OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท ยง8. Angular obstructions and the final contradiction

Lemma 8.8: The complement of two labels is measured on a rotated polynomial region

Alternating angular states constrain local color density.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A circle palette records the labels visible in each unit direction around a center. The local question concerns two labels present on alternating angular sectors and the planar density of their complement.

Let ๐•‹=โ„/(2ฯ€โ„ค)\mathbb T=\mathbb R/(2\pi\mathbb Z) be the circle of anglesโœฆ, let ฮผ\mu be its normalized angular Haar measureโœฆ, and write u(t)=eitu(t)=e^{it} for its unit direction.โœฆ Let mm denote planar Lebesgue measure. For a natural number kk, a weak measurable coloring c:โ„‚โ†’Finkc\colon\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}\,k is an almost everywhere measurable function satisfying the exclusion condition (1): c(p)โ‰ c(p+u(t))for almost every (p,t) with respect to mร—ฮผ.c(p)\ne c(p+u(t)) \quad\text{for almost every }(p,t)\text{ with respect to }m\times\mu.(1)โœฆ For the circle constructions, take a Borel measurable representative cc.

For a set AโІโ„‚A\subseteq\mathbb C, its density-one set ๐’Ÿ1(A)\mathcal D_1(A) consists of points where the proportion of AA in shrinking closed disks tends to one, as in (2); the limit is taken in the extended nonnegative reals: ๐’Ÿ1(A)={pโˆˆโ„‚:limrโ†“0m(AโˆฉBยฏ(p,r))m(Bยฏ(p,r))=1}.\mathcal D_1(A)= \left\{p\in\mathbb C: \lim_{r\downarrow0} \frac{m(A\cap\overline B(p,r))}{m(\overline B(p,r))}=1\right\}.(2)โœฆ A typical color point pp is a point of ๐’Ÿ1({q:c(q)=c(p)})\mathcal D_1(\{q:c(q)=c(p)\}).โœฆ Typical circle sampling at a center yy and a radius rr means that r>0r>0 and y+ru(t)y+ru(t) is a typical color point for almost every tt with respect to ฮผ\mu.โœฆ

Circle Traces and Angular States

The real space E=L2(๐•‹,ฮผ;โ„)E=L^2(\mathbb T,\mu;\mathbb R) consists of square-integrable real functions, with functions equal almost everywhere identified.โœฆ For a center yโˆˆโ„‚y\in\mathbb C, a real radius rr and a label iโˆˆFinki\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k, the circle color indicator fy,r,i:๐•‹โ†’โ„f_{y,r,i}\colon\mathbb T\to\mathbb R is the function in (3): fy,r,i(t)=๐Ÿ{c(y+ru(t))=i}.f_{y,r,i}(t)=\mathbf1_{\{c(y+ru(t))=i\}}.(3) This indicator belongs to L2(ฮผ)L^2(\mu); denote its class by sy,r,iโˆˆEs_{y,r,i}\in E.

For a real Hilbert space EE, the weak unit ball Bw(E)B_w(E) is the unit ball of its continuous dual with the weak dual topology.โœฆ The Riesz duality embedding sends vโˆˆEv\in E to the functional wโ†ฆโŸจv,wโŸฉw\mapsto\langle v,w\rangleโœฆ; its restriction to โˆฅvโˆฅโ‰ค1\|v\|\le1 is the weak unit ball embedding.โœฆ The inverse Riesz identification gives the underlying Hilbert vector of an element of Bw(E)B_w(E).โœฆ

A weak trace vector bb is an element of Bw(E)FinkB_w(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,k}, with the product topology.โœฆ For a weak trace vector bโˆˆBw(E)Finkb\in B_w(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,k} and a label iโˆˆFinki\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k, the trace color component vi(b)โˆˆEv_i(b)\in E is the underlying Hilbert vector of bib_i.โœฆ For a center yโˆˆโ„‚y\in\mathbb C and a real radius rr, the circle sampling vector ฮฒ(y,r)โˆˆBw(E)Fink\beta(y,r)\in B_w(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,k} is the weak trace vector whose component at each label iโˆˆFinki\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k is the weak unit ball embedding of sy,r,is_{y,r,i}.โœฆ

The typical circle sample graph ๐’ฎ\mathscr S is the set of triples (y,r,ฮฒ(y,r))(y,r,\beta(y,r)) for which typical circle sampling holds.โœฆ A circle trace bb at a center xโˆˆโ„‚x\in\mathbb C is a weak trace vector satisfying (x,1,b)โˆˆ๐’ฎยฏ(x,1,b)\in\overline{\mathscr S}.โœฆ Write ๐’ฏx\mathscr T_x for the set of all such traces.โœฆ

For a circle trace bโˆˆ๐’ฏxb\in\mathscr T_x and a label iโˆˆFinki\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k, the positive trace set Ti(b)T_i(b) is the subset of ๐•‹\mathbb T defined by Ti(b)={tโˆˆ๐•‹:vi(b)(t)>0}T_i(b)=\{t\in\mathbb T:v_i(b)(t)>0\}.โœฆ Choose countable palette generators ๐’ขx,iโІ๐’ฏx\mathscr G_{x,i}\subseteq\mathscr T_x whose positive trace sets realize the essential union of this family with respect to ฮผ\mu.โœฆ The palette color set Ci(x)โІ๐•‹C_i(x)\subseteq\mathbb T is the union of the positive trace sets chosen by ๐’ขx,i\mathscr G_{x,i}, and the circle palette PxP_x is the map assigning to each direction u(t)u(t) the labels whose palette color sets contain tt, as in (4): Ci(x)=โ‹ƒbโˆˆ๐’ขx,iTi(b),Px(u(t))={i:tโˆˆCi(x)}.C_i(x)=\bigcup_{b\in\mathscr G_{x,i}}T_i(b), \qquad P_x(u(t))=\{i:t\in C_i(x)\}.(4) The lifted color palette set Cฬƒi(x)\widetilde C_i(x) for a center xโˆˆโ„‚x\in\mathbb C and a label iโˆˆFinki\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k is the subset of โ„\mathbb R defined by Cฬƒi(x)={tโˆˆโ„:[t]โˆˆCi(x)}\widetilde C_i(x)=\{t\in\mathbb R:[t]\in C_i(x)\}, where [t][t] is the class of tt in ๐•‹\mathbb T.

A real angular state at xx for a finite label set JJ is a Borel set AโІโ„A\subseteq\mathbb R satisfying (5), where ฮป\lambda denotes Lebesgue measure on โ„\mathbb R: ฮป(A\Cฬƒi(x))=0(iโˆˆJ).\lambda\bigl(A\setminus\widetilde C_i(x)\bigr)=0 \qquad(i\in J).(5)โœฆ For a phase ฯ†โˆˆโ„\varphi\in\mathbb R, the positive triple-angle sectors are S+(ฯ†)={t:sin⁡(3(tโˆ’ฯ†))>0}S_+(\varphi)=\{t:\sin(3(t-\varphi))>0\}โœฆ, and the negative triple-angle sectors are Sโˆ’(ฯ†)={t:sin⁡(3(tโˆ’ฯ†))<0}S_-(\varphi)=\{t:\sin(3(t-\varphi))<0\}.โœฆ

Writing a point of โ„‚\mathbb C as ฮพ+iฯ…\xi+i\upsilon with ฮพ,ฯ…โˆˆโ„\xi,\upsilon\in\mathbb R, the three-label region ฮฉโІโ„‚\Omega\subseteq\mathbb C is the polynomial region in (6), with โ„“=ฮพ2+ฯ…2\ell=\xi^2+\upsilon^2: ฮฉ={ฮพ+iฯ…:0<โ„“<4,ฯ…2(3ฮพ2โˆ’ฯ…2)2<โ„“3(1โˆ’โ„“/4)(โ„“โˆ’1)2}.\Omega=\left\{\xi+i\upsilon: 0<\ell<4,\quad \upsilon^2(3\xi^2-\upsilon^2)^2 <\ell^3(1-\ell/4)(\ell-1)^2\right\}.(6)โœฆ

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let c:โ„‚โ†’Finkc\colon\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}\,k be a Borel measurable weak coloring, let xโˆˆโ„‚x\in\mathbb C, and let a,bโˆˆFinka,b\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k and ฯ†โˆˆโ„\varphi\in\mathbb R. Suppose that S+(ฯ†)S_+(\varphi) is a real angular state at xx for {a}\{a\} and that Sโˆ’(ฯ†)S_-(\varphi) is a real angular state at xx for {b}\{b\}. For every zโˆˆฮฉz\in\Omega, x+eiฯ†zโˆˆ๐’Ÿ1({qโˆˆโ„‚:c(q)โˆ‰{a,b}}).x+e^{i\varphi}z\in \mathcal D_1\bigl(\{q\in\mathbb C:c(q)\notin\{a,b\}\}\bigr).(7)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: after rotating the triangle outsider sectors to phase zero, write z=ฮพ+iฯ…z=\xi+i\upsilon and โ„“=ฮพ2+ฯ…2\ell=\xi^2+\upsilon^2; if 0<โ„“<40<\ell<4 and ฯ…2(3ฮพ2โˆ’ฯ…2)2<โ„“3(1โˆ’โ„“/4)(โ„“โˆ’1)2\upsilon^2(3\xi^2-\upsilon^2)^2<\ell^3(1-\ell/4)(\ell-1)^2, a neighborhood of x+zx+z uses only the three triangle labels up to a plane-null set.

What Is Checked

The assertion (7) is stated over a Borel measurable weak coloring, its real angular states at xx, and the three-label region (6). The circle indicators (3) satisfy โˆฅsy,r,iโˆฅL2(ฮผ)โ‰ค1\|s_{y,r,i}\|_{L^2(\mu)}\le1 for every center yy, real radius rr and label ii.โœฆ