The Setting
The maximal defect of a sphere isometry concerns distances from a unit vector to scalar multiples of other unit vectors.
Let and be nonzero real normed spaces. Their unit spheres are and , with the inherited distances, and let be a surjective isometry.✦ The signed defect of is the real-valued function of and defined by (1)✦ For another sphere isometry , write for the same expression with in place of .
The absolute defect values of form the set , and their supremum is its maximal defect : (2) For real normed spaces and , a uniform defect bound for a sphere isometry is a real number satisfying (3)
Completed Ultrapowers
Let be an ultrafilter on . For a real sequence , the real ultralimit is its chosen limit along ; whenever the sequence converges along , this is its limit.✦ The bounded sequence space consists of sequences in for which .✦ For a real normed space and an ultrafilter on , the ultranorm is the real-valued function on obtained by taking the ultralimit of the coordinate norms, the normed ultrapower is the quotient of by the sequences of ultranorm zero, and is the completion of this quotient: (4) The quotient projection in (4) is denoted by . Use the same notation with in place of .
A sequence of unit vectors in is a bounded sequence, and denotes its unit-vector class in . A unit representative of is a sequence in whose class is ; write for a chosen unit representative.✦ The coordinatewise ultrapower sphere map is the map defined by (5)✦
For a real normed space , the sphere embedding sends each unit vector to its image in the completion.✦ The sphere completion map of a real normed space is the continuous extension of the map sending each unit vector of to its image in the completion, where is the metric completion of the unit sphere.✦ For a sphere isometry , write for its metric completion extension. The ambient completion extension of a sphere isometry between real normed spaces and is the map defined by (6) The completed ultrapower sphere isometry is the extension (6) of from (5). Fix a free ultrafilter on .
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be any ultrafilter on , and let be a uniform defect bound for in the sense of (3). Then (7)✦
Theorem 2. Let be any ultrafilter on , let , and let and be sequences in . Then (8)✦
Theorem 3. Suppose the maximal defect in (2) is positive, and put . There are , an orientation , and unit vectors in the domain sphere of such that (9)✦
In the paper, the result reads: if a surjective isometry between unit spheres of nonzero real Banach spaces has , there are possibly different nonzero real Banach spaces, a surjective sphere isometry again denoted , and , , such that for every and , and .
What Is Checked
The attainment assertion (9) is stated over nonzero real normed spaces, a surjective sphere isometry with positive maximal defect, and the completed ultrapowers for the fixed free ultrafilter. The bound (7) is stated for any ultrafilter and any original uniform defect bound; the identity (8) allows every real and arbitrary sequences of unit vectors.
Every unit vector in has a unit representative.✦ The coordinatewise map (5) preserves distances✦, and its inverse is the coordinatewise map associated with . The extended sphere embedding preserves distances✦ and identifies with .✦ The metric completion extension of a sphere isometry has inverse the extension of its inverse.