OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Incompatible invariances

Lemma 5.1 [Reduction to a common invariant line seminorm]: Quadratic values constant along the rulings and identified by the three graph matrices

Graph restrictions identify the two line forms.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

On S=ℙ1×ℙ1S=\mathbb P^1\times\mathbb P^1, let GG be the bundle arising from divisor and lift data, and consider a finite plurisubharmonic quadratic form on its dual F=G∨F=G^\vee. Its two line restrictions concern the two factors of SS; their dependence on the opposite ruling and their identifications along three graphs are the subject of the lemma.

The standard affine charts Ui≃ℂ2U_i\simeq\mathbb C^2 have indices i=(i1,i2)∈{0,1}2i=(i_1,i_2)\in\{0,1\}^2 and coordinates z=(z1,z2)z=(z_1,z_2). For u∈ℂu\in\mathbb C, r,t∈{0,1}r,t\in\{0,1\} and chart indices i,j∈{0,1}2i,j\in\{0,1\}^2, the normalized homogeneous representatives, projective coordinate changes and homogeneous transition factors are those of (1); the complementary index to rr is 1−r1-r. uˆ0=(1,u),uˆ1=(u,1),τrt(u)={ur=t,u−1r≠t,trt(u)={1r=t,ur≠t,τij(z)=(τi1j1(z1),τi2j2(z2)),t1=ti1j1(z1),t2=ti2j2(z2).\begin{aligned} \widehat u_0&=(1,u),&\widehat u_1&=(u,1),\\ \tau_{rt}(u)&=\begin{cases}u&r=t,\\u^{-1}&r\ne t,\end{cases} &t_{rt}(u)&=\begin{cases}1&r=t,\\u&r\ne t,\end{cases}\\ \tau_{ij}(z)&=(\tau_{i_1j_1}(z_1),\tau_{i_2j_2}(z_2)), &t_1&=t_{i_1j_1}(z_1),\qquad t_2=t_{i_2j_2}(z_2). \end{aligned}(1) The overlap is the locus where the overlap polynomial t1t2t_1t_2 is nonzero.✦ Local polynomial equations belong to ℂ[z1,z2]\mathbb C[z_1,z_2], and evaluation means substitution of the base coordinates.

Divisor and lift data 𝒟=(di,ℓi)\mathcal D=(d_i,\ell_i) consist of nonzero squarefree polynomials did_i defining a reduced divisor DD, and polynomials ℓi\ell_i satisfying (2) on overlaps.✦ The lifts represent the line bundle identification β=(α∨)−1\beta=(\alpha^\vee)^{-1} along DD, where α\alpha is the corresponding identification on inverse line bundles; the exponent is fixed at b=24b=24. di(z)=(t1t2)3dj(τij(z)),t224ℓj(τij(z))=ℓi(z)t124when di(z)=0,ℓi(z)≠0when di(z)=0.\begin{aligned} d_i(z)&=(t_1t_2)^3d_j(\tau_{ij}(z)),\\ t_2^{24}\ell_j(\tau_{ij}(z))&=\ell_i(z)t_1^{24} &&\text{when }d_i(z)=0,\\ \ell_i(z)&\ne0&&\text{when }d_i(z)=0. \end{aligned}(2)

A function ff on an overlap of affine charts is regular with a common denominator if it is a quotient of two bivariate polynomials whose denominator is nowhere zero on that overlap.✦ A lower transition coefficient kijk_{ij} on the overlap of UiU_i and UjU_j is a quotient of two bivariate polynomials with denominator nowhere zero on the overlap satisfying (3), which also defines its numerator NijN_{ij} and the local transition matrix CijC_{ij}. The quotient line transition factor is t224t_2^{24}.✦ Nij(z)=t224ℓj(τij(z))−ℓi(z)t124,di(z)kij(z)=Nij(z),Cij(z)=(t1240kij(z)t1−3t221).\begin{aligned} N_{ij}(z)&=t_2^{24}\ell_j(\tau_{ij}(z))-\ell_i(z)t_1^{24}, &d_i(z)k_{ij}(z)&=N_{ij}(z),\\ C_{ij}(z)&=\begin{pmatrix}t_1^{24}&0\\k_{ij}(z)&t_1^{-3}t_2^{21}\end{pmatrix}. \end{aligned}(3)

The Quadratic Restrictions

A real function uu on a subset Ω⊆ℂ\Omega\subseteq\mathbb C is subharmonic there if it is upper semicontinuous on Ω\Omega and, for every positive-radius disc centered in Ω\Omega whose closed disc lies in Ω\Omega, is integrable on the open disc and has its value at the center bounded by its disc average.✦ A real function ff on a complex vector space is plurisubharmonic on a subset EE if it is upper semicontinuous on EE and has subharmonic pullback under every holomorphic map from a plane domain into EE.✦

A plurisubharmonic dual form qq on FF is one finite real total-space function whose local functions qiq_i are plurisubharmonic on all of ℂ2×ℂ2\mathbb C^2\times\mathbb C^2 and satisfy (4).✦ Here the fiber coordinates are ξ∈ℂ2\xi\in\mathbb C^2, and each Hi(z)H_i(z) is a positive semidefinite Hermitian 2×22\times2 complex matrix; zero is allowed, including over DD. qi(z,ξ)=Re⁡(ξ¯tHi(z)ξ),qi(z,ξ)=qj(τij(z),Cij(z)tξ)on overlaps.\begin{aligned} q_i(z,\xi)&=\operatorname{Re}\bigl(\overline\xi^{\,t}H_i(z)\xi\bigr),\\ q_i(z,\xi)&=q_j\bigl(\tau_{ij}(z),C_{ij}(z)^t\xi\bigr) &&\text{on overlaps}. \end{aligned}(4) For a fiber scalar c∈ℂc\in\mathbb C, the first and second restricted quadratic forms ni(1),ni(2)n_i^{(1)},n_i^{(2)} of qq are the functions in (5). ni(1)(z;c)=qi(z,(c,0)),ni(2)(z;c)=qi(z,c(ℓi(z),di(z))).n_i^{(1)}(z;c)=q_i(z,(c,0)),\qquad n_i^{(2)}(z;c)=q_i\bigl(z,c(\ell_i(z),d_i(z))\bigr).(5)

A plurisubharmonic line form hh on 𝒪ℙ1(−24)\mathcal O_{\mathbb P^1}(-24) is a finite, nonnegative function whose local functions hr(u,c)h_r(u,c) are plurisubharmonic on ℂ×ℂ\mathbb C\times\mathbb C and obey (6) for every scalar λ∈ℂ\lambda\in\mathbb C; the second identity is required when r=tr=t or u≠0u\ne0. hr(u,λc)=|λ|2hr(u,c),hr(u,c)=ht(τrt(u),trt(u)24c).h_r(u,\lambda c)=|\lambda|^2h_r(u,c),\qquad h_r(u,c)=h_t\bigl(\tau_{rt}(u),t_{rt}(u)^{24}c\bigr).(6) The first and second descended line forms a(1),a(2)a^{(1)},a^{(2)} of qq on 𝒪ℙ1(−24)\mathcal O_{\mathbb P^1}(-24) are the restrictions in (7). ar(1)(u,c)=n(r,0)(1)((u,0);c),ar(2)(u,c)=n(0,r)(2)((0,u);c).a_r^{(1)}(u,c)=n_{(r,0)}^{(1)}((u,0);c),\qquad a_r^{(2)}(u,c)=n_{(0,r)}^{(2)}((0,u);c).(7) The homogeneous function HhH_h of degree 4848 associated to a line form hh is defined by (8), with r=0r=0 when x0≠0x_0\ne0 and r=1r=1 otherwise for a nonzero vector x=(x0,x1)x=(x_0,x_1).✦ Write H1=Ha(1)H_1=H_{a^{(1)}} and H2=Ha(2)H_2=H_{a^{(2)}}. Hh(x)=hr(x1−rxr,xr24)(x≠0),Hh(0)=0.H_h(x)=h_r\left(\frac{x_{1-r}}{x_r},x_r^{24}\right) \quad(x\ne0),\qquad H_h(0)=0.(8) For x∈ℂ2x\in\mathbb C^2, its affine projective coordinate in chart rr is the ratio of its component with complementary index to its component with index rr, with value zero when the denominator vanishes.

The Three Graphs

Three graph parameters T=(a,s,μ,ν)∈ℂ4T=(a,s,\mu,\nu)\in\mathbb C^4 are complex numbers satisfying (9).✦ Their graph matrices are the identity matrix M0=IM_0=I, the diagonal matrix M1=A=diag⁡(a,a−1)M_1=A=\operatorname{diag}(a,a^{-1}) and the matrix M2=B=(sμν1−s)M_2=B=\begin{pmatrix}s&\mu\\\nu&1-s\end{pmatrix}.✦ a3=−1,s(1−s)=1+μν,s+a2(1−s)+2a=0,μ≠0,ν≠0.a^3=-1,\qquad s(1-s)=1+\mu\nu,\qquad s+a^2(1-s)+\sqrt2\,a=0,\qquad \mu\ne0,\quad\nu\ne0.(9) For a 2×22\times2 complex matrix MM and a chart index ii, the matrix graph equation gM,ig_{M,i} and the three-graph divisor equation dT,id_{T,i} are the polynomials in (10). gM,i(z)=det⁡(z2ˆi2,Mz1ˆi1),dT,i(z)=∏k=02gMk,i(z).g_{M,i}(z)=\det\bigl(\widehat{z_2}_{i_2},M\widehat{z_1}_{i_1}\bigr),\qquad d_{T,i}(z)=\prod_{k=0}^2g_{M_k,i}(z).(10)

The linear polynomials L,JL,J and the intersection polynomials P1,P2P_1,P_2 are given in (11); choose unmixed and mixed division quotients R0,R1∈ℂ[X]R_0,R_1\in\mathbb C[X] satisfying its last two identities. L(X)=s−νX,J(X)=μ−(1−s)X,P1(X)=νX2+(1−2s)X−μ,P2(X)=νX2+(a2(1−s)−s)X−a2μ,L24−1=P1P2R0,J24−X24=P1P2R1.\begin{aligned} L(X)&=s-\nu X,&J(X)&=\mu-(1-s)X,\\ P_1(X)&=\nu X^2+(1-2s)X-\mu, &P_2(X)&=\nu X^2+\bigl(a^2(1-s)-s\bigr)X-a^2\mu,\\ L^{24}-1&=P_1P_2R_0,&J^{24}-X^{24}&=P_1P_2R_1. \end{aligned}(11) An affine chart UiU_i of SS is mixed when i1≠i2i_1\ne i_2; let ϵ=1\epsilon=1 in that case and ϵ=0\epsilon=0 otherwise. The identity and diagonal graph polynomials used in interpolation are G1,ϵG_{1,\epsilon} and G2,ϵG_{2,\epsilon} from (12). G1,0(z)=z2−z1,G1,1(z)=z1z2−1,G2,0(z)=z2−a2z1,G2,1(z)=z1z2−a2.\begin{aligned} G_{1,0}(z)&=z_2-z_1,&G_{1,1}(z)&=z_1z_2-1,\\ G_{2,0}(z)&=z_2-a^2z_1,&G_{2,1}(z)&=z_1z_2-a^2. \end{aligned}(12) The interpolating lift polynomial ℓT,ϵ\ell_{T,\epsilon} is defined in (13), where (h0,h1)=(1,z224)(h_0,h_1)=(1,z_2^{24}) and the chart-dependent linear polynomials are (K0,K1)=(L,J)(K_0,K_1)=(L,J). ℓT,ϵ(z)=hϵ+G1,ϵ(z)G2,ϵ(z)Kϵ(z2)2Rϵ(z2).\ell_{T,\epsilon}(z)=h_\epsilon+ G_{1,\epsilon}(z)G_{2,\epsilon}(z)K_\epsilon(z_2)^2R_\epsilon(z_2).(13) The inverted parameters are T̃=(a−1,1−s,ν,μ)\widetilde T=(a^{-1},1-s,\nu,\mu).✦ The local graph parameters TiT_i equal T̃\widetilde T when i2=0i_2=0 and TT otherwise.✦ For each chart ii, write ϵi\epsilon_i for its mixed-chart indicator; the chartwise lift is ℓTi,ϵi\ell_{T_i,\epsilon_i}, and the three graph divisor and lift data 𝒟T\mathcal D_T consist of these lifts and the equations dT,id_{T,i}.

The explicit parameters T*T_* are those in (14). T*=(a*,s*,1,2/3),a*=eiπ/3,s*=12−i(1+22)23.T_*=(a_*,s_*,1,\sqrt2/3),\qquad a_*=e^{i\pi/3},\qquad s_*=\frac12-\frac{i(1+2\sqrt2)}{2\sqrt3}.(14)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let 𝒟\mathcal D be divisor and lift data, and let qq be a plurisubharmonic dual form. For chart indices i,j,k∈{0,1}i,j,k\in\{0,1\} and z,y,w,c∈ℂz,y,w,c\in\mathbb C, the first restriction satisfies (15) and the second satisfies (16). n(i,j)(1)((z,y);c)=n(i,k)(1)((z,w);c).n_{(i,j)}^{(1)}((z,y);c)=n_{(i,k)}^{(1)}((z,w);c).(15)✦ n(j,i)(2)((y,z);c)=n(k,i)(2)((w,z);c).n_{(j,i)}^{(2)}((y,z);c)=n_{(k,i)}^{(2)}((w,z);c).(16)✦ For three graph parameters TT, take 𝒟=𝒟T\mathcal D=\mathcal D_T. For k∈{0,1,2}k\in\{0,1,2\} and x∈ℂ2x\in\mathbb C^2 with x≠0x\ne0 and Mkx≠0M_kx\ne0, the graph identification is (17). H1(x)=H2(Mkx).H_1(x)=H_2(M_kx).(17)✦ For T=T*T=T_*, the homogeneous functions satisfy (18) for every x∈ℂ2x\in\mathbb C^2. H1(x)=H2(x).H_1(x)=H_2(x).(18)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for the bundle GG of Proposition 2.3, every finite, nonnegative, nonzero plurisubharmonic function qq on F=G∨F=G^\vee that is Hermitian quadratic on every fiber gives a finite, nonnegative, nonzero plurisubharmonic function a•a_\bullet on 𝒪ℙ1(−24)\mathcal O_{\mathbb P^1}(-24), positive semidefinite Hermitian quadratic on every fiber, with a•(Mx,M⊗24v)=a•(x,v)a_\bullet(Mx,M^{\otimes24}v)=a_\bullet(x,v) for M=A,BM=A,B and every base point xx and fiber vector vv.

What Is Checked

The ruling statements are stated over arbitrary divisor and lift data and a compatible plurisubharmonic dual form; the graph statement uses 𝒟T\mathcal D_T, and the final equality uses the explicit parameters T*T_*.

Every transition numerator in (3) admits a lower coefficient regular with a common denominator on its overlap.✦ The division quotients in (11) exist for every set of graph parameters.✦ The inverted parameters again satisfy (9), as do the explicit values in (14). The three-graph equations in (10) are nonzero✦ and squarefree, with the bidegree (3,3)(3,3) changes in (2).✦ The chartwise lifts from (13) satisfy the lift gluing rule in (2)✦ and are nowhere zero on the divisor.✦