OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Incompatible invariances

Proposition 5.4 [Vanishing of every quadratic plurisubharmonic form]: The local homogeneous classification and the incompatible invariances under the source automorphisms

Plurisubharmonic quadratic forms on the source vanish.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

On S=ℙ1×ℙ1S=\mathbb P^1\times\mathbb P^1, the three-graph construction determines a rank-two bundle GG from a divisor and lifts along it. Write F=G∨F=G^\vee for the dual bundle and fix the exponent b=24b=24.

A system of three graph parameters is a tuple T=(ζ,σ,p,q)∈ℂ4T=(\zeta,\sigma,p,q)\in\mathbb C^4 satisfying (1).✦ Its graph matrices are MT,0=IM_{T,0}=I, MT,1=ATM_{T,1}=A_T and MT,2=BTM_{T,2}=B_T, also given there.✦ ζ3=−1,σ(1−σ)=1+pq,p≠0,q≠0,σ+ζ2(1−σ)+2ζ=0,AT=(ζ00ζ−1),BT=(σpq1−σ).\begin{gathered} \zeta^3=-1,\qquad \sigma(1-\sigma)=1+pq,\qquad p\ne0,\quad q\ne0,\\ \sigma+\zeta^2(1-\sigma)+\sqrt2\,\zeta=0,\\ A_T=\begin{pmatrix}\zeta&0\\0&\zeta^{-1}\end{pmatrix},\qquad B_T=\begin{pmatrix}\sigma&p\\q&1-\sigma\end{pmatrix}. \end{gathered}(1)

The source tuple T0T_0 is specified by (2). The source linear automorphisms A,B∈GL2(ℂ)A,B\in\mathrm{GL}_2(\mathbb C) are AT0A_{T_0} and BT0B_{T_0}. The sixth root aa is the complex number eiπ/3e^{\mathrm i\pi/3}. The explicit parameter s∈ℂs\in\mathbb C is the value given in (2). a=eiπ/3,s=12−i(1+22)23,T0=(a,s,1,2/3).a=e^{\mathrm i\pi/3},\qquad s=\frac12-\frac{\mathrm i(1+2\sqrt2)}{2\sqrt3},\qquad T_0=(a,s,1,\sqrt2/3).(2)

The four standard affine charts have indices i=(i1,i2)∈{0,1}2i=(i_1,i_2)\in\{0,1\}^2 and base coordinates z=(x,y)∈ℂ2z=(x,y)\in\mathbb C^2. For ϵ,δ∈{0,1}\epsilon,\delta\in\{0,1\}, the normalized homogeneous representatives e0,e1e_0,e_1 and scalar coordinate changes κϵδ\kappa_{\epsilon\delta} are defined in (3). The scalar homogeneous transition factors are ρϵδ\rho_{\epsilon\delta}. e0(t)=(1t),e1(t)=(t1),κϵδ(t)={tϵ=δ,t−1ϵ≠δ,ρϵδ(t)={1ϵ=δ,tϵ≠δ.\begin{gathered} e_0(t)=\begin{pmatrix}1\\t\end{pmatrix},\qquad e_1(t)=\begin{pmatrix}t\\1\end{pmatrix},\\ \kappa_{\epsilon\delta}(t)= \begin{cases}t&\epsilon=\delta,\\t^{-1}&\epsilon\ne\delta,\end{cases} \qquad \rho_{\epsilon\delta}(t)= \begin{cases}1&\epsilon=\delta,\\t&\epsilon\ne\delta.\end{cases} \end{gathered}(3)

For two charts, the first and second transition factors are rij(z)=ρi1j1(x)r_{ij}(z)=\rho_{i_1j_1}(x) and tij(z)=ρi2j2(y)t_{ij}(z)=\rho_{i_2j_2}(y). Their overlap polynomial oijo_{ij}, overlap UijU_{ij} and coordinate change χij\chi_{ij} are specified by (4). oij=rijtij,Uij={z:oij(z)≠0},χij(x,y)=(κi1j1(x),κi2j2(y)).o_{ij}=r_{ij}t_{ij},\qquad U_{ij}=\{z:o_{ij}(z)\ne0\},\qquad \chi_{ij}(x,y)= \bigl(\kappa_{i_1j_1}(x),\kappa_{i_2j_2}(y)\bigr).(4)

Divisor and Lift Data

Divisor and lift data 𝒟=(di,ℓi)\mathcal D=(d_i,\ell_i) consist of polynomials in ℂ[x,y]\mathbb C[x,y] on each standard chart, with every did_i nonzero and squarefree, satisfying (5).✦ Here D⊂SD\subset S is the divisor with local equations di=0d_i=0. The lifts represent β=(α∨)−1\beta=(\alpha^\vee)^{-1}, where α\alpha is the isomorphism on the inverse line bundles along DD. di(z)=(rij(z)tij(z))3dj(χij(z))(z∈Uij),tij(z)24ℓj(χij(z))=ℓi(z)rij(z)24(z∈Uij,di(z)=0),ℓi(z)≠0(di(z)=0).\begin{gathered} d_i(z)=(r_{ij}(z)t_{ij}(z))^3d_j(\chi_{ij}(z)) \qquad(z\in U_{ij}),\\ t_{ij}(z)^{24}\ell_j(\chi_{ij}(z)) =\ell_i(z)r_{ij}(z)^{24} \qquad(z\in U_{ij},\ d_i(z)=0),\\ \ell_i(z)\ne0\qquad(d_i(z)=0). \end{gathered}(5)

For a complex 2×22\times2 matrix MM, the matrix graph equation gM,ig_{M,i} is the bivariate polynomial in (6).✦ The three-graph divisor equation dT,id_{T,i} is the product given there.✦ gM,i(x,y)=det⁡(ei2(y),Mei1(x)),dT,i=∏k=02gMT,k,i.g_{M,i}(x,y)=\det\bigl(e_{i_2}(y),Me_{i_1}(x)\bigr),\qquad d_{T,i}=\prod_{k=0}^2g_{M_{T,k},i}.(6)

The linear polynomials LT,JT∈ℂ[t]L_T,J_T\in\mathbb C[t] and the intersection polynomials PT,1,PT,2∈ℂ[t]P_{T,1},P_{T,2}\in\mathbb C[t] are defined by (7). LT(t)=σ−qt,JT(t)=p−(1−σ)t,PT,1(t)=qt2+(1−2σ)t−p,PT,2(t)=qt2+(ζ2(1−σ)−σ)t−ζ2p.\begin{aligned} L_T(t)&=\sigma-qt,& J_T(t)&=p-(1-\sigma)t,\\ P_{T,1}(t)&=qt^2+(1-2\sigma)t-p,& P_{T,2}(t)&=qt^2+(\zeta^2(1-\sigma)-\sigma)t-\zeta^2p. \end{aligned}(7)

The unmixed and mixed division quotients RT,0,RT,1∈ℂ[t]R_{T,0},R_{T,1}\in\mathbb C[t] are chosen to satisfy (8). LT24−1=PT,1PT,2RT,0,JT24−t24=PT,1PT,2RT,1.L_T^{24}-1=P_{T,1}P_{T,2}R_{T,0},\qquad J_T^{24}-t^{24}=P_{T,1}P_{T,2}R_{T,1}.(8)

A chart ii is mixed when i1≠i2i_1\ne i_2; let ϵi\epsilon_i be 11 in that case and 00 otherwise.✦ The identity and diagonal graph polynomials used for interpolation, and the chart-dependent linear polynomial KT,ϵK_{T,\epsilon}, are given in (9). G1,0=y−x,G1,1=xy−1,G2,T,0=y−ζ2x,G2,T,1=xy−ζ2,KT,0=LT,KT,1=JT.\begin{gathered} G_{1,0}=y-x,\qquad G_{1,1}=xy-1,\\ G_{2,T,0}=y-\zeta^2x,\qquad G_{2,T,1}=xy-\zeta^2,\\ K_{T,0}=L_T,\qquad K_{T,1}=J_T. \end{gathered}(9)

The inverted parameters are Tι=(ζ−1,1−σ,q,p)T^\iota=(\zeta^{-1},1-\sigma,q,p).✦ The local parameters are Ti=TιT_i=T^\iota when i2=0i_2=0 and Ti=TT_i=T when i2=1i_2=1.✦ The interpolating polynomial hT,ϵ∈ℂ[x,y]h_{T,\epsilon}\in\mathbb C[x,y] and chartwise lift ℓT,i\ell_{T,i} are defined by (10). The three-graph data are 𝒟T=(dT,i,ℓT,i)\mathcal D_T=(d_{T,i},\ell_{T,i}).✦ hT,ϵ(x,y)=y24ϵ+G1,ϵG2,T,ϵKT,ϵ(y)2RT,ϵ(y),ℓT,i=hTi,ϵi.h_{T,\epsilon}(x,y)=y^{24\epsilon} +G_{1,\epsilon}G_{2,T,\epsilon} K_{T,\epsilon}(y)^2R_{T,\epsilon}(y),\qquad \ell_{T,i}=h_{T_i,\epsilon_i}.(10)

A function k:U→ℂk:U\to\mathbb C, with U⊂ℂ2U\subset\mathbb C^2, is regular with a common denominator if k=p0/q0k=p_0/q_0 on UU for polynomials p0,q0∈ℂ[x,y]p_0,q_0\in\mathbb C[x,y] with q0q_0 nowhere zero on UU.✦ For divisor and lift data 𝒟\mathcal D, the lower-left transition coefficient kijk_{ij} is a choice of such a function satisfying the identity in (11).✦ The upper diagonal factor uiju_{ij}, lower diagonal factor wijw_{ij} and quotient line factor qijq_{ij} specify the transition numerator nijn_{ij} and matrix CijC_{ij} there. uij=rij24,wij=rij−3tij21,qij=tij24,nij(z)=qij(z)ℓj(χij(z))−ℓi(z)uij(z),di(z)kij(z)=nij(z)(z∈Uij),Cij(z)=(uij(z)0kij(z)wij(z)).\begin{gathered} u_{ij}=r_{ij}^{24},\qquad w_{ij}=r_{ij}^{-3}t_{ij}^{21},\qquad q_{ij}=t_{ij}^{24},\\ n_{ij}(z)=q_{ij}(z)\ell_j(\chi_{ij}(z))-\ell_i(z)u_{ij}(z),\\ d_i(z)k_{ij}(z)=n_{ij}(z)\quad(z\in U_{ij}),\qquad C_{ij}(z)=\begin{pmatrix}u_{ij}(z)&0\\k_{ij}(z)&w_{ij}(z)\end{pmatrix}. \end{gathered}(11)

Quadratic Forms and Homogeneity

A real function uu on a plane set Ω\Omega is subharmonic if it is upper semicontinuous and satisfies (12) for every x∈Ωx\in\Omega and every r>0r>0 with B(x,r)¯⊂Ω\overline{B(x,r)}\subset\Omega, with uu integrable on B(x,r)B(x,r).✦ Here dAdA is planar Lebesgue measure and |B(x,r)||B(x,r)| is the disc’s area. |B(x,r)|u(x)≤∫B(x,r)u(y)dA(y).|B(x,r)|u(x)\le\int_{B(x,r)}u(y)\,dA(y).(12)

A real function q:Ω→ℝq:\Omega\to\mathbb R on a subset Ω\Omega of a complex normed vector space is plurisubharmonic if it is upper semicontinuous and its pullback by every holomorphic map from an open plane set into Ω\Omega is subharmonic.✦ A plurisubharmonic dual form QQ for 𝒟\mathcal D is a finite real-valued function on the dual total space whose local functions QiQ_i are plurisubharmonic on all of ℂ2×ℂ2\mathbb C^2\times\mathbb C^2 and satisfy (13).✦ At every base point, Hi(z)H_i(z) is a Hermitian positive semidefinite 2×22\times2 matrix, and v*v^* denotes the conjugate transpose of the fiber vector v∈ℂ2v\in\mathbb C^2. Qi(z,v)=Re⁡(v*Hi(z)v),Qi(z,v)=Qj(χij(z),Cij(z)𝗍v)(z∈Uij).\begin{gathered} Q_i(z,v)=\operatorname{Re}\bigl(v^*H_i(z)v\bigr),\\ Q_i(z,v)=Q_j\bigl(\chi_{ij}(z),C_{ij}(z)^{\mathsf t}v\bigr) \qquad(z\in U_{ij}). \end{gathered}(13)

A real function uu on a plane set Ω\Omega satisfies the local disc submean condition if it is upper semicontinuous and, at each x∈Ωx\in\Omega, there is one r>0r>0 with B(x,r)¯⊂Ω\overline{B(x,r)}\subset\Omega for which uu is integrable and (12) holds.✦

A homogeneous local plurisubharmonic metric ψ:ℂ2→ℝ\psi:\mathbb C^2\to\mathbb R of exponent 2424 is a nonnegative function, upper semicontinuous away from the origin, satisfying (14) and the following disc condition.✦ For every open U⊂ℂU\subset\mathbb C and holomorphic maps f:U→ℂ2\{0}f:U\to\mathbb C^2\setminus\{0\} and t:U→ℂt:U\to\mathbb C, the function z↦|t(z)|2ψ(f(z))z\mapsto |t(z)|^2\psi(f(z)) satisfies the local disc submean condition on UU. Write ℋ24\mathcal H_{24} for these metrics. ψ(cv)=|c|48ψ(v)(c∈ℂ,v∈ℂ2).\psi(cv)=|c|^{48}\psi(v)\qquad(c\in\mathbb C,\ v\in\mathbb C^2).(14)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let QQ be a plurisubharmonic dual form for the source data 𝒟T0\mathcal D_{T_0} on FF. Its values satisfy (15) on every standard chart. Qi(z,v)=0(z∈ℂ2,v∈ℂ2).Q_i(z,v)=0\qquad(z\in\mathbb C^2,\ v\in\mathbb C^2).(15)✦

Let ψ∈ℋ24\psi\in\mathcal H_{24} be invariant under the source automorphisms AA and BB. Then (16) holds. ψ(v)=0(v∈ℂ2).\psi(v)=0\qquad(v\in\mathbb C^2).(16)✦

Let λ>1\lambda>1 be real and let ψ∈ℋ24\psi\in\mathcal H_{24} be invariant under diag⁡(λ,λ−1)\operatorname{diag}(\lambda,\lambda^{-1}). Writing v=(v1,v2)v=(v_1,v_2) for a vector in ℂ2\mathbb C^2, there is a real constant C≥0C\ge0 such that (17) holds. ψ(v)=C(|v1||v2|)24(v∈ℂ2).\psi(v)=C\bigl(|v_1|\,|v_2|\bigr)^{24}\qquad(v\in\mathbb C^2).(17)✦

What Is Checked

The assertions concern the source data 𝒟T0\mathcal D_{T_0} and their dual bundle, and the functions in ℋ24\mathcal H_{24} with the indicated linear invariances.

The source tuple T0T_0 satisfies (1), including its cube and relative trace relations. The inverted tuple TιT^\iota is again a system of graph parameters.

For every system TT of graph parameters, the equations dT,id_{T,i} are nonzero✦ and squarefree✦ and have the bidegree (3,3)(3,3) transition rule in (5).✦ The lifts ℓT,i\ell_{T,i} obey its lift gluing rule✦ and are nonvanishing along the divisor.✦ Polynomial quotients satisfying (8) exist.✦ For every pair of charts, the regular lower coefficient in (11) exists for any divisor and lift data.✦