OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. An exact coercive identity

Lemma 4.1: The quartic as squares, a flow derivative, two products and a remainder at least 16615071521000000v4\tfrac{1661507}{1521000000}v^4 on nonnegative variables

An exact rational identity for z2−12Rvb2+6v4z^2 - 12Rvb^2 + 6v^4..

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

On an interval where the order parameter γ\gamma is constant, equal to cc, write v=cΦγ,xxv = c\,\Phi_{\gamma,xx} and z=cΦγ,xxxxz = c\,\Phi_{\gamma,xxxx} for the second and fourth spatial derivatives of the value function Φγ\Phi_\gamma, scaled by cc. With two further real variables RR and bb, form the quartic z2−12Rvb2+6v4z^2 - 12Rvb^2 + 6v^4; the question is how far it is from dominating a positive multiple of v4v^4. The answer is pure algebra, in these four variables and three more, KK, jj and LL.

The Polynomials

The coefficients of the polynomials below are built from ten rational constants, A=113,C=5324,T0=7348,k=1916,g0=233110000,h=872500,x0=46635000,y=685310000,m=−1051400,n0=−1073500.\begin{gathered} A = \tfrac{1}{13},\quad C = \tfrac{53}{24},\quad T_0 = \tfrac{73}{48},\quad k = \tfrac{19}{16},\quad g_0 = \tfrac{2331}{10000},\\ h = \tfrac{87}{2500},\quad x_0 = \tfrac{4663}{5000},\quad y = \tfrac{6853}{10000},\quad m = -\tfrac{1051}{400},\quad n_0 = -\tfrac{1073}{500}. \end{gathered}(1)

The quadratic form QQ in the real variables RR, KK, vv, bb and the quadratic form TT in the real variables RR, vv, jj are Q(R,K,v,b)=Avb+Cv2+kKv−2kRb+T0Rv,T(R,v,j)=v(g0R+hj).Q(R,K,v,b) = Avb + Cv^2 + kKv - 2kRb + T_0Rv, \qquad T(R,v,j) = v\,(g_0R + hj).(2) The polynomial SS in RR, vv, bb and zz is S=z+bv−2RbS = z + bv - 2Rb.

In the real variables RR, KK, vv, bb and jj, the cubic form F1F_1 is F1=b2(2kR−Av)−bv(2kK+g0R+2T0R+2Cv+hj),F_1 = b^2(2kR - Av) - bv\,(2kK + g_0R + 2T_0R + 2Cv + hj),(3)✦ and the cubic form F2F_2 is F2=v2(x0j+yv+mK+n0R)−F1.F_2 = v^2(x_0j + yv + mK + n_0R) - F_1.(4)✦ The partial derivatives of F2F_2 in RR, KK, vv, bb and jj are written ∂RF2\partial_RF_2, ∂KF2\partial_KF_2, ∂vF2\partial_vF_2, ∂bF2\partial_bF_2 and ∂jF2\partial_jF_2; the last two are ∂bF2=2Q+T\partial_bF_2 = 2Q + T✦ and ∂jF2=x0v2+hbv\partial_jF_2 = x_0v^2 + hbv✦.

The flow derivative DF2DF_2 at real numbers RR, KK, vv, bb, jj, zz and LL is the derivative of F2F_2 along a polynomial vector field in (R,K,v,b,j)(R,K,v,b,j), with the partial derivatives taken at (R,K,v,b,j)(R,K,v,b,j): DF2=2Rv∂RF2+(2vK+Rj)∂KF2−Rb∂vF2−(z+bv)∂bF2+(Kb−jv−L)∂jF2.DF_2 = 2Rv\,\partial_RF_2 + (2vK + Rj)\,\partial_KF_2 - Rb\,\partial_vF_2 - (z + bv)\,\partial_bF_2 + (Kb - jv - L)\,\partial_jF_2.(5)✦ The weighted derivative WF2WF_2 of the cubic form F2F_2 at real numbers RR, KK, vv, bb, jj, zz and LL is the polynomial WF2=DF2+(v+R−K)F2(R,K,v,b,j).WF_2 = DF_2 + (v + R - K)\,F_2(R,K,v,b,j).(6)

At real numbers RR, KK, vv, bb, BB and jj, the square terms P0,…,P4P_0, \dots, P_4 are squares weighted by products of the variables, P0=Rj(b−7v)2,P1=RB(b−73v)2,P2=Kv(b−92v)2,P3=vB(K+14R−17v)2,P4=(vb−145v2−134Kv+43Rv)2,\begin{gathered} P_0 = Rj\,(b - 7v)^2,\qquad P_1 = RB\,\bigl(b - \tfrac{7}{3}v\bigr)^2,\qquad P_2 = Kv\,\bigl(b - \tfrac{9}{2}v\bigr)^2,\\ P_3 = vB\,\bigl(K + \tfrac{1}{4}R - \tfrac{1}{7}v\bigr)^2,\qquad P_4 = \bigl(vb - \tfrac{14}{5}v^2 - \tfrac{13}{4}Kv + \tfrac{4}{3}Rv\bigr)^2, \end{gathered}(7) and the weighted sum of squares Σ(R,K,v,b,B,j)\Sigma(R,K,v,b,B,j) is Σ=33710000P0+1832500P1+41110000P2+114615000P3+64710000P4.\Sigma = \tfrac{337}{10000}P_0 + \tfrac{183}{2500}P_1 + \tfrac{411}{10000}P_2 + \tfrac{11461}{5000}P_3 + \tfrac{647}{10000}P_4.(8)✦

The remainder ρ\rho in the real variables RR, KK, vv, BB and jj is the homogeneous quartic with positive rational coefficients ρ(R,K,v,B,j)=223160000R2v2+4007240000R2vB+1097120000R2B2+8380000RKv2+334324000RKvB+1625923400000Rv3+301795460000Rv2B+26625Rv2j+10715000RvB2+32500RvBj+12132500RB3+1110000RB2j+57920000K2v2+2072500K2vB+911975000Kv3+349420000Kv2B+50115000Kv2j+133130000KvB2+872500KvBj+16615071521000000v4+633799621075000v3B+106571690000v2B2.\begin{aligned} \rho(R,K,v,B,j) ={}& \tfrac{223}{160000}R^2v^2 + \tfrac{4007}{240000}R^2vB + \tfrac{1097}{120000}R^2B^2 + \tfrac{83}{80000}RKv^2\\ &+ \tfrac{3343}{24000}RKvB + \tfrac{16259}{23400000}Rv^3 + \tfrac{30179}{5460000}Rv^2B + \tfrac{26}{625}Rv^2j\\ &+ \tfrac{107}{15000}RvB^2 + \tfrac{3}{2500}RvBj + \tfrac{121}{32500}RB^3 + \tfrac{11}{10000}RB^2j\\ &+ \tfrac{579}{20000}K^2v^2 + \tfrac{207}{2500}K^2vB + \tfrac{911}{975000}Kv^3 + \tfrac{349}{420000}Kv^2B\\ &+ \tfrac{5011}{5000}Kv^2j + \tfrac{133}{130000}KvB^2 + \tfrac{87}{2500}KvBj + \tfrac{1661507}{1521000000}v^4\\ &+ \tfrac{633799}{621075000}v^3B + \tfrac{10657}{1690000}v^2B^2. \end{aligned}(9)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let RR, KK, vv, bb, jj, zz and LL be real numbers. Then z2−12Rvb2+6v4=(z+Q(R,K,v,b))2+ST(R,v,j)+Σ(R,K,v,b,b−2v,j)+WF2(R,K,v,b,j,z,L)+L(x0v2+hbv)+ρ(R,K,v,b−2v,j).\begin{aligned} z^2 - 12Rvb^2 + 6v^4 ={}& \bigl(z + Q(R,K,v,b)\bigr)^2 + S\,T(R,v,j) + \Sigma(R,K,v,b,b - 2v,j)\\ &+ WF_2(R,K,v,b,j,z,L) + L\,(x_0v^2 + hbv) + \rho(R,K,v,b - 2v,j). \end{aligned}(10)✦ If RR, KK, vv, BB and jj are nonnegative real numbers, then ρ(R,K,v,B,j)≥16615071521000000v4.\rho(R,K,v,B,j) \ge \tfrac{1661507}{1521000000}\,v^4.(11)✦

What Is Checked

The identity (10) is stated for all real values of RR, KK, vv, bb, jj, zz and LL, over the quadratic forms QQ and TT, the weighted derivative WF2WF_2 of the cubic form F2F_2, the weighted sum of squares Σ\Sigma and the remainder ρ\rho, with the constants (1), and the bound (11) over the remainder alone, for all nonnegative values of RR, KK, vv, BB and jj.