The Setting
Take a three-vertex triangle and a matrix index set, together with a variational Hessian quadratic cost associated with matrix energy. The question at any vertex is how the sum of the two neighbor Hessian costs compares with the vertex-star Hessian cost (the star cost) at that vertex, first for arbitrary matrix families and then for Gaussian-weighted local Gram matrices, both pointwise in the centers and integrated over planes of constant center sum.
Triangle Block Matrices
The triangle vertex set is the canonical three-element set under cyclic addition, with cyclic successor and predecessor for each vertex .✦ The triangle block space on an index set is the Cartesian product of and .✦
The block matrix assembly of a matrix whose entries are complex square matrices on an index set is the complex square matrix on obtained by flattening into a single matrix.✦ The block diagonal matrix of a family of complex square matrices on an index set is the complex square matrix on whose diagonal block is for each and whose off-diagonal blocks vanish.✦
The triangle block matrix of a family of complex square matrices on an index set is the matrix with complex blocks on defined by (1): (1)✦ The triangle matrix of a family of complex square matrices on is the block matrix assembly on .✦
The vertex block projection at a vertex on an index set is the diagonal complex square matrix on whose diagonal entry at is if and otherwise.✦ The vertex-star row of a family of complex square matrices on an index set at a vertex is the complex square matrix on , which isolates the -th block row of .✦
The center Gram matrix of a family of complex square matrices on an index set at a vertex is the complex square matrix on defined by (2): (2)✦ The vertex-star Gram matrix of a family of complex square matrices on at a vertex is the complex square matrix on .✦ The vertex-star insertion matrix of families and of complex square matrices on an index set at a vertex is the complex square matrix on .✦
The Hessian Quadratic Cost
The real trace of a complex square matrix on an index set is the real part of the trace of .✦ The real Hilbert-Schmidt inner product of two complex square matrices and on an index set is the real trace .✦
The Sylvester operator of a complex square matrix on an index set is the operator on complex square matrices on defined by .✦ The Sylvester penalty of complex square matrices and on an index set is the real number .✦
The Sylvester variational functional of complex square matrices , , and on an index set is the real number .✦ The root Hessian cost of complex square matrices and on an index set is the real number defined by (3): (3)✦ where the supremum ranges over all complex square matrices on . The Hessian cost of complex square matrices and on an index set is the root Hessian cost .✦
Gaussian Heat Weights and Plane Integrals
The Gaussian density of variance at is the real number given by (4): (4)✦ The Gaussian score of a point , a center , and a variance is the real number .✦ The heat weight of a step size , a point , a center , and a variance is the real number .✦ The vertex heat weights of a step size , node coordinates , centers , and variances on an index set form the family of real node weights on defined by (5): (5)✦
The vertex root matrix of a family of real node weights on an index set is the diagonal complex square matrix on whose diagonal entry at is .✦ The vertex-star base row of a matrix family on , real node weights on , and a vertex is the complex square matrix on .✦ Given a matrix family and real node weights on , the vertex-star base column at a vertex is the complex square matrix on .✦ The fixed base matrix of a matrix family on , real node weights on , and vertices is the complex square matrix on defined by (6): (6)✦
The weighted Gram matrix of a complex square matrix on an index set and a real weight function is the complex square matrix on , where is the diagonal matrix on with diagonal entry at .✦ The grouped heat weight of a step size , coordinates on an index set , a group assignment into an index set , centers , and variances is the real-valued function on sending each to ✦ The grouped first-variation weight of a step size , coordinates on an index set , a group assignment into an index set , centers , variances , and a group is the real-valued function on given by (7): (7)✦
The first-coordinate projection on is the projection map from to sending each pair to , and the lifted coordinate map of node coordinates is the function defined by . The local Gram matrix of a matrix family on , a step size , node coordinates , centers , variances , and vertices is the complex square matrix on defined by (8): (8)✦ The local first-variation matrix associated to a matrix family on , a step size , node coordinates , centers , variances , and vertices is the complex square matrix on defined by (9): (9)✦ The heat Hessian cost of a matrix family on , a step size , node coordinates , centers , variances , and vertices is the real number given by (10): (10)✦
The constant-sum center plane at sum level is the hyperplane in . The plane coordinate chart of a vertex , a sum level , and a pair is the triple in defined by (11): (11)✦ The plane integral of a real-valued function at a sum level is the Lebesgue integral over given by (12): (12)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be an index set, let and be families of complex square matrices on , and let be a vertex. Then the matrix neighbor comparison (13) holds: (13)✦ For any family of complex square matrices on , any step size , any node coordinates , any centers , any variances satisfying for every , and any vertex , the heat-cost neighbor comparison (14) holds: (14)✦ Under the same hypotheses on , , , , and , and for any sum level , the plane-cost neighbor comparison (15) holds: (15)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for every choice of the weighted matrices and every vertex , , where and denote and . Whereas the paper states the two-neighbor bound for the weighted matrices, (13) allows arbitrary matrix families and and sums over all , while (14) and (15) restrict to the neighbors for Gaussian heat weights and constant-sum plane integrals.
What Is Checked
The claims are stated over an index set , a vertex , arbitrary families and of complex square matrices on indexed by together with the triangle matrix blocks , center Gram matrix , vertex-star Gram matrix , vertex-star insertion matrix , and variational Hessian cost in (13), and over a matrix family , positive step size , positive variances , arbitrary node coordinates , centers or sum level , the heat Hessian cost , and the constant-sum plane integral in (14) and (15).