OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Three critical points on the fixed submanifold

Remark 4.2: A bilinear calculation for a polynomial ff on S2×S2S^2\times S^2 at a critical point q0q_0

The tangent Hessian has a two-dimensional kernel.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Consider the restriction of a polynomial on E=ℝ3×ℝ3E=\mathbb R^3\times\mathbb R^3 to S2×S2S^2\times S^2, where S2S^2 is the unit sphere in Euclidean three-space. Coordinates on each copy of ℝ3\mathbb R^3 are indexed by 0,1,20,1,2. The north pole pp, equatorial point ee, and distinguished pair q0∈S2×S2q_0\in S^2\times S^2 are given by (1): p=(0,0,1),e=(1,0,0),q0=(p,−e).p=(0,0,1),\qquad e=(1,0,0),\qquad q_0=(p,-e).(1) The ambient polynomial f:E→ℝf:E\to\mathbb R is the function defined by (2): f(x,y)=e⋅x+(x−p)⋅y.f(x,y)=e\cdot x+(x-p)\cdot y.(2)✦

For i∈{0,1,2}i\in\{0,1,2\}, the coordinate linear forms ξi,ηi:E→ℝ\xi_i,\eta_i:E\to\mathbb R are defined by (3): ξi(x,y)=xi,ηi(x,y)=yi.\xi_i(x,y)=x_i,\qquad \eta_i(x,y)=y_i.(3) The ambient differential dfq:E→ℝdf_q:E\to\mathbb R at q=(x,y)q=(x,y) is the linear form (4): df(x,y)=(1+y0)ξ0+y1ξ1+y2ξ2+x0η0+x1η1+(x2−1)η2.df_{(x,y)}=(1+y_0)\xi_0+y_1\xi_1+y_2\xi_2 +x_0\eta_0+x_1\eta_1+(x_2-1)\eta_2.(4)✦

For q=(x,y)∈Eq=(x,y)\in E, the tangent subspace Tq⊂ET_q\subset E is the space defined by (5); at a point of S2×S2S^2\times S^2 it is the product sphere tangent space: Tq={(r,s)∈E:x⋅r=0,y⋅s=0}.T_q=\{(r,s)\in E:x\cdot r=0,\ y\cdot s=0\}.(5)✦ The tangent coordinate map C:ℝ4→Tq0C:\mathbb R^4\to T_{q_0} is defined by (6), with w=(u,v,a,b)w=(u,v,a,b): C(u,v,a,b)=((u,v,0),(0,a,b)).C(u,v,a,b)=\bigl((u,v,0),(0,a,b)\bigr).(6)✦ The tangent Hessian in these coordinates is the bilinear form H:ℝ4×ℝ4→ℝH:\mathbb R^4\times\mathbb R^4\to\mathbb R defined by (7), where D2f(q0)D^2f(q_0) denotes the ambient second derivative: H(w,z)=D2f(q0)(Cw,Cz).H(w,z)=D^2f(q_0)(Cw,Cz).(7)

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the polynomial ff at q0q_0, the ambient differential vanishes: dfq0=0.df_{q_0}=0.(8)✦ For vectors w,z∈ℝ4w,z\in\mathbb R^4, with coordinates indexed by 0,1,2,30,1,2,3, the tangent Hessian has the formula H(w,z)=w1z2+w2z1.H(w,z)=w_1z_2+w_2z_1.(9)✦ Its kernel is ker⁡H={u(1,0,0,0)+b(0,0,0,1):u,b∈ℝ}.\ker H=\{u(1,0,0,0)+b(0,0,0,1):u,b\in\mathbb R\}.(10)✦ There is a nonzero tangent vector annihilated by the restricted Hessian: ∃r∈Tq0\{0},D2f(q0)(r,s)=0for every s∈Tq0.\exists\,r\in T_{q_0}\setminus\{0\},\qquad D^2f(q_0)(r,s)=0\quad\text{for every }s\in T_{q_0}.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: at q0=(p,−e)q_0=(p,-e), the local expression of ff in coordinates (u,v,a,b)(u,v,a,b) is vava plus terms of order at least three, its Hessian has eigenvalues 1,−1,0,01,-1,0,0 and rank two, and the complete critical-point calculation shows that this degenerate critical point is isolated.

What Is Checked

The statements (8), (11), (9) and (10) concern the polynomial (2) with the ambient differential (4) and the tangent constructions (5) and (6) at q0q_0.