OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. The reconstruction problem

The canonical map [α] ↦ [α*]: Conjugation by an extension of a field isomorphism α\alpha to algebraic closures gives α*:ΠLa→ΠKa\alpha^*\colon\Pi_L^a\to\Pi_K^a, and ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} sends [α][\alpha] to [α*][\alpha^*]

The canonical map from field isomorphisms to Galois isomorphisms.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix the prime ℓ\ell, algebraically closed fields kk and ll, and function fields K/kK/k and L/lL/l. For a field FF, F¯\overline{F} is a fixed algebraic closure of FF, GFG_F is the absolute Galois group Gal(F¯/F)\mathrm{Gal}(\overline{F}/F), and GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} is its maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient. An isomorphism of fields from KK to LL acts on Galois groups in the opposite direction, from GLG_L to GKG_K, by conjugation with an extension of it to the algebraic closures.

Birational anabelian geometry asks how much of KK is remembered by a small quotient of GK(ℓ)G_K^{(\ell)}: its abelianization ΠKa\Pi_K^a, with the commutator pairing that the next quotient ΠKc\Pi_K^c puts on it. The canonical map ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} sends a field isomorphism to its action on these data. Its domain is the set IsomFi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) of isomorphisms of perfect closures up to powers of Frobenius; its target is the set Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times of isomorphisms respecting the commutator pairings, up to ℓ\ell-adic units. The reconstruction problem asks when ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} is a bijection.

The canonical map ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} is described by its graph, which admits every extension of a field isomorphism to the algebraic closures, and by a formula, through one extension fixed once and for all.

Galois Groups and the Commutator Pairing

The maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} of GFG_F is the quotient of GFG_F by the intersection of all open normal subgroups HH of GFG_F for which GF/HG_F/H is an ℓ\ell-group.✦ For a topological group GG, write [G,G]¯\overline{[G,G]} for the closure of its commutator subgroup; the closed lower central subgroup Γ3(G)\Gamma^3(G) of GG is the closure of the subgroup generated by the commutators of elements of [G,G]¯\overline{[G,G]} with elements of GG.✦ With G=GF(ℓ)G=G_F^{(\ell)}, the abelianization ΠFa\Pi_F^a and the central quotient ΠFc\Pi_F^c of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} are the quotient groups ΠFa=G/[G,G]¯,ΠFc=G/Γ3(G).\Pi_F^a=G/\overline{[G,G]},\qquad \Pi_F^c=G/\Gamma^3(G).(1) The identity of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} induces a projection ΠFc→ΠFa\Pi_F^c\to\Pi_F^a✦, and ΔF\Delta_F is its kernel✦.

The commutator of two elements xx and yy of a group is [x,y]=x−1y−1xy[x,y]=x^{-1}y^{-1}xy.✦ The commutator pairing [,]F:ΠFa×ΠFa→ΔF[\,,\,]_F\colon\Pi_F^a\times\Pi_F^a\to\Delta_F of FF is the map sending xx and yy to the class in ΠFc\Pi_F^c of the commutator of their lifts x̃\tilde{x} and ỹ\tilde{y} to GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)}, a lift of each element of ΠFa\Pi_F^a being chosen once and for all: [x,y]F=x̃−1ỹ−1x̃ỹmod⁡Γ3(GF(ℓ)).[x,y]_F=\tilde{x}^{-1}\tilde{y}^{-1}\tilde{x}\tilde{y}\bmod\Gamma^3(G_F^{(\ell)}).(2)✦

An isomorphism of topological groups φ:ΠLa→ΠKa\varphi\colon\Pi_L^a\to\Pi_K^a is bracket-compatible if there is an isomorphism of topological groups ψ:ΔL→ΔK\psi\colon\Delta_L\to\Delta_K with ψ([x,y]L)=[φ(x),φ(y)]Kfor all x,y∈ΠLa,\psi([x,y]_L)=[\varphi(x),\varphi(y)]_K\qquad\text{for all } x,y\in\Pi_L^a,(3)✦ and Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a) is the set of bracket-compatible isomorphisms✦.

Two elements φ\varphi and χ\chi of Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a) differ by a unit uu of ℤℓ\mathbb{Z}_\ell when χ(x)=limn→∞φ(x)un=φ(x)ufor all x∈ΠLa,\chi(x)=\lim_{n\to\infty}\varphi(x)^{u_n}=\varphi(x)^u\qquad\text{for all } x\in\Pi_L^a,(4)✦ where unu_n is the nn-th integer approximation of uu, congruent to uu modulo ℓn\ell^n. The set Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times is the quotient of Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a) by the equivalence relation generated by this relation.✦

Perfect Closures and Frobenius

The perfect closure FiF^i of a field FF is the subfield of F¯\overline{F} of the elements purely inseparable over FF: those with some pnp^n-th power in FF when FF has characteristic p>0p>0, and FF itself in characteristic zero.✦ An isomorphism of perfect closures from KK to LL is a field isomorphism α:Ki→Li\alpha\colon K^i\to L^i with α(k)=l\alpha(k)=l, and Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) is the set of them.✦

When LL has characteristic p>0p>0, FrobL(y)=yp\mathrm{Frob}_L(y)=y^p is the Frobenius of LiL^i, and IsomFi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L) is the quotient of Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) by the equivalence relation generated by α∼FrobL∘α\alpha\sim\mathrm{Frob}_L\circ\alpha, whose classes are [α]={FrobLn∘α:n∈ℤ}.[\alpha]=\{\mathrm{Frob}_L^n\circ\alpha : n\in\mathbb{Z}\}.(5)✦ In characteristic zero no two isomorphisms are identified, and IsomFi(K,L)=Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L)=\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L).

The Definition

Definition 1. For a field FF, πF\pi_F is the composite of the quotient maps πF:GF→GF(ℓ)→ΠFa.\pi_F\colon G_F\longrightarrow G_F^{(\ell)}\longrightarrow\Pi_F^a.(6)✦

The pullback graph PK,LP_{K,L} is the set of pairs (α,φ)(\alpha,\varphi) with α∈Isomi(K,L)\alpha\in\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) and φ∈Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\varphi\in\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a) for which α\alpha extends to a field isomorphism β:K¯→L¯\beta\colon\overline{K}\to\overline{L}, with β(x)=α(x)\beta(x)=\alpha(x) for x∈Kix\in K^i, such that every σ∈GL\sigma\in G_L has some τ∈GK\tau\in G_K with β∘τ=σ∘βandφ(πL(σ))=πK(τ).\beta\circ\tau=\sigma\circ\beta\qquad\text{and}\qquad\varphi(\pi_L(\sigma))=\pi_K(\tau).(7)✦

The graph ΓΦ\Gamma_\Phi of ΦK,L\Phi_{K,L} is the subset of IsomFi(K,L)×Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L)\times\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times given by ΓΦ={([α],[φ]):(α,φ)∈PK,L}.\Gamma_\Phi=\{([\alpha],[\varphi]) : (\alpha,\varphi)\in P_{K,L}\}.(8)✦

For α∈Isomi(K,L)\alpha\in\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L), let βα:K¯→L¯\beta_\alpha\colon\overline{K}\to\overline{L} be the extension of α\alpha fixed once and for all.✦ Conjugation σ↦βα−1∘σ∘βα\sigma\mapsto\beta_\alpha^{-1}\circ\sigma\circ\beta_\alpha is an isomorphism of topological groups GL→GKG_L\to G_K✦, and the canonical pullback α*∈Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\alpha^*\in\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a) is the isomorphism it induces on the maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotients and then on their abelianizations: α*(πL(σ))=πK(βα−1∘σ∘βα)for σ∈GL.\alpha^*(\pi_L(\sigma))=\pi_K(\beta_\alpha^{-1}\circ\sigma\circ\beta_\alpha) \qquad\text{for } \sigma\in G_L.(9)✦

The canonical map is ΦK,L:IsomFi(K,L)→Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×,[α]↦[α*].\Phi_{K,L}\colon\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L)\to\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times, \qquad[\alpha]\mapsto[\alpha^*].(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: field isomorphisms induce contravariant isomorphisms of Galois groups, and passing to the quotients gives the map ΦK,L:IsomFi(K,L)→Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)/ℤℓ×\Phi_{K,L}\colon\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L)\to\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a)/\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times.

What Is Checked

The definition is stated over the maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotients GK(ℓ)G_K^{(\ell)} and GL(ℓ)G_L^{(\ell)}, their abelianizations with the commutator pairings into ΔK\Delta_K and ΔL\Delta_L, the set Isomc(ΠLa,ΠKa)\mathrm{Isom}^c(\Pi_L^a,\Pi_K^a) with its quotient by ℤℓ×\mathbb{Z}_\ell^\times, the set Isomi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) of isomorphisms of the perfect closures in fixed algebraic closures with its quotient by Frobenius, and, for α*\alpha^*, the extension βα\beta_\alpha of each α\alpha fixed once and for all.

About these constructions the library proves that F¯\overline{F} is an algebraic closure of FiF^i✦, and that for an extension β\beta of α∈Isomi(K,L)\alpha\in\mathrm{Isom}^i(K,L) the inverse β−1\beta^{-1} extends α−1\alpha^{-1}✦ and conjugation by β\beta is continuous from GLG_L to GKG_K✦. It also proves that the isomorphism ΠLa→ΠKa\Pi_L^a\to\Pi_K^a induced by conjugation with any such β\beta is bracket-compatible, and that [α*][\alpha^*] depends only on [α][\alpha], which makes (10) a map on IsomFi(K,L)\mathrm{Isom}^i_F(K,L).