OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· 3. Balancing slopes by modifications

Lemma 3.1 (elementary-transform portion only): A coherent torsion-free quotient of the divisor restriction of an admissible extension gives another admissible extension

A Cartier transform retains its puncture framing.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

An elementary transformation concerns a coherent sheaf on a scheme with a Cartier divisor and a quotient of its restriction to that divisor. Let k:Dβ†ͺYk:D\hookrightarrow Y be a closed immersion of locally Noetherian schemes whose ideal sheaf π’₯k\mathcal J_k is invertible. A line bundle β„’\mathcal L on YY is an π’ͺY\mathcal O_Y-module locally isomorphic to π’ͺY\mathcal O_Y; choose such local trivializations of π’₯k\mathcal J_k. Write Coh⁡(Z)\operatorname{Coh}(Z) for the coherent π’ͺZ\mathcal O_Z-modules on a locally Noetherian scheme ZZ.✦ A sheaf β„±\mathcal F on ZZ is sectionwise torsion-free, denoted TFZ(β„±)\mathrm{TF}_Z(\mathcal F), when β„±(V)\mathcal F(V) is torsion-free over π’ͺZ(V)\mathcal O_Z(V) for every open subset VβŠ†ZV\subseteq Z. The tensor product of two module sheaves over a structure sheaf is the sheaf associated to the presheaf of tensor products of their sections.

The ideal, restriction unit and elementary transform are given by (1). Here β„°βˆˆCoh⁡(Y)\mathcal E\in\operatorname{Coh}(Y), P=k*β„°P=k^*\mathcal E, and q:Pβ† Gq:P\twoheadrightarrow G is a surjection to a coherent sheaf on DD: π’₯k=ker⁡(π’ͺYβ†’k*π’ͺD),Ξ·β„°:β„°β†’k*k*β„°,qΜƒ=k*qβˆ˜Ξ·β„°,β„°β€²=ker⁡qΜƒ,Kq=ker⁡q.\begin{aligned} \mathcal J_k&=\ker(\mathcal O_Y\longrightarrow k_*\mathcal O_D), &\eta_{\mathcal E}&:\mathcal E\longrightarrow k_*k^*\mathcal E,\\ \widetilde q&=k_*q\circ\eta_{\mathcal E}, &\mathcal E'&=\ker\widetilde q, &K_q&=\ker q. \end{aligned}(1) Write jq:β„°β€²β†ͺβ„°j_q:\mathcal E'\hookrightarrow\mathcal E for the kernel inclusion. The map Ξ±q:k*β„°β€²β†’Kq\alpha_q:k^*\mathcal E'\to K_q is induced by this inclusion, and Ξ΄q:GβŠ—k*π’₯kβ†’k*β„°β€²\delta_q:G\otimes k^*\mathcal J_k\to k^*\mathcal E' is the Cartier connecting morphism.

The Completed Source

The concrete surface comes from the line radicands (u,v,uβˆ’1,vβˆ’1,uβˆ’v)(u,v,u-1,v-1,u-v) in K=β„‚(u,v)K=\mathbb C(u,v), the fraction field of β„‚[u,v]\mathbb C[u,v]. For a prime pp, let LpL_p be the subfield of an algebraic closure of KK generated by chosen ppth roots of these five radicands.✦ Use L=L7L=L_7, with chosen roots y0,…,y4y_0,\ldots,y_4, and put z=(1,y0,…,y4)z=(1,y_0,\ldots,y_4). For (a0,b0)=(1,4)(a_0,b_0)=(1,4), (a1,b1)=(2,3)(a_1,b_1)=(2,3) and (a2,b2)=(5,0)(a_2,b_2)=(5,0), set sij=zizajzbjs_{ij}=z_i z_{a_j}z_{b_j}, where 0≀i≀50\leq i\leq5 and 0≀j≀20\leq j\leq2.✦ The section algebra BB, its normalized coefficient spaces TnT_n, and the polynomial and completed section rings CC and RR are defined in (2), with tt an indeterminate: B=β„‚[sijt]βŠ†L[t],Tn={c∈L:ctn is integral over B},C=⨁nβ‰₯0TntnβŠ†L[t],R={βˆ‘nβ‰₯0cntn:cn∈Tn}βŠ†L[[t]].\begin{aligned} B&=\mathbb C[s_{ij}t]\subseteq L[t], &T_n&=\{c\in L:ct^n\text{ is integral over }B\},\\ C&=\bigoplus_{n\geq0}T_nt^n\subseteq L[t], &R&=\left\{\sum_{n\geq0}c_nt^n:c_n\in T_n\right\}\subseteq L[[t]]. \end{aligned}(2) The normalized projective surface is X=Proj⁡CX=\operatorname{Proj}C, with graded components Cn=TntnC_n=T_nt^n. The inclusion Cβ†’RC\to R regards a polynomial as a series.✦ The corresponding section monomials are sijt∈L[t]s_{ij}t\in L[t].

Choose nonzero w0,w1,w2∈T1w_0,w_1,w_2\in T_1 for which the homomorphism S=β„‚[x0,x1,x2]β†’CS=\mathbb C[x_0,x_1,x_2]\to C, xi↦witx_i\mapsto w_it, is finite and injective. It induces f:Xβ†’β„™β„‚2f:X\to\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C}.✦ Put A=β„‚[[x0,x1,x2]]A=\mathbb C[[x_0,x_1,x_2]]; substitution xi↦witx_i\mapsto w_it defines its homomorphism to RR. The completed tensor identification is (3): AβŠ—SCβ†’βˆΌR,aβŠ—b↦a(w0t,w1t,w2t)b.A\otimes_S C\xrightarrow{\ \sim\ }R, \qquad a\otimes b\longmapsto a(w_0t,w_1t,w_2t)b.(3) Let kk be a field. An integral homogeneous homomorphism of graded kk-algebras whose source has only scalars in degree zero induces a morphism of their projective schemes in the opposite direction. The target irrelevant ideal is contained in the radical of the extension of the source irrelevant ideal.

For a family vi∈Tdiv_i\in T_{d_i} with positive integers did_i, the generating series are the monomials vitdi∈L[[t]]v_it^{d_i}\in L[[t]]✦, each of which has zero constant coefficient.✦ Substituting these series for the variables gives a complex algebra homomorphism from the multivariate power series ring to RR.✦

Let π”ͺ=(x0,x1,x2)βŠ‚S\mathfrak m=(x_0,x_1,x_2)\subset S.✦ With Ο„\tau an indeterminate, the polynomial blowup is V0=Proj⁡(⨁nβ‰₯0π”ͺnΟ„n)V_0=\operatorname{Proj}\bigl(\bigoplus_{n\geq0}\mathfrak m^n\tau^n\bigr), with blowdown b0:V0β†’Spec⁡Sb_0:V_0\to\operatorname{Spec}S and direction morphism d0:V0β†’β„™β„‚2d_0:V_0\to\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C} given by the degree-one Rees sections xiΟ„x_i\tau. Its degree-zero ring is SS.✦ The completed blowup and the source models are the fibre products in (4), where the morphism from VV to β„™β„‚2\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C} is the projection to V0V_0 followed by d0d_0: V=V0Γ—Spec⁡SSpec⁡A,W0=XΓ—β„™β„‚2V0,W=XΓ—β„™β„‚2V.V=V_0\times_{\operatorname{Spec}S}\operatorname{Spec}A, \qquad W_0=X\times_{\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C}}V_0, \qquad W=X\times_{\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C}}V.(4) Write g0:W0β†’V0g_0:W_0\to V_0 and g:Wβ†’Vg:W\to V for the projections. The origin fibre of b0b_0 is identified by d0d_0 with β„™β„‚2\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C}.✦ Its inclusion and the constant-term map Aβ†’β„‚A\to\mathbb C give the completed zero section e:β„™β„‚2β†ͺVe:\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C}\hookrightarrow V.✦ The corresponding source zero section is i:Xβ†ͺWi:X\hookrightarrow W. Denote their ideals by ℐ\mathcal I and π’₯\mathcal J, respectively, and write π’ͺX(H)=i*π’₯\mathcal O_X(H)=i^*\mathcal J for the conormal line. The framed open subset is U=gβˆ’1(V\e(β„™β„‚2))U=g^{-1}(V\setminus e(\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C})).✦

The graded direction homomorphism maps the standard polynomial grading in three variables over β„‚\mathbb C to the Rees grading, sending its iith coordinate variable to the generating Rees section xiΟ„x_i\tau. The irrelevant ideal of the Rees grading is contained in the radical of the ideal generated by the images of the positive-degree elements of the standard polynomial grading under the graded direction homomorphism.✦ The completed blowdown b:Vβ†’Spec⁡Ab:V\to\operatorname{Spec}A is the second projection of the fibre product defining VV.✦ The completed direction morphism d:Vβ†’β„™β„‚2d:V\to\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C} is the projection to V0V_0 followed by d0d_0.✦

The graded polynomial substitution homomorphism is obtained by substituting degree-one elements of a graded algebra for the variables of a polynomial ring over the same field.✦ It sends every homogeneous polynomial of degree nn into the degree-nn component.✦

For 0≀i≀20\leq i\leq2, let Pi=(S[xiβˆ’1])0P_i=(S[x_i^{-1}])_0 and Ci=(C[(wit)βˆ’1])0C_i=(C[(w_it)^{-1}])_0 be the standard affine coordinate rings of the plane and XX. Let BiB_i be the degree-zero localization of the Rees algebra at xiΟ„x_i\tau.✦ The blowup and source charts have the rings in (5), where Ο„i\tau_i is the image of the base coordinate xix_i: Bi≃Pi[Ο„i],Di=CiβŠ—PiBi≃Ci[Ο„i].B_i\simeq P_i[\tau_i], \qquad D_i=C_i\otimes_{P_i}B_i\simeq C_i[\tau_i].(5) The spectra of the DiD_i cover W0W_0.✦ Homogeneous chart evaluation defines Ο€0:W0β†’Spec⁡C\pi_0:W_0\to\operatorname{Spec}C by (6); scalar extension and (3) give the completed cone morphism Ο€:Wβ†’Spec⁡R\pi:W\to\operatorname{Spec}R: Cβ†’Di,ctn↦cwinΟ„in(c∈Tn).C\longrightarrow D_i, \qquad ct^n\longmapsto \frac{c}{w_i^n}\tau_i^n \quad(c\in T_n).(6) The surface chart direction homomorphism Piβ†’CiP_i\to C_i is the homomorphism of degree-zero localizations induced by the graded normalization homomorphism. The graded direction homomorphism likewise induces the blowup chart direction homomorphism Piβ†’BiP_i\to B_i. The blowdown chart homomorphism Sβ†’BiS\to B_i is the identification of SS with the degree-zero Rees component followed by its canonical map into the homogeneous localization BiB_i. The surface and blowup chart tensor inclusions into Di=CiβŠ—PiBiD_i=C_i\otimes_{P_i}B_i send cc to cβŠ—1c\otimes1 and bb to 1βŠ—b1\otimes b, respectively. Composing the blowdown chart homomorphism with the blowup chart tensor inclusion gives the source chart base homomorphism Sβ†’DiS\to D_i. The chart coefficient homomorphism Ciβ†’LC_i\to L sends a homogeneous fraction with denominator (wit)n(w_it)^n and numerator ctnct^n to c/winc/w_i^n. It is induced by evaluation at t=1t=1 after inverting the linear section witw_it. The scalar extended cone evaluation is the morphism Wβ†’Spec⁡AΓ—Spec⁡SSpec⁡CW\to\operatorname{Spec}A\times_{\operatorname{Spec}S}\operatorname{Spec}C with coordinates b∘gb\circ g and Ο€0∘ρ\pi_0\circ\rho, where ρ:Wβ†’W0\rho:W\to W_0 is the source completion projection.

Homogeneous polynomial rescaling at wiw_i is the complex algebra homomorphism from CC to L[t]L[t] obtained by substituting wiβˆ’1tw_i^{-1}t for tt.✦ Every rescaled section polynomial has its coefficients in the image of the chart coefficient homomorphism Ciβ†’LC_i\to L.✦ The chart coefficient homomorphism Ciβ†’LC_i\to L preserves complex scalars✦ and is a complex algebra homomorphism.✦

The plane and surface chart open immersions are the standard inclusions Spec⁡Piβ†ͺβ„™β„‚2\operatorname{Spec}P_i\hookrightarrow\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C} and Spec⁡Ciβ†ͺX\operatorname{Spec}C_i\hookrightarrow X, and the blowup chart open immersion Spec⁡Biβ†ͺV0\operatorname{Spec}B_i\hookrightarrow V_0 is the standard Proj chart at xiΟ„x_i\tau.✦ Their fibre product over the plane chart is the source chart open immersion Spec⁡Diβ†ͺW0\operatorname{Spec}D_i\hookrightarrow W_0.✦

The blowup chart polynomial isomorphism Pi[T]≃BiP_i[T]\simeq B_i is given by the blowup chart direction homomorphism on coefficients and sends TT to the image of xix_i.✦ Its inverse, followed by scalar extension from PiP_i to CiC_i and the polynomial base change isomorphism, gives the source chart polynomial isomorphism Di≃Ci[T]D_i\simeq C_i[T].✦

For an RR-module MM, let MΜƒ\widetilde M be its associated sheaf on Spec⁡R\operatorname{Spec}R. The double-dual pullback β„°M\mathcal E_M is the sheaf in (7), where the dual means the sheaf of π’ͺW\mathcal O_W-linear maps into π’ͺW\mathcal O_W: β„°M=(Ο€*MΜƒ)∨∨,β„±βˆ¨=β„‹omπ’ͺW(β„±,π’ͺW).\mathcal E_M=(\pi^*\widetilde M)^{\vee\vee}, \qquad \mathcal F^\vee=\mathcal H om_{\mathcal O_W}(\mathcal F,\mathcal O_W).(7)✦ An admissible framed extension of MM is a pair (ℬ,Ο•)(\mathcal B,\phi) with β„¬βˆˆCoh⁡(W)\mathcal B\in\operatorname{Coh}(W), both ℬ\mathcal B and i*ℬi^*\mathcal B sectionwise torsion-free, and an isomorphism Ο•:ℬ|Uβ†’βˆΌβ„°M|U\phi:\mathcal B|_U\xrightarrow{\sim}\mathcal E_M|_U.✦ Write π’œU(M)\mathscr A_U(M) for the collection of these extensions. Restriction on the source means the Cartier restriction i*i^*, and its elementary transform is the specialization of (1) to i:Xβ†ͺWi:X\hookrightarrow W.

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the Cartier immersion k:Dβ†ͺYk:D\hookrightarrow Y, let q:k*β„°β† Gq:k^*\mathcal E\twoheadrightarrow G be a coherent quotient and define β„°β€²\mathcal E' as in (1). If TFY(β„°)\mathrm{TF}_Y(\mathcal E), then (8) is short exact: 0β†’GβŠ—π’ͺDk*π’₯kβ†’Ξ΄qk*β„°β€²β†’Ξ±qKqβ†’0.0\longrightarrow G\otimes_{\mathcal O_D}k^*\mathcal J_k \xrightarrow{\delta_q}k^*\mathcal E' \xrightarrow{\alpha_q}K_q\longrightarrow0.(8)✦ For any open subset VβŠ†YV\subseteq Y with kβˆ’1(V)=βŒ€k^{-1}(V)=\varnothing, the puncture identification is (9): jq|V:β„°β€²|Vβ†’βˆΌβ„°|V.j_q|_V:\mathcal E'|_V\xrightarrow{\ \sim\ }\mathcal E|_V.(9)✦ On the completed source i:Xβ†ͺWi:X\hookrightarrow W, suppose that β„°\mathcal E, P=i*β„°P=i^*\mathcal E and GG are sectionwise torsion-free. For a coherent quotient q:Pβ† Gq:P\twoheadrightarrow G, the transformed restriction satisfies (10): TFX(i*β„°β€²).\mathrm{TF}_X(i^*\mathcal E').(10)✦ For (ℬ,Ο•)βˆˆπ’œU(M)(\mathcal B,\phi)\in\mathscr A_U(M) and a coherent quotient q:i*ℬ↠Gq:i^*\mathcal B\twoheadrightarrow G with TFX(G)\mathrm{TF}_X(G), the transformation of the framed extension is (11), where ℬ′\mathcal B' is its elementary transform: Tq(ℬ,Ο•):=(ℬ′,Ο•βˆ˜(jq|U))βˆˆπ’œU(M).T_q(\mathcal B,\phi) :=\bigl(\mathcal B',\,\phi\circ(j_q|_U)\bigr) \in\mathscr A_U(M).(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if WW is an integral Noetherian scheme, i:Xβ†ͺWi:X\hookrightarrow W is an effective Cartier divisor with XX a smooth integral projective complex surface and π’₯|X≃π’ͺX(H)\mathcal J|_X\simeq\mathcal O_X(H) ample, and β„°\mathcal E is a coherent torsion-free sheaf on WW whose restriction PP is torsion-free of positive rank, then there is a coherent torsion-free sheaf β„°β€²\mathcal E' agreeing with β„°\mathcal E off XX, with torsion-free restriction whose normalized Harder-Narasimhan slopes with respect to HH lie in an interval of length at most one.

What Is Checked

The statements are over coherent sheaves on locally Noetherian schemes, with the torsion-free conditions imposed on sections over every open subset, and over the specified completed source and its zero-section ideal line. The source completion is Cartesian: W≃W0Γ—Spec⁡SSpec⁡AW\simeq W_0\times_{\operatorname{Spec}S}\operatorname{Spec}A, compatibly with the blowdowns and the completion morphism Spec⁡Aβ†’Spec⁡S\operatorname{Spec}A\to\operatorname{Spec}S.✦ The source completion projection ρ:Wβ†’W0\rho:W\to W_0 retains the coordinate in XX and projects the completed blowup coordinate from VV to V0V_0.

The completed source has the affine open cover Spec⁡DΛ†i\operatorname{Spec}\widehat D_i, where DΛ†i=DiβŠ—SA\widehat D_i=D_i\otimes_S A and Ο„Λ†i=Ο„iβŠ—1\widehat\tau_i=\tau_i\otimes1. Evaluation at Ο„i=0\tau_i=0, together with constant-term evaluation on AA, defines Ξ΅i:DΛ†iβ†’Ci\varepsilon_i:\widehat D_i\to C_i.✦ The quotient identification and regularity are (12): DΛ†i/(Ο„Λ†i)β†’Ξ΅i∼Ci,Ο„Λ†i is a non-zero-divisor in DΛ†i.\widehat D_i/(\widehat\tau_i) \xrightarrow[\varepsilon_i]{\ \sim\ }C_i, \qquad \widehat\tau_i\text{ is a non-zero-divisor in }\widehat D_i.(12) The induced morphisms Spec⁡Ciβ†’Spec⁡DΛ†i\operatorname{Spec}C_i\to \operatorname{Spec}\widehat D_i commute with the zero section ii and the chart inclusions. On an affine Cartier chart Spec⁡Q\operatorname{Spec}Q whose divisor has ideal (a)(a) for a regular element a∈Qa\in Q, sections of its ideal sheaf identify with the kernel of Qβ†’Q/(a)Q\to Q/(a), and multiplication by aa identifies QQ with that ideal.✦ The chosen completed source chart trivializations give a line bundle trivialization of π’₯\mathcal J.✦ The source zero evaluation Diβ†’CiD_i\to C_i is evaluation at Ο„i=0\tau_i=0 under the polynomial identification Di≃Ci[Ο„i]D_i\simeq C_i[\tau_i], and it is surjective. It is a homomorphism over SS when SS acts on CiC_i by evaluation at the origin followed by the complex scalar map. The completed zero section ideal in DΛ†i\widehat D_i is the extension of the kernel of the source zero evaluation Diβ†’CiD_i\to C_i along Diβ†’DΛ†iD_i\to\widehat D_i.

For a finitely presented module sheaf 𝒩\mathcal N on Spec⁡Q\operatorname{Spec}Q, a QQ-linear isomorphism Ξ“(Spec⁡Q,𝒩)≃Q\Gamma(\operatorname{Spec}Q,\mathcal N)\simeq Q determines a sheaf isomorphism 𝒩≃π’ͺSpec⁡Q\mathcal N\simeq\mathcal O_{\operatorname{Spec}Q}.✦

For a surjective homomorphism Bβ†’DB\to D of QQ-algebras and a QQ-algebra Aβ€²A', the quotient of BβŠ—QAβ€²B\otimes_Q A' by the extension of the kernel is isomorphic to DβŠ—QAβ€²D\otimes_Q A'.✦ Let Οƒ\sigma range over an index set. If a polynomial ring Sβ€²=k[xΟƒ]S'=k[x_\sigma] acts on a kk-algebra DD through evaluation at the origin, then DβŠ—Sβ€²k[[xΟƒ]]D\otimes_{S'}k[[x_\sigma]] is isomorphic to DD.✦ This origin base change isomorphism sends dβŠ—ad\otimes a to dd times the scalar image of the constant coefficient of aa, and its inverse sends dd to dβŠ—1d\otimes1.✦

For the general immersion kk, its ideal π’₯k\mathcal J_k and the pushforward k*Nk_*N of a coherent sheaf NN on DD are coherent. Tensoring by a line bundle, including the conormal line on DD, preserves coherence. For β„±βˆˆCoh⁡(Y)\mathcal F\in\operatorname{Coh}(Y), let aβ„±:π’₯kβŠ—β„±β†’β„±a_{\mathcal F}:\mathcal J_k\otimes\mathcal F\to\mathcal F be ideal multiplication.✦ The Cartier first Tor sheaf 𝒯1(β„±)\mathcal T_1(\mathcal F) on DD and the restriction have the kernel and cokernel identifications in (13); the same display gives the supported restriction and conormal identifications, with the line bundle projection formula: ker⁡aℱ≃k*𝒯1(β„±),coker⁡aℱ≃k*k*β„±,k*k*N≃N,𝒯1(k*N)≃k*π’₯kβŠ—π’ͺDN,π’₯kβŠ—π’ͺYk*N≃k*(k*π’₯kβŠ—π’ͺDN),ak*N=0.\begin{aligned} \ker a_{\mathcal F}&\simeq k_*\mathcal T_1(\mathcal F), &\operatorname{coker}a_{\mathcal F}&\simeq k_*k^*\mathcal F,\\ k^*k_*N&\simeq N, &\mathcal T_1(k_*N)&\simeq k^*\mathcal J_k\otimes_{\mathcal O_D}N,\\ \mathcal J_k\otimes_{\mathcal O_Y}k_*N &\simeq k_*(k^*\mathcal J_k\otimes_{\mathcal O_D}N), &a_{k_*N}&=0. \end{aligned}(13) The line bundle twist β„’βŠ—β„±\mathcal L\otimes\mathcal F of a coherent sheaf β„±\mathcal F by a line bundle β„’\mathcal L on YY is their tensor product, a coherent sheaf on YY. The conormal twist k*π’₯kβŠ—π’ͺDNk^*\mathcal J_k\otimes_{\mathcal O_D}N of a coherent sheaf NN on DD is its tensor product with the conormal line.

For a short exact sequence β„±1β†’β„±2β†’β„±3\mathcal F_1\to\mathcal F_2\to\mathcal F_3 of coherent sheaves on YY, the Cartier connecting map 𝒯1(β„±3)β†’k*β„±1\mathcal T_1(\mathcal F_3)\to k^*\mathcal F_1 gives exactness at these two terms of the Tor and restriction sequence. The restricted complex is exact at k*β„±2k^*\mathcal F_2. The ambient elementary modification has the short exact sequence (14): 0β†’β„°β€²β†’jqβ„°β†’qΜƒk*Gβ†’0.0\longrightarrow\mathcal E'\xrightarrow{j_q}\mathcal E \xrightarrow{\widetilde q}k_*G\longrightarrow0.(14)✦ The supported restriction identification k*k*G≃Gk^*k_*G\simeq G identifies the kernel of the restricted quotient map k*qΜƒk^*\widetilde q with KqK_q.