OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. The problem and the result

§1 (setting): Coulomb couplings, preserving maps, and density regularity: Couplings and preserving maps for smooth compact probability densities

Coulomb transport and strict Monge nonattainment.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For a prescribed particle distribution, the Coulomb transport problem compares arbitrary joint laws with transports determined by the position of the first particle.

The Definition

Definition 1. The particle space EE is Euclidean three-space, as in (1). E=ℝ3.E=\mathbb R^3.(1)✦ A three-particle configuration is a point (x,y,z)(x,y,z) of the space 𝒳\mathcal X in (2); its coordinate projections are p1(x,y,z)=xp_1(x,y,z)=x, p2(x,y,z)=yp_2(x,y,z)=y and p3(x,y,z)=zp_3(x,y,z)=z. 𝒳=E×E×E.\mathcal X=E\times E\times E.(2)✦

For x,y∈Ex,y\in E, the extended inverse distance ι(x,y)∈[0,+∞]\iota(x,y)\in[0,+\infty] is (3). ι(x,y)={|x−y|−1,x≠y,+∞,x=y.\iota(x,y)= \begin{cases} |x-y|^{-1},&x\ne y,\\ +\infty,&x=y. \end{cases}(3)✦ The Coulomb cost c:𝒳→[0,+∞]c:\mathcal X\to[0,+\infty] is the sum in (4), with each reciprocal interpreted as in (3). c(x,y,z)=1|x−y|+1|x−z|+1|y−z|.c(x,y,z)=\frac1{|x-y|}+\frac1{|x-z|}+\frac1{|y-z|}.(4)✦

For a real function ρ:E→ℝ\rho:E\to\mathbb R, its density measure μρ\mu_\rho is (5), where ρ+(x)=max⁡{ρ(x),0}\rho_+(x)=\max\{\rho(x),0\} and dxdx denotes Lebesgue measure; for nonnegative ρ\rho write μ=ρdx\mu=\rho\,dx. μρ=ρ+dx.\mu_\rho=\rho_+\,dx.(5)✦

Write 𝒫(S)\mathcal P(S) for the Borel probability measures on a Euclidean space SS. A three-marginal coupling of a Borel measure μ\mu on EE is a probability measure π\pi on 𝒳\mathcal X satisfying the marginal conditions in (6). Π(μ,μ,μ)={π∈𝒫(𝒳):(p1)#π=(p2)#π=(p3)#π=μ}.\Pi(\mu,\mu,\mu)= \bigl\{\pi\in\mathcal P(\mathcal X): (p_1)_\#\pi=(p_2)_\#\pi=(p_3)_\#\pi=\mu\bigr\}.(6)✦

A measure-preserving map for μ\mu is a Borel map T:E→ET:E\to E satisfying the pushforward condition in (7); 𝒜(μ)\mathcal A(\mu) denotes this class. 𝒜(μ)={T:E→E:T is Borel measurable,T#μ=μ}.\mathcal A(\mu)= \bigl\{T:E\to E:T\text{ is Borel measurable},\ T_\#\mu=\mu\bigr\}.(7)✦ For maps T2,T3:E→ET_2,T_3:E\to E, the graph cost Jμ(T2,T3)J_\mu(T_2,T_3) is the nonnegative extended integral (8). Jμ(T2,T3)=∫Ec(x,T2(x),T3(x))dμ(x).J_\mu(T_2,T_3)=\int_E c\bigl(x,T_2(x),T_3(x)\bigr)\,d\mu(x).(8)✦

The Kantorovich value E*(μ)E_*(\mu) is the infimum over couplings in (9). E*(μ)=infπ∈Π(μ,μ,μ)∫𝒳cdπ.E_*(\mu)=\inf_{\pi\in\Pi(\mu,\mu,\mu)}\int_{\mathcal X}c\,d\pi.(9)✦ The Monge value M*(μ)M_*(\mu) is the infimum over preserving maps in (10). M*(μ)=infT2,T3∈𝒜(μ)Jμ(T2,T3).M_*(\mu)=\inf_{T_2,T_3\in\mathcal A(\mu)}J_\mu(T_2,T_3).(10)✦

A smooth compact probability density on EE is a real function ρ\rho belonging to the class 𝒟\mathcal D in (11). 𝒟={ρ:E→ℝ:ρ≥0,ρ,ρ∈Cc∞(E),∫Eρdx=1}.\mathcal D=\left\{\rho:E\to\mathbb R: \rho\ge0,\quad \rho,\sqrt\rho\in C_c^\infty(E),\quad \int_E\rho\,dx=1\right\}.(11)✦

The Kantorovich value for μ\mu is attained when there exists a coupling π\pi satisfying (12). π∈Π(μ,μ,μ),∫𝒳cdπ=E*(μ).\pi\in\Pi(\mu,\mu,\mu),\qquad \int_{\mathcal X}c\,d\pi=E_*(\mu).(12)✦ A Borel measure μ\mu has no Monge optimizer when every pair of preserving maps satisfies the strict cost comparison (13). E*(μ)<Jμ(T2,T3)for every T2,T3∈𝒜(μ).E_*(\mu)<J_\mu(T_2,T_3) \qquad\text{for every }T_2,T_3\in\mathcal A(\mu).(13)✦

A Coulomb counterexample is a real function ρ:E→ℝ\rho:E\to\mathbb R satisfying (14). ρ∈𝒟,μ=ρdx∈𝒫(E),E*(μ)<+∞,E*(μ) is attained,μ has no Monge optimizer.\begin{gathered} \rho\in\mathcal D,\qquad \mu=\rho\,dx\in\mathcal P(E),\qquad E_*(\mu)<+\infty,\\ E_*(\mu)\text{ is attained},\qquad \mu\text{ has no Monge optimizer}. \end{gathered}(14)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a Borel probability measure μ\mu on ℝ3\mathbb R^3, Π(μ,μ,μ)\Pi(\mu,\mu,\mu) consists of probability measures on (ℝ3)3(\mathbb R^3)^3 with all three marginals equal to μ\mu, the cost is c(x,y,z)=1/|x−y|+1/|x−z|+1/|y−z|c(x,y,z)=1/|x-y|+1/|x-z|+1/|y-z| with value +∞+\infty at every collision, E*(μ)E_*(\mu) is its infimum over Π(μ,μ,μ)\Pi(\mu,\mu,\mu), an admissible Monge plan is (Id⁡,T2,T3)#μ(\operatorname{Id},T_2,T_3)_\#\mu for Borel maps satisfying (T2)#μ=(T3)#μ=μ(T_2)_\#\mu=(T_3)_\#\mu=\mu, and the density class requires ρ≥0\rho\ge0, ∫ρdx=1\int\rho\,dx=1 and ρ,ρ∈Cc∞(ℝ3)\rho,\sqrt\rho\in C_c^\infty(\mathbb R^3).

What Is Checked

The counterexample condition (14) is stated for real densities on EE, with couplings from (6) and preserving maps from (7).