OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §8. A Pfaffian cocycle detecting the trace coefficient

Proposition 8.3: Lift independence and centralizer invariance on cyclic cosets, including the degree parameter m=0m=0

Pfaffian cocycles pair with even path chains.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For a group GG, even path chains attached to a matrix over ℂ[G]\mathbb C[G] admit pairings with functionals on cyclic cosets. The kernels used here record the change of exponent when their arguments are multiplied by powers of a fixed group element.

Let GG be a group and g∈Gg\in G. Write H=CG(g)H=C_G(g) for its centralizer and Y=⟨g⟩∖GY=\langle g\rangle\backslash G for the coset vertex set.✦ The coset projection is π(h)=⟨g⟩h\pi(h)=\langle g\rangle h, and the centralizer action is cπ(h)=π(ch)c\pi(h)=\pi(ch) for c∈Hc\in H. Choose a representative section ℓ:Y→G\ell:Y\to G, so that π(ℓ(y))=y\pi(\ell(y))=y.✦

For a vertex set ZZ, the vertex vector space V(Z)V(Z) consists of the finitely supported complex functions on ZZ, with coordinate unit vectors δz\delta_z.✦ Its exterior algebra is ⋀V(Z)\bigwedge V(Z).✦ The augmented simplex spaces Ej(Z)E_j(Z) and oriented vertex wedges are defined in (1): Ej(Z)=⋀j+1V(Z)(j≥−1),E−1(Z)=ℂ,[z0,…,zj]=δz0∧⋯∧δzj.\begin{aligned} E_j(Z)&=\bigwedge^{j+1}V(Z)\qquad(j\geq -1), &E_{-1}(Z)&=\mathbb C,\\ [z_0,\ldots,z_j]&=\delta_{z_0}\wedge\cdots\wedge\delta_{z_j}. \end{aligned}(1) After ordering ZZ, the oriented simplex basis consists of the wedges over increasing subsets of cardinality j+1j+1.✦

For a linear functional α\alpha on a module MM, contraction ια\iota_\alpha on ⋀M\bigwedge M is the antiderivation that agrees with α\alpha on vectors and lowers exterior degree by one.✦ The vertex augmentation ε\varepsilon on V(Z)V(Z) is the linear functional that sums coefficients, and the exterior algebra boundary is its contraction. Its graded restrictions are denoted ∂\partial, as in (2): ε(∑zazδz)=∑zaz,∂=ιε:Ej(Z)→Ej−1(Z).\varepsilon\left(\sum_z a_z\delta_z\right)=\sum_z a_z, \qquad \partial=\iota_\varepsilon:E_j(Z)\longrightarrow E_{j-1}(Z).(2) A vertex map f:Z→Z′f:Z\to Z' induces a linearized vertex map by summing coefficients over its fibers, sending δz\delta_z to δf(z)\delta_{f(z)}.✦ Its induced exterior power maps on the simplex spaces are also denoted f*f_*.✦

The Pfaffian Detector

The coordinate space WIW_I of an index set II is the complex vector space of finitely supported functions on II, with coordinate vectors eie_i, equal to one at ii and zero elsewhere, and coordinate exterior algebra ⋀WI\bigwedge W_I. For finite II, WI=ℂIW_I=\mathbb C^I, and a prescribed coordinate family aa determines the vector ∑iaiei\sum_i a_i e_i; write uI=∑ieiu_I=\sum_i e_i. Exterior multiplication by a vector v∈WIv\in W_I is the linear map x↦v∧xx\mapsto v\wedge x.✦ For I={0,…,n−1}I=\{0,\ldots,n-1\}, the coordinate vectors eie_i form the standard coordinate basis of WIW_I.✦

The unnormalized bivector Ω̃B\widetilde\Omega_B and matrix bivector ΩB\Omega_B of a complex matrix BB on II are given by (3): Ω̃B=∑i,j∈IBijei∧ej,ΩB=12Ω̃B.\widetilde\Omega_B=\sum_{i,j\in I}B_{ij}e_i\wedge e_j, \qquad \Omega_B=\frac12\widetilde\Omega_B.(3) For a nonnegative integer mm, the normalized exterior power Pm(B)P_m(B) and odd Pfaffian form Fm(B)F_m(B) are the forms with respectively 2m2m and 2m+12m+1 wedge factors in (4): Pm(B)=ΩB∧mm!,Fm(B)=uI∧Pm(B).P_m(B)=\frac{\Omega_B^{\wedge m}}{m!}, \qquad F_m(B)=u_I\wedge P_m(B).(4)

Take I={0,…,n−1}I=\{0,\ldots,n-1\}. Its top exterior basis consists of e0∧⋯∧en−1e_0\wedge\cdots\wedge e_{n-1}, indexed by the full coordinate subset.✦ The top coefficient tnt_n on the top exterior power of W{0,…,n−1}W_{\{0,\ldots,n-1\}} is the linear functional that extracts the coefficient of e0∧⋯∧en−1e_0\wedge\cdots\wedge e_{n-1}.✦ The Pfaffian detector is the scalar in (5): Dm(B)=t2m+1(Fm(B))(B∈M2m+1(ℂ)).D_m(B)=t_{2m+1}\bigl(F_m(B)\bigr) \qquad\bigl(B\in M_{2m+1}(\mathbb C)\bigr).(5)✦ For a complex kernel β\beta on a set ZZ and a tuple h∈Z2mh\in Z^{2m}, write pm(h)=t2m(Pm((β(hi,hj))i,j))p_m(h)=t_{2m}\bigl(P_m((\beta(h_i,h_j))_{i,j})\bigr).

An alternating function ff on nn-tuples in ZZ, with values in an additive commutative group, is a function that changes by the sign of a permutation of its arguments and vanishes when two arguments coincide.✦ For an alternating function ff with values in a complex vector space AA, its linear extension is the complex linear map En−1(Z)→AE_{n-1}(Z)\to A assigning to each oriented simplex basis vector the value of ff on the increasing enumeration.✦ For a complex kernel β\beta on ZZ, the alternating Pfaffian detector is the function v↦Dm((β(vi,vj))i,j)v\mapsto D_m((\beta(v_i,v_j))_{i,j}) on (2m+1)(2m+1)-tuples; its linear extension is the Pfaffian cocycle on E2m(Z)E_{2m}(Z).

A skew kernel β\beta on GG is a function G×G→ℂG\times G\to\mathbb C satisfying (S) in (6). Its lift translation law is (L), and its centralizer invariance is (I): (S)β(h,k)=−β(k,h),(L)β(grh,gsk)=β(h,k)+s−r(r,s∈ℤ),(I)β(ch,ck)=β(h,k)(c∈H).\begin{aligned} \text{(S)}\quad&\beta(h,k)=-\beta(k,h),\\ \text{(L)}\quad&\beta(g^r h,g^s k)=\beta(h,k)+s-r &&(r,s\in\mathbb Z),\\ \text{(I)}\quad&\beta(ch,ck)=\beta(h,k)&&(c\in H). \end{aligned}(6) Here h,kh,k range over GG. For any complex kernel β\beta on GG, the coset Pfaffian cocycle ψm,β:E2m(Y)→ℂ\psi_{m,\beta}:E_{2m}(Y)\to\mathbb C is the linear functional specified using the chosen representatives by (7): ψm,β([y0,…,y2m])=Dm((β(ℓ(yi),ℓ(yj)))0≤i,j≤2m).\psi_{m,\beta}([y_0,\ldots,y_{2m}]) =D_m\bigl((\beta(\ell(y_i),\ell(y_j)))_{0\leq i,j\leq 2m}\bigr).(7)✦

Path Weights and Coinvariants

The coinvariant relation space RjR_j in Ej(Y)E_j(Y) is the span of the differences between centralizer translates of chains and the original chains.✦ The coinvariant chain space E¯j(Y)\overline E_j(Y) is the quotient of Ej(Y)E_j(Y) by RjR_j, as in (8); write qjq_j for its canonical quotient map. Rj=span⁡ℂ{c*x−x:c∈H,x∈Ej(Y)},E¯j(Y)=Ej(Y)/Rj.R_j=\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb C} \{c_*x-x:c\in H,\ x\in E_j(Y)\}, \qquad \overline E_j(Y)=E_j(Y)/R_j.(8)

Let ι\iota be a finite index set and e∈Mι(ℂ[G])e\in M_\iota(\mathbb C[G]) a group ring matrix. Its coefficient matrix es∈Mι(ℂ)e_s\in M_\iota(\mathbb C) at s∈Gs\in G has entries (es)ij=coeff⁡s(eij)(e_s)_{ij}=\operatorname{coeff}_s(e_{ij}).✦ Two paths h,k∈Gn+1h,k\in G^{n+1} are centralizer equivalent when ki=chik_i=ch_i for one c∈Hc\in H and every ii.✦ Denote their centralizer path orbit space by 𝒪n+1\mathcal O_{n+1}.✦ The twisted increments Δi(h)\Delta_i(h) and path weight we,g(h)w_{e,g}(h) are given in (9), with the matrix product taken in the displayed order: Δi(h)={hi−1hi+1,0≤i<n,hn−1gh0,i=n,we,g(h)=tr⁡(eΔ0(h)⋯eΔn(h)).\Delta_i(h)= \begin{cases} h_i^{-1}h_{i+1},&0\leq i<n,\\ h_n^{-1}gh_0,&i=n, \end{cases} \qquad w_{e,g}(h)=\operatorname{tr} \bigl(e_{\Delta_0(h)}\cdots e_{\Delta_n(h)}\bigr).(9)

The orbit weight w¯e,g\overline w_{e,g} is the function on 𝒪n+1\mathcal O_{n+1} assigning we,g(h)w_{e,g}(h) to the orbit of hh.✦ The weighted path orbit vector vn+1v_{n+1} is the finitely supported complex function on 𝒪n+1\mathcal O_{n+1} with values given in (10), and the total path weight Tn(e,g)T_n(e,g) is the sum of its coefficients; λ\lambda denotes the degree-zero total weight. vn+1(O)=w¯e,g(O),Tn(e,g)=∑O∈supp⁡(vn+1)vn+1(O),λ=T0(e,g).v_{n+1}(O)=\overline w_{e,g}(O), \qquad T_n(e,g)=\sum_{O\in\operatorname{supp}(v_{n+1})}v_{n+1}(O), \qquad \lambda=T_0(e,g).(10) For a path h∈Gn+1h\in G^{n+1}, write [h][h] for its centralizer orbit in 𝒪n+1\mathcal O_{n+1}. The path orbit chain projection PnP_n is the map from 𝒪n+1\mathcal O_{n+1} to E¯n(Y)\overline E_n(Y) given in (11), and the path chain zn∈E¯n(Y)z_n\in\overline E_n(Y) is the weighted sum of its values given there: Pn([h])=qn[π(h0),…,π(hn)],zn=∑O∈supp⁡(vn+1)vn+1(O)Pn(O).P_n([h])=q_n[\pi(h_0),\ldots,\pi(h_n)], \qquad z_n=\sum_{O\in\operatorname{supp}(v_{n+1})}v_{n+1}(O)P_n(O).(11) For a kernel satisfying (L) and (I), the coinvariant cocycle ψ¯m,β:E¯2m(Y)→ℂ\overline\psi_{m,\beta}:\overline E_{2m}(Y)\to\mathbb C is the linear functional induced by the coset cocycle, characterized by (12): ψ¯m,β(q2m(x))=ψm,β(x).\overline\psi_{m,\beta}\bigl(q_{2m}(x)\bigr)=\psi_{m,\beta}(x).(12)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let GG be a group, g∈Gg\in G, and m≥0m\geq0 an integer. If gg has infinite order, there exist a skew kernel β\beta satisfying (L) and a complex linear functional Ψ:E2m(Y)→ℂ\Psi:E_{2m}(Y)\to\mathbb C with the properties in (13): Ψ∘∂=0,Ψ∘c*=Ψ(c∈H),Ψ([π(h0),…,π(h2m)])=Dm((β(hi,hj))0≤i,j≤2m)(h∈G2m+1).\begin{aligned} \Psi\circ\partial&=0,\\ \Psi\circ c_*&=\Psi&&(c\in H),\\ \Psi([\pi(h_0),\ldots,\pi(h_{2m})]) &=D_m\bigl((\beta(h_i,h_j))_{0\leq i,j\leq2m}\bigr) &&(h\in G^{2m+1}). \end{aligned}(13)✦

For any kernel β\beta satisfying (L), evaluation on a tuple h∈G2m+1h\in G^{2m+1} is given by (14): ψm,β([π(h0),…,π(h2m)])=Dm((β(hi,hj))0≤i,j≤2m).\psi_{m,\beta}([\pi(h_0),\ldots,\pi(h_{2m})]) =D_m\bigl((\beta(h_i,h_j))_{0\leq i,j\leq2m}\bigr).(14)✦ For any skew kernel β\beta, the coset cocycle satisfies (15) for every x∈E2m+1(Y)x\in E_{2m+1}(Y): ψm,β(∂x)=0.\psi_{m,\beta}(\partial x)=0.(15)✦ For a kernel satisfying (L) and (I), its centralizer invariance is (16), for every c∈Hc\in H and x∈E2m(Y)x\in E_{2m}(Y): ψm,β(c*x)=ψm,β(x).\psi_{m,\beta}(c_*x)=\psi_{m,\beta}(x).(16)✦ Let ee be a finite group ring matrix with e2=ee^2=e, and let β\beta satisfy (S), (L), and (I). The pairing is (17): ψ¯m,β(z2m)=2−mT0(e,g).\overline\psi_{m,\beta}(z_{2m})=2^{-m}T_0(e,g).(17)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for every integer m≥1m\geq1, the expression ψm(y0,…,y2m)=∑i=02m(−1)ipm(h0,…,hiˆ,…,h2m)\psi_m(y_0,\ldots,y_{2m})=\sum_{i=0}^{2m}(-1)^i p_m(h_0,\ldots,\widehat{h_i},\ldots,h_{2m}), where each hih_i is any lift of yiy_i, defines an HH-invariant linear functional E2m(Y)→ℂE_{2m}(Y)\to\mathbb C satisfying ψm∂=0\psi_m\partial=0 and ψm(z2m)=2−mλ\psi_m(z_{2m})=2^{-m}\lambda.

What Is Checked

The existence assertion is stated for an infinite-order element of an arbitrary group; the pairing concerns finite idempotent matrices over ℂ[G]\mathbb C[G] and kernels satisfying (S), (L), and (I). For every group ring matrix and every n≥0n\geq0, the orbit weights are nonzero on only finitely many centralizer path orbits.✦