The Setting
Let be the staircase partition of . Saxl’s conjecture asks that for every each irreducible representation of occur in the tensor square , that is, that the Kronecker coefficient be positive for every partition of . Inside the tensor square lies the cyclic module generated by the tensor of the polytabloids of two staircase tableaux, one the transpose of the other. The question here is whether occurs in when lies below the staircase in dominance order.
Words, Tableaux and Specht Modules
Write with basis . A word of length over letters is a map from the positions to the letters , and the vectors form a basis of ; a vector of is identified with its coefficient function .✦ The symmetric group acts on by permuting positions: (1)✦ For representations and of , is the space of intertwiners from to . The cyclic module of a vector of a representation of is the span of the translates , .
A Young tableau of shape on positions is a bijection from the positions to the cells of the Young diagram , a cell lying in row and column , both counted from .✦ The column stabilizer of is the subgroup of of the permutations such that lies in the column of for every position .✦ The row word of is the word over letters, the number of rows of , that sends each position to the row of .✦ The polytabloid of is the vector (2)✦ of , and the Specht module of is its cyclic module ✦; tableaux of the same shape give the same Specht module.
For a Young diagram and , let be the number of cells of in its first rows.✦ A Young diagram dominates a Young diagram , written , if (3)✦
The Staircase Cyclic Module
The staircase is the Young diagram of the cells with .✦ The staircase tableau is a tableau of shape on positions fixed once and for all, the canonical tableau of .✦ The row staircase tableau puts each position in the transpose of the cell .✦ The column stabilizer of is the row stabilizer of , the subgroup of of the permutations that keep each position in its row of . The row reversal is the permutation in that sends the position of the cell under to the position of ✦.
The row average of is the vector (4)✦ of .
A pair of letters , among letters and among , is one letter among , the basis vector of . Regrouping by position identifies with : for in and in , the coefficient of at the pair word , whose first and second factors are the words and , is (5) and with acting diagonally on the tensor product this is an isomorphism of representations.✦ The staircase word is (6)✦ and the staircase cyclic module is .✦
Sign Twists
The sign twist of a representation of is the same space with acting by times its action on .✦ The sign-cancelling map of an intertwiner is the same linear map, as an intertwiner (7)✦ For representations , , of and an intertwiner , the anti-tensor map of is the intertwiner (8)✦ acting diagonally on both tensor products. For an intertwiner of representations of , the same linear map is an intertwiner , the sign twist of .
The Dominated Quotient Map
On take the dot product . For a subrepresentation of that is closed under complex conjugation, the pairing is an isomorphism of representations from onto its dual, and the orthogonal projection sends to the vector of with for every in . The Specht module in is closed under complex conjugation.
Fix an isomorphism of representations . Let be the inclusion of into . The ambient sign map is the intertwiner (9) The paired antisymmetry map is the anti-tensor map of the ambient sign map , read through (5) as an intertwiner from to .
A linear map gives the intertwiner .✦ The pair sum map is , where sends to when and to otherwise.✦
The target word is the word on positions over letters that puts the letter at every position of row of .✦ For a word , the orbit projection is the intertwiner that projects onto the span of the over the rearrangements , , of , and sends every other basis vector to .✦ The dominated quotient map is the intertwiner (10)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let , let be a Young diagram dominated by the staircase, , and let be the Specht module of a tableau of shape on positions. Then (11)✦
What Is Checked
The claim (11) is stated over the Specht module of a tableau of shape on positions, the dominance order (3), the staircase and the cyclic module of the staircase word .
About the staircase the library states that (12)✦ as representations of . Its row average satisfies (13)✦ and for every isomorphism as in (12) there is a nonzero complex number with (14)✦ The signed average of the staircase word over is (15)✦
For pair sums the library states a rigidity. Let be a finite set, and real functions on , and a permutation of with and . If , and are permutations of with and , then (16)✦
On the staircase, the orbit projection of the pair sum of is (17)✦ and for every isomorphism as in (12) the dominated quotient map satisfies (18)✦