The Setting
The three-marginal Coulomb problem minimizes the repulsion of three particles in while prescribing the same probability measure for each particle. A configuration is a triple ; write for its coordinate projections. The inverse distance of and is , with value when .✦ The Coulomb cost is given by (1), with value at every collision: (1)✦
A three-marginal self-coupling of a Borel measure on is a probability measure on whose three coordinate marginals are .✦ The set of self-couplings of a Borel measure on consists of probability measures on whose three coordinate marginals are , as in (2): (2)✦ The Kantorovich value of a Borel measure on is the infimum of the Coulomb integral over , as in (3): (3)✦
A measure-preserving map for is a Borel map with ; let be the set of these maps.✦ For a Borel measure on and maps , the graph cost is the nonnegative extended Coulomb integral along the graph of ✦, and the Monge value is its infimum over measure-preserving pairs, as in (4): (4)
Densities and Attainment
A smooth compact probability density is a nonnegative function such that and .✦ The density measure associated with a real function is the Borel measure obtained by weighting Lebesgue measure by .✦ For nonnegative , this is , specified by (5): (5)
Kantorovich attainment for a Borel probability measure on is the existence of a self-coupling attaining the Kantorovich value , as in (6): (6)✦ Monge nonattainment for a Borel probability measure on is the strict inequality in (7) for every pair of Borel maps preserving : (7)✦ A Borel probability measure on admits finite-cost Monge approximation when, for every , there are maps satisfying (8): (8)✦
The class of Coulomb counterexample densities consists of smooth compact probability densities whose associated measure is a probability measure, has finite Kantorovich value, and satisfies Kantorovich attainment and Monge nonattainment.✦ A density has the full Coulomb conclusion when it belongs to the class in (9): (9)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1 (Smooth Coulomb nonattainment). The class in (9) is nonempty: (10)✦ The separated local Coulomb charts and their global certificate supply a density with the full Coulomb conclusion: (11)✦
In the paper, the result reads: there is a nonnegative density on , with and , such that for the value is finite and attained in , while every pair of Borel maps with satisfies , allowing an infinite left side.
What Is Checked
The statement (10) concerns real functions on and the class of (9), with extended Coulomb integrals over probability self-couplings and graph costs of Borel maps preserving .