OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Integral Lie algebras and the special identity

Lemma 2.4 [The special identity]: The special derivation identity and its tangent linearization under substitution into arbitrary rational Lie algebras

Homogeneous solutions above weight two satisfy special identities.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The special identity for a two-variable Lie polynomial concerns bracket evaluations on three elements with sum zero; its linearization concerns variation in the second argument.

The Lie algebra LL is the rational free Lie algebra on the generators xx and yy.✦ For a rational Lie algebra MM and elements a,b∈Ma,b\in M, the substitution homomorphism ev⁡a,b\operatorname{ev}_{a,b} from LL to MM is the unique Lie algebra homomorphism specified in (1); its value on p∈Lp\in L is denoted p(a,b)p(a,b).✦ ev⁡a,b:L→M,x↦a,y↦b,p(a,b)=ev⁡a,b(p).\operatorname{ev}_{a,b}:L\longrightarrow M, \qquad x\longmapsto a,\quad y\longmapsto b, \qquad p(a,b)=\operatorname{ev}_{a,b}(p).(1)

For an alphabet α\alpha with a weight function w:α→ℕw:\alpha\to\mathbb N, a Lie word qq of weight nn in the rational free Lie algebra on α\alpha is a word in the free generators obtained by ordinary brackets: a generator corresponding to s∈αs\in\alpha has weight w(s)w(s), and a bracket of words has the sum of their weights.✦ The weight component VnwV_n^w associated to an alphabet α\alpha and a weight function w:α→ℕw:\alpha\to\mathbb N is the rational linear subspace of the free Lie algebra on α\alpha spanned by Lie words of weight nn, as in (2)✦; the homogeneous component LnL_n of LL gives each of x,yx,y weight one.✦ Vnw=span⁡ℚ{q∈Lie⁡ℚ⟨α⟩:q is a Lie word of weight n},Ln=Vn1⊆L.V_n^w=\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb Q} \{q\in\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Q}\langle\alpha\rangle: q\text{ is a Lie word of weight }n\}, \qquad L_n=V_n^1\subseteq L.(2)

Let I={0,1,2,3}I=\{0,1,2,3\} be the strand label set. A chord on four strands is a pair (i,j)∈I×I(i,j)\in I\times I with i<ji<j✦, and the free chord Lie algebra FF is the rational free Lie algebra on these chords.✦ The free chord generator cijc_{ij} of FF is the generator corresponding to the unordered pair {i,j}\{i,j\} when i≠ji\ne j, and cii=0c_{ii}=0.✦

The infinitesimal braid relations form the subset ℛ\mathcal R of FF in (3)✦, and the infinitesimal braid relation ideal 𝔟\mathfrak b is the Lie ideal they generate.✦ The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 is the quotient of FF by 𝔟\mathfrak b, with chord generator tijt_{ij} the image of cijc_{ij}. ℛ={[cij,ckl]:i,j,k,l∈I pairwise distinct}∪{[cij,cik+cjk]:i,j,k∈I pairwise distinct},𝔟=⟨ℛ⟩Lie,𝔱4=F/𝔟,tij=cij+𝔟.\begin{aligned} \mathcal R={}& \{[c_{ij},c_{kl}]:i,j,k,l\in I\text{ pairwise distinct}\}\\ &{}\cup \{[c_{ij},c_{ik}+c_{jk}]:i,j,k\in I\text{ pairwise distinct}\},\\ \mathfrak b={}&\langle\mathcal R\rangle_{\mathrm{Lie}}, \qquad \mathfrak t_4=F/\mathfrak b, \qquad t_{ij}=c_{ij}+\mathfrak b. \end{aligned}(3)

A Drinfeld solution is an element p∈Lp\in L satisfying the antisymmetry and three-cycle relations in LL and the infinitesimal pentagon relation in 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4, displayed in (4).✦ p(x,y)+p(y,x)=0,p(x,y)+p(y,−x−y)+p(−x−y,x)=0,p(t01,t12+t13)+p(t02+t12,t23)=p(t12,t23)+p(t01+t02,t13+t23)+p(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} p(x,y)+p(y,x)&=0,\\ p(x,y)+p(y,-x-y)+p(-x-y,x)&=0,\\ p(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+p(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23}) &={}p(t_{12},t_{23})\\ &\quad{}+p(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23}) +p(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(4) The solution space WW is the subset of LL consisting of Drinfeld solutions; the weight-nn part Wn=W∩LnW_n=W\cap L_n of WW is the subset consisting of homogeneous elements of weight nn.

For a commutative ring RR and an RR-Lie algebra NN, the space JR(N)J_R(N) of first-order Lie jets consists of pairs (a,u)∈N×N(a,u)\in N\times N, and its velocity projection ν\nu is the map given by ν(a,u)=u\nu(a,u)=u.✦ For a rational Lie algebra MM and p∈Lp\in L, the differential dp(a,b)(u,v)\mathrm d p_{(a,b)}(u,v) at (a,b)∈M2(a,b)\in M^2 in the direction (u,v)∈M2(u,v)\in M^2 is the element of MM given by the velocity in (5), where the substitution is into Jℚ(M)J_{\mathbb Q}(M).✦ dp(a,b)(u,v)=ν(p((a,u),(b,v))).\mathrm d p_{(a,b)}(u,v) =\nu\bigl(p((a,u),(b,v))\bigr).(5)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let nn be a natural number greater than two, let p∈Wnp\in W_n, and let MM be a rational Lie algebra. For a,b∈Ma,b\in M, the special derivation identity holds: [a,p(b,a)]+[−a−b,p(b,−a−b)]=0.[a,p(b,a)]+[-a-b,p(b,-a-b)]=0.(6)✦ For a,u∈Ma,u\in M, the second-argument tangent linearization holds: dp(a,−a)(0,u)=0.\mathrm d p_{(a,-a)}(0,u)=0.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for p∈Wnp\in W_n with n>2n>2, in the free Lie algebra on a,ba,b and with c=−a−bc=-a-b, one has [a,p(b,a)]+[c,p(b,c)]=0[a,p(b,a)]+[c,p(b,c)]=0 and ∂2p(a,−a)T=0\partial_2p(a,-a)T=0 for an extra free letter TT, where ∂2p(a,−a)T\partial_2p(a,-a)T is the coefficient of a central parameter tt in p(a,−a+tT)p(a,-a+tT).

What Is Checked

The identities (6) and (7) are stated for homogeneous p∈Wnp\in W_n with n>2n>2, under substitution into any rational Lie algebra MM. The solution set WW is a rational linear subspace of LL.✦