OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Three critical points on the fixed submanifold

Proposition 4.1: The multiplier and tangent criteria agree, with an intrinsic critical count and explicit critical values

Three critical points on two spheres.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The sphere-product calculation concerns the restriction of a polynomial on paired Euclidean three-spaces. Let EE be Euclidean three-space, with linear coordinate isomorphism c:E→ℝ3c:E\to\mathbb R^3, and write a coordinate vector as x=(x0,x1,x2)x=(x_0,x_1,x_2). The ambient space P=ℝ3×ℝ3P=\mathbb R^3\times\mathbb R^3 consists of pairs q=(x,y)q=(x,y).✦ The Euclidean squared norm of a coordinate vector is given by (1): ‖x‖2=x02+x12+x22.\lVert x\rVert^2=x_0^2+x_1^2+x_2^2.(1)✦

Fix the north pole p=(0,0,1)p=(0,0,1) and the equatorial point e=(1,0,0)e=(1,0,0) in ℝ3\mathbb R^3. The ambient polynomial f:P→ℝf:P\to\mathbb R is the function defined by (2): f(x,y)=e⋅x+(x−p)⋅y.f(x,y)=e\cdot x+(x-p)\cdot y.(2)✦

The unit sphere S2⊂ES^2\subset E and the coordinate sphere product Σ⊂P\Sigma\subset P are the sets in (3): S2={a∈E:‖a‖=1},Σ={(x,y)∈P:‖x‖2=1,‖y‖2=1}.S^2=\{a\in E:\lVert a\rVert=1\}, \qquad \Sigma=\{(x,y)\in P:\lVert x\rVert^2=1,\ \lVert y\rVert^2=1\}.(3) The sphere coordinate embedding ι:S2→ℝ3\iota:S^2\to\mathbb R^3 is the restriction of cc, and the sphere product embedding I:S2×S2→PI:S^2\times S^2\to P applies ι\iota to each component, as in (4): ι(a)=c(a),I(a,b)=(ι(a),ι(b)).\iota(a)=c(a),\qquad I(a,b)=(\iota(a),\iota(b)).(4) The restricted function F:S2×S2→ℝF:S^2\times S^2\to\mathbb R is defined by (5): F=f∘I.F=f\circ I.(5)✦

Criticality on the Sphere Product

A multiplier critical point of ff on Σ\Sigma is a point q=(x,y)∈Σq=(x,y)\in\Sigma for which real multipliers λ,μ\lambda,\mu satisfy the equations in (6); denote this condition by M(q)M(q).✦ M(x,y)⇔(x,y)∈Σ and ∃λ,μ∈ℝ:e+y=λx,x−p=μy.M(x,y)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (x,y)\in\Sigma\ \text{ and } \exists\lambda,\mu\in\mathbb R: \quad e+y=\lambda x,\qquad x-p=\mu y.(6)✦

A tangent critical point of ff on Σ\Sigma is a point q=(x,y)∈Σq=(x,y)\in\Sigma whose ambient differential vanishes on every pair of tangent vectors to the two spheres.✦ Denote this condition by T(q)T(q), as in (7): T(x,y)⇔(x,y)∈Σ and df(x,y)(u,v)=0whenever u,v∈ℝ3,x⋅u=0,y⋅v=0.T(x,y)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (x,y)\in\Sigma\ \text{ and } df_{(x,y)}(u,v)=0 \quad\text{whenever }u,v\in\mathbb R^3, \quad x\cdot u=0,\quad y\cdot v=0.(7)✦ The intrinsic critical set Crit⁡(F)\operatorname{Crit}(F) of FF is the subset of S2×S2S^2\times S^2 consisting of all points where the manifold differential of FF vanishes, including degenerate critical points: Crit⁡(F)={a∈S2×S2:dFa=0}.\operatorname{Crit}(F) =\{a\in S^2\times S^2:dF_a=0\}.(8) For the set in (8), the cardinality #Crit⁡(F)\#\operatorname{Crit}(F) is taken in the extended natural numbers ℕ∪{∞}\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\}.

The distinguished pairs q0,q+,q−∈Pq_0,q_+,q_-\in P are defined by (9): q0=(p,−e),q+=((32,0,−12),(12,0,−32)),q−=((−32,0,−12),(12,0,32)).\begin{aligned} q_0&=(p,-e),\\ q_+&=\left(\left(\frac{\sqrt3}{2},0,-\frac12\right), \left(\frac12,0,-\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\right)\right),\\ q_-&=\left(\left(-\frac{\sqrt3}{2},0,-\frac12\right), \left(\frac12,0,\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\right)\right). \end{aligned}(9)

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the polynomial ff and its restriction FF defined above, and for every q∈Pq\in P, the following assertions hold: f∈C∞(P,ℝ).f\in C^\infty(P,\mathbb R).(10)✦ M(q)⇔q∈{q0,q+,q−}.M(q)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad q\in\{q_0,q_+,q_-\}.(11)✦ T(q)⇔M(q).T(q)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad M(q).(12)✦ T(q)⇔q∈{q0,q+,q−}.T(q)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad q\in\{q_0,q_+,q_-\}.(13)✦ F∈C∞(S2×S2,ℝ).F\in C^\infty(S^2\times S^2,\mathbb R).(14)✦ #Crit⁡(F)=3.\#\operatorname{Crit}(F)=3.(15)✦ f(q0)=0.f(q_0)=0.(16)✦ f(q+)=332.f(q_+)=\frac{3\sqrt3}{2}.(17)✦ f(q−)=−332.f(q_-)=-\frac{3\sqrt3}{2}.(18)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for p=(0,0,1)p=(0,0,1) and e=(1,0,0)e=(1,0,0), the smooth function F:S2×S2→ℝF:S^2\times S^2\to\mathbb R given by F(x,y)=e⋅x+(x−p)⋅yF(x,y)=e\cdot x+(x-p)\cdot y has exactly three critical points.

What Is Checked

The regularity assertions (10) and (14), the criticality assertions (11), (12) and (13), the count (15), and the evaluations (16), (17) and (18) are stated over the coordinate polynomial (2), the sphere constraints (3), the embeddings (4), and the standard smooth product S2×S2S^2\times S^2.