OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Integral Lie algebras and the special identity

Lemma 2.2 [Ordinary Lie lattices]: Ordinary free Lie algebras embed in associative words, with saturated integral lattices and compatible reduction to every field

Integral Lie words have field-independent homogeneous dimensions.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Integral Lie expressions in a rational free associative algebra have coefficients on associative words. The questions are whether integral word coefficients determine the integral Lie lattice and whether a homogeneous component changes dimension with the coefficient field.

Let XX be an alphabet and SS a commutative ring. The free associative algebra ASA_S is the algebra of finite SS-linear combinations of words on XX, with concatenation as product; write ewe_w for the basis element belonging to a word ww and a=e(a)a=e_{(a)} for the generator belonging to a∈Xa\in X. Let LSL_S be the free ordinary Lie algebra over SS on generators jaj_a, including when SS has characteristic two.✦ The universal associative map ιS:LS→AS\iota_S:L_S\to A_S is the unique Lie homomorphism sending each free generator jaj_a to the associative generator aa, with the commutator bracket on ASA_S, as in (1).✦ AS=S⟨X⟩,ιS:LS→AS,ιS(ja)=a,[u,v]=uv−vu(u,v∈AS).A_S=S\langle X\rangle,\qquad \iota_S:L_S\longrightarrow A_S,\qquad \iota_S(j_a)=a,\qquad [u,v]=uv-vu\quad(u,v\in A_S).(1)

A bracketed word tt on XX is a letter or an ordered bracket of two bracketed words.✦ Its evaluation ev⁡S(t)\operatorname{ev}_S(t) belongs to LSL_S, and its underlying word λ(t)\lambda(t) lists its letters in order, as in (2). ev⁡S(a)=ja,ev⁡S([t,u])=[ev⁡S(t),ev⁡S(u)],λ(a)=(a),λ([t,u])=λ(t)λ(u).\begin{aligned} \operatorname{ev}_S(a)&=j_a,& \operatorname{ev}_S([t,u])&=[\operatorname{ev}_S(t),\operatorname{ev}_S(u)],\\ \lambda(a)&=(a),& \lambda([t,u])&=\lambda(t)\lambda(u). \end{aligned}(2)

Writing X*X^* for the set of finite words on XX, the integral word lattice MM inside Aℚ=ℚ⟨X⟩A_{\mathbb Q}=\mathbb Q\langle X\rangle is the ℤ\mathbb Z-span of all ewe_w, as in (3).✦ The integral Lie lattice KℤK_{\mathbb Z} in AℚA_{\mathbb Q} is the Lie subalgebra over ℤ\mathbb Z generated by the letters a∈Xa\in X✦, and the rational Lie algebra 𝔩ℚ\mathfrak l_{\mathbb Q} in AℚA_{\mathbb Q} is the Lie subalgebra over ℚ\mathbb Q generated by the letters a∈Xa\in X.✦ M=span⁡ℤ{ew:w∈X*},Kℤ=Lie⁡ℤ⟨a:a∈X⟩⊆Aℚ,𝔩ℚ=Lie⁡ℚ⟨a:a∈X⟩⊆Aℚ.M=\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb Z}\{e_w:w\in X^*\},\qquad K_{\mathbb Z}=\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Z}\langle a:a\in X\rangle \subseteq A_{\mathbb Q},\qquad \mathfrak l_{\mathbb Q}=\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Q}\langle a:a\in X\rangle \subseteq A_{\mathbb Q}.(3)

Weights and Coordinates

A weight function wt:X→ℕ\mathrm{wt}:X\to\mathbb N assigns to a word the sum of the weights of its letters.✦ A bracketed word has the weight of its underlying word.✦ For n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, write InI_n for the set of associative words of weight nn, as in (4).✦ |w|wt=∑a in wwt(a),|t|wt=|λ(t)|wt,In={w∈X*:|w|wt=n}.|w|_{\mathrm{wt}}=\sum_{a\text{ in }w}\mathrm{wt}(a),\qquad |t|_{\mathrm{wt}}=|\lambda(t)|_{\mathrm{wt}},\qquad I_n=\{w\in X^*:|w|_{\mathrm{wt}}=n\}.(4)

For a condition PP on words on XX, the prescribed word space AS(P)A_S(P) is the SS-submodule of ASA_S spanned by the basis elements ewe_w whose words satisfy PP.✦ The word coefficient map cS,Pc_{S,P} associated to a condition PP on words on XX sends an element pp of AS(P)A_S(P) to the family of its coefficients [w]p[w]p indexed by words ww satisfying PP, according to (5).✦ AS(P)=span⁡S{ew:P(w)},cS,P:AS(P)→S{w:P(w)},cS,P(p)=([w]p)w.A_S(P)=\operatorname{span}_S\{e_w:P(w)\},\qquad c_{S,P}:A_S(P)\longrightarrow S^{\{w:P(w)\}},\qquad c_{S,P}(p)=([w]p)_w.(5)

The associative component AS,nA_{S,n} of weight nn is the SS-submodule of ASA_S spanned by the basis words satisfying |w|wt=n|w|_{\mathrm{wt}}=n.✦ The Lie component LS,nL_{S,n} of weight nn is the SS-submodule of LSL_S spanned by the evaluations of bracketed words of weight nn, as in (6).✦ AS,n=AS(|w|wt=n),LS,n=span⁡S{ev⁡S(t):|t|wt=n}.A_{S,n}=A_S(|w|_{\mathrm{wt}}=n),\qquad L_{S,n}=\operatorname{span}_S \{\operatorname{ev}_S(t):|t|_{\mathrm{wt}}=n\}.(6)

The homogeneous associative map ιS,n\iota_{S,n} from LS,nL_{S,n} to AS,nA_{S,n} is the restriction of ιS\iota_S to LS,nL_{S,n}.✦ The Lie coefficient map γS,n\gamma_{S,n} assigns to a homogeneous Lie element the word coefficients of its associative image✦, and ES,nE_{S,n} is its image, as in (7).✦ ιS,n:LS,n→AS,n,γS,n=cS,|w|wt=n∘ιS,n,ES,n=im⁡(γS,n)⊆SIn.\iota_{S,n}:L_{S,n}\longrightarrow A_{S,n},\qquad \gamma_{S,n}=c_{S,|w|_{\mathrm{wt}}=n}\circ\iota_{S,n},\qquad E_{S,n}=\operatorname{im}(\gamma_{S,n})\subseteq S^{I_n}.(7)

For an index set II and a rational subspace E⊆ℚIE\subseteq\mathbb Q^I, the coordinate lattice ℒ(E)\mathcal L(E) is the subgroup of ℤI\mathbb Z^I consisting of the integral vectors whose rational images belong to EE.✦ The inclusion cIc_I sends an integral vector to the same coordinate vector over ℚ\mathbb Q, as in (8).✦ cI:ℤI→ℚI,cI(u)=(ui)i,ℒ(E)={u∈ℤI:cI(u)∈E}.c_I:\mathbb Z^I\longrightarrow\mathbb Q^I,\qquad c_I(u)=(u_i)_i,\qquad \mathcal L(E)=\{u\in\mathbb Z^I:c_I(u)\in E\}.(8)

For a field FF and a rational subspace E⊆ℚIE\subseteq\mathbb Q^I, the lattice scalar extension map θF,E\theta_{F,E} is the FF-linear map from F⊗ℤℒ(E)F\otimes_{\mathbb Z}\mathcal L(E) to FIF^I obtained by extending the map that sends an integral coordinate vector to its coordinates in FF.✦ The reduction ρF(E)\rho_F(E) is the FF-subspace of FIF^I given by the image of the lattice scalar extension map θF,E\theta_{F,E}, as in (9); here m¯=m1F\overline m=m1_F for m∈ℤm\in\mathbb Z.✦ θF,E:F⊗ℤℒ(E)→FI,θF,E(b⊗u)=(bui¯)i,ρF(E)=im⁡(θF,E).\theta_{F,E}:F\otimes_{\mathbb Z}\mathcal L(E)\longrightarrow F^I,\qquad \theta_{F,E}(b\otimes u)=(b\overline{u_i})_i,\qquad \rho_F(E)=\operatorname{im}(\theta_{F,E}).(9)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let XX be an alphabet. For every commutative ring SS, ker⁡(ιS)={0}.\ker(\iota_S)=\{0\}.(10)✦ For every p∈𝔩ℚ∩Mp\in\mathfrak l_{\mathbb Q}\cap M, p∈Kℤ.p\in K_{\mathbb Z}.(11)✦ Let wt:X→ℕ\mathrm{wt}:X\to\mathbb N be a weight function and n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N. Then ℒ(Eℚ,n)=Eℤ,n.\mathcal L(E_{\mathbb Q,n})=E_{\mathbb Z,n}.(12)✦ For every field FF, ρF(Eℚ,n)=EF,n.\rho_F(E_{\mathbb Q,n})=E_{F,n}.(13)✦ For every field FF, the dimension identity (14) holds for every letter-weight function and every weight nn. dim⁡FLF,n=dim⁡ℚLℚ,n.\dim_F L_{F,n}=\dim_{\mathbb Q}L_{\mathbb Q,n}.(14)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a finite alphabet XX and R=ℤ(2)R=\mathbb Z_{(2)}, the RR-span KR(X)K_R(X) of bracket monomials in R⟨X⟩R\langle X\rangle is the free ordinary Lie algebra over RR, every multihomogeneous piece is finite free, KR(X)⊗Rℚ=Lie⁡ℚ⟨X⟩K_R(X)\otimes_R\mathbb Q=\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Q}\langle X\rangle and KR(X)/2KR(X)=Lie⁡𝔽2⟨X⟩K_R(X)/2K_R(X)=\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb F_2}\langle X\rangle inside 𝔽2⟨X⟩\mathbb F_2\langle X\rangle, reduction into associative words is injective and multidegree dimensions agree over ℚ\mathbb Q and 𝔽2\mathbb F_2, with the same conclusions for a positively weighted alphabet having finitely many letters in each bounded weight.

What Is Checked

The statements (10) and (11) concern ordinary free Lie algebras over commutative rings and integral submodules of AℚA_{\mathbb Q}, while (12), (13) and (14) concern homogeneous word coordinates and lattice scalar extension to a field, with InI_n finite for the dimension equality.