OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §9. Changing the predual

Lemma 9.1: A restriction isomorphism and equality of closed perturbation images

Changing preduals by perturbing a quotient.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The question is how a perturbation of a quotient map can replace a given predual by another while retaining the closed image under the perturbation.

Let 𝕜\mathbb{k} be ℝ\mathbb{R} or ℂ\mathbb{C}, and let EE be a Banach space over 𝕜\mathbb{k}. Write E*E^* for its continuous dual, with the usual operator norm and scalar multiplication. Let YY be a closed linear subspace of E*E^*, and let Q:E*→E*/YQ:E^*\to E^*/Y be the canonical quotient map. Closures in E*/YE^*/Y are taken in its quotient norm.

The restricted canonical evaluation on YY is the bounded linear map RY:E→Y*R_Y:E\to Y^* defined by (1). (RYe)(f)=f(e)(e∈E,f∈Y).(R_Y e)(f)=f(e) \qquad (e\in E,\ f\in Y).(1)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Lemma 9.1). Suppose that RYR_Y is a surjective isometry. Let B:E*→E*/YB:E^*\to E^*/Y be a bounded linear operator with ‖B‖≤1/10\lVert B\rVert\leq 1/10. Assume that composition with BB takes each functional w∈(E*/Y)*w\in(E^*/Y)^* to evaluation at some e∈Ee\in E, so that w(Bf)=f(e)w(Bf)=f(e) for every f∈E*f\in E^*, and assume that B(E*)⊆B(Y)¯B(E^*)\subseteq\overline{B(Y)}. The space X=ker⁡(Q−B)X=\ker(Q-B) is the linear subspace of E*E^* consisting of the functionals annihilated by Q−BQ-B.

Then XX is a Banach space, and there is a bounded linear isomorphism T:E→X*T:E\to X^* satisfying (2). (Te)(x)=x(e)(e∈E,x∈X),B(X)¯=B(Y)¯.(Te)(x)=x(e)\quad(e\in E,\ x\in X), \qquad \overline{B(X)}=\overline{B(Y)}.(2)✦

What Is Checked

The assertion (2) is stated over the usual normed continuous dual of a Banach space and the restricted canonical evaluation (1), with YY closed and BB satisfying the stated perturbation hypotheses.