OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. The critical number and cup length of the quadric

Corollary 5.3: Circle-equivariant maps on unit isotropic representatives

Smooth functions on the quadric threefold have at least four critical points.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For the projective quadric threefold, the critical-number problem asks how small the critical locus of a smooth real function can be.

The complex vector space ℂn\mathbb C^n consists of vectors with complex coordinates indexed by 0,…,n−10,\ldots,n-1.✦ The squared Hermitian norm ∥w∥2\|w\|^2 of a vector w∈ℂnw\in\mathbb C^n and the quadric form PP on ℂ5\mathbb C^5 are the functions defined by (1): ∥w∥2=∑j=0n−1|wj|2(w∈ℂn),P(z)=∑j=04zj2(z∈ℂ5).\|w\|^2=\sum_{j=0}^{n-1}|w_j|^2 \quad(w\in\mathbb C^n), \qquad P(z)=\sum_{j=0}^{4}z_j^2 \quad(z\in\mathbb C^5).(1)

The projective quadric Q3Q^3 is the subset of complex projective four-space defined by (2), where [z][z] denotes the complex line represented by a nonzero vector z∈ℂ5z\in\mathbb C^5: Q3={[z]∈ℂℙ4:P(z)=0}.Q^3=\{[z]\in\mathbb{CP}^4:P(z)=0\}.(2)✦

A unit isotropic vector zz in ℂ5\mathbb C^5 is a vector of squared Hermitian norm one whose quadric form vanishes.✦ The unit isotropic cone Z⊆ℂ5Z\subseteq\mathbb C^5 is the set of unit isotropic vectors, and the projectivization map π:Z→Q3\pi:Z\to Q^3 sends each vector to its complex projective class, as in (3): Z={z∈ℂ5:∥z∥2=1,P(z)=0},π(z)=[z].Z=\{z\in\mathbb C^5:\|z\|^2=1,\ P(z)=0\}, \qquad \pi(z)=[z].(3)

Smooth Functions and Critical Loci

A local smooth function lift g:ℂ5→ℝg:\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb R of a real function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R at z∈Zz\in Z is a function smooth on an open neighborhood U⊆ℂ5U\subseteq\mathbb C^5 of zz and satisfying (4): g(y)=h(π(y))(y∈U∩Z).g(y)=h(\pi(y))\qquad(y\in U\cap Z).(4)✦

A smooth real function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R is a real-valued function on Q3Q^3 admitting a local smooth function lift at every z∈Zz\in Z.✦

For z∈ℂ5z\in\mathbb C^5, the horizontal subspace Hz⊆ℂ5H_z\subseteq\mathbb C^5 consists of the vectors specified in (5): Hz={v∈ℂ5:∑j=04zj¯vj=0,∑j=04zjvj=0}.H_z=\left\{v\in\mathbb C^5: \sum_{j=0}^{4}\overline{z_j}v_j=0,\quad \sum_{j=0}^{4}z_jv_j=0\right\}.(5)✦

A critical point of a real function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R is a point q∈Q3q\in Q^3 such that, at every representative z∈Zz\in Z with π(z)=q\pi(z)=q, every local smooth function lift gg of hh satisfies dgz(v)=0dg_z(v)=0 for all v∈Hzv\in H_z.✦ The critical locus Crit⁡(h)⊆Q3\operatorname{Crit}(h)\subseteq Q^3 of a smooth real function hh is the set of its critical points, including degenerate ones.✦

For a set AA, its extended cardinality #∞A\#_{\infty}A is its finite cardinality when AA is finite and is ∞\infty otherwise. Write C∞(Q3,ℝ)C^\infty(Q^3,\mathbb R) for the set of smooth real functions on Q3Q^3. The critical number Crit⁡(Q3)\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3) is the infimum in the extended natural numbers ℕ∞=ℕ∪{∞}\mathbb N_{\infty}=\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\} defined by (6): Crit⁡(Q3)=infh∈C∞(Q3,ℝ)#∞Crit⁡(h),\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3) =\inf_{h\in C^\infty(Q^3,\mathbb R)} \#_{\infty}\operatorname{Crit}(h),(6)✦

Circle Equivariance

A map F:ℂ5→ℂ3F:\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb C^3 is circle-equivariant on ZZ when it satisfies (7), with the circle acting on both spaces by scalar multiplication: F(az)=aF(z)(z∈Z,a∈ℂ,|a|2=1).F(az)=aF(z)\qquad(z\in Z,\ a\in\mathbb C,\ |a|^2=1).(7) Smoothness of an ambient map FF means smoothness over ℝ\mathbb R.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R be a smooth real function. Then 4≤#∞Crit⁡(h).4\leq\#_{\infty}\operatorname{Crit}(h).(8)✦ The critical number satisfies 4≤Crit⁡(Q3).4\leq\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3).(9)✦

Suppose that h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R is smooth and #∞Crit⁡(h)≤3\#_{\infty}\operatorname{Crit}(h)\leq3. There is a smooth map F:ℂ5→ℂ3F:\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb C^3, circle-equivariant on ZZ, such that F(z)≠0(z∈Z).F(z)\neq0\qquad(z\in Z).(10)✦

Let F:ℂ5→ℂ3F:\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb C^3 be smooth and circle-equivariant on ZZ. There is a vector z∈Zz\in Z for which ∥F(z)∥2≠1.\|F(z)\|^2\neq1.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads Crit⁡(Q3)=cuplength⁡(Q3;ℚ)=4\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3)=\operatorname{cuplength}(Q^3;\mathbb Q)=4, where cuplength⁡(Q3;ℚ)\operatorname{cuplength}(Q^3;\mathbb Q) denotes rational cup length.

What Is Checked

The bounds (8) and (9) concern smooth real functions on the literal projective quadric, with smoothness defined by local ambient lifts; (10) and (11) concern smooth maps ℂ5→ℂ3\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb C^3 whose equivariance is required on ZZ.