OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. The projection in the prescribed ultrapower · §6

§6 (proof of Theorem 1.1): diagonal argument and density: A projection of BωB^\omega commuting with BB and halving every limit trace, given approximate ones for each finite set of unitaries of AA

From approximate to exact halving projections in the ultrapower.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a C*^*-algebra and τ=(τi)i∈I\tau=(\tau_i)_{i\in I} a family of tracial states of AA. The uniform tracial completion BB of AA for τ\tau sits in its ultrapower BωB^\omega at a free ultrafilter ω\omega on ℕ\mathbb{N}, which carries the family Λω\Lambda_\omega of limit traces. A projection p∈Bωp\in B^\omega that commutes with BB and halves every limit trace on BB, that is, λ(px)=12λ(x)\lambda(px)=\tfrac12\lambda(x) for x∈Bx\in B and λ∈Λω\lambda\in\Lambda_\omega, is what uniform property Γ\Gamma asks for.

The question is how to obtain one from projections that commute and halve only approximately: on a finite set of unitaries of AA at a time, up to an error ε\varepsilon in the supremum over Λω\Lambda_\omega of the 2-norms of the commutators and of the halving errors. The same projection is sought for a simple infinite-dimensional AA with the family of all its tracial states, from conditions on AA and on BωB^\omega instead.

Completion, Ultrapower and Limit Traces

Let DD be a C*^*-algebra and τ=(τi)i∈I\tau=(\tau_i)_{i\in I} a family of tracial states of DD. The uniform 2-norm of a∈Da\in D for τ\tau is sup⁡i∈I∥a∥2,τi\sup_{i\in I}\|a\|_{2,\tau_i}, the supremum of the trace 2-norms ∥a∥2,τi=τi(a*a)1/2\|a\|_{2,\tau_i}=\tau_i(a^*a)^{1/2}✦, and the uniform halving error of x∈Dx\in D under p∈Dp\in D for τ\tau is sup⁡i∈I|τi(px)−12τi(x)|\sup_{i\in I}|\tau_i(px)-\tfrac12\tau_i(x)|.✦ Write T(D)T(D) for the set of tracial states of DD. The uniform 2-norm and the uniform halving error over T(D)T(D) are supτ∈T(D)∥a∥2,τ,supτ∈T(D)|τ(px)−12τ(x)|.\sup_{\tau\in T(D)}\|a\|_{2,\tau}, \qquad \sup_{\tau\in T(D)}\bigl|\tau(px)-\tfrac12\tau(x)\bigr|.(1) The uniform trace norm of a∈Da\in D for τ\tau is sup⁡i∈I|τi(a)|\sup_{i\in I}|\tau_i(a)|, so the uniform halving error of xx under pp for τ\tau is the uniform trace norm of px−12xpx-\tfrac12x.

Let XX be a set and FF a filter on XX. A bounded family (an)n∈X(a_n)_{n\in X} in DD is null for τ\tau along FF when its uniform 2-norms sup⁡i∥an∥2,τi\sup_i\|a_n\|_{2,\tau_i} tend to 00 along FF, and the null ideal of τ\tau along FF is the closed two-sided ideal of ℓ∞(X,D)\ell^\infty(X,D), the C*^*-algebra of bounded families, formed by the null families.✦ A sequence (an)(a_n) in DD is Cauchy for τ\tau when sup⁡i∥am−an∥2,τi→0\sup_i\|a_m-a_n\|_{2,\tau_i}\to0 as mm and nn tend to infinity.✦

The uniform tracial completion BB of a C*^*-algebra AA for a family τ=(τi)i∈I\tau=(\tau_i)_{i\in I} of its tracial states is the quotient of the Cauchy algebra, the *^*-subalgebra of ℓ∞(ℕ,A)\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N},A) formed by the sequences Cauchy for τ\tau, by the Cauchy null ideal, formed by those null along the cofinite filter: B={(an)∈ℓ∞(ℕ,A):supi∥am−an∥2,τi→0}/{(an):supi∥an∥2,τi→0}.B=\bigl\{(a_n)\in\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N},A):\ \sup_i\|a_m-a_n\|_{2,\tau_i}\to0\bigr\} \big/\bigl\{(a_n):\ \sup_i\|a_n\|_{2,\tau_i}\to0\bigr\}.(2)✦ The completion map is the unital *^*-homomorphism A→BA\to B sending aa to the class of the constant sequence (a,a,…)(a,a,\dots).✦ The completion trace τ‾i\bar\tau_i is the tracial state of BB induced by the Cauchy trace of τi\tau_i, the tracial state of the Cauchy algebra that takes a sequence to the limit of the values of τi\tau_i at its terms: τ‾i([(an)])=limn→∞τi(an).\bar\tau_i\bigl([(a_n)]\bigr)=\lim_{n\to\infty}\tau_i(a_n).(3)✦

The tracial ultrapower DωD^\omega of a C*^*-algebra DD for a family τ=(τi)i∈I\tau=(\tau_i)_{i\in I} of its tracial states, at an ultrafilter ω\omega on ℕ\mathbb{N}, is the quotient of ℓ∞(ℕ,D)\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N},D) by the null ideal of τ\tau along ω\omega: Dω=ℓ∞(ℕ,D)/{(an):limn→ωsupi∥an∥2,τi=0}.D^\omega=\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N},D)\big/ \bigl\{(a_n):\ \lim_{n\to\omega}\sup_i\|a_n\|_{2,\tau_i}=0\bigr\}.(4)✦ The diagonal embedding is the unital *^*-homomorphism D→DωD\to D^\omega sending aa to the class of the constant sequence (a,a,…)(a,a,\dots).✦ For a sequence s:ℕ→Is\colon\mathbb{N}\to I, the limit trace λs\lambda_s is the tracial state of DωD^\omega induced by the ultraproduct trace of ℓ∞(ℕ,D)\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N},D), which takes a bounded sequence to the limit along ω\omega of the values of τs(n)\tau_{s(n)} at its terms: λs([(an)])=limn→ωτs(n)(an),\lambda_s\bigl([(a_n)]\bigr)=\lim_{n\to\omega}\tau_{s(n)}(a_n),(5)✦ and Λω=(λs)s\Lambda_\omega=(\lambda_s)_s is the family of limit traces.

The ultrapower BωB^\omega is the tracial ultrapower of BB for the completion traces (τ‾i)i∈I(\bar\tau_i)_{i\in I}, and an element of AA or of BB stands for its image in BωB^\omega under the completion map and the diagonal embedding.

Simplicity, Real Rank Zero and Positive Diagonals

A C*^*-algebra AA is simple when its only closed two-sided ideals are 00 and AA.✦ A C*^*-algebra DD has real rank zero when for every self-adjoint a∈Da\in D and every ε>0\varepsilon>0 there is a self-adjoint b∈Db\in D with finite spectrum and ∥a−b∥<ε\|a-b\|<\varepsilon.✦

For a finite subset KK of the unitary group U(A)U(A) of AA and μ>0\mu>0, a positive diagonal for KK with tolerance μ\mu is a finite family of weights w1,…,wn≥0w_1,\dots,w_n\ge0 with ∑iwi=1\sum_iw_i=1 and of elements v1,…,vnv_1,\dots,v_n of AA of norm at most 11 whose weighted average ∑iwivivi*\sum_iw_iv_iv_i^* and diagonal commutators satisfy ∥1−∑i=1nwivivi*∥<μ,∥∑i=1nwi(xvi⊗vi*−vi⊗vi*x)∥<μ(x∈K),\Bigl\|1-\sum_{i=1}^nw_iv_iv_i^*\Bigr\|<\mu, \qquad \Bigl\|\sum_{i=1}^nw_i\,(xv_i\otimes v_i^*-v_i\otimes v_i^*x)\Bigr\|<\mu \quad(x\in K),(6)✦ the second norm taken in the tensor product A⊗AA\otimes A.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ω\omega be a free ultrafilter on ℕ\mathbb{N}.

(a) Let AA be a C*^*-algebra with a family τ=(τi)i∈I\tau=(\tau_i)_{i\in I} of tracial states, BB its uniform tracial completion and Λω\Lambda_\omega the limit traces of BωB^\omega. Suppose that for every finite set K⊆U(A)K\subseteq U(A) and every ε>0\varepsilon>0 there is a projection P∈BωP\in B^\omega with supλ∈Λω∥[P,u]∥2,λ<εandsupλ∈Λω|λ(Pu)−12λ(u)|<ε(u∈K).\sup_{\lambda\in\Lambda_\omega}\|[P,u]\|_{2,\lambda}<\varepsilon \quad\text{and}\quad \sup_{\lambda\in\Lambda_\omega}\bigl|\lambda(Pu)-\tfrac12\lambda(u)\bigr|<\varepsilon \qquad(u\in K).(7) Then there is a projection p∈Bωp\in B^\omega with px=xpandλ(px)=12λ(x)(x∈B,λ∈Λω).px=xp\quad\text{and}\quad\lambda(px)=\tfrac12\lambda(x) \qquad(x\in B,\ \lambda\in\Lambda_\omega).(8)✦

(b) Let DD be a C*^*-algebra with a family τ=(τi)i∈I\tau=(\tau_i)_{i\in I} of tracial states, Λω\Lambda_\omega the limit traces of DωD^\omega and (xk)k∈ℕ(x_k)_{k\in\mathbb{N}} a sequence in DD. Suppose that for every n∈ℕn\in\mathbb{N} and every ε>0\varepsilon>0 there is a projection P∈DωP\in D^\omega satisfying (7) for u=x0,…,xnu=x_0,\dots,x_n. Then there is a projection p∈Dωp\in D^\omega with pxk=xkpandλ(pxk)=12λ(xk)(k∈ℕ,λ∈Λω).px_k=x_kp\quad\text{and}\quad\lambda(px_k)=\tfrac12\lambda(x_k) \qquad(k\in\mathbb{N},\ \lambda\in\Lambda_\omega).(9)✦

(c) Let A⊆EA\subseteq E be a unital inclusion of C*^*-algebras, (σs)s∈S(\sigma_s)_{s\in S} a family of tracial states of EE, p∈Ep\in E, and (un)n∈ℕ(u_n)_{n\in\mathbb{N}} a dense sequence in U(A)U(A). If pun=unppu_n=u_np and σs(pun)=12σs(un)\sigma_s(pu_n)=\tfrac12\sigma_s(u_n) for all nn and ss, then pa=apandσs(pa)=12σs(a)(a∈A,s∈S).pa=ap\quad\text{and}\quad\sigma_s(pa)=\tfrac12\sigma_s(a) \qquad(a\in A,\ s\in S).(10)✦

(d) With AA, τ\tau and BB as in (a), for every x∈Bx\in B and every ε>0\varepsilon>0 there is a∈Aa\in A with supi∈I∥x−a∥2,τ‾i<ε.\sup_{i\in I}\|x-a\|_{2,\bar\tau_i}<\varepsilon.(11)✦

(e) Let (σs)s∈S(\sigma_s)_{s\in S} be a family of tracial states of a C*^*-algebra EE such that z=0z=0 is the only element of EE with ∥z∥2,σs=0\|z\|_{2,\sigma_s}=0 for every ss. Let p∈Ep\in E be a projection and x∈Ex\in E, and suppose that for every ε>0\varepsilon>0 there is b∈Eb\in E with sup⁡s∈S∥x−b∥2,σs<ε\sup_{s\in S}\|x-b\|_{2,\sigma_s}<\varepsilon, pb=bppb=bp and σs(pb)=12σs(b)\sigma_s(pb)=\tfrac12\sigma_s(b) for every ss. Then px=xpandσs(px)=12σs(x)(s∈S).px=xp\quad\text{and}\quad\sigma_s(px)=\tfrac12\sigma_s(x) \qquad(s\in S).(12)✦

(f) For a family (τi)i∈I(\tau_i)_{i\in I} of tracial states of a C*^*-algebra DD and every a∈Da\in D, supi∈I∥a∥2,τi≤supτ∈T(D)∥a∥2,τ.\sup_{i\in I}\|a\|_{2,\tau_i}\le\sup_{\tau\in T(D)}\|a\|_{2,\tau}.(13)✦

(g) With DD and (τi)i∈I(\tau_i)_{i\in I} as in (f), for all p,x∈Dp,x\in D, supi∈I|τi(px)−12τi(x)|≤supτ∈T(D)|τ(px)−12τ(x)|.\sup_{i\in I}\bigl|\tau_i(px)-\tfrac12\tau_i(x)\bigr| \le\sup_{\tau\in T(D)}\bigl|\tau(px)-\tfrac12\tau(x)\bigr|.(14)✦

(h) Let AA be a simple infinite-dimensional C*^*-algebra, BB its uniform tracial completion for the family T(A)T(A) of all its tracial states and Λω\Lambda_\omega the limit traces of BωB^\omega. Suppose that BωB^\omega has real rank zero and that for every finite set K⊆U(A)K\subseteq U(A) and every μ>0\mu>0 there is a positive diagonal for KK with tolerance μ\mu. Then there is a projection p∈Bωp\in B^\omega with px=xpandλ(px)=12λ(x)(x∈B,λ∈Λω).px=xp\quad\text{and}\quad\lambda(px)=\tfrac12\lambda(x) \qquad(x\in B,\ \lambda\in\Lambda_\omega).(15)✦

In the paper, the result reads: finite-stage projections PnP_n are lifted and diagonalized to one projection pp for the original ω\omega; density of a sequence of unitaries extends the commutation and halving identities to AA, and uniform 2-density of AA in BB extends them to BB.

What Is Checked

The eight statements are stated over the uniform tracial completion (2) of a C*^*-algebra for a family of tracial states, built from Cauchy and null sequences, with its completion map and completion traces (3); over the tracial ultrapower (4), its diagonal embedding and its limit traces (5); over the uniform 2-norm and halving error for a family and over T(D)T(D) (1); and, in (15), over simplicity, real rank zero and the positive diagonals (6).

About these constructions the library proves that constant sequences are Cauchy for the uniform 2-norm✦, that the zero family is null✦ and the adjoint of a null family is null✦, and that the value lim⁡n→ωτs(n)(an)\lim_{n\to\omega}\tau_{s(n)}(a_n) is additive✦ and homogeneous in the bounded sequence (an)(a_n).✦ It proves that each ultraproduct trace vanishes on the null ideal✦ and each Cauchy trace on the Cauchy null ideal✦, and that a tracial state vanishing on a closed *^*-ideal takes the same value at two elements congruent modulo it.✦ It also proves that the null families are stable under sums, negatives and products with bounded families, that the sequences Cauchy for the family are stable under sums, products and adjoints and contain the constants, and that the ultraproduct trace, and the trace induced on a quotient by a closed *^*-ideal on which a tracial state vanishes, are positive, normalized and tracial.