OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. A matrix energy and its Hessian

Lemma 2.2: For positive semidefinite AA and Hermitian BB with A≤BA \le B, and comparing bQ(K)b_Q(K) with bP(K)b_P(K) under Sylvester solvability at P1/2P^{1/2}

Sylvester solvability monotonicity and Hessian cost bounds under Loewner order.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Take complex square matrices AA, BB, PP, QQ, and KK indexed by a set ι\iota, ordered by the Loewner order, with A≤BA \le B and P≤QP \le Q or P≤cQP \le c Q for a real scalar c>0c > 0. The question is whether A≤BA \le B preserves solvability for the Sylvester operator and how comparing PP with QQ or cQc Q constrains the variationally defined Hessian quadratic cost at QQ in terms of the cost at PP.

The Hessian Quadratic Cost

The real trace Re⁡tr⁡(A)\operatorname{Re}\operatorname{tr}(A) of a complex square matrix AA indexed by ι\iota is the real number given by the real part of its trace.✦

The real Hilbert-Schmidt inner product Re⁡tr⁡(X*Y)\operatorname{Re}\operatorname{tr}(X^* Y) of complex square matrices XX and YY indexed by ι\iota is the real number given by the real trace of X*YX^* Y.✦

Associated with a complex square matrix AA indexed by ι\iota, the Sylvester operator SAS_A is the map on complex square matrices XX indexed by ι\iota defined by SA(X)=AX+XA.S_A(X) = A X + X A.(1)✦

The Sylvester penalty pA(X)p_A(X) of complex square matrices AA and XX indexed by ι\iota is the real number given by the real Hilbert-Schmidt inner product of XX with SA(X)S_A(X), pA(X)=Re⁡tr⁡(X*SA(X)).p_A(X) = \operatorname{Re}\operatorname{tr}\bigl(X^* S_A(X)\bigr).(2)✦

The Sylvester variational functional VA,KV_{A,K} of complex square matrices AA and KK indexed by ι\iota is the map on complex square matrices XX indexed by ι\iota defined by VA,K(X)=2Re⁡tr⁡(K*X)−pA(X).V_{A,K}(X) = 2\operatorname{Re}\operatorname{tr}(K^* X) - p_A(X).(3)✦

For complex square matrices AA and KK indexed by ι\iota, the root variational cost rA(K)r_A(K) is the real number determined over all complex square matrices XX indexed by ι\iota by rA(K)=32supXVA,K(X).r_A(K) = \frac{3}{2} \sup_{X} V_{A,K}(X).(4)✦

The Hessian quadratic cost bP(K)b_P(K) of complex square matrices PP and KK indexed by ι\iota is the real number given by evaluating the root variational cost at the square root P1/2P^{1/2} of PP and at KK, bP(K)=rP1/2(K).b_P(K) = r_{P^{1/2}}(K).(5)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ι\iota be an index set, and let AA, BB, PP, QQ, and KK be complex square matrices indexed by ι\iota.

  1. Suppose AA is positive semidefinite, BB is Hermitian, A≤BA \le B in the Loewner order, and SA(Y)=KS_A(Y) = K for some complex square matrix YY indexed by ι\iota. Then there exists a complex square matrix ZZ indexed by ι\iota such that SB(Z)=K.S_B(Z) = K.(6)✦

  2. If P≤QP \le Q and SP1/2(Y)=KS_{P^{1/2}}(Y) = K for some complex square matrix YY indexed by ι\iota, then bQ(K)≤bP(K).b_Q(K) \le b_P(K).(7)✦

  3. If QQ is positive semidefinite, c>0c > 0 is a real scalar with P≤cQP \le c Q, and SP1/2(Y)=KS_{P^{1/2}}(Y) = K for some complex square matrix YY indexed by ι\iota, then bQ(K)≤cbP(K).b_Q(K) \le \sqrt{c}\, b_P(K).(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for positive semidefinite matrices PP and QQ on the same Hilbert space and a scalar a≥1a \ge 1 satisfying P≤aQP \le a Q, every Hermitian KK supported on PP is supported on QQ, and bP(K)≥a−1/2bQ(K)b_P(K) \ge a^{-1/2} b_Q(K). In the library’s statement, KK need not be Hermitian, Sylvester solvability in (6) replaces the support condition, and (8) allows any c>0c > 0 in place of a≥1a \ge 1 while (7) omits positive semidefiniteness on QQ.

What Is Checked

Claims (6), (7), and (8) are stated over complex square matrices indexed by ι\iota: (6) concerns a positive semidefinite matrix AA, a Hermitian matrix BB with A≤BA \le B in the Loewner order, and solvability of SA(Y)=KS_A(Y) = K, while (7) and (8) concern the Hessian quadratic cost bP(K)b_P(K) (built from the real trace, the real Hilbert-Schmidt inner product, the Sylvester operator, the Sylvester penalty, the Sylvester variational functional, and the root variational cost) under solvability of SP1/2(Y)=KS_{P^{1/2}}(Y) = K, with P≤QP \le Q in (7) and with P≤cQP \le c Q, c>0c > 0, and QQ positive semidefinite in (8).