OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Cancellation at disks and three local bounds · §2

Lemma 2.4 [Concentration in a thin shell]: Outside a set of area O(δ)O(\delta), a shell of radius r∈[1,2]r\in[1,2] and ν\nu-mass ≥U\ge U has all but 2U2U of its mass near one point

Off a small set, heavy thin shells concentrate near one point.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The centered maximal function MgMg of a function gg on the plane ℂ\mathbb C is the function whose value at a point x∈ℂx\in\mathbb C is the supremum over t>0t>0 of the averages ut=Atgu_t=A_t g of gg over the open disks B(x,t)={y∈ℂ:|y−x|<t}B(x,t)=\{y\in\mathbb C : |y-x|<t\}. Between two close radii t<t′t<t', the integral of gg over B(x,t)B(x,t) changes by its integral over the annulus t≤|y−x|<t′t\le|y-x|<t', so estimates on how utu_t varies with tt meet measures restricted to thin shells about circles centered at xx.

Mass at least UU of a finite positive measure ν\nu on a thin shell about the circle of center xx and radius rr may be spread along the circle, or gathered within a distance ρ\rho of one of its points, ρ\rho being large next to the width of the shell. The question is how large, in area, the set of centers xx can be about which some shell of radius between 11 and 22 is heavy with its mass spread, and how that area shrinks with the half-width δ\delta of the shell, the amount by which the distance to xx may differ from the radius.

Thin Shells

For a point x∈ℂx\in\mathbb C and real numbers rr and δ\delta, the thin shell D(x,r,δ)D(x,r,\delta) about the circle of center xx and radius rr is the set of points of ℂ\mathbb C whose distance to xx differs from rr by at most δ\delta: D(x,r,δ)={y∈ℂ:||y−x|−r|≤δ}.D(x,r,\delta)=\bigl\{y\in\mathbb C : \bigl|\,|y-x|-r\,\bigr|\le\delta\bigr\}.(1)✦ For 0<δ<r0<\delta<r it is a closed annulus, and the open disk B(x,r−δ)B(x,r-\delta) is the region it encloses.

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Concentration in a thin shell). Let ν\nu and SS be finite positive Borel measures on ℂ\mathbb C, and let ρ\rho, δ\delta, TT and UU be real numbers with 0<ρ≤10<\rho\le 1, 0<δ≤ρ2/16000<\delta\le\rho^2/1600, T≥0T\ge 0 and U>0U>0. There is a Borel set E⊂ℂE\subset\mathbb C whose Lebesgue measure satisfies |E|≤156δρν(ℂ)2U2+2400πδρ2(1+TU)ν(ℂ)U,|E|\le\frac{156\,\delta}{\rho}\,\frac{\nu(\mathbb C)^2}{U^2} +\frac{2400\pi\,\delta}{\rho^2}\Bigl(1+\frac{T}{U}\Bigr)\frac{\nu(\mathbb C)}{U},(2)✦ with the following property: whenever x∈ℂ\Ex\in\mathbb C\setminus E and 1≤r≤21\le r\le 2 are such that ν(D(x,r,δ))≥U\nu(D(x,r,\delta))\ge U and S(B(x,r−δ))≤TS(B(x,r-\delta))\le T, some point z∈D(x,r,δ)z\in D(x,r,\delta) satisfies (S+ν)(D(x,r,δ)\B(z,ρ))≤2U(S+\nu)\bigl(D(x,r,\delta)\setminus B(z,\rho)\bigr)\le 2U.

In the paper, the result reads: for finite positive Borel measures SS and ν\nu on ℝ2\mathbb R^2, U>0U>0, T≥0T\ge 0, 0<ρ≤10<\rho\le 1 and 0<δ≤ρ2/16000<\delta\le\rho^2/1600, there is a Borel set EE with |E|≤C[(ν(ℝ2)/U)2δ/ρ+(ν(ℝ2)/U)(δ/ρ2)(1+T/U)]|E|\le C\bigl[(\nu(\mathbb R^2)/U)^2\,\delta/\rho+(\nu(\mathbb R^2)/U)(\delta/\rho^2)(1+T/U)\bigr] for an absolute constant CC, such that for every x∉Ex\notin E and r∈[1,2]r\in[1,2] with ν(D(x,r,δ))≥U\nu(D(x,r,\delta))\ge U and S(B(x,r−δ))≤TS(B(x,r-\delta))\le T some z∈D(x,r,δ)z\in D(x,r,\delta) has (S+ν)(D(x,r,δ)\B(z,ρ))≤2U(S+\nu)(D(x,r,\delta)\setminus B(z,\rho))\le 2U, neither EE nor its bound depending on rr.

What Is Checked

The claim (2) is stated over two finite positive Borel measures ν\nu and SS on ℂ\mathbb C, Lebesgue measure on ℂ\mathbb C, the open disks B(x,t)B(x,t) and the thin shells D(x,r,δ)D(x,r,\delta) of (1), for 0<ρ≤10<\rho\le 1, 0<δ≤ρ2/16000<\delta\le\rho^2/1600, T≥0T\ge 0 and U>0U>0.