This item concerns the shrunk-subspace obstruction in the proof of Proposition 2.1 of the preprint: for a linear pencil of order over a field with coefficient matrices , subspaces with and for every , whose presence prevents the pencil from being invertible at matrices of positive order.
The Setting
Let be a field and the coefficient matrices of a linear pencil of order in homogeneous form. The test of the pencil at linear maps between vector spaces and over is the linear map from to that sends to the vector whose entry is (1)
The span of a vector is the subspace of spanned by its entries, and the maps carry it to .✦
Block Evaluation and Coefficient Matrices
Fix . The Kronecker block matrix of and is the matrix of order (2)✦ The block evaluation of at is the linear map on the space of families of vectors of that sends to the family with members (3)✦ up to the order of the basis, its matrix is .
Given a basis of the span of , the coefficient matrix of in that basis is the matrix whose row is the coordinate vector of , a vector of : (4)✦ The concatenation of with the pencil is the matrix (5) whose column is column of .
For vectors of , the image combination map of at is the linear map given by (6)✦ At the basis of , its image is .
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a field, , , and linear maps between vector spaces over .
Suppose that and that the block evaluation is injective. If lies in the kernel of the test (1) and its span has dimension , then (7)✦
Suppose that and that is injective. If and are subspaces of with for , then (8)✦
Let lie in the kernel of the test, let be a basis of its span , and let be the coefficient matrix of in that basis. If , then (9)✦
If the block matrix is invertible, then (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: a nonzero vector in the kernel of the test gives subspaces with , and for every , which no substitution of matrices with invertible allows.
What Is Checked
The claim is stated over the block matrix (2) and the block evaluation (3) of the coefficient matrices at , the test (1), the span of a vector with the coefficient matrix (4) of in a basis of and its concatenation (5), and the image combination map (6) at that basis.