OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Perturbing a finite-order Hamiltonian map

§2 (proof of Theorem 1.1): A Hamiltonian path with algebraic restrictions on its fixed points

Perturbing the quadric involution by midpoint steps.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The construction perturbs the quadric involution by composing a rotation with an implicit midpoint map. The fixed points of the resulting Hamiltonian map are related to constrained critical points on a product of two spheres.

Let V=ℂ5V=\mathbb C^5, with coordinates indexed from 00 to 44.✦ The projective quadric Q3⊂ℂℙ4Q^3\subset\mathbb {CP}^4 and its unit representatives U⊂VU\subset V are defined by (1); the projection is z↦[z]z\mapsto[z]. Q3={[z]:∑j=04zj2=0},U={z:∥z∥2:=∑j=04|zj|2=1,∑j=04zj2=0}.Q^3=\left\{[z]:\sum_{j=0}^4z_j^2=0\right\},\qquad U=\left\{z:\|z\|^2:=\sum_{j=0}^4|z_j|^2=1, \ \sum_{j=0}^4z_j^2=0\right\}.(1) A horizontal tangent vector v∈Vv\in V at z∈Uz\in U satisfies the two equations in (2); the symplectic normalization for horizontal tangent vectors v,w∈Vv,w\in V at zz is given by (2). ∑jzj¯vj=0,∑jzjvj=0,ω(v,w)=2Im⁡∑jvj¯wj.\sum_j\overline{z_j}v_j=0,\qquad \sum_jz_jv_j=0,\qquad \omega(v,w)=2\operatorname{Im}\sum_j\overline{v_j}w_j.(2) For the Lipschitz estimate, use the norm ∥z∥∞=max⁡j|zj|\|z\|_\infty=\max_j|z_j|. Choose a unit representative u(q)∈Uu(q)\in U of every q∈Q3q\in Q^3. A map F:V→VF:V\to V preserving UU induces the map q↦[F(u(q))]q\mapsto[F(u(q))]; if FF is phase-equivariant on UU, this sends [z][z] to [F(z)][F(z)], and a pair of mutually inverse such phase-equivariant maps induces an automorphism. The form ω\omega on Q3Q^3 is the Fubini-Study form.

The oriented plane coordinates mab:V→ℝm_{ab}:V\to\mathbb R and the self-dual and anti-self-dual coordinate maps x,y:V→ℝ3x,y:V\to\mathbb R^3 are defined in (3). The paired coordinate map V→ℝ3×ℝ3V\to\mathbb R^3\times\mathbb R^3 is the map z↦(x(z),y(z))z\mapsto(x(z),y(z)).✦ mab(z)=2Im⁡(za¯zb),x(z)=(m12+m34,m13−m24,m14+m23)(z),y(z)=(m12−m34,m13+m24,m14−m23)(z).\begin{aligned} m_{ab}(z)&=2\operatorname{Im}(\overline{z_a}z_b),\\ x(z)&=(m_{12}+m_{34},\ m_{13}-m_{24},\ m_{14}+m_{23})(z),\\ y(z)&=(m_{12}-m_{34},\ m_{13}+m_{24},\ m_{14}-m_{23})(z). \end{aligned}(3) Let S2⊂ℝ3S^2\subset\mathbb R^3 be the unit sphere. For p=(0,0,1)p=(0,0,1) and e=(1,0,0)e=(1,0,0), let f:S2×S2→ℝf:S^2\times S^2\to\mathbb R be the function in (4), and let 𝒞f⊂ℝ3×ℝ3\mathcal C_f\subset\mathbb R^3\times\mathbb R^3 be its constrained critical set, defined by the multiplier equations there. The Euclidean squared norm is |x|2=x02+x12+x22|x|^2=x_0^2+x_1^2+x_2^2.✦ S2×S2={(x,y):|x|2=|y|2=1},f(x,y)=e⋅x+(x−p)⋅y,𝒞f={(x,y)∈S2×S2:e+y=λx,x−p=μy for some λ,μ∈ℝ}.\begin{aligned} S^2\times S^2&=\{(x,y):|x|^2=|y|^2=1\},\\ f(x,y)&=e\cdot x+(x-p)\cdot y,\\ \mathcal C_f&=\{(x,y)\in S^2\times S^2: e+y=\lambda x,\ x-p=\mu y \text{ for some }\lambda,\mu\in\mathbb R\}. \end{aligned}(4)

Write eae_a for the coordinate vectors of VV. The coordinate rotation generators Jab:V→VJ_{ab}:V\to V and their self-dual and anti-self-dual combinations Li,RiL_i,R_i are the real linear operators in (5). Jabz=zaeb−zbea,(L0,L1,L2)=(J12+J34,J13−J24,J14+J23),(R0,R1,R2)=(J12−J34,J13+J24,J14−J23).\begin{aligned} J_{ab}z&=z_a e_b-z_b e_a,\\ (L_0,L_1,L_2)&=(J_{12}+J_{34},\ J_{13}-J_{24},\ J_{14}+J_{23}),\\ (R_0,R_1,R_2)&=(J_{12}-J_{34},\ J_{13}+J_{24},\ J_{14}-J_{23}). \end{aligned}(5) The self-dual Casimir c:V→ℝc:V\to\mathbb R, the sphere pairing d:V→ℝd:V\to\mathbb R, the mixed field W:V→VW:V\to V and the self-dual radial field D:V→VD:V\to V are given by (6). c(z)=|x(z)|2,d(z)=x(z)⋅y(z),W(z)=∑i=02(yi(z)Liz+xi(z)Riz),D(z)=∑i=02xi(z)Liz.\begin{aligned} c(z)&=|x(z)|^2,& d(z)&=x(z)\cdot y(z),\\ W(z)&=\sum_{i=0}^2\bigl(y_i(z)L_i z+x_i(z)R_i z\bigr),& D(z)&=\sum_{i=0}^2x_i(z)L_i z. \end{aligned}(6) Choose a smooth function β:ℝ→ℝ\beta:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R satisfying (7).✦ Let χ:ℝ→ℝ\chi:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R be the smooth bump centered at 00 with inner radius 44 and outer radius 88.✦ β(s)=s−1/2(1/32≤s≤32).\beta(s)=s^{-1/2}\qquad (1/32\le s\le32).(7) The regularized inverse square root β:ℝ→ℝ\beta:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R is a smooth extension of the reciprocal square root from [1/32,32][1/32,32] to ℝ\mathbb R.

For t∈ℝt\in\mathbb R, the simultaneous rotation ℛt:V→V\mathcal R_t:V\to V rotates the coordinate planes (1,2)(1,2) and (3,4)(3,4) through angle πt\pi t.✦ The Hamiltonian HrotH_{\mathrm{rot}} of the simultaneous rotation ℛt\mathcal R_t is specified in (8); the endpoint ℛ1\mathcal R_1 induces the quadric involution A([z])=[ℛ1z]A([z])=[\mathcal R_1z]. $$\begin{aligned} \mathcal R_tz={}&\bigl(z_0, \cos(\pi t)z_1-\sin(\pi t)z_2, \sin(\pi t)z_1+\cos(\pi t)z_2,\\ &\hspace{31mm}\cos(\pi t)z_3-\sin(\pi t)z_4, \sin(\pi t)z_3+\cos(\pi t)z_4\bigr),\\ H_{\mathrm{rot}}(z)={}&\pi\bigl(m_{12}(z)+m_{34}(z)\bigr). \end{aligned}$$(8)

Let EE be a real Banach space, Z:E→EZ:E\to E a smooth field with Lipschitz constant CZ≥0C_Z\ge0, and η:ℝ→ℝ\eta:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R a smooth function satisfying |η(t)|CZ<1|\eta(t)|C_Z<1 for every tt. For t∈ℝt\in\mathbb R and w∈Ew\in E, the nonlinear resolvent rηZ(t,w)∈Er^Z_\eta(t,w)\in E is the unique solution of the first equation in (9).✦ The implicit midpoint step SηZ:ℝ×E→ES^Z_\eta:\mathbb R\times E\to E is the map defined in (9); for a smooth potential P:E→ℝP:E\to\mathbb R, its Hamiltonian ℋηZ,P:ℝ×E→ℝ\mathcal H^{Z,P}_\eta:\mathbb R\times E\to\mathbb R is the real-valued map defined there. rηZ(t,w)=w+η(t)Z(rηZ(t,w)),SηZ(t,w)=2rηZ(t,w)−w,ℋηZ,P(t,w)=2η′(t)P(r−ηZ(t,w)).\begin{aligned} r^Z_\eta(t,w)&=w+\eta(t)Z\bigl(r^Z_\eta(t,w)\bigr),\\ S^Z_\eta(t,w)&=2r^Z_\eta(t,w)-w,\\ \mathcal H^{Z,P}_\eta(t,w)&=2\eta'(t) P\bigl(r^Z_{-\eta}(t,w)\bigr). \end{aligned}(9) For any nonnegative constant CZC_Z, if a real step parameter η\eta satisfies |η(t)|CZ<1|\eta(t)|C_Z<1 at every real time, then its negative satisfies the same contraction bound.

A lifted Hamiltonian path to an automorphism ϕ\phi of Q3Q^3 is a triple of smooth maps F,G:ℝ×V→VF,G:\mathbb R\times V\to V and H:ℝ×V→ℝH:\mathbb R\times V\to\mathbb R with the following conditions for 0≤t≤10\le t\le1. The maps Ft,GtF_t,G_t preserve UU, commute with unit complex phases on UU, and are mutually inverse there; HtH_t is invariant under those phases. The endpoints and Hamiltonian equation are (10), with z∈Uz\in U and vv horizontal at Ft(z)F_t(z). Write ℋ(ϕ)\mathscr H(\phi) for the collection of lifted Hamiltonian paths to an automorphism ϕ\phi of Q3Q^3. F0(z)=z,[F1(z)]=ϕ([z]),ω(∂tFt(z),v)=(dHt)Ft(z)(v).F_0(z)=z,\qquad [F_1(z)]=\phi([z]),\qquad \omega\bigl(\partial_tF_t(z),v\bigr)=(dH_t)_{F_t(z)}(v).(10)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Define the potential K:V→ℝK:V\to\mathbb R by (11). K(z)=x0(z)−y2(z)+β(c(z))d(z).K(z)=x_0(z)-y_2(z)+\beta(c(z))d(z).(11)✦ The uncut field Y:V→VY:V\to V and the smooth compactly supported truncated field X:V→VX:V\to V are defined by (12). Y(z)=L0z−R2z+β(c(z))W(z)+2β′(c(z))d(z)D(z),X(z)=χ(∥z∥2)Y(z).\begin{aligned} Y(z)&=L_0z-R_2z+\beta(c(z))W(z) +2\beta'(c(z))d(z)D(z),\\ X(z)&=\chi(\|z\|^2)Y(z). \end{aligned}(12) The global Lipschitz estimate is (13). ∃C≥0∀z,w∈V,∥X(z)−X(w)∥∞≤C∥z−w∥∞.\exists C\ge0\quad \forall z,w\in V,\qquad \|X(z)-X(w)\|_\infty\le C\|z-w\|_\infty.(13)✦

For the midpoint construction (9), let σ\sigma be a continuous skew bilinear form on EE. Fix (t,w)(t,w), and suppose σ(Z(u),⋅)=dPu\sigma(Z(u),\cdot)=dP_u for all uu in a neighborhood of rηZ(t,w)r^Z_\eta(t,w). Then (14) holds for every v∈Ev\in E. σ(∂tSηZ(t,w),v)=(dℋηZ,P(t,⋅))SηZ(t,w)(v).\sigma\bigl(\partial_tS^Z_\eta(t,w),v\bigr) =\bigl(d\mathcal H^{Z,P}_\eta(t,\cdot)\bigr)_{S^Z_\eta(t,w)}(v).(14)✦

Fix a constant CC supplied by (13).✦ Define the step scale ε∈ℝ\varepsilon\in\mathbb R by (15) and the parameter τ:ℝ→ℝ\tau:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R by (16). ε=1100(C+1).\varepsilon=\frac{1}{100(C+1)}.(15)✦ τ(t)=εsin⁡(πt/2).\tau(t)=\varepsilon\sin(\pi t/2).(16)✦ Using (9) with Z=XZ=X, define the forward midpoint map Mt=SτX(t,⋅)M_t=S^X_\tau(t,\cdot)✦ and the backward midpoint map Nt=S−τX(t,⋅)N_t=S^X_{-\tau}(t,\cdot).✦ The forward lift F:ℝ×V→VF:\mathbb R\times V\to V is (17). Ft(z)=ℛt(Mt(z)).F_t(z)=\mathcal R_t\bigl(M_t(z)\bigr).(17)✦ The inverse lift G:ℝ×V→VG:\mathbb R\times V\to V, perturbation Hamiltonian h:ℝ×V→ℝh:\mathbb R\times V\to\mathbb R and full Hamiltonian HH are defined by (18). Gt(w)=Nt(ℛ−tw),h(t,w)=ℋτX,K(t,w),H(t,w)=Hrot(w)+h(t,ℛ−tw).\begin{aligned} G_t(w)&=N_t(\mathcal R_{-t}w),\\ h(t,w)&=\mathcal H^{X,K}_\tau(t,w),\\ H(t,w)&=H_{\mathrm{rot}}(w)+h(t,\mathcal R_{-t}w). \end{aligned}(18) Let ϕ:Q3→Q3\phi:Q^3\to Q^3 be the automorphism induced by F1F_1, with inverse induced by G1G_1.✦ These lifts and Hamiltonian give the path in (19). (F,G,H)∈ℋ(ϕ).(F,G,H)\in\mathscr H(\phi).(19)✦

Let z∈Uz\in U have projective class fixed by ϕ\phi. Its zeroth coordinate satisfies (20), and its paired sphere coordinates satisfy (21). z0=0.z_0=0.(20)✦ (x(z),y(z))∈𝒞f.(x(z),y(z))\in\mathcal C_f.(21)✦ Let z∈Uz\in U satisfy z0=0z_0=0 and Y(z)=bizY(z)=b\,iz for a real number bb with |b|≤3|b|\le3. Then (22) holds. ϕ([z])=[z].\phi([z])=[z].(22)✦

In the paper, the result reads: ϕ=A∘Bε\phi=A\circ B_\varepsilon, where AA is the quadric involution and BtB_t is the Hamiltonian flow of an AA-invariant extension of the chosen function on its fixed surface, and Proposition 2.1 and Lemma 2.2 exclude every other fixed point.

What Is Checked

The midpoint equation is stated over a real Banach space with a continuous skew bilinear form; the quadric construction uses the unit isotropic vectors in ℂ5\mathbb C^5 and their projective classes. Every point of Q3Q^3 has a unit representative.✦

The chosen parameter and its negation satisfy the bounds in (23) for every real tt. |τ(t)|C<1,|−τ(t)|C<1.|\tau(t)|C<1,\qquad |-\tau(t)|C<1.(23) The lifts F,GF,G preserve UU for every real tt and are smooth on ℝ×V\mathbb R\times V, as is HH.✦ For t∈ℝt\in\mathbb R, z∈Uz\in U and every v∈Vv\in V, their Hamiltonian equation is (24). ω(∂tFt(z),v)=(dHt)Ft(z)(v).\omega\bigl(\partial_tF_t(z),v\bigr)=(dH_t)_{F_t(z)}(v).(24)✦