OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction

Theorem 1.1: A Hamiltonian map of the projective quadric Q3Q^3 with a degenerate fixed point

Three fixed points below the critical number.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The fixed points of a Hamiltonian map of the projective quadric Q3Q^3 can be compared with the critical points of smooth real functions on that quadric. The ambient space is V=ℂ5V=\mathbb C^5, with coordinates indexed from 00 to 44.✦ The quadratic form 𝔮\mathfrak q, the squared Hermitian norm nn, and the unit isotropic cone SS give the projective quadric and its projectivization map π\pi in (1): 𝔮(z)=∑j=04zj2,n(z)=∥z∥2=∑j=04|zj|2,S={z∈V:n(z)=1,𝔮(z)=0},Q3={[z]∈ℂℙ4:𝔮(z)=0},π:S→Q3,π(z)=[z].\begin{gathered} \mathfrak q(z)=\sum_{j=0}^4 z_j^2,\qquad n(z)=\|z\|^2=\sum_{j=0}^4|z_j|^2,\qquad S=\{z\in V:n(z)=1,\ \mathfrak q(z)=0\},\\ Q^3=\{[z]\in\mathbb{CP}^4:\mathfrak q(z)=0\},\qquad \pi:S\longrightarrow Q^3,\quad \pi(z)=[z]. \end{gathered}(1)

A horizontal tangent vector at z∈Sz\in S is a vector v∈Vv\in V satisfying both orthogonality conditions in (2); write ℋz\mathcal H_z for their space.✦ The Fubini-Study form has the normalization given there on horizontal vectors: ℋz={v∈V:∑j=04zj¯vj=0,∑j=04zjvj=0},ω(v,w)=2Im⁡∑j=04vj¯wj.\mathcal H_z=\left\{v\in V: \sum_{j=0}^4\overline{z_j}v_j=0,\quad \sum_{j=0}^4z_jv_j=0\right\},\qquad \omega(v,w)=2\operatorname{Im}\sum_{j=0}^4\overline{v_j}w_j.(2)

For a real function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R, a local smooth lift at z∈Sz\in S is a function g:V→ℝg:V\to\mathbb R smooth on an open neighbourhood UU of zz, such that g(y)=h(π(y))g(y)=h(\pi(y)) for y∈U∩Sy\in U\cap S.✦ A smooth function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R is a real function admitting a local smooth lift at every z∈Sz\in S; write C∞(Q3,ℝ)C^\infty(Q^3,\mathbb R) for the space of these functions. A critical point q∈Q3q\in Q^3 of a real function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R is a point for which Dgz(v)=0Dg_z(v)=0 for every unit representative zz of qq, every local smooth lift gg of hh at zz, and every v∈ℋzv\in\mathcal H_z.✦ The critical locus Crit⁡(h)\operatorname{Crit}(h) of a smooth real function h:Q3→ℝh:Q^3\to\mathbb R is the set of its critical points, including degenerate ones.✦

The fixed set Fix⁡(ψ)\operatorname{Fix}(\psi) of a bijection ψ:Q3→Q3\psi:Q^3\to Q^3 is the subset of Q3Q^3 given by Fix⁡(ψ)={q∈Q3:ψ(q)=q}\operatorname{Fix}(\psi)=\{q\in Q^3:\psi(q)=q\}.✦ All set counts #A\#A take values in the extended natural numbers ℕ∞\mathbb N_\infty. The critical number Crit⁡(Q3)\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3) of Q3Q^3 is the infimum in (3): Crit⁡(Q3)=infh∈C∞(Q3,ℝ)#Crit⁡(h).\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3) =\inf_{h\in C^\infty(Q^3,\mathbb R)}\#\operatorname{Crit}(h).(3)✦

Hamiltonian Maps and Degeneracy

A lifted Hamiltonian isotopy from the identity to a bijection ψ\psi consists of smooth maps F,B:ℝ×V→VF,B:\mathbb R\times V\to V and a smooth function H:ℝ×V→ℝH:\mathbb R\times V\to\mathbb R. For 0≤t≤10\leq t\leq1, the maps FtF_t and BtB_t preserve SS, commute there with multiplication by unit complex scalars, and are mutually inverse on SS; HtH_t is invariant under the same circle action on SS. The endpoint conditions and Hamiltonian equation are (4), for z∈Sz\in S and v∈ℋFt(z)v\in\mathcal H_{F_t(z)}: F0(z)=z,π(F1(z))=ψ(π(z)),ω(∂tFt(z),v)=D(Ht)Ft(z)(v).F_0(z)=z,\qquad \pi(F_1(z))=\psi(\pi(z)),\qquad \omega\bigl(\partial_tF_t(z),v\bigr)=D(H_t)_{F_t(z)}(v).(4) A Hamiltonian map ψ:Q3→Q3\psi:Q^3\to Q^3 is a bijection admitting a lifted Hamiltonian isotopy from the identity to ψ\psi; write Ham⁡(Q3,ω)\operatorname{Ham}(Q^3,\omega) for these maps, with the convention ιXω=dH\iota_X\omega=dH in (4).

A degenerate fixed point q=π(z)q=\pi(z) of a bijection ψ:Q3→Q3\psi:Q^3\to Q^3, with z∈Sz\in S, is a fixed point admitting a smooth local lift G:V→VG:V\to V on an open neighbourhood UU of zz, with G(z)=zG(z)=z, such that G(U∩S)⊆SG(U\cap S)\subseteq S and π(G(y))=ψ(π(y))\pi(G(y))=\psi(\pi(y)) for y∈U∩Sy\in U\cap S, and a nonzero horizontal vector satisfying (5).✦ The set DegFix⁡(ψ)\operatorname{DegFix}(\psi) of a bijection ψ:Q3→Q3\psi:Q^3\to Q^3 consists of its degenerate fixed points: v∈ℋz\{0},DGz(v)−v∈ℝiz.v\in\mathcal H_z\setminus\{0\},\qquad DG_z(v)-v\in\mathbb R\,iz.(5)

The Constructed Map

The oriented plane coordinates mabm_{ab} and the self-dual and anti-self-dual sphere factor maps x,y:V→ℝ3x,y:V\to\mathbb R^3 are defined by (6): mab(z)=2Im⁡(za¯zb),x=(m12+m34,m13−m24,m14+m23),y=(m12−m34,m13+m24,m14−m23).\begin{gathered} m_{ab}(z)=2\operatorname{Im}(\overline{z_a}z_b),\\ x=(m_{12}+m_{34},\ m_{13}-m_{24},\ m_{14}+m_{23}),\qquad y=(m_{12}-m_{34},\ m_{13}+m_{24},\ m_{14}-m_{23}). \end{gathered}(6) The coordinates of the sphere factors are indexed by 0,1,20,1,2.

Let 𝒆a\mathbf e_a denote the coordinate vectors of VV. The coordinate plane rotation generators TabT_{ab} and the self-dual and anti-self-dual infinitesimal rotations Li,RiL_i,R_i, indexed by i=0,1,2i=0,1,2, are the real linear maps in (7): Tabz=za𝒆b−zb𝒆a,(L0,L1,L2)=(T12+T34,T13−T24,T14+T23),(R0,R1,R2)=(T12−T34,T13+T24,T14−T23).\begin{gathered} T_{ab}z=z_a\mathbf e_b-z_b\mathbf e_a,\\ (L_0,L_1,L_2)=(T_{12}+T_{34},\ T_{13}-T_{24},\ T_{14}+T_{23}),\\ (R_0,R_1,R_2)=(T_{12}-T_{34},\ T_{13}+T_{24},\ T_{14}-T_{23}). \end{gathered}(7)

The self-dual Casimir ss, the sphere factor pairing kk, the self-dual radial field VsV_s, and the mixed sphere field VmV_m are given by (8): s(z)=∑i=02xi(z)2,k(z)=∑i=02xi(z)yi(z),Vs(z)=∑i=02xi(z)Liz,Vm(z)=∑i=02(yi(z)Liz+xi(z)Riz).\begin{gathered} s(z)=\sum_{i=0}^2x_i(z)^2,\qquad k(z)=\sum_{i=0}^2x_i(z)y_i(z),\\ V_s(z)=\sum_{i=0}^2x_i(z)L_i z,\qquad V_m(z)=\sum_{i=0}^2\bigl(y_i(z)L_i z+x_i(z)R_i z\bigr). \end{gathered}(8)

Choose a smooth regularized inverse square root b:ℝ→ℝb:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R satisfying (9), and let χ\chi be the smooth bump centered at 00 with inner radius 44 and outer radius 88: b(r)=1r(132≤r≤32).b(r)=\frac1{\sqrt r}\qquad\left(\frac1{32}\leq r\leq32\right).(9) The uncut Hamiltonian vector field X0X_0 and its truncation XX are defined by (10): X0(z)=L0z−R2z+b(s(z))Vm(z)+2b′(s(z))k(z)Vs(z),X(z)=χ(n(z))X0(z).\begin{gathered} X_0(z)=L_0z-R_2z+b(s(z))V_m(z) +2b'(s(z))k(z)V_s(z),\\ X(z)=\chi(n(z))X_0(z). \end{gathered}(10)

For a global Lipschitz constant C≥0C\geq0 of XX, the step scale ε\varepsilon and the time-dependent parameter τ\tau are defined by (11): ε=1100(C+1),τ(t)=εsin⁡(πt2).\varepsilon=\frac1{100(C+1)},\qquad \tau(t)=\varepsilon\sin\left(\frac{\pi t}{2}\right).(11) For σ∈{+1,−1}\sigma\in\{+1,-1\}, the nonlinear resolvent utσ(z)u_t^\sigma(z) is the unique solution of the first equation in (12).✦ The forward and backward implicit midpoint maps St+S_t^+ and St−S_t^- are defined by its second equation: utσ(z)=z+στ(t)X(utσ(z)),Stσ(z)=2utσ(z)−z.u_t^\sigma(z)=z+\sigma\tau(t)X(u_t^\sigma(z)),\qquad S_t^\sigma(z)=2u_t^\sigma(z)-z.(12)

The simultaneous planar rotation ℛ(c,d)\mathcal R(c,d) and rotation isotopy AtA_t are the maps in (13), where the block decomposition uses the coordinates z0z_0, (z1,z2)(z_1,z_2) and (z3,z4)(z_3,z_4): ℛ(c,d)=1⊕(c−ddc)⊕(c−ddc),At=ℛ(cos⁡(πt),sin⁡(πt)).\mathcal R(c,d)=1\oplus \begin{pmatrix}c&-d\\d&c\end{pmatrix}\oplus \begin{pmatrix}c&-d\\d&c\end{pmatrix},\qquad A_t=\mathcal R(\cos(\pi t),\sin(\pi t)).(13) The lifted isotopy FtF_t, its inverse BtB_t, and the constructed quotient map φ\varphi are given by (14): Ft=At∘St+,Bt=St−∘A−t,φ([z])=[F1(z)].F_t=A_t\circ S_t^+,\qquad B_t=S_t^-\circ A_{-t},\qquad \varphi([z])=[F_1(z)].(14)

The Claim

Theorem 1. On the quadric (Q3,ω)(Q^3,\omega), there is a Hamiltonian map ψ\psi such that #Fix⁡(ψ)=3<4≤Crit⁡(Q3),DegFix⁡(ψ)≠⌀.\#\operatorname{Fix}(\psi)=3<4\leq\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3),\qquad \operatorname{DegFix}(\psi)\ne\varnothing.(15)✦ The constructed map φ\varphi of (14) satisfies φ∈Ham⁡(Q3,ω),\varphi\in\operatorname{Ham}(Q^3,\omega),(16)✦ #Fix⁡(φ)=3,\#\operatorname{Fix}(\varphi)=3,(17)✦ 4≤Crit⁡(Q3),4\leq\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3),(18)✦ DegFix⁡(φ)≠⌀.\operatorname{DegFix}(\varphi)\ne\varnothing.(19)✦

In the paper, the result reads: there is a smooth Hamiltonian diffeomorphism ϕ\phi of the closed connected symplectic six-manifold Q3Q^3 such that #Fix⁡(ϕ)=3<4=Crit⁡(Q3)=cuplength⁡(Q3;ℚ)\#\operatorname{Fix}(\phi)=3<4=\operatorname{Crit}(Q^3) =\operatorname{cuplength}(Q^3;\mathbb Q), with cup-length counted including the unit, and at least one fixed point of ϕ\phi is degenerate.

What Is Checked

The assertions (15), (16), (17), (18) and (19) are stated over Q3Q^3, with smooth functions and Hamiltonian maps specified by their lifts on VV. Every point of Q3Q^3 has a unit representative.✦ For a chosen unit representative z(q)z(q), a map T:V→VT:V\to V preserving SS induces q↦π(T(z(q)))q\mapsto\pi(T(z(q))); mutually inverse circle-equivariant maps preserving SS induce a quotient automorphism.

A smooth function bb satisfying (9) exists.✦ The truncated field XX of (10) admits a global Lipschitz constant✦, and the selected constant CC and the parameters of (11) satisfy (20), for every z,w∈Vz,w\in V and t∈ℝt\in\mathbb R: ∥X(z)−X(w)∥≤C∥z−w∥,|τ(t)|C<1,|−τ(t)|C<1.\|X(z)-X(w)\|\leq C\|z-w\|,\qquad |\tau(t)|C<1,\qquad |-\tau(t)|C<1.(20)