OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction

Theorem 1.1 [Ample bundles without Griffiths-positive metrics]: On SS, the product of two projective lines, positive power pullbacks twisted by 𝒪S(1,1)\mathcal O_S(1,1) eventually lack smooth strictly Griffiths-positive metrics

Ample bundles without Griffiths-positive metrics.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let S=ℙ1×ℙ1S=\mathbb P^1\times\mathbb P^1 and P=𝒪S(1,1)P=\mathcal O_S(1,1). The question is whether ampleness forces a rank-two bundle on SS to admit a smooth strictly Griffiths-positive Hermitian metric.

Write UiU_i for the standard affine chart of SS indexed by i=(i1,i2)∈{0,1}2i=(i_1,i_2)\in\{0,1\}^2. Its coordinates (z,w)∈ℂ2(z,w)\in\mathbb C^2 are specified by the representatives in (1); changing either index replaces the corresponding coordinate by its reciprocal. x0(z)=(1,z),x1(z)=(z,1),(z,w)↦([xi1(z)],[xi2(w)]).x_0(z)=(1,z),\qquad x_1(z)=(z,1),\qquad (z,w)\longmapsto ([x_{i_1}(z)],[x_{i_2}(w)]).(1) On Ui∩UjU_i\cap U_j, let ϕij\phi_{ij} be this coordinate change, and put rij=1r_{ij}=1 when i1=j1i_1=j_1 and rij=zr_{ij}=z otherwise; define tijt_{ij} similarly using the second coordinate. The overlap in UiU_i is {rijtij≠0}\{r_{ij}t_{ij}\ne0\}.✦ These factors are the transitions of the two hyperplane line bundles; their product is the transition of PP.

A principal affine chart Ui,p⊂UiU_{i,p}\subset U_i is the locus p(z,w)≠0p(z,w)\ne0 for a polynomial p∈ℂ[z,w]p\in\mathbb C[z,w].✦ A function ff on an affine domain Ω\Omega is algebraically regular if, near each point of Ω\Omega, it is a quotient of polynomials with denominator nonzero there.✦ A function ff on an affine domain Ω\Omega is regular with a common denominator if a quotient of polynomials represents ff throughout Ω\Omega and its denominator vanishes nowhere on Ω\Omega.✦

An algebraic rank-two bundle VV on SS is a bundle trivialized on a finite cover by principal affine charts, with regular 2×22\times2 complex transition matrices τij\tau_{ij} satisfying (2).✦ Its dual transition matrix is Aij=τji𝖳A_{ij}=\tau_{ji}^{\mathsf T}.✦ τii=I,τijτjk=τikon the respective overlaps.\tau_{ii}=I,\qquad \tau_{ij}\tau_{jk}=\tau_{ik} \quad\text{on the respective overlaps}.(2)

For a positive integer mm, the power map fm:S→Sf_m:S\to S and the polarized power pullback EmE_m of a bundle GG are given by (3). fm([x0:x1],[y0:y1])=([x0m:x1m],[y0m:y1m]),Em=fm*G⊗P,τijEm(x)=(rijtij)(x)τijG(fm(x)).\begin{aligned} f_m([x_0:x_1],[y_0:y_1]) &=([x_0^m:x_1^m],[y_0^m:y_1^m]),\\ E_m&=f_m^*G\otimes P,\qquad \tau^{E_m}_{ij}(x)=(r_{ij}t_{ij})(x)\, \tau^G_{ij}(f_m(x)). \end{aligned}(3) The principal chart equations for this pullback are pi(zm,wm)p_i(z^m,w^m) when those of GG are pi(z,w)p_i(z,w).✦

Ampleness and Curvature

For a nonnegative integer nn, a section ss of Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^n V is a collection of homogeneous fiber polynomials with regular coefficients, compatible with the dual transitions as in (4).✦ Here v=(v0,v1)∈ℂ2v=(v_0,v_1)\in\mathbb C^2 is a dual fiber coordinate.✦ si(x,v)=∑k=0naik(x)v0kv1n−k,si(x,Aij(x)v)=sj(x,v).s_i(x,v)=\sum_{k=0}^n a_{ik}(x)v_0^kv_1^{n-k},\qquad s_i(x,A_{ij}(x)v)=s_j(x,v).(4) For NN such sections, their evaluation vector is σi(x,v)=(s1,i(x,v),…,sN,i(x,v))\sigma_i(x,v)=(s_{1,i}(x,v),\ldots,s_{N,i}(x,v)). A homogeneous algebraic cone CC in ℂN\mathbb C^N is a subset that is the common zero locus of a collection of homogeneous polynomials.✦

A collection s1,…,sNs_1,\ldots,s_N of sections of Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^n V gives a closed projective embedding of ℙ(V∨)\mathbb P(V^\vee) when its evaluation vector is nonzero on every nonzero dual vector, proportional evaluation vectors identify precisely the same point of ℙ(V∨)\mathbb P(V^\vee), and the cone over its image is homogeneous algebraic, with the origin included. The inverse is required to be regular locally on the image: the two base coordinates and a fiber ratio are quotients of polynomials in normalized evaluation coordinates, on domains where their denominators do not vanish. A bundle VV on SS is ample if some positive symmetric power has a finite collection of sections giving a closed projective embedding of ℙ(V∨)\mathbb P(V^\vee).✦

A smooth Hermitian metric hh on VV is represented on the dual bundle by smooth positive definite Hermitian matrices HiH_i satisfying (5). Hj(x)=Aij(x)*Hi(x)Aij(x).H_j(x)=A_{ij}(x)^*H_i(x)A_{ij}(x).(5)✦ For a smooth matrix function HH on an affine coordinate domain and a tangent vector u∈ℂ2u\in\mathbb C^2, its holomorphic derivative and mixed Hessian are (6), where DuD_u denotes real directional differentiation. ∂uH=12(DuH−iDiuH),Huu‾=14(Du2H+Diu2H).\partial_u H=\tfrac12(D_uH-\mathrm iD_{\mathrm iu}H),\qquad H_{u\bar u}=\tfrac14(D_u^2H+D_{\mathrm iu}^2H).(6) A smooth Hermitian metric hh on VV satisfying (5) is strictly Griffiths-positive if its matrices obey (7) at every point of every coordinate domain. Hi,uu‾−(∂uHi)*Hi−1∂uHi>0(u≠0).H_{i,u\bar u}-(\partial_uH_i)^*H_i^{-1}\partial_uH_i>0 \qquad (u\ne0).(7)✦ Write ℳ+(V)\mathcal M^+(V) for the set of smooth Hermitian metrics on VV satisfying (7), with the derivatives of (6).

The Three-graph Bundle

A system of graph parameters is a tuple T=(a,s,η,θ)∈ℂ4T=(a,s,\eta,\theta)\in\mathbb C^4 satisfying (8); its associated matrices are given in (9). The exponent in the construction is fixed at b=24b=24. a3=−1,s(1−s)=1+ηθ,s+a2(1−s)+2a=0,ηθ≠0.a^3=-1,\qquad s(1-s)=1+\eta\theta,\qquad s+a^2(1-s)+\sqrt2a=0,\qquad \eta\theta\ne0.(8) M1=I,M2=(a00a−1),M3=(sηθ1−s).M_1=I,\qquad M_2=\begin{pmatrix}a&0\\0&a^{-1}\end{pmatrix},\qquad M_3=\begin{pmatrix}s&\eta\\\theta&1-s\end{pmatrix}.(9) For a matrix MM, its graph equation in UiU_i is qM,i=y0(Mx)1−y1(Mx)0q_{M,i}=y_0(Mx)_1-y_1(Mx)_0, where x=xi1(z)x=x_{i_1}(z) and y=xi2(w)y=x_{i_2}(w) use (1).✦ The three-graph divisor DD on SS is the divisor with local equation di=qM1,iqM2,iqM3,id_i=q_{M_1,i}q_{M_2,i}q_{M_3,i}, using (9).✦

Divisor and lift data on SS consist of nonzero squarefree polynomials did_i and polynomials ℓi\ell_i, nonvanishing on {di=0}\{d_i=0\}, satisfying (10) on overlaps.✦ The second equality is required only on the divisor. di=(rijtij)3(dj∘ϕij),tij24(ℓj∘ϕij)=ℓirij24on {di=0}.\begin{aligned} d_i&=(r_{ij}t_{ij})^3(d_j\circ\phi_{ij}),\\ t_{ij}^{24}(\ell_j\circ\phi_{ij})&=\ell_i r_{ij}^{24} \qquad\text{on }\{d_i=0\}. \end{aligned}(10)

The graph lift is an interpolation polynomial. For parameters TT, define the one-variable polynomials in (11); RR and R′R' are polynomial quotients satisfying the last line. L(t)=s−θt,J(t)=η−(1−s)t,P1(t)=θt2+(1−2s)t−η,P2(t)=θt2+(a2(1−s)−s)t−a2η,L24−1=P1P2R,J24−t24=P1P2R′.\begin{aligned} L(t)&=s-\theta t,& J(t)&=\eta-(1-s)t,\\ P_1(t)&=\theta t^2+(1-2s)t-\eta,& P_2(t)&=\theta t^2+(a^2(1-s)-s)t-a^2\eta,\\ L^{24}-1&=P_1P_2R,&J^{24}-t^{24}&=P_1P_2R'. \end{aligned}(11) Let ε=0\varepsilon=0 on unmixed charts, whose two indices agree, and ε=1\varepsilon=1 on mixed charts, whose indices differ. Set g1,0=w−zg_{1,0}=w-z, g2,0=w−a2zg_{2,0}=w-a^2z, g1,1=zw−1g_{1,1}=zw-1 and g2,1=zw−a2g_{2,1}=zw-a^2. The two lift polynomials are (12), with the quotients from (11). λT,0(z,w)=1+g1,0g2,0L(w)2R(w),λT,1(z,w)=w24+g1,1g2,1J(w)2R′(w).\lambda_{T,0}(z,w)=1+g_{1,0}g_{2,0}L(w)^2R(w),\qquad \lambda_{T,1}(z,w)=w^{24}+g_{1,1}g_{2,1}J(w)^2R'(w).(12)✦ The chartwise lift ℓi\ell_i on UiU_i is the polynomial λTi,ε\lambda_{T_i,\varepsilon} from (12), where Ti=(a−1,1−s,θ,η)T_i=(a^{-1},1-s,\theta,\eta) if i2=0i_2=0 and Ti=TT_i=T if i2=1i_2=1; all polynomials in that formula use TiT_i. The identity graph equation is g1,εg_{1,ε}. The diagonal graph equation for TT is g2,εg_{2,ε}, with the same chart convention. The inverted graph parameters of T=(a,s,η,θ)T=(a,s,\eta,\theta) are (a−1,1−s,θ,η)(a^{-1},1-s,\theta,\eta); they again satisfy (8). The linear polynomial L(t)L(t) has constant coefficient ss and coefficient −θ-\theta of tt. The linear polynomial J(t)J(t) has constant coefficient η\eta and coefficient −(1−s)-(1-s) of tt. The first intersection polynomial P1(t)P_1(t) is the quadratic with coefficients θ\theta, 1−2s1-2s and −η-\eta in descending degree. The second intersection polynomial P2(t)P_2(t) is the quadratic with coefficients θ\theta, a2(1−s)−sa^2(1-s)-s and −a2η-a^2\eta in descending degree.

The bundle GG on SS associated to divisor and lift data in (10) is the bundle with the four standard affine trivializations and transition matrices (13).✦ The lower coefficient kijk_{ij} is regular with a common denominator on {rijtij≠0}\{r_{ij}t_{ij}\ne0\}. τij=(rij240kijrij−3tij21),dikij=tij24(ℓj∘ϕij)−ℓirij24.\begin{aligned} \tau_{ij}&=\begin{pmatrix} r_{ij}^{24}&0\\ k_{ij}&r_{ij}^{-3}t_{ij}^{21} \end{pmatrix},\\ d_i k_{ij}&=t_{ij}^{24}(\ell_j\circ\phi_{ij})-\ell_i r_{ij}^{24}. \end{aligned}(13) Let G*G_* denote the bundle on SS with transition matrices (13) for the graph divisor and lifts determined by the explicit graph parameters in (14). a*=eiπ/3,s*=12−i(1+22)23,η*=1,θ*=23.a_*=e^{\mathrm i\pi/3},\qquad s_*=\frac12-\frac{\mathrm i(1+2\sqrt2)}{2\sqrt3},\qquad \eta_*=1,\qquad \theta_*=\frac{\sqrt2}{3}.(14)✦ The upper diagonal transition factor in (13) is rij24r_{ij}^{24}. On the lower diagonal, the transition factor is rij−3tij21r_{ij}^{-3}t_{ij}^{21}. For the quotient line, the transition factor is tij24t_{ij}^{24}. The transition coefficient numerator is the difference tij24(ℓj∘ϕij)−ℓirij24t_{ij}^{24}(\ell_j\circ\phi_{ij})-\ell_i r_{ij}^{24} in (13). The sixth root a*a_* is the complex number eiπ/3e^{\mathrm i\pi/3}. The explicit diagonal parameter s*s_* is one half minus i\mathrm i times the ratio of 1+221+2\sqrt2 to 232\sqrt3.

The Claim

Theorem 1. There exist an algebraic rank-two bundle GG on SS and a positive integer m0m_0 for which the family Em=fm*G⊗PE_m=f_m^*G\otimes P of (3) satisfies (15). Em is ample(m≥1),ℳ+(Em)=⌀(m≥m0).\begin{aligned} E_m&\text{ is ample} &&(m\ge1),\\ \mathcal M^+(E_m)&=\varnothing &&(m\ge m_0). \end{aligned}(15)✦ For the bundle G*G_* determined by (14) and (13), there is a positive integer m*m_* such that (16) holds. ℳ+(fm*G*⊗P)=⌀for every integer m≥m*.\mathcal M^+(f_m^*G_*\otimes P)=\varnothing \qquad\text{for every integer }m\ge m_*.(16)✦

What Is Checked

The statements concern algebraic rank-two bundles on SS with finite principal affine trivializations, ampleness through symmetric sections, and smooth metrics on the dual bundle with the strict curvature condition (7).

The four standard affine charts cover SS.✦ The explicit parameters (14) satisfy the first and third identities in (8). For graph parameters, the divisor polynomials did_i are nonzero and squarefree; their transformations and the nonvanishing chart lifts satisfy (10).