OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. The reconstruction problem

Theorem 1.1: ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} is injective on classes modulo Frobenius, for function fields of transcendence degree at least 22 over algebraically closed fields of characteristic other than ℓ\ell

The canonical map from field to Galois isomorphisms is injective.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix a prime ℓ\ell. Let kk be an algebraically closed field of characteristic different from ℓ\ell and K/kK/k a function field of transcendence degree at least 22. Bogomolov’s program asks how much of KK is remembered by a small piece of its absolute Galois group: the abelianization ΠKa\Pi^a_K of the maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient, with the commutator pairing [⋅,⋅]K[\,\cdot\,,\cdot\,]_K into the kernel ΔK\Delta_K of the projection from the central quotient of the same pro-ℓ\ell group onto ΠKa\Pi^a_K.

For a second such function field L/lL/l, isomorphisms of perfect closures Ki→LiK^i\to L^i carrying kk onto ll act on these data, contravariantly, by transport of Galois actions. The question is which isomorphisms ΠLa→ΠKa\Pi^a_L\to\Pi^a_K compatible with the pairings arise in this way, and from how many field isomorphisms, the former counted modulo ℤℓ×\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times and the latter modulo Frobenius.

The library proves the part of the answer that runs from fields to Galois groups, and formulates the whole answer as one assertion, the reconstruction statement, made precise in (8).

Galois Groups and the Commutator Pairing

For a field FF with a fixed algebraic closure F¯\overline F, GF=Gal(F¯/F)G_F=\mathrm{Gal}(\overline F/F) is its absolute Galois group. The pro-ℓ\ell kernel of a group GG with a topology is the intersection of the open normal subgroups HH of GG for which G/HG/H is an ℓ\ell-group.✦ The maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient GF(ℓ)G^{(\ell)}_F of GFG_F is the quotient of GFG_F by its pro-ℓ\ell kernel.✦

For a topological group GG, write [G,G]¯\overline{[G,G]} for the closure of its commutator subgroup. The closed lower central subgroup Γ3(G)\Gamma^3(G) of GG is the closure of the subgroup [[G,G]¯,G][\overline{[G,G]},G] generated by the commutators of elements of [G,G]¯\overline{[G,G]} with elements of GG.✦ With G=GF(ℓ)G=G^{(\ell)}_F, the abelianization is ΠFa=G/[G,G]¯\Pi^a_F=G/\overline{[G,G]}✦ and the central quotient is ΠFc=G/Γ3(G)\Pi^c_F=G/\Gamma^3(G)✦. The projection ΠFc→ΠFa\Pi^c_F\to\Pi^a_F is the homomorphism induced by the identity of GG✦, and ΔF\Delta_F is its kernel✦. The projection πF:GF→ΠFa\pi_F\colon G_F\to\Pi^a_F is the composite of the two quotient maps through GG.✦

The commutator pairing [x,y]F[x,y]_F of two elements xx, yy of ΠFa\Pi^a_F is the element of ΔF\Delta_F given by the commutator of chosen lifts x̃\tilde x, ỹ∈G\tilde y\in G of xx and yy: [x,y]F=x̃−1ỹ−1x̃ỹmod⁡Γ3(G).[x,y]_F=\tilde x^{-1}\tilde y^{-1}\tilde x\tilde y \bmod \Gamma^3(G).(1)✦

Let KK and LL be fields. An isomorphism of topological groups φ:ΠLa→ΠKa\varphi\colon\Pi^a_L\to\Pi^a_K is bracket-compatible if there is an isomorphism of topological groups ψ:ΔL→ΔK\psi\colon\Delta_L\to\Delta_K with ψ([x,y]L)=[φ(x),φ(y)]K(x,y∈ΠLa).\psi\bigl([x,y]_L\bigr)=\bigl[\varphi(x),\varphi(y)\bigr]_K\qquad(x,y\in\Pi^a_L).(2)✦ The set Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K) is the set of bracket-compatible isomorphisms ΠLa→ΠKa\Pi^a_L\to\Pi^a_K.✦ Two elements φ\varphi and χ\chi of Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K) differ by a unit u∈ℤℓ×u\in\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times if χ(x)=limn→∞φ(x)un(x∈ΠLa),\chi(x)=\lim_{n\to\infty}\varphi(x)^{u_n}\qquad(x\in\Pi^a_L),(3)✦ where unu_n is the integer approximation of uu modulo ℓn\ell^n. The quotient Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times is the set of classes of Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K) for the equivalence relation generated by differing by a unit.✦

Field Isomorphisms and the Canonical Map

Let K/kK/k and L/lL/l be field extensions. The perfect closure KiK^i of KK is the subfield of K¯\overline K of the elements purely inseparable over KK: those with some pnp^n-th power in KK when KK has characteristic p>0p>0, and KK itself in characteristic zero.✦ The set Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) is the set of field isomorphisms α:Ki→Li\alpha\colon K^i\to L^i with α(k)=l\alpha(k)=l.✦ An element α′\alpha' of Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) is the Frobenius twist of an element α\alpha if LL has prime characteristic pp and α′(x)=α(x)p(x∈Ki).\alpha'(x)=\alpha(x)^p\qquad(x\in K^i).(4)✦ The set IsomFi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) is the set of classes of Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) for the equivalence relation generated by Frobenius twists.✦

An isomorphism β:K¯→L¯\beta\colon\overline K\to\overline L extends α∈Isomi(K,L)\alpha\in\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) if it agrees with α\alpha on KiK^i. Conjugation by such an isomorphism β\beta is the map cβ:GL→GK,cβ(σ)=β−1∘σ∘β.c_\beta\colon G_L\to G_K,\qquad c_\beta(\sigma)=\beta^{-1}\circ\sigma\circ\beta.(5)✦ An element φ\varphi of Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K) is a pullback of α∈Isomi(K,L)\alpha\in\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) if some isomorphism β\beta extending α\alpha satisfies φ(πL(σ))=πK(cβ(σ))(σ∈GL).\varphi\bigl(\pi_L(\sigma)\bigr)=\pi_K\bigl(c_\beta(\sigma)\bigr)\qquad(\sigma\in G_L).(6)✦ The Galois graph 𝒢\mathcal G is the set of pairs (a,b)(a,b), with a∈IsomFi(K,L)a\in\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) and b∈Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×b\in\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times, such that some element of bb is a pullback of some element of aa.✦

The canonical pullback α*∈Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\alpha^*\in\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K) of α∈Isomi(K,L)\alpha\in\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) is the isomorphism of the abelianizations induced by cα̃c_{\tilde\alpha} for a chosen extension α̃:K¯→L¯\tilde\alpha\colon\overline K\to\overline L of α\alpha.✦ The canonical map ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L}, which sends the class [α][\alpha] of α\alpha to the class [α*][\alpha^*] of α*\alpha^*, is ΦK,L:IsomFi(K,L)→Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×,[α]↦[α*].\Phi_{K,L}\colon\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L)\to \mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times,\qquad[\alpha]\mapsto[\alpha^*].(7)✦

The Claim

Let kk and ll be algebraically closed fields and K/kK/k, L/lL/l finitely generated field extensions. The reconstruction statement for KK and LL is the assertion that, if kk and ll have characteristic different from ℓ\ell and K/kK/k and L/lL/l have transcendence degree at least 22, then 𝒢\mathcal G is the graph of a bijection: #{b:(a,b)∈𝒢}=1for every a∈IsomFi(K,L),#{a:(a,b)∈𝒢}=1for every b∈Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×.\begin{aligned} \#\{b:(a,b)\in\mathcal G\}&=1\quad\text{for every }a\in\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L),\\ \#\{a:(a,b)\in\mathcal G\}&=1\quad\text{for every } b\in\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times. \end{aligned}(8)✦ The reconstruction statement (8) is only stated in the library, not proved there: the library does not prove the surjectivity of ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} that it asserts.

Theorem 1. Let kk and ll be algebraically closed fields of characteristic different from ℓ\ell, and K/kK/k, L/lL/l finitely generated field extensions of transcendence degree at least 22. Then each class a∈IsomFi(K,L)a\in\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) lies in exactly one pair of the Galois graph, #{b:(a,b)∈𝒢}=1,\#\{b:(a,b)\in\mathcal G\}=1,(9)✦ two classes aa and a′a' of IsomFi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) paired with the same class bb of Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times are equal, (a,b)∈𝒢and(a′,b)∈𝒢⇒a=a′,(a,b)\in\mathcal G\ \text{and}\ (a',b)\in\mathcal G\ \Longrightarrow\ a=a',(10)✦ and the canonical map is injective: ΦK,L(a)=ΦK,L(a′)⇒a=a′.\Phi_{K,L}(a)=\Phi_{K,L}(a')\ \Longrightarrow\ a=a'.(11)✦ The first of these conclusions holds for arbitrary fields kk, ll and arbitrary extensions K/kK/k, L/lL/l, without the hypotheses above: #{b:(a,b)∈𝒢}=1for every a∈IsomFi(K,L).\#\{b:(a,b)\in\mathcal G\}=1\quad\text{for every }a\in\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L).(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for arbitrary algebraically closed fields kk and ll of characteristics different from ℓ\ell and function fields K/kK/k, L/lL/l with trdeg(K/k),trdeg(L/l)≥2\mathrm{trdeg}(K/k),\mathrm{trdeg}(L/l)\ge 2, the map ΦK,L:IsomFi(K,L)→Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\Phi_{K,L}\colon\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L)\to\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times, [α]↦[α*][\alpha]\mapsto[\alpha^*], is a bijection.

The theorem gives that this map is well-defined and injective, and its bijectivity is the reconstruction statement (8), which the library does not prove.

What Is Checked

Lean checks (10), (9), (11) and (12). The reconstruction statement (8) is only stated, as a definition: Lean checks no proof of it, and the surjectivity of ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} is not proved.

The theorem is stated over the maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotients GF(ℓ)G^{(\ell)}_F, the groups ΠFa\Pi^a_F, ΠFc\Pi^c_F and ΔF\Delta_F with the commutator pairing (1), the set Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi^a_L,\Pi^a_K) and its quotient by ℤℓ×\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times, the set IsomFi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) of classes of isomorphisms of perfect closures, the Galois graph 𝒢\mathcal G and the canonical map ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L}, for algebraically closed fields kk and ll of characteristic different from ℓ\ell and finitely generated extensions K/kK/k and L/lL/l of transcendence degree at least 22.

The library proves that F¯\overline F is an algebraic closure of FiF^i✦, and that β−1\beta^{-1} extends α−1\alpha^{-1} whenever β\beta extends α\alpha✦. It proves as well that conjugation cβc_\beta is a continuous group isomorphism GL→GKG_L\to G_K with inverse cβ−1c_{\beta^{-1}}✦.