i=1,2,3,4i=1,2,3,4.✦ For neighboring letters l,a,b∈Ωl,a,b\in\Omega and a letter z∈Ωz\in\Omega, put δz=𝟏a=z\delta_z=\mathbf1_{a=z}, ηz=𝟏l=z+𝟏b=z\eta_z=\mathbf1_{l=z}+\mathbf1_{b=z} and ω=𝟏b=w\omega=\mathbf1_{b=w}, with indicator values in kk. The second-row deletion weights λT\lambda_T and the four-row deletion weights κi,T\kappa_{i,T}, with the arguments (l,a,b)(l,a,b) suppressed, are specified by (6): (λA,λC,λB)=(δeω,δp(ηe+ηw),δoηp),iκi,Aκi,Cκi,B1δeωδeωδoω2λAλC+δeηpλB30δeηp+δpηeλB4δeω(δe+δp)ωδoω\begin{gathered} (\lambda_A,\lambda_C,\lambda_B) =(\delta_e\omega,\ \delta_p(\eta_e+\eta_w),\ \delta_o\eta_p),\\[4pt] \begin{array}{c|ccc} i&\kappa_{i,A}&\kappa_{i,C}&\kappa_{i,B}\\ \hline 1&\delta_e\omega&\delta_e\omega&\delta_o\omega\\ 2&\lambda_A&\lambda_C+\delta_e\eta_p&\lambda_B\\ 3&0&\delta_e\eta_p+\delta_p\eta_e&\lambda_B\\ 4&\delta_e\omega&(\delta_e+\delta_p)\omega&\delta_o\omega \end{array} \end{gathered}(6)

For z∈𝒜k(Σ)z\in\mathcal A_k(\Sigma) and a word ss on Σ\Sigma, the row coefficient Ti(z;s)T_i(z;s) is the scalar defined by (7), using boundary letters o,wo,w.✦ The four-row kernel equation is the second equality in (7): Ti(z;s)=δκio,w(z;ϵ(s)),∑i=14Ti(z;s)=0.T_i(z;s)=\delta_{\kappa_i}^{o,w}(z;\epsilon(s)),\qquad \sum_{i=1}^4 T_i(z;s)=0.(7)✦

The Pentagon

The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4(k)\mathfrak t_4(k) is the quotient of the free Lie algebra on ordered pairs of labels 0,1,2,30,1,2,3 by the Lie ideal generated by the relations in (8), where eije_{ij} denotes the free chord generator for (i,j)(i,j): eii,eij−eji,[eij,ekl]quad({i,j}∩{k,l}=⌀),[eij,eik+ejk](i,j,k distinct).\begin{gathered} e_{ii},\qquad e_{ij}-e_{ji},\\ [e_{ij},e_{kl}]quad(\{i,j\}\cap\{k,l\}=\varnothing),\\ [e_{ij},e_{ik}+e_{jk}]\quad(i,j,k\text{ distinct}). \end{gathered}(8)✦ The chord generator tij∈𝔱4(k)t_{ij}\in\mathfrak t_4(k) is the image of eije_{ij} in this quotient.✦ For a Lie algebra MM over kk and a,b∈Ma,b\in M, Lie polynomial evaluation ψ(a,b)\psi(a,b) is the image of ψ∈𝔤\psi\in\mathfrak g under the Lie homomorphism sending xx to aa and yy to bb.✦ For ψ∈𝔤\psi\in\mathfrak g, the pentagon defect 𝒫(ψ)∈𝔱4(k)\mathcal P(\psi)\in\mathfrak t_4(k) is the element given by (9): 𝒫(ψ)=ψ(t01,t12+t13)+ψ(t02+t12,t23)−ψ(t12,t23)−ψ(t01+t02,t13+t23)−ψ(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} \mathcal P(\psi)={}&\psi(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13}) +\psi(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23})\\ &-\psi(t_{12},t_{23}) -\psi(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23}) -\psi(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(9)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Deletion kernel). Let q∈𝔣q\in\mathfrak f and m,r∈ℕm,r\in\mathbb N. Suppose that ιΣ(q)\iota_\Sigma(q) belongs to 𝒜ν,m∩𝒜β,r\mathcal A_{\nu,m}\cap\mathcal A_{\beta,r}, that ρ0(q)=0\rho_0(q)=0, and that the four row equation (7) holds for every slot word ss with |s|ν=m|s|_\nu=m and |s|β=r|s|_\beta=r. Then q∈𝔥.q\in\mathfrak h.(10)✦

Theorem 2 (Leading pentagon term). Let ψ∈𝔤\psi\in\mathfrak g, p∈𝔣p\in\mathfrak f, and n,r,m∈ℕn,r,m\in\mathbb N, with r<nr<n and n=2m+rn=2m+r. Suppose that U(p)=ι{x,y}(ψ)U(p)=\iota_{\{x,y\}}(\psi), that ιΣ(p)∈𝒜wt,n∩Fβ≥r\iota_\Sigma(p)\in\mathcal A_{\mathrm{wt},n}\cap F_\beta^{\ge r}, and that 𝒫(ψ)=0\mathcal P(\psi)=0. Set χ=pβ,r\chi=p_{\beta,r} and suppose that ρ0(χ)=0\rho_0(\chi)=0. Then χ∈𝔥.\chi\in\mathfrak h.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for ψ‾\bar\psi in the paper’s weight nn space L‾n\bar L_n, with n=2m+r>2n=2m+r>2 and leading BB-count rr part χ\chi satisfying the scalar leading-pentagon equations, the condition χ(0,C,B)=0\chi(0,C,B)=0 places χ\chi in Lie⁡𝔽2⟨A,B⟩\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb F_2}\langle A,B\rangle with exactly mm occurrences of AA and rr of BB.

What Is Checked

The statements (10) and (11) concern ordinary free Lie algebras over 𝔽2\mathbb F_2, associative word gradings and the deletion coefficients (5); the latter statement also imposes the pentagon equation in the infinitesimal braid quotient defined by (8).