OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท ยง8. Angular obstructions and the final contradiction

Lemma 8.6: For Borel representatives of weak colorings, with a local angular statement for the five-label triangle state

Two-label strips yield local essential constancy.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A one-sided strip near a unit circle specifies both an arc of directions and an inner or outer radial neighborhood. The local data here concern two such strips whose central directions differ by ฯ€/3\pi/3, and three sets approaching a common center in prescribed directions.

Write mm for planar Lebesgue measure, ๐•‹=โ„/2ฯ€โ„ค\mathbb T=\mathbb R/2\pi\mathbb Z for the circle of angles, and ฮผ\mu for its normalized angular Haar measure. The unit direction at tโˆˆ๐•‹t\in\mathbb T is d(t)=eitโˆˆโ„‚d(t)=e^{it}\in\mathbb C, and Rz=eiฯ€/3zRz=e^{i\pi/3}z is rotation by ฯ€/3\pi/3. For a number of labels kk, a weak measurable coloring c:โ„‚โ†’Finkc:\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}\,k is an almost everywhere measurable function satisfying the exclusion in (1). c(z)โ‰ c(z+d(t))for (mร—ฮผ)-almost every (z,t).c(z)\ne c(z+d(t)) \quad\text{for }(m\times\mu)\text{-almost every }(z,t).(1)โœฆ

The essential color interior EiโІโ„‚E_i\subseteq\mathbb C of a label ii consists of the points with an open neighborhood on which c=ic=i almost everywhere.โœฆ For a Boolean function s:๐•‹โ†’{0,1}s:\mathbb T\to\{0,1\}, its essential angular interior Ab(s)A_b(s) consists of the angles with an open neighborhood on which s=bs=b almost everywhere.โœฆ Ei={z:โˆƒU open,zโˆˆU,c=im-almost everywhere on U},Ab(s)={t:โˆƒJ open in ๐•‹,tโˆˆJ,s=bฮผ-almost everywhere on J}.\begin{aligned} E_i&=\{z:\exists U\text{ open},\ z\in U, \ c=i\quad m\text{-almost everywhere on }U\},\\ A_b(s)&=\{t:\exists J\text{ open in }\mathbb T,\ t\in J, \ s=b\quad\mu\text{-almost everywhere on }J\}. \end{aligned}(2)

For a center xx, a unit direction ee, a width ฮด>0\delta>0, and a sign ฯƒโˆˆ{โˆ’1,1}\sigma\in\{-1,1\}, the one-sided strip Sฯƒ(x,e;ฮด)S_\sigma(x,e;\delta) is the set in (3); the sign 11 selects outer radii and โˆ’1-1 selects inner radii. Sฯƒ(x,e;ฮด)={x+reโ€ฒ:|eโ€ฒ|=1,|eโ€ฒโˆ’e|<ฮด,r>0,|rโˆ’1|<ฮด,ฯƒ(rโˆ’1)>0}.S_\sigma(x,e;\delta)= \{x+re': |e'|=1,\ |e'-e|<\delta,\ r>0, \ |r-1|<\delta,\ \sigma(r-1)>0\}.(3)

Circle Traces and Palettes

The real space L2(ฮผ)L^2(\mu) consists of square-integrable real functions on ๐•‹\mathbb T, identified almost everywhere.โœฆ For a real Hilbert space EE, its weak dual unit ball ๐’ฒ(E)\mathcal W(E) consists of continuous linear functionals of norm at most one, with the weak dual topology.โœฆ The Riesz duality map sends vโˆˆEv\in E to the functional wโ†ฆโŸจw,vโŸฉw\mapsto\langle w,v\rangle.โœฆ For the real Hilbert space EE, the weak unit ball embedding is the restriction of the Riesz duality map to โˆฅvโˆฅโ‰ค1\|v\|\leq1, with value ฮน(v)\iota(v) at vv; write val⁡(a)โˆˆE\operatorname{val}(a)\in E for the inverse Riesz image of aโˆˆ๐’ฒ(E)a\in\mathcal W(E).

A weak trace vector ฮฒ\beta for kk labels is a family (ฮฒi)iโˆˆFink(\beta_i)_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k} in ๐’ฒ(L2(ฮผ))\mathcal W(L^2(\mu)); its color component is ฮฒiโ™ญ=val⁡(ฮฒi)\beta_i^\flat=\operatorname{val}(\beta_i). For a Borel measurable coloring cc, a planar center yy, a real radius rr, and a label ii, the circle color indicator fy,r,if_{y,r,i}, its L2L^2 class Fy,r,iF_{y,r,i}, and the circle sampling vector B(y,r)B(y,r) are given by (4). fy,r,i(t)=๐Ÿ{c(y+rd(t))=i},Fy,r,i=[fy,r,i]L2(ฮผ),B(y,r)i=ฮน(Fy,r,i).f_{y,r,i}(t)=\mathbf 1_{\{c(y+rd(t))=i\}},\qquad F_{y,r,i}=[f_{y,r,i}]_{L^2(\mu)},\qquad B(y,r)_i=\iota(F_{y,r,i}).(4)

A set DโІโ„‚D\subseteq\mathbb C has density one at a point zz when the area ratio in (5) tends to one in the extended nonnegative reals, where Bยฏ(z,r)\overline B(z,r) denotes the closed planar ball with center zz and radius rr. limrโ†“0m(DโˆฉBยฏ(z,r))m(Bยฏ(z,r))=1.\lim_{r\downarrow0} \frac{m(D\cap\overline B(z,r))}{m(\overline B(z,r))}=1.(5)โœฆ A typical color point zz of the coloring cc is a point of the complex plane where the class cโˆ’1(c(z))c^{-1}(c(z)) has density one.โœฆ A typical circle sampling (y,r)(y,r) of the coloring cc is a pair consisting of a planar center and a real radius with r>0r>0 such that y+rd(t)y+rd(t) is a typical color point for ฮผ\mu-almost every tt.โœฆ The typical circle sample graph ๐’ฎ\mathcal S of the coloring cc is the set of triples (y,r,B(y,r))(y,r,B(y,r)) arising from typical circle samplings of cc.โœฆ A circle trace at xx is a weak trace vector ฮฒ\beta with (x,1,ฮฒ)โˆˆ๐’ฎยฏ(x,1,\beta)\in\overline{\mathcal S}; write ๐’ฏx\mathcal T_x for the set of these traces, with closure taken in the product of the planar, real, and weak trace vector topologies.

The positive trace set Qx,i(ฮฒ)Q_{x,i}(\beta) of ฮฒโˆˆ๐’ฏx\beta\in\mathcal T_x is the set where ฮฒiโ™ญ\beta_i^\flat is positive.โœฆ The countable palette generators Gx,iโІ๐’ฏxG_{x,i}\subseteq\mathcal T_x are a chosen countable family whose positive trace sets realize the essential union of all such sets.โœฆ The palette color set Cx,iโІ๐•‹C_{x,i}\subseteq\mathbb T is the union of the positive trace sets of the countable palette generators at xx for label ii, as in (6). Qx,i(ฮฒ)={t:ฮฒiโ™ญ(t)>0},Cx,i=โ‹ƒฮฒโˆˆGx,iQx,i(ฮฒ).Q_{x,i}(\beta)=\{t:\beta_i^\flat(t)>0\},\qquad C_{x,i}=\bigcup_{\beta\in G_{x,i}}Q_{x,i}(\beta).(6) For five labels, write sx:๐•‹โ†’{0,1}s_x:\mathbb T\to\{0,1\} for the angular triangle palette state of cc at xx.

Directional Approach and Straddling

For a label jj, the spatial essential support HjโІโ„‚H_j\subseteq\mathbb C of that label is the support of mm restricted to cโˆ’1(j)c^{-1}(j).โœฆ The unit-distance straddling region Str⁡(K)\operatorname{Str}(K) of a set KโІโ„‚K\subseteq\mathbb C is the set of planar points lying at distance less than one from some point of KK and greater than one from another, as in (7). Hj=supp⁡(m|cโˆ’1(j)),Str⁡(K)={z:โˆƒp,qโˆˆK,|zโˆ’p|<1<|zโˆ’q|}.H_j=\operatorname{supp}(m|_{c^{-1}(j)}),\qquad \operatorname{Str}(K)= \{z:\exists p,q\in K,\ |z-p|<1<|z-q|\}.(7)

For a set KโІโ„‚K\subseteq\mathbb C, a center xโˆˆKx\in K, and a unit direction vv, directional approach data are sequences of radii rnr_n and directions wnw_n satisfying (8). rn>0,|wn|=1,x+rnwnโˆˆK,rnโ†’0,wnโ†’v.r_n>0,\quad |w_n|=1,\quad x+r_nw_n\in K,\qquad r_n\longrightarrow0,\quad w_n\longrightarrow v.(8)โœฆ

The triangle edge color pairs โ„ฐiโІFin5\mathcal E_i\subseteq\mathrm{Fin}\,5, indexed by iโˆˆFin3i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,3, are specified in (9). โ„ฐ0={0,1},โ„ฐ1={1,2},โ„ฐ2={2,0}.\mathcal E_0=\{0,1\},\qquad \mathcal E_1=\{1,2\},\qquad \mathcal E_2=\{2,0\}.(9)โœฆ

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let c:โ„‚โ†’Finkc:\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}\,k be a Borel measurable representative of a weak measurable coloring. Let a,ba,b be labels and U,VโІโ„‚U,V\subseteq\mathbb C open sets on which cโˆˆ{a,b}c\in\{a,b\} almost everywhere. Fix a center xx, a unit direction ee, a number ฮด>0\delta>0, and signs ฯƒ,ฯ„โˆˆ{โˆ’1,1}\sigma,\tau\in\{-1,1\}. Suppose Sฯƒ(x,e;ฮด)โІUS_\sigma(x,e;\delta)\subseteq U and Sฯ„(x,Re;ฮด)โІVS_\tau(x,Re;\delta)\subseteq V. There are a label iโˆˆ{a,b}i\in\{a,b\} and a number ฮท>0\eta>0 such that Sฯƒ(x,e;ฮท)โІEi.S_\sigma(x,e;\eta)\subseteq E_i.(10)โœฆ

Now let k=5k=5. For each iโˆˆFin3i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,3, let viv_i be a unit direction and let KiโІโ„‚K_i\subseteq\mathbb C have directional approach data at xx toward viv_i. Suppose HjโˆฉStr⁡(Ki)=โŒ€H_j\cap\operatorname{Str}(K_i)=\varnothing for every jโˆˆโ„ฐij\in\mathcal E_i. Let tโˆˆ๐•‹t\in\mathbb T satisfy โŸจd(t),viโŸฉโ‰ 0\langle d(t),v_i\rangle\ne0 and โŸจRd(t),viโŸฉโ‰ 0\langle Rd(t),v_i\rangle\ne0 for every ii, where the brackets denote the real Euclidean inner product. There is a Boolean value bโˆˆ{0,1}b\in\{0,1\} such that tโˆˆAb(sx).t\in A_b(s_x).(11)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: in the triangle-cycle setting, if e0e_0 and Re0Re_0 lie outside the exceptional direction set BB, the Boolean outsider state ss is almost everywhere constant on an angular neighborhood of e0e_0.

What Is Checked

The strip statement (10) is stated over open planar sets and a Borel representative of a weak measurable coloring; the triangle statement (11) is stated over the five-label angular palette state, directional approach data, and spatial support exclusions on straddling regions. For every Borel measurable coloring, every center yy, every real radius rr, and every label ii, the circle indicator fy,r,if_{y,r,i} belongs to L2(ฮผ)L^2(\mu)โœฆ and its class satisfies โˆฅFy,r,iโˆฅL2(ฮผ)โ‰ค1\|F_{y,r,i}\|_{L^2(\mu)}\leq1.โœฆ