OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. Attaining the maximal defect

Lemma 3.1 [Attainment of a positive maximal defect]: One orientation attains the original maximal defect in a completed ultrapower

A positive defect is attained after completion.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The maximal defect of a sphere isometry concerns distances from a unit vector to scalar multiples of other unit vectors.

Let XX and YY be nonzero real normed spaces. Their unit spheres are SX={x∈X:∥x∥=1}S_X=\{x\in X:\|x\|=1\} and SY={y∈Y:∥y∥=1}S_Y=\{y\in Y:\|y\|=1\}, with the inherited distances, and let f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y be a surjective isometry.✦ The signed defect Dq(x,y)D_q(x,y) of f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y is the real-valued function of x,y∈SXx,y\in S_X and q∈ℝq\in\mathbb R defined by Dq(x,y)=∥f(x)−qf(y)∥−∥x−qy∥,x,y∈SX,q∈ℝ.D_q(x,y)=\|f(x)-qf(y)\|-\|x-qy\|, \qquad x,y\in S_X,\quad q\in\mathbb R.(1)✦ For another sphere isometry gg, write DqgD_q^g for the same expression with gg in place of ff.

The absolute defect values of ff form the set 𝒜f\mathcal A_f, and their supremum is its maximal defect MM: 𝒜f={|Dq(x,y)|:x,y∈SX,0≤q≤1},M=sup⁡𝒜f.\mathcal A_f =\{|D_q(x,y)|:x,y\in S_X,\ 0\le q\le1\}, \qquad M=\sup\mathcal A_f.(2) For real normed spaces EE and GG, a uniform defect bound CC for a sphere isometry g:SE→SGg:S_E\to S_G is a real number satisfying |Dqg(a,b)|≤C(a,b∈SE,0≤q≤1).|D_q^g(a,b)|\le C \qquad(a,b\in S_E,\ 0\le q\le1).(3)

Completed Ultrapowers

Let 𝒰\mathcal U be an ultrafilter on ℕ\mathbb N. For a real sequence (bn)(b_n), the real ultralimit lim⁡𝒰bn\lim_{\mathcal U}b_n is its chosen limit along 𝒰\mathcal U; whenever the sequence converges along 𝒰\mathcal U, this is its limit.✦ The bounded sequence space ℓ∞(X)\ell^\infty(X) consists of sequences a=(an)a=(a_n) in XX for which sup⁡n∥an∥<∞\sup_n\|a_n\|<\infty.✦ For a real normed space XX and an ultrafilter 𝒰\mathcal U on ℕ\mathbb N, the ultranorm ∥⋅∥𝒰\|\cdot\|_{\mathcal U} is the real-valued function on ℓ∞(X)\ell^\infty(X) obtained by taking the ultralimit of the coordinate norms, the normed ultrapower X𝒰X_{\mathcal U} is the quotient of ℓ∞(X)\ell^\infty(X) by the sequences of ultranorm zero, and Xˆ𝒰\widehat X_{\mathcal U} is the completion of this quotient: ∥a∥𝒰=lim𝒰∥an∥,N𝒰={a∈ℓ∞(X):∥a∥𝒰=0},X𝒰=ℓ∞(X)/N𝒰,Xˆ𝒰=X𝒰ˆ.\|a\|_{\mathcal U}=\lim_{\mathcal U}\|a_n\|, \qquad N_{\mathcal U}=\{a\in\ell^\infty(X):\|a\|_{\mathcal U}=0\}, \qquad X_{\mathcal U}=\ell^\infty(X)/N_{\mathcal U}, \qquad \widehat X_{\mathcal U}=\widehat{X_{\mathcal U}}.(4) The quotient projection in (4) is denoted by a↦[a]𝒰a\mapsto[a]_{\mathcal U}. Use the same notation with YY in place of XX.

A sequence s=(sn)s=(s_n) of unit vectors in XX is a bounded sequence, and [s]𝒰[s]_{\mathcal U} denotes its unit-vector class in X𝒰X_{\mathcal U}. A unit representative of z∈SX𝒰z\in S_{X_{\mathcal U}} is a sequence in SXS_X whose class is zz; write r𝒰(z)r_{\mathcal U}(z) for a chosen unit representative.✦ The coordinatewise ultrapower sphere map f𝒰:SX𝒰→SY𝒰f_{\mathcal U}:S_{X_{\mathcal U}}\to S_{Y_{\mathcal U}} is the map defined by f𝒰(z)=[(f(r𝒰(z)n))n∈ℕ]𝒰,z∈SX𝒰.f_{\mathcal U}(z) =\bigl[(f(r_{\mathcal U}(z)_n))_{n\in\mathbb N}\bigr]_{\mathcal U}, \qquad z\in S_{X_{\mathcal U}}.(5)✦

For a real normed space EE, the sphere embedding ιE:SE→SEˆ\iota_E:S_E\to S_{\widehat E} sends each unit vector to its image in the completion.✦ The sphere completion map JE:SEˆ→SEˆJ_E:\widehat{S_E}\to S_{\widehat E} of a real normed space EE is the continuous extension of the map sending each unit vector of EE to its image in the completion, where SEˆ\widehat{S_E} is the metric completion of the unit sphere.✦ For a sphere isometry h:SE→SGh:S_E\to S_G, write h¯:SEˆ→SGˆ\overline h:\widehat{S_E}\to\widehat{S_G} for its metric completion extension. The ambient completion extension hˆ:SEˆ→SGˆ\widehat h:S_{\widehat E}\to S_{\widehat G} of a sphere isometry h:SE→SGh:S_E\to S_G between real normed spaces EE and GG is the map defined by hˆ=JG∘h¯∘JE−1.\widehat h=J_G\circ\overline h\circ J_E^{-1}.(6) The completed ultrapower sphere isometry F𝒰:SXˆ𝒰→SYˆ𝒰F_{\mathcal U}:S_{\widehat X_{\mathcal U}}\to S_{\widehat Y_{\mathcal U}} is the extension (6) of f𝒰f_{\mathcal U} from (5). Fix a free ultrafilter 𝒰0\mathcal U_0 on ℕ\mathbb N.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let 𝒰\mathcal U be any ultrafilter on ℕ\mathbb N, and let CC be a uniform defect bound for ff in the sense of (3). Then |DqF𝒰(a,b)|≤C(a,b∈SXˆ𝒰,0≤q≤1).|D_q^{F_{\mathcal U}}(a,b)|\le C \qquad (a,b\in S_{\widehat X_{\mathcal U}},\ 0\le q\le1).(7)✦

Theorem 2. Let 𝒰\mathcal U be any ultrafilter on ℕ\mathbb N, let q∈ℝq\in\mathbb R, and let s=(sn)s=(s_n) and r=(rn)r=(r_n) be sequences in SXS_X. Then DqF𝒰(ιX𝒰([s]𝒰),ιX𝒰([r]𝒰))=lim𝒰Dq(sn,rn).D_q^{F_{\mathcal U}} \bigl(\iota_{X_{\mathcal U}}([s]_{\mathcal U}), \iota_{X_{\mathcal U}}([r]_{\mathcal U})\bigr) =\lim_{\mathcal U}D_q(s_n,r_n).(8)✦

Theorem 3. Suppose the maximal defect MM in (2) is positive, and put F=F𝒰0F=F_{\mathcal U_0}. There are t∈(0,1)t\in(0,1), an orientation g∈{F,F−1}g\in\{F,F^{-1}\}, and unit vectors x,yx,y in the domain sphere of gg such that |DqF(a,b)|≤M(a,b∈SXˆ𝒰0,0≤q≤1),|DqF−1(c,d)|≤M(c,d∈SYˆ𝒰0,0≤q≤1),Dtg(x,y)=M.\begin{aligned} |D_q^F(a,b)|&\le M &&(a,b\in S_{\widehat X_{\mathcal U_0}},\ 0\le q\le1),\\ |D_q^{F^{-1}}(c,d)|&\le M &&(c,d\in S_{\widehat Y_{\mathcal U_0}},\ 0\le q\le1),\\ D_t^g(x,y)&=M. \end{aligned}(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if a surjective isometry between unit spheres of nonzero real Banach spaces has M>0M>0, there are possibly different nonzero real Banach spaces, a surjective sphere isometry again denoted f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y, and x0,y∈SXx_0,y\in S_X, 0<t<10<t<1, such that |Dq(a,c)|≤M|D_q(a,c)|\le M for every a,c∈SXa,c\in S_X and 0≤q≤10\le q\le1, and Dt(x0,y)=M>0D_t(x_0,y)=M>0.

What Is Checked

The attainment assertion (9) is stated over nonzero real normed spaces, a surjective sphere isometry with positive maximal defect, and the completed ultrapowers for the fixed free ultrafilter. The bound (7) is stated for any ultrafilter and any original uniform defect bound; the identity (8) allows every real qq and arbitrary sequences of unit vectors.

Every unit vector in X𝒰X_{\mathcal U} has a unit representative.✦ The coordinatewise map (5) preserves distances✦, and its inverse is the coordinatewise map associated with f−1f^{-1}. The extended sphere embedding JEJ_E preserves distances✦ and identifies SEˆ\widehat{S_E} with SEˆS_{\widehat E}.✦ The metric completion extension of a sphere isometry has inverse the extension of its inverse.