OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §9. Completion of the trace theorem

Assembly and passage to arbitrary groups: Vanishing at infinite-order conjugacy classes for idempotent matrices and both Grothendieck groups

The Bass trace theorem for arbitrary groups.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The Hattori-Stallings trace of an idempotent matrix over a complex group ring takes values on conjugacy classes. The question is which classes can occur in its support, both for matrices and for classes of finitely generated projective right modules.

Let GG be a group and let ι\iota be a finite index set. A group ring matrix ee over ℂ[G]\mathbb C[G] is an element of Mι(ℂ[G])M_{\iota}(\mathbb C[G]).✦ For a matrix e∈Mι(ℂ[G])e\in M_{\iota}(\mathbb C[G]) and s∈Gs\in G, the coefficient matrix e(s)e(s) is the complex matrix whose entries are given in (1)✦; the matrix support supp⁡(e)\operatorname{supp}(e) is the finite subset of GG specified there: e(s)ij=the coefficient of s in eij,supp⁡(e)={s∈G:e(s)≠0}.e(s)_{ij}=\text{the coefficient of }s\text{ in }e_{ij}, \qquad \operatorname{supp}(e)=\{s\in G:e(s)\ne0\}.(1)✦ An idempotent matrix e∈Mι(ℂ[G])e\in M_{\iota}(\mathbb C[G]) is a finite square matrix satisfying e2=ee^2=e.✦

Write [g][g] for the conjugacy class of g∈Gg\in G. For a∈ℂ[G]a\in\mathbb C[G], write asa_s for the coefficient of s∈Gs\in G in aa; its conjugacy class coefficient c[g](a)c_{[g]}(a) is the sum in (2).✦ The conjugacy class trace cl⁡G(a)\operatorname{cl}_G(a) of a∈ℂ[G]a\in\mathbb C[G] is the finitely supported complex function on conjugacy classes whose value at [g][g] is c[g](a)c_{[g]}(a).✦ For a finite square matrix e∈Mq(ℂ[G])e\in M_q(\mathbb C[G]) and g∈Gg\in G, the idempotent trace coefficient tg(e)t_g(e) is the complex number given in (2): c[g](a)=∑s∈[g]as,cl⁡G(a)([g])=c[g](a),tg(e)=c[g](tr⁡e).\begin{aligned} c_{[g]}(a)&=\sum_{s\in[g]}a_s, &\operatorname{cl}_G(a)([g])&=c_{[g]}(a),\\ t_g(e)&=c_{[g]}(\operatorname{tr}e). \end{aligned}(2)✦

Path Weights

For n≥0n\ge0, a path with n+1n+1 vertices is a tuple h=(h0,…,hn)h=(h_0,\ldots,h_n) in Gn+1G^{n+1}. For g∈Gg\in G, the centralizer CG(g)C_G(g) is the subgroup {c∈G:cg=gc}\{c\in G:cg=gc\} of GG; it acts on paths by simultaneous left multiplication. Two paths h=(h0,…,hn)h=(h_0,\ldots,h_n) and k=(k0,…,kn)k=(k_0,\ldots,k_n) in Gn+1G^{n+1} are centralizer-equivalent when ki=chik_i=ch_i for all ii for some c∈CG(g)c\in C_G(g)✦; their orbit space is denoted by 𝒪n+1(g)\mathcal O_{n+1}(g).

Given g∈Gg\in G, a path h∈Gn+1h\in G^{n+1}, and a group ring matrix ee, define the twisted increments δigh∈G\delta_i^g h\in G and the complex path weight we(g,h)w_e(g,h) by (3); the product follows the vertex order: δigh={hi−1hi+1,0≤i<n,hn−1gh0,i=n,we(g,h)=tr⁡(∏i=0ne(δigh)).\delta_i^g h= \begin{cases} h_i^{-1}h_{i+1},&0\le i<n,\\ h_n^{-1}gh_0,&i=n, \end{cases} \qquad w_e(g,h)=\operatorname{tr}\!\left(\prod_{i=0}^{n}e(\delta_i^g h)\right).(3) For a group ring matrix ee and g∈Gg\in G, the orbit weight is the complex function on 𝒪n+1(g)\mathcal O_{n+1}(g) that assigns we(g,h)w_e(g,h) to the orbit [h][h].✦ The weighted path orbit vector vn+1(e,g)v_{n+1}(e,g) of a group ring matrix ee at g∈Gg\in G is the finite complex linear combination of orbits in 𝒪n+1(g)\mathcal O_{n+1}(g) given in (4).✦ Its coefficients sum to the total path weight Wn(e,g)W_n(e,g): vn+1(e,g)=∑[h]∈𝒪n+1(g)we(g,h)[h],Wn(e,g)=∑[h]∈𝒪n+1(g)we(g,h).v_{n+1}(e,g)=\sum_{[h]\in\mathcal O_{n+1}(g)}w_e(g,h)[h], \qquad W_n(e,g)=\sum_{[h]\in\mathcal O_{n+1}(g)}w_e(g,h).(4)✦

The Two Grothendieck Groups

Let RR be a ring and let ℐ(R)\mathcal I(R) denote its idempotent matrices of all finite sizes. Write ⟨e⟩\langle e\rangle for the generator associated to ee in the free abelian group ℤ[ℐ(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal I(R)]. For idempotent matrices e,f∈ℐ(R)e,f\in\mathcal I(R), the idempotent direct sum e⊕fe\oplus f is the block diagonal matrix over RR with blocks ee and ff, of size equal to the sum of their sizes.✦ The idempotent relation subgroup DRD_R of ℤ[ℐ(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal I(R)] is the subgroup generated by the two kinds of differences in (5); in the first, aa and bb are rectangular matrices of the appropriate sizes.✦ Algebraic K0id(R)K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(R) in the idempotent model is the quotient group of ℤ[ℐ(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal I(R)] by DRD_R✦, and the idempotent class [e]∈K0id(R)[e]\in K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(R) is the coset of ⟨e⟩\langle e\rangle given in (5): DR=⟨⟨e⟩−⟨f⟩(ab=e,ba=f),⟨e⊕f⟩−⟨e⟩−⟨f⟩⟩,K0id(R)=ℤ[ℐ(R)]/DR,[e]=⟨e⟩+DR.\begin{gathered} D_R=\bigl\langle\, \langle e\rangle-\langle f\rangle\quad(ab=e,\ ba=f),\quad \langle e\oplus f\rangle-\langle e\rangle-\langle f\rangle \,\bigr\rangle,\\ K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(R)=\mathbb Z[\mathcal I(R)]/D_R, \qquad [e]=\langle e\rangle+D_R. \end{gathered}(5)✦

For R=ℂ[G]R=\mathbb C[G], the trace before quotienting is the additive extension HS̃G\widetilde{\mathrm{HS}}_G of the rule in (6)✦; the trace coefficient before quotienting at gg is the additive extension c̃g\widetilde c_g in the same display.✦ The idempotent Hattori-Stallings trace HSG\mathrm{HS}_G is the homomorphism from K0id(ℂ[G])K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(\mathbb C[G]) to finitely supported complex functions on conjugacy classes specified there: HS̃G(⟨e⟩)=HSG([e])=cl⁡G(tr⁡e),c̃g(⟨e⟩)=tg(e).\widetilde{\mathrm{HS}}_G(\langle e\rangle) =\mathrm{HS}_G([e])=\operatorname{cl}_G(\operatorname{tr}e), \qquad \widetilde c_g(\langle e\rangle)=t_g(e).(6)✦

A finitely generated projective right RR-module PP is a right RR-module whose additive group is abelian and which is finitely generated and projective.✦ For finitely generated projective right RR-modules PP and QQ, the direct sum P⊕QP\oplus Q is the right RR-module whose underlying set is the Cartesian product of PP and QQ, with componentwise operations.✦ Let 𝒫(R)\mathcal P(R) denote the collection of finitely generated projective right RR-modules, and let ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle denote the generator associated to PP in the free abelian group ℤ[𝒫(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal P(R)]. The module relation subgroup MRM_R of ℤ[𝒫(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal P(R)] is the subgroup generated by the differences for isomorphic modules and the direct sum differences given in (7).✦ The module Grothendieck group K0mod(R)K_0^{\mathrm{mod}}(R) is the quotient group of ℤ[𝒫(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal P(R)] by MRM_R✦, and the module class [P]∈K0mod(R)[P]\in K_0^{\mathrm{mod}}(R) is the coset of ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle given in (7): MR=⟨⟨P⟩−⟨Q⟩(P≅RQ),⟨P⊕Q⟩−⟨P⟩−⟨Q⟩⟩,K0mod(R)=ℤ[𝒫(R)]/MR,[P]=⟨P⟩+MR.\begin{gathered} M_R=\bigl\langle\, \langle P\rangle-\langle Q\rangle\quad(P\cong_R Q),\quad \langle P\oplus Q\rangle-\langle P\rangle-\langle Q\rangle \,\bigr\rangle,\\ K_0^{\mathrm{mod}}(R)=\mathbb Z[\mathcal P(R)]/M_R, \qquad [P]=\langle P\rangle+M_R. \end{gathered}(7)

A finite free module retraction onto a right RR-module PP consists of a rank rr and right module maps p:Rr→Pp:R^r\to P and i:P→Rri:P\to R^r satisfying pi=id⁡Ppi=\operatorname{id}_P.✦ For a matrix A=(aijop)A=(a_{ij}^{\mathrm{op}}) over the opposite ring RopR^{\mathrm{op}}, its opposite ring transpose A∨A^\vee is the matrix over RR with entries (A∨)ij=aji(A^\vee)_{ij}=a_{ji}.✦ The right module homomorphism matrix of a right RR-module map f:Rr→Rsf:R^r\to R^s is the matrix over RR obtained as the opposite ring transpose of its coordinate matrix over RopR^{\mathrm{op}}.✦ The idempotent associated to a finite free module retraction onto a right RR-module PP, with maps p:Rr→Pp:R^r\to P and i:P→Rri:P\to R^r, is the matrix over RR given by the right module homomorphism matrix of ipip.✦

For finite free module retractions of ranks rr and ss, the free module sum isomorphism Rr+s≅Rr⊕RsR^{r+s}\cong R^r\oplus R^s identifies their direct sum with a retraction of rank r+sr+s.✦ Transport along a right module isomorphism u:P→Qu:P\to Q replaces pp and ii by upup and iu−1iu^{-1}.✦

Choose a finite free retraction for each P∈𝒫(R)P\in\mathcal P(R), and denote its idempotent by EPE_P.✦ The idempotent presentation class of a finitely generated projective right RR-module PP is the class [EP]∈K0id(R)[E_P]\in K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(R) determined by its chosen finite free retraction.✦ The presentation before quotienting is the homomorphism from ℤ[𝒫(R)]\mathbb Z[\mathcal P(R)] to K0id(R)K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(R) that additively extends ⟨P⟩↦[EP]\langle P\rangle\mapsto[E_P].✦ The idempotent presentation homomorphism πR\pi_R and, for R=ℂ[G]R=\mathbb C[G], the module Hattori-Stallings trace are given in (8): πR:K0mod(R)→K0id(R),πR([P])=[EP],HSG(x)=HSG(πℂ[G](x)).\pi_R:K_0^{\mathrm{mod}}(R)\longrightarrow K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(R), \qquad \pi_R([P])=[E_P], \qquad \mathrm{HS}_G(x)=\mathrm{HS}_G(\pi_{\mathbb C[G]}(x)).(8)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let GG be a group, let g∈Gg\in G have infinite order, and let e∈Mι(ℂ[G])e\in M_{\iota}(\mathbb C[G]) be idempotent, where ι\iota is finite.

Suppose that S⊆GS\subseteq G is a finite generating set, closed under inverses, and containing supp⁡(e)\operatorname{supp}(e). The total path weight satisfies (9): W0(e,g)=0.W_0(e,g)=0.(9)✦

When GG is countable and finitely generated, the conjugacy class coefficient satisfies (10): c[g](tr⁡e)=0.c_{[g]}(\operatorname{tr}e)=0.(10)✦

For arbitrary GG and each idempotent f∈Mq(ℂ[G])f\in M_q(\mathbb C[G]), where q≥0q\ge0, the idempotent trace coefficient satisfies (11): tg(f)=0.t_g(f)=0.(11)✦

The Hattori-Stallings trace of x∈K0id(ℂ[G])x\in K_0^{\mathrm{id}}(\mathbb C[G]) satisfies (12): HSG(x)([g])=0.\mathrm{HS}_G(x)([g])=0.(12)✦

If x∈K0mod(ℂ[G])x\in K_0^{\mathrm{mod}}(\mathbb C[G]), then its module Hattori-Stallings trace satisfies (13): HSG(x)([g])=0.\mathrm{HS}_G(x)([g])=0.(13)✦

What Is Checked

The assertions concern finite matrices over ℂ[G]\mathbb C[G] and the two Grothendieck groups in (5) and (7), with the finite inverse-closed generating set required in (9) and the countability and finite generation required in (10).