OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Integral Lie algebras and the special identity

Lemma 2.3 [The free fiber]: Pair derivations describe the base action; ordered enveloping products and finite-strand rationalization are injective

One new strand gives a free fiber.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Adjoining a strand to an infinitesimal braid algebra introduces one chord to each old strand. The interaction of these new chords with the old algebra also governs their products in the universal enveloping algebra.

Let KK be a commutative ring and II a set of strands. Write I+=I⊔{*}I_+=I\sqcup\{*\} for the set with one strand adjoined, and let FK(I)F_K(I) be the free Lie algebra over KK on letters sis_i, for i∈Ii\in I. The free Lie algebra PK(I)P_K(I) over KK on ordered pairs of strands has letters uiju_{ij}.✦ The braid relation ideal JK(I)J_K(I) of PK(I)P_K(I) is the Lie ideal generated by the elements in (1), where the disjoint-pair commutators have {i,j}∩{k,l}=⌀\{i,j\}\cap\{k,l\}=\varnothing and the final commutators have i,j,ki,j,k distinct: PK(I)=Lie⁡K⟨uij:i,j∈I⟩,JK(I)=⟨uii,uij−uji,[uij,ukl],[uij,uik+ujk]⟩Lie.\begin{aligned} P_K(I)&=\operatorname{Lie}_K\langle u_{ij}:i,j\in I\rangle,\\ J_K(I)&=\big\langle u_{ii},\ u_{ij}-u_{ji},\ [u_{ij},u_{kl}],\ [u_{ij},u_{ik}+u_{jk}]\big\rangle_{\mathrm{Lie}}. \end{aligned}(1) The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱K(I)\mathfrak t_K(I) is the quotient in (2)✦; its chord generator tijt_{ij} is the image of uiju_{ij}: 𝔱K(I)=PK(I)/JK(I),tij=uij+JK(I).\mathfrak t_K(I)=P_K(I)/J_K(I),\qquad t_{ij}=u_{ij}+J_K(I).(2) For a KK-Lie algebra EE and a family aij∈Ea_{ij}\in E satisfying the braid relations, the braid evaluation map ev⁡a:𝔱K(I)→E\operatorname{ev}_a:\mathfrak t_K(I)\to E is the Lie homomorphism taking tijt_{ij} to aija_{ij}.✦

A first-order Lie jet (m,v)∈M⊕M(m,v)\in M\oplus M of a KK-Lie algebra MM is a pair with base mm and velocity vv; write 𝒥K(M)\mathcal J_K(M) for its jet Lie algebra.✦ For a family f:I→FK(I)f:I\to F_K(I), the jet lift jfj_f is the Lie homomorphism specified in (3).✦ The free derivation extension ∂f\partial_f of FK(I)F_K(I) associated to the family f:I→FK(I)f:I\to F_K(I) is the derivation given by the velocity component of the jet lift jfj_f: jf:FK(I)→𝒥K(FK(I)),jf(si)=(si,f(i)),∂f(q)=pr⁡2(jf(q)).j_f:F_K(I)\longrightarrow\mathcal J_K(F_K(I)),\qquad j_f(s_i)=(s_i,f(i)),\qquad \partial_f(q)=\operatorname{pr}_2(j_f(q)).(3)

The free Lie fiber map ιF\iota_F and the base Lie map ιB\iota_B are the Lie homomorphisms specified on generators in (4): ιF:FK(I)→𝔱K(I+),si↦t*i,ιB:𝔱K(I)→𝔱K(I+),tij↦tij.\begin{aligned} \iota_F:F_K(I)&\longrightarrow\mathfrak t_K(I_+),& s_i&\longmapsto t_{*i},\\ \iota_B:\mathfrak t_K(I)&\longrightarrow\mathfrak t_K(I_+),& t_{ij}&\longmapsto t_{ij}. \end{aligned}(4) Here the tijt_{ij} on the right belong to the enlarged strand set.

The free associative algebra AK(I)=K⟨si:i∈I⟩A_K(I)=K\langle s_i:i\in I\rangle consists of finite KK-linear combinations of words in the sis_i.✦ Given a KK-algebra CC and elements f(i)∈Cf(i)\in C, the associative evaluation map ev⁡f:AK(I)→C\operatorname{ev}_f:A_K(I)\to C is the algebra homomorphism taking sis_i to f(i)f(i).✦ Put UK(I)=UK(𝔱K(I))U_K(I)=U_K(\mathfrak t_K(I)), and write ηI:𝔱K(I)→UK(I)\eta_I:\mathfrak t_K(I)\to U_K(I) for the canonical Lie map.✦ The fiber algebra map aa is associative evaluation at ηI+(t*i)\eta_{I_+}(t_{*i})✦, and the base algebra map bb is the enveloping map induced by ιB\iota_B; their defining formulas are (5): a:AK(I)→UK(I+),a(si)=ηI+(t*i),b:UK(I)→UK(I+),b(ηI(g))=ηI+(ιB(g)).\begin{aligned} a:A_K(I)&\longrightarrow U_K(I_+),& a(s_i)&=\eta_{I_+}(t_{*i}),\\ b:U_K(I)&\longrightarrow U_K(I_+),& b(\eta_I(g))&=\eta_{I_+}(\iota_B(g)). \end{aligned}(5)

For a commutative ring SS, the integral scalar extension map κS:𝔱ℤ(I)→𝔱S(I)\kappa_S:\mathfrak t_{\mathbb Z}(I)\to\mathfrak t_S(I) is the ℤ\mathbb Z-Lie homomorphism taking each integral chord to the corresponding SS-coefficient chord.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let KK be a commutative ring and II a set. For distinct i,j∈Ii,j\in I, the pair derivation DijD_{ij} of FK(I)F_K(I) is the free derivation extension with values (6)✦, with Dii=0D_{ii}=0✦: Dij(sh)={[si,sj],h=i,[sj,si],h=j,0,h∉{i,j}.D_{ij}(s_h)= \begin{cases} [s_i,s_j],&h=i,\\ [s_j,s_i],&h=j,\\ 0,&h\notin\{i,j\}. \end{cases}(6)✦ The infinitesimal braid action ρ\rho is the Lie homomorphism specified by (7): ρ:𝔱K(I)→Der⁡K(FK(I)),ρ(tij)=Dij.\rho:\mathfrak t_K(I)\longrightarrow\operatorname{Der}_K(F_K(I)),\qquad \rho(t_{ij})=D_{ij}.(7)✦ In FK(I)⋊ρ𝔱K(I)F_K(I)\rtimes_\rho\mathfrak t_K(I), the semidirect fiber generator is (si,0)(s_i,0)✦ and the semidirect base chord is (0,tij)(0,t_{ij}).✦ The semidirect chords cabc_{ab}, for a,b∈I+a,b\in I_+, are the elements of FK(I)⋊ρ𝔱K(I)F_K(I)\rtimes_\rho\mathfrak t_K(I) given by c**=0c_{**}=0, c*i=ci*=(si,0)c_{*i}=c_{i*}=(s_i,0) and cij=(0,tij)c_{ij}=(0,t_{ij}) for i,j∈Ii,j\in I.✦ The semidirect projection Φ\Phi in (8) is the Lie homomorphism given by braid evaluation at the semidirect chords cabc_{ab}✦; the inverse Ψ\Psi of Φ\Phi is the semidirect universal map associated to ιF\iota_F and ιB\iota_B✦: Φ:𝔱K(I+)→∼FK(I)⋊ρ𝔱K(I),Φ(tab)=cab,Ψ(p,g)=ιF(p)+ιB(g).\begin{aligned} \Phi:\mathfrak t_K(I_+)&\xrightarrow{\ \sim\ } F_K(I)\rtimes_\rho\mathfrak t_K(I),& \Phi(t_{ab})&=c_{ab},\\ \Psi(p,g)&=\iota_F(p)+\iota_B(g).&& \end{aligned}(8)✦ The enveloping normal form map NN is the KK-linear map defined in (9) by multiplication with the fiber factor first: N:AK(I)⊗KUK(I)→UK(I+),N(p⊗u)=a(p)b(u).N:A_K(I)\otimes_K U_K(I)\longrightarrow U_K(I_+),\qquad N(p\otimes u)=a(p)b(u).(9)✦ Its injectivity is (10): ker⁡N={0}.\ker N=\{0\}.(10)✦ For a finite strand set II, integral rationalization satisfies (11): κℚ:𝔱ℤ(I)→𝔱ℚ(I),ker⁡κℚ={0}.\kappa_{\mathbb Q}:\mathfrak t_{\mathbb Z}(I)\longrightarrow \mathfrak t_{\mathbb Q}(I),\qquad \ker\kappa_{\mathbb Q}=\{0\}.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: over its coefficient rings kk, on qq strands, forgetting the last strand gives 𝔱k({1,…,q})≅Lie⁡k⟨s1,…,sq−1⟩⋊𝔱k({1,…,q−1})\mathfrak t_k(\{1,\ldots,q\})\cong \operatorname{Lie}_k\langle s_1,\ldots,s_{q-1}\rangle\rtimes \mathfrak t_k(\{1,\ldots,q-1\}), with si=tiqs_i=t_{iq} and base action Dij(si)=[si,sj]D_{ij}(s_i)=[s_i,s_j], Dij(sj)=[sj,si]D_{ij}(s_j)=[s_j,s_i] and Dij(sh)=0D_{ij}(s_h)=0 for h∉{i,j}h\notin\{i,j\}, multiplication identifies k⟨s1,…,sq−1⟩⊗kUk(𝔱k({1,…,q−1}))k\langle s_1,\ldots,s_{q-1}\rangle\otimes_k U_k(\mathfrak t_k(\{1,\ldots,q-1\})) with Uk(𝔱k({1,…,q}))U_k(\mathfrak t_k(\{1,\ldots,q\})), recursively ordered fiber words form a basis, and over R=ℤ(2)R=\mathbb Z_{(2)} these Lie and enveloping algebras are torsion-free and the normal form commutes with rationalization and reduction.

What Is Checked

The decomposition and enveloping normal map are stated over an arbitrary commutative ring KK and an arbitrary strand set II; the rationalization assertion is stated for the integral braid algebra on a finite strand set.

The pair derivations are symmetric in their indices.✦ When {i,j}∩{k,l}=⌀\{i,j\}\cap\{k,l\}=\varnothing, they satisfy the disjoint commutator identity in (12)✦; when i,j,ki,j,k are distinct, they satisfy the three-strand identity there: Dij=Dji,[Dij,Dkl]=0,[Dij,Dik+Djk]=0.D_{ij}=D_{ji},\qquad [D_{ij},D_{kl}]=0,\qquad [D_{ij},D_{ik}+D_{jk}]=0.(12) The semidirect chords cabc_{ab} satisfy the braid relations prescribed by (1) on I+I_+. For g∈𝔱K(I)g\in\mathfrak t_K(I) and p∈FK(I)p\in F_K(I), the fiber and base Lie maps satisfy the compatibility identity (13): ιF(ρ(g)p)=[ιB(g),ιF(p)].\iota_F(\rho(g)p)=[\iota_B(g),\iota_F(p)].(13)✦